Abstract
A complete history of early atomic models would fill volumes, but a reasonably coherent tale of the path from mechanical atoms to the quantum can be told by focusing on the relevant work of three great contributors to atomic physics, in the critically important years between 1904 and 1913: J.J. Thomson, Ernest Rutherford and Niels Bohr. We first examine the origins of Thomson’s mechanical atomic models, from his ethereal vortex atoms in the early 1880’s, to the myriad “corpuscular” atoms he proposed following the discovery of the electron in 1897. Beyond qualitative predictions for the periodicity of the elements, the application of Thomson’s atoms to problems in scattering and absorption led to quantitative predictions that were confirmed by experiments with high-velocity electrons traversing thin sheets of metal. Still, the much more massive and energetic α-particles being studied by Rutherford were better suited for exploring the interior of the atom, and careful measurements on the angular dependence of their scattering eventually allowed him to infer the existence of an atomic nucleus. Niels Bohr was particularly troubled by the radiative instability inherent to any mechanical atom, and succeeded in 1913 where others had failed in the prediction of emission spectra, by making two bold hypotheses that were in contradiction to the laws of classical physics, but necessary in order to account for experimental facts.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Badash, L. 1967. Nagaoka to Rutherford, 22 February 1911. Phys. Today. 20: 55–60
Bohr, N. 1913a. On the theory of the decrease of velocity of moving electrified particles on passing through matter. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 25: 10–31
Bohr, N. 1913b. On the constitution of atoms and molecules, Part I. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 26: 1–25
Bohr, N. 1913c. On the constitution of atoms and molecules, Part II. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 26: 476–502
Bragg, W.H. and R. Kleeman. 1905. On the α particles of radium, and their loss of range in passing through various atoms and molecules. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 10: 318–340
Crowther, J.A. 1910. On the Scattering of homogeneous β-rays and the number of electrons in the atom. Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 84: 226–247
Darwin, C.G. 1912. A theory of the absorption and scattering of the α rays. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 28: 901–920
Davis, E.A. and I.J. Falconer. 1997. J.J. Thomson and the Discovery of the Electron, Taylor & Francis, London
Franklin, A. 2001. Are There Really Neutrinos? Perseus, Cambridge
Geiger, H. 1908. On the scattering of the α-particles by matter. Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 81: 174–177
Geiger, H. 1910. The Scattering of the α-Particles by Matter. Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 83: 492–504
Geiger, H. and E. Marsden. 1909. On the Diffuse Reflection of the α-Particles. Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 82: 495–500
Haas, A.E. 1910. Der Zusammenhang des Planckschen elementaren Wirkungsquatums mit den Grundgrossen der Electronentheorie. Jahrbuch der Radioaktivitaet und Elektronik 7: 261–268
Heilbron, J.L. 1981. Historical Studies in the Theory of Atomic Structure, Arno Press, New York
Hermann, A. 1971. The Genesis of Quantum Theory, MIT Press, Cambridge (English translation by Claude W. Nash)
Kelvin, Lord 1902. Aepinus Atomized. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 3: 257–283
Kragh, H. 2012. Niels Bohr and the Quantum Atom, Oxford University Press, Oxford
Maxwell, J.C. 1859. On the Stability of the Motion of Saturn’s Rings, Macmillan and Co., London
Maxwell, J.C. 1861. On physical lines of Force. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 21: 161–175
Mayer, A.M. 1878. On the morphological laws of the configurations formed by Magnets floating vertically and subjected to the attraction of a superposed magnet. American Journal of Science and Arts 16: 247–256
Nagaoka, H. 1904. Kinetics of a System of Particles illustrating the Line and the Band Spectrum and the Phenomena of Radioactivity. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 7: 445–455
Nicholson, J.W. 1912. The Constitution of the solar Corona II. Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 72: 677–692
Pais, A. 1991. Niels Bohr’s Times, in Physics, Philosophy, and Polity, Oxford University Press, Oxford
Patterson, G. 2007. Jean Perrin and the triumph of the atomic doctrine. Endeavor 31: 50–53
Rutherford, E. 1905a. Some properties of the α rays from radium. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 10: 163–176
Rutherford, E. 1905b. Charge carried by the α and β rays of radium. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 10: 193–208
Rutherford, E. 1906a. Retardation of the α Particle from radium in passing through Matter. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 12: 134–146
Rutherford, E. 1906b. Some properties of the α rays from radium. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 11: 166–176
Rutherford, E. 1911. The Scattering of α- and β-Particles by Matter and the Structure of the Atom. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 21: 669–688
Rutherford, E. and H. Geiger. 1908a. An electrical method of counting the number of α-Particles from Radio-active Substances. Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 81: 141–161
Rutherford, E. and H. Geiger. 1908b. The Charge and Nature of the α-Particle. Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 81: 162–173
Schott, G.A. 1904. On the Kinetics of a System of Particles illustrating the Line and Band Spectrum. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 8: 384–387
Stoney, G.J. 1894. Of the ‘Electron’ or Atom of Electricity. Philos. Mag. Lett. 38: 418–420
Thomson, J.J. 1883a. A treatise on the motion of vortex rings, Macmillan and Co., London
Thomson, J.J. 1883b. On the Theory of the Electric Discharge in Gases. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 15: 427–434
Thomson, J.J. 1897. Cathode rays. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 44: 296–314
Thomson, J.J. 1903. The magnetic properties of systems of corpuscles describing circular orbits. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 7: 237–265
Thomson, J.J. 1904. On the structure of the atom. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 7: 237–265
Thomson, J.J. 1906. On the number of corpuscles in an atom. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 11: 769–781
Thomson, J.J. 1910. On the Scattering of rapidly moving electrified particles. Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 15: 465–471
Thomson, J.J. 1912a. Multiply-Charged Atoms. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 24: 668–672
Thomson, J.J. 1912b. Ionization by moving electrified particles. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 23: 449–457
Thomson, J.J. 1936. Recollections and Reflections, Bell & Sons, London. [Page numbers in the text refer to the 1937 U.S. reprint by Macmillan & Co.]
Thomson, W. (Lord Kelvin) 1867. On vortex atoms. Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 34: 15–24
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Baily, C. Early atomic models – from mechanical to quantum (1904–1913). EPJ H 38, 1–38 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1140/epjh/e2012-30009-7
Received:
Revised:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjh/e2012-30009-7