Abstract
Cloning – the process of creating a cell, tissue line or even a complete organism from a single cell – or the strands that led to the cloning of a mammal, Dolly, are not new. Yet the media coverage of Dolly's inception raised a range of reactions from fear or moral repulsion, to cautious optimism. The implications for controlling human reproduction were clearly in the forefront, though many issues about animals emerged as well. On topics of public interest such as cloning, historians of biology have the opportunity to make a unique contribution. Such debates are often aired as if they have no precedents, either in biology or in the ethical, moral, and social concerns arising in the public arena. The technology leading to Dolly draws on strands of research going back to the 1890s, and the cycle of public response has been repeated often in the past century. What can we learn from examining these events historically, and how can we – or should we even try – to inform public opinion? I think we should try and will outline briefly some of the ways that can work.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abbott, A. 1999. “European Embryology Experts Offer to Advise on Ethics of Cloning.” Nature 400: 103.
Andrews, Lori B. 1999. The Clone Age. Adventures in the New World of Reproductive Technology. Henry Holt.
Bergmann, L. 1959. “A New Technique for Isolating and Cloning Cells of Higher Plants.” Nature 184: 648–649.
Boffey, Philip. 1997. “Cloning as an Anticlimax.” The New York Times.
Campbell, K.H.S., McWhir, J., Ritchie, W.A. and Wilmut, I. 1996. “Sheep Cloned by Nuclear Transfer from a Cultured Cell Line.” Nature 380: 64–66.
Edwards, Robert and Steptoe, Patrick. 1980. A Matter of Life. William Morrow.
Goodfield, June. 1977. Playing God. Random House.
Gurdon, J. and Colman, A. 1999. “The Future of Cloning.” Nature, 402: 743–746.
Hamburger, Viktor. 1988. The Heritage of Experimental Embryology. Hans Spemann and the Organizer. Oxford University Press.
Harrison, R.G. 1907. “Experiments in Transplanting Limbs and their Bearing upon the Problems of the Development of Nerves.” Journal of Experimental Zoology 4: 239–281.
Hawkes, Nigel. 2000. “Experts Back Use of Therapeutic Cloning.” London Times.
Johnson, G. 1997. “Ideas and Trends; Ethics Fears Aside, Science Plunges On.” The New York Times.
Jones, Maggie. 2000. “The Genetic Report Card.” The New York Times Magazine, p. 80.
Kitcher, Philip. 1997. The Lives to Come: The Genetic Revolution and Human Possibilities. Touchstone Books.
Kolata, Gina. February 23, 1997. “Scientist Reports First Cloning Ever of Adult Mammal.” The New York Times.
December 2, 1997. “On Cloning Humans, ‘Never’ Turns Swiftly into ‘Why Not?’ ” The New York Times.
1998. Clone: The Road to Dolly, and the Path Ahead. William Morrow and Company.
Loeb, J. 1899. “On the Nature of the Process of Fertilization and the Artificial Production of Normal Larvae (Plutei) from the Unfertilized Eggs of the Sea Urchin.” American Journal of Physiology 3: 135–138.
Maienschein, Jane. 1991. Transforming Traditions in American Biology, 1880–1915. Johns Hopkins University Press.
Masood, E. 1999. “Expert Group to Look at UK Cloning Law.”Nature400: 4.
Paul, Diana. 1995. Controlling Human Heredity. 1865 to Present. Humanities Press.
Pauly, Philip. 1987. Controlling Life. Jacques Loeb and the Engineering Ideal in Biology. Oxford University Press, especially chapter 5.
Pennisi, P. 1997. “The Lamb That Roared.” Science 278: 2038–2039.
Pollard, C.L. 1905. “On the Spelling of ‘Clon.’ ” Science 21: 87–88.
Proctor, Robert. 1992. “Genomics and Eugenics: How Fair is the Comparison?” George J. Annas and Sherman Elias (eds.), Gene Mapping: Using Law and Ethics as Guides. Oxford University Press, pp. 57–93.
Schneike, A.E., Kind, A.J., Ritchie, W.A., Mycock, K., Scott, A.R., Ritchie, M. Wilmut, I., Colman, A. and Campbell, K.H.S.1997. “Human factor X Transgenic Sheep Produced by Transfer of Nuclei from Fetal Fibroblasts.” Science 278:2130–2133.
Spemann, Hans. 1938. Embryonic Development and Induction. Yale University Press.
Specter, Michael with Kolata, Gina. 1997. “After Decades and Many Missteps, Cloning Success.” The New York Times.
Steinfels, Peter. March 8, 1997. “Beliefs.” The New York Times.
Vogt, M. 1959. “A Study of the Relationship between Karyotype and Phenotype in Cloned Lines of Strain HeLa.” Genetics 44: 1257–1270.
Watson, J.D., Tooze, J. and Kurtz, D.T. 1983. Recombinant DNA. A Short Course. New York: Scientific American Books, pp. 207–208.
Wade, Nicholas. 1979. The Ultimate Experiment. Walker and Company.
Webber, H.J. 1903. “New Horticultural and Agricultural Terms.” Science 18: 501–503.
Wilson, Edmund B. 1896. The Cell in Inheritance and Development. Macmillan.
Wilmut, I. 1998. “Cloning for Medicine.” Scientific American.
Wilmut, I., Campbell, K. and Tudge, C. 2000. The Second Creation. Dolly and the Age of Biological Control. Farrar, Straus, and Giroux.
Wilmut, I., Schnieke, A.E., McWhir, J., Kind, A.J. and Campbell, K.H.S. 1997. “Viable Offspring derived from Fetal and Adult Mammalian Cells.” Nature 385: 810–813.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Maienschein, J. On Cloning: Advocating History of Biology in the Public Interest. Journal of the History of Biology 34, 423–432 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1012994614765
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1012994614765