Abstract
While the Gaussian copula model is commonly used as a static quotation device for CDO tranches, its use for hedging is questionable. In particular, the spread delta computed from the Gaussian copula model assumes constant base correlations, whereas we show that the correlations are dynamic and correlated to the index spread. It might therefore be expected that a dynamic model of credit risk, which is able to capture the dependence between the base correlations and the index spread, will have better hedging performances. In this paper, we compare delta hedging of spread risk based on the Gaussian copula model, to the implementation of jump-to-default ratio computed from the dynamic local intensity model. Theoretical and empirical analysis are illustrated by using the market data in both before and after the subprime crisis. We observe that delta hedging of spread risk outperforms the implementation of jump-to-default ratio in the pre-crisis period associated with CDX.NA.IG series 5, and the two strategies have comparable performance for crisis period associated with CDX.NA.IG series 9 and 10. This shows that, although the local intensity model is a dynamic model, it is not sufficient to explain the joint dynamic of the index spread and the base correlations, and a richer dynamic model is required to obtain better hedging results. Moreover, although different specifications of the local intensity can be fitted to the market data equally well, their hedging results can be significant different. This reveals substantial model risk when hedging CDO tranches.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ammann, M., & Brommundt, B. (2009). Hedging Collateralized Debt Obligations. Working paper, University of St Gallen.
Bielecki, T. R., Cousin, A., Crépey, S., & Herbertsson, A. (2011). Pricing and hedging portfolio credit derivatives in a bottom-up model with simultaneous defaults (working paper).
Bielecki, T. R., Crépey, S., & Jeanblanc, M. (April, 2010). Up and down credit risk. Quantitative Finance, pp. 1–15.
Cont R., Deguest R., Kan Y. H. (2010) Recovering default intensity from CDO spreads: Inversion formula and model calibration. SIAM Journal on Financial Mathematics 1: 555–585
Cont R., Kan Y. H. (2011) Dynamic hedging of portfolio credit derivatives. SIAM Journal on Financial Mathematics 2: 112–140
Cont, R., & Minca, A. Recovering portfolio default intensities implied by CDO quotes. Financial Engineering Report No. 2008-01, Columbia University.
Cousin A., Laurent J.-P. (2008) Comparison results for exchangeable credit risk portfolios. Insurance: Mathematics and Economics 42(3): 1118–1127
Cousin A., Laurent J.-P. (2008) An overview of factor modeling for pricing CDO tranches. In: Cont R. (eds) Frontiers in quantitative finance. Wiley Finance, London
Cousin A., Laurent J.-P. (2008) Hedging issues for CDOs. In: Meissner G. (eds) The definitive guide to CDOs, Chap. 17. Risk Books, New York, pp 461–480
Cousin, A., & Laurent, J.-P. (2010). Dynamic hedging of synthetic CDO tranches: Bridging the gap between theory and practice. In Credit Risk Frontiers: Subprime crisis, pricing and hedging, CVA, MBS, ratings and liquidity. London: Wiley (to appear).
Cousin, A., Jeanblanc, M., & Laurent, J.-P. (2010). Hedging CDO tranches in a Markovian environment. In Paris-Princeton lectures in mathematical finance, Lecture Notes in Mathematics. Berlin: Springer.
Crépey S. (2004) Delta hedging vega risk?. Quantitative Finance 4: 559–579
Derman E. (1999) Regimes of volatility. Risk Magazine, USA
El Karoui N., Jeanblanc M., Jiao Y. (2010) What happens after a default: The conditional density approach. Stochastic Processes and Applications 120(7): 1011–1032
El Karoui N., Jeanblanc M., Shreve S. (1997) Robustness of the black and scholes formula. Mathematical Finance 7: 1–71
Fermanian J.-D., Vigneron O. (2010) On break-even correlation: The way to price structured credit derivatives by replication. Risk Magazine, USA
Frey, R., & Backhaus, J. (2010). Dynamic hedging of synthetic CDO-tranches with spread- and contagion risk. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 34(4), 710–724.
Frey R., Backhaus J. (2008) Pricing and hedging of portfolio credit derivatives with interacting default intensities. International Journal of Theoretical and Applied Finance 11(6): 611–634
Hagan P., Kumar D., Lesniewski A., Woodward D. (2002) Managing smile risk. Wilmott Magazine, London
Herbertsson A. (2008) Pricing synthetic CDO tranches in a model with default contagion using the matrix-analytic approach. Journal of Credit Risk 4(4): 3–35
Jobst N. (2007) An introduction to the risk management of collateral debt obligations. In: de Servigny A., Jobst N. (eds) The handbook of structured finance. McGraw Hill, New York, pp 295–338
Kakodkar A., Galiani S., Jonsson J., Gallo A. (2006) Credit derivatives handbook, Vol. 2. Merrill Lynch, USA
Laurent, J.-P., Cousin, A., & Fermanian, J.-D. (April, 2010). Hedging default risks of CDOs in Markovian contagion models. Quantitative Finance.
Li D.-X. (2000) On default correlation: A copula approach. Journal on Fixed Income 9: 43–54
Mang, C., & Sengupta, A. N. (2008). CDO tranche sensitivities in the Gaussian copula model. Working Paper.
Meissner G., Hector R., Rasmussen T. (2008) Hedging CDOs within the Gaussian copula framework In The definitive guide to CDOs—Market, application, valuation, and hedging. RISK books, USA
O’Kane, D., & Livesey, M. (Nov. 2004). Base correlation explained. Lehman Brothers Fixed Income Quantitative Credit Research.
Petrelli A., Zhang J., Jobst N., Kapoor V. (2007) A practical guide to CDO trading risk management. In: de Servigny A., Jobst N. (eds) The handbook of structured finance. McGraw Hill, New York, pp 339–371
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
The research of author Areski Cousin is benefited from the support of the DGE and the ANR project Ast&Risk.
The research of authors Stéphane Crépey and Yu Hang Kan is benefited from the support of the ‘Chaire Risque de crédit’, FBF.
The authors warmly thank Rama Cont and Jean-Paul Laurent for stimulating discussions throughout the preparation of this work.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cousin, A., Crépey, S. & Kan, Y.H. Delta-hedging correlation risk?. Rev Deriv Res 15, 25–56 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11147-011-9068-3
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11147-011-9068-3