Abstract
This article explores the possibilities and limits of urban constitutionalism and its relation to the rule of law for fifteenth century Bruges. Late medieval Bruges was a city of great prominence where several important trade flows came together. Providing adequate justice was a top priority for the aldermen. Scholars have traditionally stressed the importance of privileges in providing this security. Privileges granted a theoretical protection but also entailed other deviations from the general rule. The grant of privileges lay the foundation of an unequal treatment of merchants. This article argues that, though these privileges were essential in protecting merchants, the aldermen of Bruges did not grant far-reaching procedural advantages to merchant communities. In doing so, the aldermen of Bruges ensured that certain basic notions, such as access to the aldermen of Bruges, equal opportunities before this court and the prevalence of Flemish law over foreign law, were present. In the city’s belief that proper justice equalled the common good, some embryonic notions of the rule of law become apparent. However, we should not overextend this argument. The city depended on these merchant communities. Therefore, the city was more susceptible to the leverage of the merchant communities, than, for example, the state. Bruges refused demands for procedural advantages for the most part of the fifteenth century, but once the presence of these communities became indispensable, the city had to give in and alter its legal framework.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Haggard (2008); Tamanaha 2012, (242–243); Moller and Skaaning (2014).
Nevertheless, in their capacity as judges, the aldermen of Bruges represented the Count of Flanders on the level of the city. Godding (1995, 193–195).
Dumolyn, (2010, 379–380).
Dumolyn, (2008, 17). See the Hanseatic charter stating: “omme voordernesse vander coopmanscepe ende den ghemeene oorboir (…) belooft over ons ende onze naercommers tonder houdene in goeder trauwen de painte ende articlen hier near verclaerst” (for the advancement of trade and the common good (…) we promise to observe the following articles); City Archive Bruges (CAB) 96, Oude Wittenboek, fol. 20 v. – 21 r. or the English (…) pour l’utilité de la chose publique (…); Archives départementales du Nord, série b (ADNB) 519/1389.
Møller (2017).
Blackmore (2020).
We will refer to the best editions at hand: See for the Hanseatic 1289 privilege: Hansische Urkundenbuch, 295 and 1279; 1307 and 1309 privileges: Hansische Urlundenbuch, vol. II, 52 and 65–69; 1359–60 privileges Hansische Urkundenbuch, vol. III, 199; Cartulaire de l’ancien estaple, 233 and 287; 1392 privileges: Ordonnances de Philippe le Hardi, 485–507; 1438: CAB 96, Cartularium Oude Wittenboek, fol. 20 v. – 24 v.; 1457 Cartulaire de l’ancien estaple, vol. 2, 50–53.
The English 1359 privilege: The book of privileges, 193–209.
Cartulaire de l’ancien estaple, vol I, 235–236; L’inventaire des chartes de Bruges, vol. V, 802; Ordonnances de Philippe le Hardi, 52–54; Ordonnances de Jean sans Peur, 89–90.
During the rebellion of Jacob van Artevelde, the Spanish received privileges who were later confirmed by the Count; Cartulaire de l’ancien consulat d’Espagne, 8–12; Inventaire des Chartes, vol. II, 129–138; Inventaire des Chartes, vol. IV, 496–499.
Portuguese 1411 privilege: Ordonnances, 253–259; the Portuguese 1438 privilege: CAB 96, Oude Wittenboek, fol. 98 v. – 99 r.
1322: State Archive Venice, Misti Senato, vol. 15, fol. 5 r.; 1406: Ordonnances de Jean Sans Peur, 40–41; the Genoese 1414 are on Ordonnances de Jean Sans Peur, 319–324.
The nation of Viscaya was formally a part of the greater Castilian nation, but split in 1455 from the latter. Although they claimed the old Castilian privileges, Bruges did not respect this interpretation.
Boureau, (2018, 720–723).
Van Caenegem (1976).
Hansische Urkundenbuch, vol. I, 428–429.
Consulat d’Espagne, 8–12.
Ordonnances de Jean sans Peur, 297–298.
