Abstract
Britain’s exit from the European Union on the 31st of January 2020 was the culmination of what was arguably the second major failure of statecraft by the British political class this century, following the UK’s participation in the 2003 Iraq invasion. Drawing on elite theory as well as research into group behaviour, identity diversity and cognitive diversity, and decision-making and organisational performance, the article examines key stages of the Brexit process. The article argues that failures at each stage are attributable to a degree of ‘groupthink’ and ‘group polarisation’ linked to the relatively homogenous nature of the British political class and the structural attributes of British government. It goes on to advocate greater diversity in political recruitment and fundamental reform of modes and structures of British government.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aaron, R. 1950. Social structure and the ruling class. British Journal of Sociology, I 1–7: 126–144.
Acker, J. 2006. Inequality regimes: Gender, class, and race in organisations. Gender and Society 20 (4): 441–464.
Adam, K. 2019. “Get Brexit done”: Boris Johnson’s effective but misleading slogan in the British election. Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/get-brexit-done-boris-johnsons-effective-but-misleading-slogan-in-the-uk-election/2019/12/12/ec926baa-1c62-11ea-977a-15a6710ed6da_story.html Accessed 3/01/20.
Allen, P. 2018. The political class. Why it matters who our politicians are. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Allen, P., and D. Cutts. 2018. An analysis of political ambition in Britain. The Political Quarterly 89 (1): 73–81.
Allen, P. 2013. Linking parliamentary political experience and the career trajectories of the 1997 general election cohort. Parliamentary Affairs 66 (4): 685–707.
Allen, P., and P. Cairney. 2015. What do we mean when we talk about the ‘political class’? Political Studies Review. 15 (1): 18–27.
Allison, G., and P. Zellikow. 1999. Essence of decision: Explaining the Cuban Missile Crisis, 2nd ed. New York: Longman.
Annesley, C., and F. Gains. 2010. The core executive: Gender, power and change. Political Studies 58 (5): 909–929.
Arat, M., M. Aksu, and A.T. Cetin. 2015. How board diversity affects firm performance in emerging markets: Evidence on channels in controlled firms. Corporate Governance 23 (2): 83–103.
Ashcroft, M. 2016. Call me Dave: The unauthorised biography of David Cameron, 2nd ed. London: Bightback.
Aydemir, N., and R. Vliegenthart. 2016. ’Minority representatives’ in the Netherlands: Supporting, silencing or suppressing? Parliamentary Affairs 69 (1): 73–92.
Baron, R.S. 2005. So right its wrong: Groupthink and the ubiquitous nature of polarised decision making. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology. 37: 219–253.
Bauer, M., and B. Bertin-Mourot. 1996. Vers un modèle Européen de dirigeants? Comparison Allemagne/France/Grand Bretagne. Paris: C.N.R.S et Boyden Executive Search.
Bennister, M. 2009. Tony Blair as Prime Minister. In The Blair Legacy, ed. T. Casey. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Bensahel, N. 2006. Mission not accomplished: What went wrong with Iraqi reconstruction. Journal of Strategic Studies 29 (3): 453–473.
Bernile, G., V. Bhagwat, and S. Yonker. 2018. Board diversity, firm risk, and corporate policies. Journal of Financial Economics. 127 (3): 588–612.
Best, H. 2018. Elite sectors: Differentiation and integration. In The Palgrave handbook of political elites, ed. H. Best and J. Higley, 331–338. London: Palgrave.
Best, H. 2010. Associated rivals: Antagonism and cooperation in the German political elite. In Democratic elitism: New theoretical and comparative perspectives, ed. H. Best and J. Higley, 97–116. Leiden: Brill.
Bjarnegård, E. 2013. Gender, informal institutions and political recruitment. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Blyth, M. 2013. Austerity: The history of a dangerous idea. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Bobba, S. 2019. The central concept of empowerment in Indigenous health and wellbeing. Australian Journal of Primary Health. https://doi.org/10.1071/PY18097.
Boffey, D. 2019. Cameron did not think EU referendum would happen, says Tusk. The Guardian 22/1/19. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/21/donald-tusk-warned-david-cameron-about-stupid-eu-referendum-bbc. Accessed 20 Feb 2019.
