An economic assessment of rent controls: The Ontario experience
- Professor of Economics Lawrence B. Smith
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
Rent controls have existed in Ontario since 1975. Although controls have undergone numerous changes, the basic approach has remained a modified cost-pass-through system with provision for the elimination of financial loss and for a return of new capital expenditures, and, prior to 1986, an exemption for new construction. This paper analyzes the economic consequences of the first twelve years of controls. The major effects have been to reduce rents on pre-1976 units but to increase rents on newly constructed post-1975 units, to reduce new construction, to accelerate deterioration and conversion of the existing rental stock, to generate a severe rental housing shortage, to create an environment for “key money,” to inefficiently and inequitably redistribute income, and to significantly exacerbate government budgetary deficits by reducing tax revenues and inducing increased government housing expenditures.
- Arnott, Richard.Rent Control and Options for Decontrol in Ontario. Toronto: Ontario Economic Council, 1981.
- Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC), Toronto Office.Changes to the Existing Rental Apartment Stock in Metropolitan Toronto. Mimeo. 1985.
- Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC), Toronto Office.Rental Apartment Vacancy Survey. October, 1986.
- Chant, John.Complementary Policies to Rent Regulation. Paper prepared for the Commission of Inquiry into Residential Tenancies. Toronto. 1985.
- Ekos Research Associates, Inc.Report on the Study of Landlords and the Ontario Rent Review Process. Paper prepared for the Commission of Inquiry into Residential Tenancies. Toronto. 1985.
- Fallis, George and Smith, Lawrence B. “Uncontrolled Prices in a Controlled Market: The Case of Rent Controls.”American Economic Review 74 (March 1984), 193–200.
- Fallis, George and Smith, Lawrence B. “Price Effects of Rent Control on Controlled and Uncontrolled Rental Housing in Toronto: An Hedonic Index Approach.”Canadian Journal of Economics 18 (August 1985a), 652–659.
- Fallis, George and Smith, Lawrence B. “Rent Controls in Toronto: Tenant Rationing and Tenant Benefits.”Canadian Public Policy 11 (September 1985b), 543–550.
- Klein and Sears, et al.Study of Residential Intensification and Rental Housing Conservation. Study prepared for the Ontario Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing, and the Association of Municipalities of Ontario, Vol. 9. Toronto. 1983.
- Michael Mascall and Associates.Report on the Ontario Rental Housing Market. Paper prepared for the Commission of Inquiry into Residential Tenancies. 1985.
- Muller, R. Andrew.Rent Regulation and the Supply of Rental Housing. Paper prepared for the Commission of Inquiry into Residential Tenancies. Toronto. 1985.
- Muller, R. Andrew.The Effect of the Recommendations of the Rent Review Advisory Committee on New Rental Construction. Report for the Ministry of Housing. Mimeo. Toronto. May 1986.
- Ontario Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing.The Impact of Rent Review on Rental Housing in Ontario: A Staff Research Report. Toronto. July 1982.
- Peter Barnard Associates.Under Pressure: Prospects for Ontario's Low Rise Rental Stock. Study prepared for the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing. Toronto. 1985.
- Rosen, Kenneth T. and Smith, Lawrence B. “The Price Adjustment Process for Rental Housing and the Natural Vacancy Rate.”American Economic Review 73 (September 1983), 779–786.
- Slack, Enid.The Costs of Rent Review. Paper prepared for the Commission of Inquiry into Residential Tenancies. Toronto. 1986.
- Smith, Lawrence B. “A Note on the Price Adjustment Mechanism for Rental Housing.”American Economic Review 64 (June 1974), 478–481.
- Smith, Lawrence B. “Canadian Housing Policy in the Seventies.”Land Economics 57 (August 1981) 338–352.
- Smith, Lawrence B. “The Crisis in Rental Housing: A Canadian Perspective.”Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 465 (January 1983), 58–75.
- Smith, Lawrence B. “Household Headship Rates, Household Formation and Housing Demand in Canada.”Land Economics 60 (May 1984), 180–188.
- Smith, Lawrence B. “Rental Apartment Valuation: The Applicability of Rules of Thumb.”The Appraisal Journal (October 1985), 541–552.
- Smith, Lawrence B.; Rosen, Kenneth T.; Markandya, Anil; and Ullmo, Pierre. “The Demand for Housing, Headship Rates and Household Formation: An International Analysis.”Urban Studies 21 (November 1984), 407–414.
- Smith, Lawrence B. and Tomlinson, Peter. “Rent Controls in Ontario: Roofs or Ceilings?”American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association Journal 9 (Summer 1981), 93–114.
- Stanbury, William T. and Vertinsky, Ilan B.Design Characteristics of Systems of Rent Regulation and their Effects. Paper prepared for the Commission of Inquiry into Residential Tenancies. Toronto. 1985.
- Steele, Marion and Miron, John.Rent Regulation. Housing Affordability Problems and Market Imperfections. Research study #9, prepared for the Commission of Inquiry into Residential Tenancies. Toronto. 1984.
- Steele, Marion.Canadian Housing Allowances: An Economic Analysis. Ontario Economic Council. Toronto. 1986.
- An economic assessment of rent controls: The Ontario experience
The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics
Volume 1, Issue 3 , pp 217-231
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Kluwer Academic Publishers
- Additional Links
- Author Affiliations
- 1. University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada