Abstract
Controversies, i.e., multiple theory confrontations, may have a strong impact on the development of science. By an analysis of the so-called “resonance controversy” in chemistry the view that controversies and their resolution differ considerably from the process of theory succession is defended. It is argued that controversies are symptomatic of foundational problems, produce theory-scattering or domain-splitting, and induce ontological shifts. An explication is given of the role of existence claims and the applicability of Ockham's Razor in the resolution of controversies. The requirement of a realistic interpretation of theories at all times, as defended by some philosophers, is criticised.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allen, J., A. E. Oxford, R. Robinson, and J. C. Smith: 1926, ‘Mesomerism’, Journal of the Chemical Society 1926, 401–411.
Arndt, F., E. Scholz, and F. Nachtwey: 1924, ‘Uber Dipyrilene und über die Bindungsverhältnisse in Pyron-Ringsystemen’, Berichte 57, 1903–1911.
Arndt, F.: 1930, ‘Gleichgewicht und “Zwischenstufe”’, Berichte 63, 2963–2966.
Bantz, D. A.: 1980, ‘The Structure of Discovery: Evolution of Structural Accounts of Chemical Bonding’, Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 60, Reidel, Dordrecht.
Brown, H. I.: 1979, ‘A Functional Analysis of Scientific Theories’, Zeitschrift für allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie 10, 119–140.
Chelintsev, G. V.: 1949, Essays on the Theory of Organic Chemistry, Moscow.
Feyerabend, P.: 1978, Against Method, Verso, London.
Gleicher, G. J. and P. von R. Schleyer: 1967, ‘Homoaromaticity and Non-Classical Ions’, Journal of the American Chemical Society 89, 586–591.
Graham, L. R.: 1971, Science and Philosophy in the Soviet Union, Allen Lane, London.
Ingold, C. K.: 1933, ‘Significance of Tautomerism and of the Reactions of Aromatic Compounds in the Electronic Theory of Organic Reactions’, Journal of the Chemical Society 1933, 1120–1127.
Ihde, A. J.: 1964, The Development of Modern Chemistry, Harper & Row, New York.
Koertge, N.: 1971, ‘Intertheoretic Criticism and the Growth of Science’, Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 8, 160–174.
Kosolapoff, G. M.: 1952, Chemical and Engineering News 30, 2474.
Kursanov, D. N., M. G. Gonikberg, B. M. Dubinin, M. I. Kabachnik, E. D. Kaverzneva, E. N. Priliezhaeva, N. D. Sokolov and R. Kh. Freidlana: 1952, ‘The Present State of the Chemical Structural Theory’, Journal of Chemical Education 29, 2–14.
Krüger, L.: 1980, ‘Intertheoretic Relations as a Tool for the Rational Reconstruction of Scientific Development’, Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science 11, 89–101.
Langmuir, I.: 1919, ‘The Arrangement of Electrons in Atoms and Molecules’, Journal of the American Chemical Society 41, 868–934.
Langmuir, I.: 1920, ‘The Octet Theory of Valence and its Applications with Special Reference to Organic Nitrogen Compounds’, Journal of the American Chemical Society 42, 274–292.
Lewis, G. N.: 1916, ‘The Atom and the Molecule’, Journal of the American Chemical Society 38, 762–785.
Lugg, A.: 1980, ‘Theory Choice and Resistance to Change’, Philosophy of Science 47, 227–243.
Pauling, L.: 1931, ‘The Nature of the Chemical Bond’, Journal of the American Chemical Society 53, 1367–1400.
Pauling, L. and G. W. Wheland: 1933, ‘The Quantummechanical Calculation of the Resonance Energy of Benzene and Naphtalene and the Hydrocarbon Free Radicals’, Journal of Chemistry and Physics 1, 362–374.
Pauling, L.: 1939, The Nature of the Chemical Bond, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, New York.
Shapere, D.: 1969, ‘Notes Toward a Post-Positivistic Interpretation of Science’, in P. Achinstein and S. Barker (eds.), The Legacy of Logical Positivism, John Hopkins, Baltimore, pp. 115–160.
Shapere, D.: 1977, ‘Scientific Theories and Their Domains’, in F. Suppe (ed.), The Structure of Scientific Theories, University of Illinois Press, Urbana, pp. 518–565.
Sober, E.: 1981, ‘The Principle of Parsimony’, British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 32, 145–156.
Tatevskii, V. M. and M. I. Shakhparonov: 1949, ‘On a Machist Theory in Chemistry and its Propagandists’, Voprosy Filosofii 3, 176–192.
Van Spronsen, J. W.: 1969, The Periodic System of Chemical Elements, Elsevier, Amsterdam.
Wheland, G. W.: 1944, The Theory of Resonance and its Application to Organic Chemistry, John Wiley, New York.
Wheland, G. W.: 1955, Resonance in Organic Chemistry, John Wiley, New York.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
I am indebted to Clarisse Habraken and Joost van Asten for their critical remarks and their valuable comments concerning the manuscript.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Vermeeren, H.P.W. Controversies and existence claims in chemistry: The theory of resonance. Synthese 69, 273–290 (1986). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00413975
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00413975