Bourdieu, P. 1996. The state nobility. Elite schools in the field of power. Cambridge MA: Polity Press.
Bovens, M., and P. t’Hart. 2016. Revisiting the study of policy failures. Journal of European Public Policy 23 (5): 653–666.
Buckley, W. 2016. The big Eton con trick will run and run: don’t let it fool you. The Guardian 5/9/16. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/sep/05/eton-con-trick-eu-vote-etonian-prime-ministers-school. Accessed 21 Feb 2019.
Bulpitt, J. 1986. The discipline of the new democracy: Mrs Thatcher’s domestic statecraft. Political Studies 34 (1): 19–39.
Byman, D. 2008. An autopsy of the Iraq debacle: Policy failure or bridge too far? Security Studies 17 (4): 599–643.
Byrne, C., and K. Theakstone. 2018. Understanding the power of the Prime Minster: Structure and agency in models of Prime Ministerial Power. British Politics. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41293-018-0087-7.
Cairney, P., M. Keating, and A. Wilson. 2016. Solving the problem of social background in the UK ‘political class’: Do parties do things differently in Westminster, devolved and European elections? British Politics 11 (2): 142–163.
Callaway, M.R., and J. Esser. 1984. Groupthink: Effects of cohesiveness and problem solving procedures on group decision making. Social Behaviour and Personality 12: 157–164.
Chilcot, J. 2016. The report of the Iraq inquiry. https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20171123123237/http://www.iraqinquiry.org.uk/ Accessed 20 Feb 2019.
Childs, S. 2013. In the absence of electoral sex quotas: Regulating political parties for women’s representation. Representation 14 (4): 401–423.
Childs, S., and P. Cowley. 2011. The politics of local presence. Is there a case for descriptive representation? Political Studies 59 (1): 1–19.
Cline, R.J.W. 1994. Groupthink and the Watergate cover-up. The Illusion of unanimity. In Group communication in context: Studies of Natural Groups, ed. L.R. Frey. Hillsdale NJ: Erlbaum.
Coleman, S. 2013. How voters feel. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
D’Ancona, M. 2015. With his government of chums, Cameron’s stumbled upon a good idea. The Guardian 3/7/15. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jul/02/cameron-government-chums-privy-council-ed-llewellyn-lord-feldman. Accessed 20 Feb 2019.
Dahrendorf, R. 1979. Society and democracy in Germany. New York: W. W. Norton.
Darmadi, S. 2011. Board diversity and firm performance: The Indonesia evidence. Corporate Ownership and Control. 8 (2): 451–466.
Diamond, P. 2017. The Westminster system under the Cameron coalition: ‘Promiscuous partisanship’ or institutional resilience? Public policy and Administration. https://doi.org/10.1177/0952076717737595.
Disch, L. 2011. Towards a mobilisation conception of democratic representation. American Political Science Review. 105 (1): 100–114.
Dodge, T. 2007. The causes of US failure in Iraq. Survival 49 (1): 85–106.
Eder, F. 2019. Making concurrence seeking visible: Groupthink, discourse networks, and the 2003 Iraq War. Foreign Policy Analysis 15: 21–42.
Esser, J.K., and J.S. Lindoerfer. 1989. ‘Groupthink and the space shuttle Challenger accident: Towards a quantitative case analysis. Journal of Behavioural Decision Making. 2: 167–177.
Eurostat. ‘Eurobarometer’ descriptive statistics. Brussels: European Commission. https://ec.europa.eu/commfrontoffice/publicopinion/index.cfm. Accessed 10 Aug 2018.
Evans, G., and J. Tilley. 2015. The new class war: excluding the working class in 21st Century Britain. Juncture 21 (4): 298–304.
Franceschet, S., and J.M. Piscopo. 2013. Equality, democracy, and the broadening and deepening of gender quotas. Politics & Gender. 9 (3): 310–316.
George, S. 1990. An Awkward Partner: Britain in the European Community. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Giddens, A., and P. Stanworth. 1974. An economic elite: A demographic profile of company chairmen. In Elites and Power in British Society, ed. S. Philip and A. Giddens, 81–101. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Global Economy. 2019. World Bank Political Stability Index. https://www.theglobaleconomy.com/United-Kingdom/wb_political_stability/. Accessed 30 Jan 2019.
Goodwin, M., and O. Heath. 2016. The 2016 referendum, Brexit and the left behind: An aggregate-level analysis of the result. Political Quarterly 87 (3): 323–332.
Hassan, G. 2013. Groupthink fundamentals and principles in organisations. Interdisciplinary Journal of Contemporary Research in Business. 5 (8): 225–240.
Henley, J. 2018. So will the EU miss the UK when it’s gone? Probably not. The Guardian 25/11/18. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2018/nov/24/eu-wont-miss-britain-after-brexit. Accessed 30 Jan 2019.
Herrera, H., and A. Mattozzi. 2010. Quorum and turnout in referenda. Journal of the European Economic Association 8 (4): 838–871.
Hobolt, S.B. 2016. The Brexit vote: A divided nation, a divided continent. Journal of European Public Policy 23 (9): 1259–1277.
Hong, L., and S.E. Page. 2004. Groups of diverse problem solvers can outperform groups of high-ability problem solvers. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) 101 (46): 16385–16389.
Hong, L., and S.E. Page. 2001. Problem solving by groups of heterogeneous agents. Journal of Economic Theory 97 (1): 123–163.
Hug, S. 1999. Occurrence and policy consequences of referendums: A theoretical model and empirical evidence. Sand Diego CA: Typescript. UCSD Dept. of Political Science; La Jolla.
Isenberg, D.J. 1986. Group polarisation: A critical review and meta-analysis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 50 (6): 1141–1151.
van Keating, J., L. Boven, and C.M. Judd. 2016. Partisan underestimation and of the polarizing influence of group discussion. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology. 65: 52–58.
Kim, D., and L.T. Starks. 2016. Gender diversity on corporate boards: Do women contribute unique skills? American Economic Review 106 (5): 267–271.
Landemore, H. 2013. Deliberation, cognitive diversity, and democratic inclusiveness: An epistemic argument for the random selection of representatives. Synthese 190: 1209–1231.
Leighton, D.S.R. 2000. Making boards work: Recruiting for balance, competence and results. In Women in management: International challenges and opportunities, ed. R.J. Burke and M.C. Mattis, 253–261. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic.
Levine, S., and N.S. Roberts. 1993. The New Zealand electoral referendum of 1992. Electoral Studies 12 (2): 158–167.
Mangset, M. 2016. Varying Elite identities among top bureaucrats. A study of the role of higher education in France, in Great Britain and in Norway. L’Année sociologique. 66 (1): 225–250.
Micaleff, R. 2019. Facebook post. https://www.facebook.com/557630214/posts/10161445916580215/. Accessed 30 Jan 2019.
Mills, C.W. 1956. The power elite. New York: Oxford University Press.
Mueller, D.C. 1996. Constitutional democracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Myers, D.G. 1982. Polarising effects of social interaction. In Group decision making, ed. H. Brandstatter, J.H. Davis, and G. Stocker-Kreichauer, 125–161. London: Academic Press.
Nguyen, H., and R. Faff. 2006. Impact of board size and board diversity on firm value: Australian evidence. Corporate Ownership and Control. 4 (2): 24–32.
Oborne, P. 2007. The establishment is dead. But something worse has replaced it. The Spectator, 12th September. https://www.spectator.co.uk/features/162011/the-establishment-is-dead-but-something-worse-has-replaced-it/. Accessed 14 May 2019.
Odmalm, P., and C. Lees. 2006. Getting ethnic questions on the agenda: Party formation as a strategy for social movements. Social Movement Studies 6 (1): 1–18.
Oppermann, K., and A. Spencer. 2016. Telling stories of failure: Narrative constructions of foreign policy fiascos. Journal of European Public Policy 23 (5): 685–701.
Oppermann, K. 2013. The politics of discretionary government commitments to European integration referendums. Journal of European Public Policy 20 (5): 684–701.
Page, S.E. 2014. Where diversity comes from and why it matters? European Journal of Social Psychology 44: 267–279.
