Abstract
This paper outlines a critique of the use of the genetic variance–covariance matrix (G), one of the central concepts in the modern study of natural selection and evolution. Specifically, I argue that for both conceptual and empirical reasons, studies of G cannot be used to elucidate so-called constraints on natural selection, nor can they be employed to detect or to measure past selection in natural populations – contrary to what assumed by most practicing biologists. I suggest that the search for a general solution to the difficult problem of identifying causal structures given observed correlation’s has led evolutionary quantitative geneticists to substitute statistical modeling for the more difficult, but much more valuable, job of teasing apart the many possible causes underlying the action of natural selection. Hence, the entire evolutionary quantitative genetics research program may be in need of a fundamental reconsideration of its goals and how they correspond to the array of mathematical and experimental techniques normally employed by its practitioners.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
S.J. Arnold P.C. Phillips (1999) ArticleTitleHierarchical comparison of genetic variance–covariance matrices. II. Coastal-inland divergence in the garter snakeThamnophis elegans Evolution 53 1516–1527
N.H. Barton M. Turelli (1989) ArticleTitleEvolutionary quantitative genetics: how little do we know? Annu. Rev. Genet. 23 337–370
M. Begin D.A. Roff (2001) ArticleTitleAn analysis of G matrix variation in two closely related cricket species, Gryllus firmus and G. pennsylvanicus J. Evol. Biol. 14 1–13 Occurrence Handle10.1046/j.1420-9101.2001.00258.x
A.D. Bradshaw (1965) ArticleTitleEvolutionary significance of phenotypic plasticity in plants Adv. Genet. 13 115–155
E.D. Brodie SuffixIII (1993) ArticleTitleHomogeneity of the genetic variance–covariance matrix for antipredator traits in two natural populations of the garter snake Thamnophis ordinoides Evolution 47 844–854
J.M. Cheverud (1984) ArticleTitleQuantitative genetics and developmental constraints on evolution by selection J. Theor. Biol. 110 155–171
J.M. Cheverud (1988) The evolution of genetic correlation and developmental constraints G.D. Jong (Eds) Population Genetics and Evolution Springer-Verlag Berlin 94–101
C.E. Cleland (2002) ArticleTitleMethodological and epistemic differences between historical science and experimental science Philos. Sci. 69 474–496 Occurrence Handle10.1086/342455
J.K. Conner (2002) ArticleTitleGenetic mechanisms of floral trait correlations in a natural population Nature 420 407–410 Occurrence Handle10.1038/nature01105
D.E. Cowley W. Atchley (1992) ArticleTitleComparison of quantitative genetic parameters Evolution 46 1965–1966
Downes S.M. 2004. Heredity and heritability. In: Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, plato.stanford.edu. Stanford University, Stanford, CA, pp. plato.stanford.edu/entries/heredity.
D.S. Falconer T.F.C. Mackay (1996) Introduction to Quantitative Genetics Prentice Hall Harlow, England
M.H. Gromko (1995) ArticleTitleUnpredictability of correlated response to selection: pleiotropy and sampling interact Evolution 49 685–693
D.L. Hartl A.G. Clark (1989) Principles of Population Genetics Sinauer Sunderland, MA
A.A. Hoffmann R. Hallas C. Sinclair L. Patridge (2001) ArticleTitleRapid loss of stress resistance in Drosophila melanogaster under adaptation to laboratory culture Evolution 55 436–438
D. Houle (1991) ArticleTitleGenetic covariance of fitness correlates: what genetic correlations are made of and why it matters Evolution 45 630–648
J.B. Johnson (2002) ArticleTitleDivergent life histories among populations of the fish Brachyrhaphis rhabdophora: detecting putative agents of selection by candidate model analysis Oikos 96 82–91 Occurrence Handle10.1034/j.1600-0706.2002.960109.x
N.A. Johnson A.H. Porter (2001) ArticleTitleToward a new synthesis: population genetics and evolutionary developmental biology Genetica 112–113 45–58
K. Karoly J.K. Conner (2000) ArticleTitleHeritable variation in a family-diagnostic trait Evolution 54 1433–1438
O. Kempthorne (1978) ArticleTitleLogical, epistemological and statistical aspects of nature-nurture data interpretation Biometrics 34 1–23
R. Lande S.J. Arnold (1983) ArticleTitleThe measurement of selection on correlated characters Evolution 37 1210–1226
D. Layzer (1974) ArticleTitleHeritability analyses of IQ scores: science or numerology? Science 183 1259–1266
R.C. Lewontin (1974) ArticleTitleThe analysis of variance and the analysis of causes Am. J. Hum. Genet. 26 400–411
M. Matthen A. Ariew (2002) ArticleTitleTwo ways of thinking about fitness and natural selection J. Philos. 49 55–83
R.L. Millstein (2002) ArticleTitleAre random drift and natural selection conceptually distinct? Biol. Philos. 17 33–53 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1012990800358
T. Mitchell-Olds J. Bergelson (1990) ArticleTitleStatistical genetics of an annual plantImpatiens capensis. I. Genetic basis of quantitative variation Genetics 124 407–415
T. Mitchell-Olds R.G. Shaw (1987) ArticleTitleRegression analysis of natural selection: statistical inference and biological interpretation Evolution 41 1149–1161
S.M. Paulsen (1996) ArticleTitleQuantitative genetics of the wing color pattern in the buckeye butterfly (Precis coenia and Precis evarete) Evolution 50 1585–1597
P.C. Phillips S.J. Arnold (1999) ArticleTitleHierarchical comparison of genetic variance–covariance matrices. I. Using the Flury hierarchy Evolution 53 1506–1515
P.C. Phillips M.C. Whitlock K. Fowler (2001) ArticleTitleInbreeding changes the shape of the genetic covariance matrix in Drosophila melanogaster Genetics 158 1137–1145
M. Pigliucci (2001) Phenotypic Plasticity: Beyond Nature and Nurture Johns Hopkins University Press Baltimore, MD
Pigliucci M. and Kaplan J. forthcoming. Making Sense of Evolution: Toward a Coherent Picture of Evolutionary Theory. Chicago University Press, Chicago, IL.