(…) omme dat zii vele zaken ghedaen ende gheuseert hebben boven haren previlegien in contrarien van onser heerlicheit ende der vriheit ende rechten van onsen steden ende landen, ende dat zii ons niet houden willen over juge van den ghescille van haren previlegien, daer of zii hebben ghemesusert (…); Hanserecesse, I, vol. 3, n. 320; Kunze, Hansisches Urkundebuch, 253, n. 616.
(…) dat wij wullen keren unde varen unde doen (…) also lange alz man holdet unser privilegien (…); Hanserecesse, I, vol. 3, n. 105.
Ordonnances de Philippe le Hardi, 200–201; The promise of safe-conduct was usually repeated after a war; see for example in 1454; CAB, Political Charters, nr. 1064, CAB 96, Rodenboek, fol. 188v – 189r., and CAB 96, Gheluwenboek, fol. 24 r. – v.
Thielemans (1966).
(…) secundum legem scabinorum et terre (…); ADNB 504/1252–1253; Cordes (2013, 283–290).
Which was also according to Flemish custom, though the possession of these goods was claimed as part of the princely regalia; Sicking and De Klerk (2022, 207–209).
Van Houtte (1982, 96).
Ordonnances de Philippe le Hardi, 470–507.
CAB 216, Jaarrekeningen van Brugge, 1391–1392, fol. 87 r.
ADNB 6084, fol. 4 r. – v.
ARA 1504, CC, comptes en rouleaux. 1377–1378.
Inventaire des Chartes, vol. 3, 227, art. 6; Hanserecesse, vol. II, 1, 325 and 336. Inventaire des Chartes, vol. 3, 225, art. 2.; Hanserecesse, I, vol. 4, n. 39.
Hanserecesse, I, vol. 4, n. 39.
ADN B 6091, Accounts of the water bailiff, fol. 4 r.; ADN B 6095, Accounts of the water bailiff, fol. 3 r.
See Munro (1997, 44–47).
CAB 96, Oude Wittenboek, fol. 18 r.; Cartulaire de l’ancien staple, vol. 1, 228–230; “The Bruges privileges, 1359,” 199.
Que nulls Nouvelles coustumes aultres que on soloit user en l’ancien temps ne soient faictes ne ordonnees sur eulx ne sur leur avoir; Hansa: Hansische Urkundebuch, vol. II, 52–53; Spanish Cartulaire de l’ancien consulat d’Espagne, 11; Portugal: Ordonnances de Jean sans Peur, 225, art. 13.
Cauchies, Ordonnances, 40–41; 83–85; 253- 259; 297- 298; 319–324; CAB 96, Cartularium Oude Wittenboek, 46 r.; 46v.; 94 r. -95 v.; 96 r. – 97 r.; 183 v. – 184 r.
Inventaire des chartes, vol. 2, 496–499; Cartulaire, 23.
(…) Ou cas que en temps advenir nous plairont (…) pour aulcunes causes nous ad ce mouvans rappeler les previleges (…);Inventaire des chartes, 499; CAB, Spaans Consulaat, nr. 4.
Although in reality, privileges were often confirmed by a new count or duke.
In 1392 the Hanseatic merchants made sure that it was included that they could use these privileges (…) imperpetuum libere et pacifice fruantus eisdem (…);Ordonnances de Margheret de Male, 478.
Braekervelt (2009, 124–125).
CAB, Spaans consulaat, nr. 5; Inventaire des chartes, vol. 2, 498.
Dumolyn, Ryckbosch, and Speecke (2019, 341).
Hanserecesse, I, vol. 7, n. 437; Fris (1900, 32–61).
(…) dat in tiiden van node elc sculdich es met anderen te liedene ende niet te nausten te blivene bii den riguere van rechte, ende want te dier tijd groot ende swaer dierte ende ghebrec van coerne daer binnen den lande van Vlanderen was (…); Hanserecesse, II, vol. 1, 335.
They claimed that the Bruges city council saw the privileges ‘as breakable’ and as a consequence, they had large expenses in litigating before the court; Hanserecesse, II, 1, 66; In the context of the grain transport the Germans received the answer that (…) umme dat noed alle recht unde privilegien brekende were (…); Hanserecesse, II, vol. 7, 264, n. 438.
Handelingen van de Leden, vol. II, 1438–1467, 1056.