Perrigo, B. 2019. ‘Get Brexit done’: The 3 words that helped Borsi Johnson win Britain’s 2019 election. Time. https://time.com/5749478/get-brexit-done-slogan-uk-election/. Accessed 3 Jan 2020.
Piscopo, J.M., and S.C. Muntean. 2018. Corporate quotas and symbolic politics in advanced democracies. Journal of Women, Politics and Policy. 39 (3): 285–309.
Ridgeway, C.L. 1983. The dynamics of small groups. New York: St Martin’s Press.
Riker, W. 1982. Liberalism against populism. Prospect Heights, Il: Waveland.
Robinson, P. 2017. Learning from the Chilcot report: Propaganda, deception, and the War on Terror. International Journal of Contemporary Iraqi Studies. 11 (1–2): 47–73.
Rose, C. 2007. Does female board representation influence firm performance? The Danish evidence. Corporate Governance 15 (2): 404–413.
Rousseau, J. 2018. Struggling toward Indigenous representation and service improvement within the BC Ministry of Children and Family Development. Canadian Public Administration 61 (4): 641–664.
Ruostetsaari, I. 2006. Social upheaval and transformation of elite structures. The case of Finland. Political Studies 54 (1): 23–42.
Saalfeld, T. 2011. Parliamentary questions as instruments of substantive representation: Visible minorities in the House of Commons. The Journal of Legislative Studies. 17 (3): 271–289.
Saalfeld, T., and D. Bischof. 2013. Minority-ethnic MPs and the substantive representation of minority interests in the House of Commons, 2005–2011. Parliamentary Affairs. 66 (2): 305–328.
Schwartzberg, M. 2015. Epistemic democracy and its challenges. Annual Review of Political Science 18: 187–203.
Schwartzberg, M. 2013. Prelude: Acclamation and aggregation in the ancient world—the origin of supermajority rules. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Schwartzman, L.F., and A.R. Paiva. 2014. Not just racial quotas: Affirmative action in Brazilian higher education 10 years later. British Journal of Sociology of Education. 37 (4): 548–566.
Shipman, T. 2016. All-out war: How Brexit sunk Britain’s political class. London: Collins.
Steiner, I.D. 1982. Heuristic models of groupthink. In Group Decision Making, ed. H. Brandstatter, J.H. Davis, and G. Stocker-Kreichgauer. New York: Academic Press.
Straw, W. 2019. I was part of the Remain campaign. There are lessons in Brexit: The Uncivil War. The Guardian 8 January 2019. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/jan/08/i-was-in-remain-campaign-win-peoples-vote-brexit-the-uncivil-war. Accessed 1 July 2019.
Thames, F.C., and M.S. Williams. 2013. Contagious representation: Women’s political representation in democracies around the world. New York and London: New York University Press.
Turner, M.E., and A.R. Pratkanis. 1998. Twenty-five years of Groupthink theory and research: Lessons from the evaluation of a theory. Organizational Theory and Human Decision Processes 73 (2/3): 105–115.
United Nations. 1995. The United Nations and the advancement of women, 1945–1995. New York: United Nations Department of Public Education.
Verge, T. 2018a. Political party gender action plans: Pushing gender change forward beyond quotas. Party Politics. https://doi.org/10.1177/1354068818766196.
Beyme, Von. 1996. The concept of political class: A new dimension of research on elites? West European Politics 19 (1): 68–87.
Waylen, G. 2014. Informal institutions, institutional change, and gender equality. Political Research Quarterly 67 (1): 212–223.
Weber, M. 1978. Economy and society: An outline of interpretive sociology (eds.: Roth, G., and Wittich, C.) Berkeley: Berkeley University Press.
Wessels, W. 1997. An ever closer fusion? A dynamic macro-political view on integration processes. Journal of Common Market Studies 35 (2): 267–299.
Wilks, S. 1996. Britain and Europe: Awkward partner or awkward state? Politics 16 (3): 159–165.
Young, H. 1998. This blessed plot: Britain and Europe from Churchill to Blair. London: MacMillan.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lees, C. Brexit, the failure of the British political class, and the case for greater diversity in UK political recruitment. Br Polit 16, 36–57 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41293-020-00136-6
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41293-020-00136-6