Abstract
Socioeconomic factors are one of the main determinants of health inequalities. However, which component of socioeconomic status affects health most and how that relationship should be measured remains an open question. The aim of this study was to compare material and social deprivation indexes in order to determine which better explains health inequalities within an urban area. Following a review of the literature on small area deprivation indexes, a case study of the Italian city Genoa is presented. The city of Genoa is split into 71 small areas [urbanistic units (UU)], each of which has about 9,500 inhabitants. For each small area, socioeconomic indicators were extracted from the 2001 Census, whereas health indicators were computed from the death registry for 2001–2003. Factorial analyses was used to choose the deprivation variables, which were utilised to create two distinct deprivation indexes referring to material and social deprivation, respectively. Both deprivation indexes are positively correlated with health status proxied by standardised mortality ratios (SMRs) under 65. The material index, however, correlates more highly with SMRs than the social index, and thus the material index is the more suitable measure to explain variations in premature mortality within an urban area. Moreover, the two indexes must be kept distinct.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Boyle, P., Gatrell, A., Duke-Williams, O.: The effect on morbidity of variability in deprivation and population stability in England and Wales: an investigation at small-area level. Soc. Sci. Med. 49, 791–799 (1999)
Boarini. R., Mira d’Ercole, M.: Measures of material deprivation in OECD Countries, OECD Social Employment and Migration Working Papers, No. 37, OECD Publishing, Sussex (2006)
Fuchs, V.: Reflections on the socio-economic correlates of health. J. Health Econ. 23, 653–661 (2004)
Deaton, A.: Health, inequality and economic development. J. Econ. Lit. XLI, 113–158 (2003)
Van Doorslaer, E.: Socioeconomic inequalities in health: measurement, computation and statistical inference. J. Economet. 77(1), 87–103 (1997)
Jarman, B.: Identification of underprivileged areas. BMJ 286, 1705–1709 (1983)
Bartley, M., Blane, D.: Commentary: appropriateness of deprivation indices must be ensured. BMJ 309, 1479 (1994)
Davey Smith, G., Whitley, E., Dorling, D., Gunnel, D.: Area based measures of social and economic circumstances: cause specific mortality patterns depend on the choice of index. J. Epidemiol. Commun. Health 55, 149–150 (2001)
Salmond, C., Crampton, P.: Heterogeneity of deprivation within very small areas. J. Epidemiol. Commun. Health 56, 669–670 (2002)
Townsend, P.: Deprivation. J. Soc. Policy 16(2), 125–146 (1987)
Carstairs, V., Morris, R.: Deprivation and health in Scotland. Aberdeen University Press, Aberdeen (1991)
Forrest R, Gordon D (1993) People and places: a 1991 Census atlas of England. SAUS, University of Bristol
Benach, J., Yasui, Y.: Geographical patterns of excess mortality in Spain explained by two indices of deprivation. J. Epidemiol. Commun. Health 53, 423–431 (1999)
Smits, J., Westert, G., Van Den Bos, G.: Socioeconomic status of very small areas and stroke incidence in the Netherlands. J. Epidemiol. Commun. Health 56, 637–640 (2002)
Kelleher, C., Timoney, A., Friel, S., McKeown, D.: Indicators of deprivation, voting patterns and health status at area level in the Republic of Ireland. J. Epidemiol. Commun. Health 56, 36–44 (2002)
Hales, S., Black, W., Skelly, C., Salmond, C., Weinstein, P.: Social deprivation and the public health risks of community drinking water supplies in New Zealand. J. Epidemiol. Commun. Health 57, 581–583 (2003)
Crampton, P., Salmond, C., Sutton, F.: NZDep91 index of deprivation research report no. 5. Health Services Research Centre, Wellington (1997)
Gordon, D.: Census based deprivation indices: their weighting and validation. J. Epidemiol. Commun. Health 49(Suppl 2), S39–S44 (1995)
Carstairs V.: Socio-economic factors at area level and their relationship with health. In: Elliott, P., Wakefield, J., Best, N., Briggs, D. (eds.) Spatial epidemiology methods and applications, pp. 51–68. Oxford University Press, Oxford (2000)
Sen, A.: On ethics and economics. Basil Blackwell, Oxford (1987)
Townsend, P., Phillimore, P., Beattie, A.: Health and deprivation: inequality and the North. Croom Helm, London (1988)
Carr Hill, R., Jamison, J., O’Reilly, D., Stevenson, M., Reid, J.: Risk adjustment for hospital use using social security data: cross sectional small area analysis. BMJ 324, 390 (2002)
Crayford, T., Shanks, J., Bajekal, M., Langford, S.: Analysis from inner London of deprivation payments based on enumeration districts rather than wards. BMJ 311, 787–788 (1995)
Judge, K., Mays, N.: Equity in the NHS allocating resources for health and social care in England. BMJ 308, 1363–1366 (1994)
Judge, K., Mays, N.: Equity in health care. BMJ 309, 673 (1994)
Buckingham, K., Freeman, P.: Sociodemographic and morbidity indicators of need in relation to the use of community health service: observational study. BMJ 315, 994–996 (1997)
Phillimore, P., Beattie, A., Townsend, P.: Widening inequality of health in northern England, 1981–91. BMJ 308, 1125–1128 (1994)
Testi, A., Ivaldi, E., Busi, A.: Caratteristiche e potenzialità informative degli indici di deprivazione (Characteristics and informative potentialities of the deprivation indices). Tendenze Nuove 2, 111–124 (2005)
Dillon, W., Goldstein, M.: Multivariate analysis method and application. Wiley, New York (1984)
Box, G., Cox, D.: An analysis of transformations (with discussion). J.R. Stat. Soc. B 26, 211–252 (1964)
Senior, M., Williams, H., Higgs, G.: Urban-rural mortality differentials: controlling for material deprivation. Soc. Sci. Med. 51, 289–305 (2000)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Testi, A., Ivaldi, E. Material versus social deprivation and health: a case study of an urban area. Eur J Health Econ 10, 323–328 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10198-008-0136-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10198-008-0136-z