Abstract
The disign of flood warning — flood response systems is often performed as part of the overall engineering analysis of flood damage mitigation schemes. However, an important part of the flood response component of such systems is human perception of the flood hazard and its implication for the responses undertaken. This human dimension is examined from three viewpoints, the perception of the flood, the issues in the warning dissemination process, and the implications for the actions undertaken by individual flood plain occupants in response to a warning. Evidence is provided to show how the human characteristics of the flood plain occupants can signigicantly affect the benefits derived from a flood warning — flood response system. The importance of these non-engineering aspects of the problem leads to recommendations for closer collaboration between traditional technical experts and social scientists. The cooperation should extend beyond the assessment of the reduction in flood damages expected from a particular flood warning scheme into actual design of the dissemination process and response mechanisms.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Burton, I.; Kates, R.W.; White, G.F.: The environment as hazard. Oxford University Press, New York 1978.
Changnon, S.A.: Research agenda for floods to solve policy failure. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management Division, American Society of Civil Engineers 111,1, 54–64 (1985)
Chatterton, J.B.; Pirt, J.; Wood, T.R.: The benefits of flood forecasting. Journal of the Institution of Water Engineers and Scientists 33,3, 237–252 (1979)
Day, H.J.; Bugliarello, G.; Ho, P.H.P.; Houghton, V.T.: Evaluation of benefits of a flood warning system. Water Resources Research 5,5, 937–949 (1969)
Day, H.J.; Lee, K.K.: Flood damage reduction potential of river forecast. Journal of the Water Resources Planning and Management Division, American Society of Civil Engineers 102,WR1, 77–87 (1976)
Ericksen, N.J.: Flood information, expectation and protection on the Opotiki floodplain, New Zealand. In: White, G.F. (ed.), Natural Hazards — Local, National, Global, pp. 60–70. Oxford University Press, New York 1974.
Ferrell, W.R.; Krysztofowicz, R.: A model of human response to flood warnings for system evaluation. Water Resources Research 19,6, 1467–1475 (1983)
Flack, J.E.: Economic analysis of structural flood proofing. Journal of the Water Resources Planning and Management Division, American Society of Civil Engineers 104,WR1, 211–221 (1978)
Gately, J.E.: The idea of a flood. Special Publication No. 1, Flood Hazard Research Project, Middlesex Polytechnic, United Kingdom 1973.
Goulter, I.C.; Hannan, T.C.: Flood warnings and flood response for the Red River of the North. Water Resources Bulletin 20, 4, 599–610 (1984)
Goldberg, E.: Getting off Escher's staircase. New Zealand Engineering, p. 3, November 1 (1986)
Harding, D.M.; Parker, D.J.: Flood hazard at Shrewsbury, United Kingdom. In: White, G.F. (ed.), Natural Hazards —Local, National, Global, pp. 43–52. Oxford University Press, New York 1974.
Krzysztofowicz, R.; Davis, D.R.: A methodology for evaluation of flood forecast-response systems. 1 — Analyses and Concepts. Water Resources Research 19,6, 1423–1429 (1983)
Heatherwick, G.; Quinnell, A.L.: Optimising benefits to urban residents of a total flood warning system for the Brisbane Valley. Proceedings of Hydrological Symposium of Institution of Engineers, Australia, Sydney 61–66, 1976.
Moline, N.T.: Perception research and local planning: Floods on the Rock River, Illinois. In: White, G.F. (ed.), Natural Hazards — Local, National, Global. Oxford University Press, New York 1974.
Parker, D.J.; Harding, D.M.: Natural hazard evaluation, perception and adjustment. Geography 64,4, 307–316 (1979)
Penning-Roswell, E.C.; Chatterton, J.B.; Parker, D.J.: The effect of flood warning on flood damage reduction. Report from Middlesex Polytechnic Flood Hazard Research Project for Central Water Planning Unit, Enfield, Middlesex, UK 1978.
Penning-Roswell, E.C.: Non-structural approaches to flood control: Flood Plain land use regulation and flood warning schemes in England and Wales. In: Proceedings of Eleventh Congress of the International Commission on Irrigation and Drainage Q37 R13, 193–211, 1982.
Quinnell, A.L.: Social aspects of flood warnings. Proceedings of Symposium on the January 1974 Floods Moreton Region, Institution of Engineers Australia, Queensland Division 1974.
Reed, D. W.: A review of British flood forecasting practice. Institute of Hydrology Report No. 90, United Kingdom 1984.
Roder, W.: Attitude and knowledge on the Topeka flood plain. In: White, G.F. (ed.), Papers on Flood Problems, Research Paper 70. University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois 1961.
Simpson-Houseley, P.; Curtis, F.: Human response to nuclear and flood hazard: The Manitoba experience. Great Plains Rocky Mountain Geographical Journal 11, 121–127 (1983)
Sniedovich, M.; Davis, D.R.: Evaluation of flood-forecasting response systems. Journal of the Water Resources Planning and Management Division, American Society of Civil Engineers 103,WR1, 83–97 (1977)
Smith, K.; Tobin, G.A.: Human Adjustment to the Flood Hazard. Longman Group Limited, London 1979.
Schware, R.: Official and folk flood warning systems: An assessment. Environmental Management 6,3, 209–216 (1982)
White, G.F. (ed.): Natural Hazards — Local, National, Global. Oxford University Press, New York 1974.
White, G.F.: Flood hazard in the United States: a research assessment. Institute of Behavior Science Program on Technology, Environment and Man, Monograph No. NSF-RA-E-75–006, University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado 1975.
Wong, S.T.: Human behaviour and response towards storm hazard in West Vancouver, British Columbia. Water Resources Bulletin 15,2, 396–413 (1979)
Yakowitz, S.: Markov flow models and the flood warning problem. Water Resources Research 21,1, 81–88 (1985)
Quinnell, A.L.: Human information processing of flood risk, unpublished paper received in November 1986.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Goulter, I., Myska, N. The human component in flood warning and flood response system. GeoJournal 15, 297–305 (1987). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00213457
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00213457