M. Pigliucci K. Preston (Eds) (2004) Phenotypic Integration: Studying the Ecology and Evolution of Complex Phenotypes Oxford University Press Oxford
M. Pigliucci C.D. Schlichting (1997) ArticleTitleOn the limits of quantitative genetics for the study of phenotypic evolution Acta Biotheoret. 45 143–160
D.A. Roff (1997) Evolutionary Quantitative Genetics Chapman & Hall New York
D.A. Roff (2000) ArticleTitleThe evolution of the G matrix: selection or drift? Heredity 84 135–142
D.A. Roff (2002) ArticleTitleComparing G matrices: a MANOVA approach Evolution 56 1286–1291
S. Sarkar (1998) Genetics and Reductionism Cambridge University Press Cambridge, England
S.M. Scheiner (1993) ArticleTitleGenetics and evolution of phenotypic plasticity Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 24 35–68 Occurrence Handle10.1146/annurev.es.24.110193.000343
S.M. Scheiner R.J. Mitchell H.S. Callahan (2000) ArticleTitleUsing path analysis to measure natural selection J. Evol. Biol. 13 423–433 Occurrence Handle10.1046/j.1420-9101.2000.00191.x
C.D. Schlichting (1986) ArticleTitleThe evolution of phenotypic plasticity in plants Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 17 667–693 Occurrence Handle10.1146/annurev.es.17.110186.003315
J. Schmitt S. Dudley M. Pigliucci (1999) ArticleTitleManipulative approaches to testing adaptive plasticity: phytochrome-mediated shade avoidance responses in plants Am. Nat. 154 S43–S54
C.M. Sgró L. Partridge (2000) ArticleTitleEvolutionary responses of the life history of wild-caught Drosophila melanogaster to two standard methods of laboratory culture Am. Nat. 156 341–353
R.G. Shaw (1992) ArticleTitleComparison of quantitative genetic parameters: reply to Cowley and Atchley Evolution 46 1967–1968
F.H. Shaw R.G. Shaw G.S. Wilkinson M. Turelli (1995) ArticleTitleChanges in genetic variances and covariances: G whiz! Evolution 49 1260–1267
B. Shipley (2000) Cause and Correlation in Biology: A User’s Guide to Path Analysis, Structural Equations and Causal Inference Cambridge University Press Cambridge, England
R.A.J. Skipper (2002) ArticleTitleThe persistence of the R.A. Fisher–Sewall Wright controversy Biol. Philos. 17 341–367 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1020178411042
E. Sober (1984) The Nature of Selection: Evolutionary Theory in Philosophical Focus MIT Press Cambridge, MA
S.J. Steppan (1997) ArticleTitlePhylogenetic analysis of phenotypic covariance structure. I. Contrasting results from matrix correlation and common principal component analyses Evolution 51 571–586
S.J. Steppan P.C. Phillips D. Houle (2002) ArticleTitleComparative quantitative genetics: evolution of the G matrix Trends Ecol. Evol. 17 320–327 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0169-5347(02)02505-3
S.E. Sultan (1987) ArticleTitleEvolutionary implications of phenotypic plasticity in plants Evol. Biol. 21 127–178
M. Turelli (1988) ArticleTitlePhenotypic evolution, constant covariances, and the maintenance of additive variance Evolution 42 1342–1347
S. Via (1987) Genetic constraints on the evolution of phenotypic plasticity V. Loeschcke (Eds) Genetic Constraints on Adaptive Evolution Springer-Verlag Berlin 47–71
P. Waldmann S. Andersson (2000) ArticleTitleComparison of genetic (co)variance matrices within and between Scabiosa canescens and S. columbaria J. Evol. Biol. 13 826–835 Occurrence Handle10.1046/j.1420-9101.2000.00214.x
D.M. Walsh (2003) ArticleTitleFit and diversity: explaining adaptive evolution Philos. Sci. 70 280–301 Occurrence Handle10.1086/375468
D.M. Walsh T. Lewens A. Ariew (2002) ArticleTitleThe trials of life: natural selection and random drift Philos. Sci. 69 452–473 Occurrence Handle10.1086/342454
I. Weigensberg D.A. Roff (1996) ArticleTitleNatural heritabilities: can they be reliably estimated in the laboratory? Evolution 50 2149–2157
C. Wells M. Pigliucci (2000) ArticleTitleHeterophylly in aquatic plants: considering the evidence for adaptive plasticity Perspect. Plant Ecol. Evol. Syst. 3 1–18
M.J. West-Eberhard (2003) Developmental Plasticity and Evolution Oxford University Press Oxford, England
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Pigliucci, M. Genetic Variance–covariance Matrices: A Critique of the Evolutionary Quantitative Genetics Research Program. Biol Philos 21, 1–23 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-005-0399-z
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-005-0399-z