The aim of science is not things themselves, as the dogmatists in their simplicity imagine, but the relations among things; outside these relations there is no reality knowable. – Poincaré
Abstract
Recent developments in nonlinear dynamics have found wide application in many areas of science from physics to neuroscience. Nonlinear phenomena such as feedback loops, inter-level relations, wholes constraining and modifying the behavior of their parts, and memory effects are interesting candidates for emergence and downward causation. Rayleigh–Bénard convection is an example of a nonlinear system that, I suggest, yields important insights for metaphysics and philosophy of science. In this paper I propose convection as a model for downward causation in classical mechanics, far more robust and less speculative than the examples typically provided in the philosophy of mind literature. Although the physics of Rayleigh–Bénard convection is quite complicated, this model provides a much more realistic and concrete example for examining various assumptions and arguments found in emergence and philosophy of mind debates. After reviewing some key concepts of nonlinear dynamics, complex systems and the basic physics of Rayleigh–Bénard convection, I begin that examination here by (1) assessing a recently proposed definition for emergence and downward causation, (2) discussing some typical objections to downward causation and (3) comparing this model with Sperry’s examples.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alder B., Wainwright T. (1970). Decay of the velocity autocorrelation function. Physical Review A, 1, 18–21
Auyang S. (1998). Foundations of complex-system theories: In economics, evolutionary biology, and statistical physics. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
Batchelor G. (1967). An introduction to fluid dynamics. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
Batterman R. (1993). Defining chaos. Philosophy of Science, 60, 43–66
Bishop R.C. (2004). Nonequilibrium statistical mechanics Brussels–Austin style. Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics, 35, 1–30
Bishop R.C. (2006a). The hidden premise in the causal argument for physicalism. Analysis, 66, 44–52
Bishop, R. C. (2006b). Patching physics and chemistry together. Philosophy of Science, 72, forthcoming.
Bishop, R. C., & Atmanspacher, H. (2006). Contextual emergence in the description of properties. Foundations of Physics, 36 (in press).
Bishop R.C., Kronz F.K. (1999). Is chaos indeterministic?. In: Dalla Chiara M., Roberto G., Laudisa F. (eds) Language, quantum, music: Selected contributed papers of the tenth international congress of logic, methodology & philosophy of science, Florence, August 1995. London, Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp. 129–41
Brand M. (1980). Simultaneous causation. In: van Inwagen P. (eds) Time and cause. Dordrecht, D. Reidel Publishing, pp. 137–153
Busse F. (1978). Non-linear properties of thermal convection. Reports on Progress in Physics, 41:1929–1967
Cross M., Hohenberg P. (1993). Pattern formation outside of equilibrium. Reviews of Modern Physics, 65:851–1112
Crutchfield J. (1994). Observing complexity and the complexity of observation. In: Atmanspacher H., Dalenoort G. (eds) Inside versus outside. Berlin, Springer-Verlag, pp. 235–272
Dirac P. (1949). Forms of relativistic dynamics. Reviews of Modern Physics, 21, 392–399
Earman J. (1986). A primer on determinism. Dordrecht, The Netherlands, D. Reidel Publishing
Gillett C. (2002). The varieties of emergence: Their purposes, obligations and importance. Grazer Philosophische Studien, 65, 95–121
Grassberger P. (1989). Problems in quantifying self-generated complexity. Helvetica Physica Acta, 62, 489–511
Greenside H., Coughran W. Jr., Schryer N. (1982). Nonlinear pattern formation near the onset of Rayleigh–Bénard convection. Physical Review Letters, 49, 726–729
Guyon E., Hulin J.-P., Petit L., Mitescu C. (2001). Physical hydrodynamics. Oxford, Oxford University Press
Hacking I. (1983). Representing and intervening: Introductory topics in the philosophy of science. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
Hacking I. (1984). Experimentation and scientific realism. In: Leplin J. (eds) Scientific realism. Berkeley, University of California Press, pp. 154–172
