Abstract
This article pursues the varying understandings of the photograph in archival literature. An in-depth review of the scholarship uncovers several possible reasons why archivists and those writing about photographic archives apparently continue to struggle with the photograph, including: the sheer difficulty that photographs as an elusive medium present; past debates about photography in art history, history, and archival literature; and the challenges that the photograph as an evasive document presents to the contradictory nature of archives themselves and to conceptions of archival science. Having evolved from an understanding of photographs that conflated content with meaning to postmodernist notions of contingent and plural meanings in which photographs participate, archival writings on the photograph hold promise as they begin to tread the waters that Schwartz charted in the last 15 years. This paper follows that historical progression in order to trace the discourse on photographic archives that has emerged over the past three decades.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Barthes R (1982) Camera lucida: reflections on photography. Hill and Wang, New York
Berger J (1991) About looking. Vintage International, New York
Bourdieu P (1965) Un art moyen: essai sur les usages socioux de la photographie. Editions de Minuit, Paris
Burant J (1984–1985) The visual world in the Victorian age. Archivaria 19:110–121
Burke P (2001) Eyewitnessing: the use of images as historical evidence. Cornell UP, Ithaca
Callery B, Wythe D (2004) Photographs. In: Wythe D (ed) Museum archives: an introduction. Society of American Archivists, Chicago, pp 123–140
Cook T (2000) Archival science and postmodernism: new formulations for old concepts. Arch Sci 1(1):3–24
Eagleton T (1983) Literary theory: an introduction. University of Minnesota, Minneapolis
Edwards E (2001) Raw histories: photographs, anthropology, and museums. Berg, Oxford
Gilliland A, McKemmish S (2004) Introduction. Arch Sci 4:144–145
Goldstein BM (2007) All photos lie: images as data. In: Stanczak GC (ed) Visual research methods: image, society, and representation. Sage Publications, Los Angeles, pp 61–81
Hayes P, Silvester J, Hartmann W (1999) Photograph, history, and memory. In: Hayes P, Silvester J, Hartmann W (eds) The colonising camera: photographs in the making of Namibian history. Univ of Cape Town Press, Capetown, pp 2–10
Hayes P, Silvester J, Hartmann W (2002) Picturing the past’ in Namibia: the visual archive and its energies. In: Hamilton C et al (eds) Refiguring the archive. Kluwer, Dordrecht
Holmes OW (1859) The stereoscope and the stereograph. Atl Mon 8:739
Johnson L (1977–1978) Yukon archives visual photograph finding aid. Archivaria 5:112–123
Jussim E (1989a) The eternal moment. In: The eternal moment: essays on the photographic image. Aperture, New York, pp 49–60
Jussim E (1989b) The self-reflexive camera. In: The eternal moment: essays on the photographic image. Aperture, New York, pp 3–14
Kaplan E, Mifflin J (2000) Mind and sight: visual literacy and the archivist. In: Jimerson RC (ed) American archival studies: readings in theory and practice. Society for American Archivists, Chicago, pp 73–97
Ketelaar E (2000) Archivistics research saving the profession. Am Arch 63:326–327
Koltun L (1977–1978) The photograph: an annotated bibliography for archivists. Archivaria 5:124–140
Krauss R (1999) A note on photography and the simulacral. In: Squiers C (ed) Overexposed: essays on contemporary photography. The New Press, New York, pp 169–182
Lambert P (1977–1978) Photographic documentation and buildings: relationships past and present. Archivaria 5:60–77
Mifflin J (2007) Visual archives in perspective: enlarging on historical medical photographs. Am Arch 70:32–69
Pedersen D (1987) The photographic record of the Canadian YWCA, 1890–1930: a visual source for women’s history. Archivaria 24:10–35
Ritzenthaler ML, Vogt-O’Connor D, Zinkham H, Carnell B, Peterson K (2006) Photographs: archival care and management. The Society of American Archivists, Chicago
Rosenblum N (2007) A world history of photography, 4th edn. Abbeville Press, New York
Rundell W Jr (1978) Photographs as historical evidence: early texas oil. Am Arch 41(4):373–398
Sandweiss M (2002) Print the legend: photography and the American west. Yale University, New Haven
Schwartz JM (1977–1978) The photographic record of pre-confederation British Columbia. Archivaria 5:17–44
Schwartz JM (1995) We make our tools and our tools make us: lessons from photographs for the practice, politics, and poetics of diplomatics. Archivaria 40:40–74
Schwartz JM (1996) The geography lesson: photographs and the construction of imaginative geographies. J Hist Geogr 22(1):16–45
Schwartz JM (2000) Records of simple truth and precision: photography, archives, and the illusion of control. Archivaria 50:1–40
Schwartz JM (2002) Coming to terms with photographs: descriptive standards, linguistic ‘othering’, and the margins of archivy. Archivaria 54:142–171
Schwartz JM (2004) Negotiating the visual turn: new perspectives on images and archives. Am Arch 67:107–122
Sekula A (2004) Reading an archive: photography between labour and capital. In: Wells L (ed) The photography reader. Routledge, London, pp 443–452
Sontag S (1977) On photography. Picador, New York
Tagg J (2004) Evidence, truth, and order: photographic records and the growth of the state. In: Wells L (ed) The photography reader. Routledge, London, pp 257–260
Taylor HA (1979) Documentary art and the role of the archivist. Am Arch 42(4):417–428
Thomassen T (2001) A first introduction to archival science. Arch Sci 1:374
Trace CB (2002) What is recorded is never simply ‘what happened’: record keeping in modern organizational culture. Arch Sci 2:137–159
Wells L (2004) Words and pictures: on reviewing photography. In: Wells L (ed) The photography reader. Routledge, London, pp 428–434
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Schlak, T. Framing photographs, denying archives: the difficulty of focusing on archival photographs. Arch Sci 8, 85–101 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10502-009-9081-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10502-009-9081-6