Haken H. (1983a). Synergetics: An introduction, Third Revised and Enlarged Edition. Berlin, Springer-Verlag
Haken H. (1983b). Advanced synergetics: Instability hierarchies of self-organizing systems and devices. Berlin, Springer-Verlag
Huemer M., Kovitz B. (2003). Causation as simultaneous and continuous. The Philosophical Quarterly, 53, 556–565
Hill R. (1967). Instantaneous action-at-a-distance in classical relativistic mechanics. Journal of Mathematical Physics, 8, 201–220
Hobbs J. (1991). Chaos and indeterminism. Canadian Journal of Philosophy, 21, 141–164
Juarrero A. (1999). Dynamics in action: Intentional behavior as a complex system. Cambridge, MA, MIT Press
Kellert S. (1993). In the wake of chaos. Chicago, University of Chicago Press
Kim J. (1993). Supervenience and mind. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
Kim J. (1998). Mind in a physical world: An essay on the mind–body problem and mental causation. Cambridge, MA, MIT Press
Kim J. (1999). Making sense of emergence. Philosophical Studies, 95, 3–36
Kronz F. (1998). Nonseparability and quantum chaos. Philosophy of Science, 65, 50–75
Kronz F., Tiehen J. (2002). Emergence and quantum mechanics. Philosophy of Science, 6, 324–347
Le Van Quyen M. (1997a). Temporal patterns in human epileptic activity are modulated by perceptual discriminations. NeuroReport, 8:1703–1710
Le Van Quyen M. (1997b). Unstable periodic orbits in human epileptic activity. Physical Review E, 56:3401–3411
Malraison B., Atten P., Bergé P., Dubois M. (1983). Dimension of strange attractors: An experimental determination for the chaotic regime of two convective systems. Journal of Physics Letters, 44, 897–902
Mareschal M. (1997). Microscopic simulations of complex flows. Advances in Chemical Physics, 100, 317–392
McLaughlin B. (1982). British emergentism. In: Beckermann A., Flohr H., Kim J. (eds) Emergence or reduction? Essays on the prospects of nonreductive physicalism. Berlin, Walter de Gruyter, pp. 49–93
Pathria R. (1972). Statistical mechanics. Oxford, Pergamon Press
Pattee H. (1973). The physical basis and origin of hierarchical control. In: Pattee H. (eds) Hierarchy theory: The challenge of complex systems. New York, George Braziller, pp. 69–108
Paul M., Chiam K.-H., Cross M., Greenside H. (2003). Pattern formation and dynamics in convection: Numerical simulations of experimentally realistic geometries. Physica D, 184, 114–126
Pomeau Y., Résibois P. (1975). Time dependent correlation functions and mode–mode coupling theories. Physics Reports, 19, 63–139
Primas H. (1983). Chemistry, quantum mechanics and reductionism: Perspectives in theoretical chemistry. Berlin, Springer-Verlag
Scott A. (1999). Nonlinear science: Emergence & dynamics of coherent structures. Oxford, Oxford University Press
Silberstein M., McGeever J. (1999). The search for ontological emergence. The Philosophical Quarterly, 49, 182–200
Smith P. (1998). Explaining chaos. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
Sperry R. (1969). A modified concept of consciousness. Psychological Review, 76, 532–536
Stone M. (1989). Chaos, prediction and laplacean determinism. American Philosophical Quarterly, 26, 123–131
Taylor R. (1963). Causation. Monist, 47, 287–313
Taylor R. (1966). Action and purpose. Englewood Cliffs, NJ, Prentice-Hall
Teller P. (1986). Relational holism and quantum mechanics. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 37, 71–81
Terry P. (2000). Suppression of turbulence and transport by sheared flow. Reviews of Modern Physics, 72, 109–165
Thompson E., Varela F. (2001). Radical embodiment: Neural dynamics and consciousness. TRENDS in Cognitive Science, 5, 418–425
Van Gulick R. (2001). Reduction, emergence and other recent options on the mind/body problem: A philosophic overview. Journal of Consciousness Studies, 8, 1–34
Wackerbauer R., Witt A., Atmanspacher A., Kurths J., Scheingraber H. (1994). A comparative classification of complexity measures. Chaos, Solitons, Fractals, 4:133–173
Walter H. (2001). Neurophilosophy of Free Will: From libertarian illusions to a concept of natural autonomy, C Klohr (Trans.). Cambridge, MA, MIT Press
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bishop, R.C. Downward causation in fluid convection. Synthese 160, 229–248 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-006-9112-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-006-9112-2