Handelingen van de Leden, vol. II, 1438–1467, 858; CAB, Political Charters, nr. 1039.
See for example: Handelingen van de leden, 389.
Other – more optimistic – reasons cannot be discarded. The Hansa proclaimed that these killings should be used to better the position of the Hanseatic merchant: (…) uppe dat de pyne des enen sii en vrucht veler ander (…); Hanserecesse, II, vol. 2,nr. 608; Hanserecesse, II, vol. 2, 492, n. 587.
Dumolyn (1996, 321).
See on banishment Frankot (2022).
CAB 96, Ouden Wittenboek, fol. 21 r. – v.
Ordonnances de Jean sans Peur, 255.
Maréchal (1953).
CAB 130, Poortersboeken, 1434–1450, fol. 65 r., 103 v.; CAB 130, Poortersboeken, 1454–1478, fol. 14 r., 40 r., 108 r.; CAB 130, Poortersboeken, 1479–1496, fol. 33 v.
See for a “free” citizenship on request op Pieter Bladelin; CAB 130, Poortersboeken, 1454–1478, fol. 67 r. See on the Burgundian official Bladelin Braekevelt (2012).
CAB 130, Poortersboeken, 1454–1478, fol. 34 v. and 103 v.
CAB 130, Poortersboeken, 1418–1434, fol. 8 r.
Hanserecesse, II, vol. 4, n. 162.
Hanserecesse, II, 4, n. 162.
Hanserecesse, II, 4, n. 162.
Although one of the concessions the duke wanted to give was a codification of all customs regarding commerce. Needless to say, the cities were no great fans; Hanserecesse, II, vol. 4, n 211.
Hanserecesse, II, 4, n. 444, p. 312, art. 5.; Hanserecesse, II, vol. 4, n. 444.
ASV, Misti Senato, vol. 15, fol. 5 r.
ASV, Commemoriali, N. 302, fol. 121 r. – v.
Handelingen van de leden (1384–1405). 429–430.
On the war against the succession of Maximilian of Austria see: Haemers (2014).
See for example the recognition of Bruges as a staple: CAB, Political charters, 1273; CAB 96 Cartularium Groenenboek B, fol. 107 v. – 108 v.
(…) laquelle sera réputée pour caution bourgoise (…); Consulat d’Espagne, 165, art. 8.
Consulat d’Espagne, 180, art. 31.
Cartulaire de l’ancien estaple, vol. I, 283–284.
Consulat d’Espagne, 161, art. 47, 48, 49; CAB 96, Cartularium Groenenboek B, fol. 165 v. – 166 r.
Cartulaire de l’Etaple, vol. I, 290.
CAB 96, Cartularium Groenenboek B, fol. 116 v – 117 r; Consulat d’Espagne, p. 156–157, art. 23, 24, 25.
The Castilian merchants were the exception and remained in the sixteenth century in Bruges; Phillips (1986, 41).
Literature
Baldwin J (2015) Due process in Magna Carta. Its sources in English law, canon law and Stephen Langton. In: Griffith-Jones R, Hill M (eds) Magna Carta. Religion and the Rule of Law, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 31–52
Barber BR (2013) If mayors ruled the world. Dysfunctional nations, rising cities. Yale University Press, New York
Beuken JHA (1950) Hanze en Vlaanderen. Van Aelst, Maastricht
Blackmore R (2020) The effects of commercial privileges in late medieval Bordeaux. Fr Hist 34:1–21
Blockmans WP, Prevenier W. (1999) The promised lands. The Low Countries under Burgundian Rule, 1369–1530. University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia
Blockmans WP (2022) Villes et monarchies: complémentarité et rivalité entre commerce et politique. Histoire Urbaine 2:7–30
Bolton JL, Guidi-Bruscoli F (2008) When did Antwerp replace Bruges as the commercial and financial centre of north-western Europe? The evidence of the Borromei ledger for 1438. Economic History Review 61:360–379
Boone M and Haemers J (2020) Bien commun. Gouvernance, discipline, culture politique. In: Billen C, Blondé B, Boone M, Van Bruaene AL (eds.), Faire société au Moyen Âge. Histoire urbaine des anciens Pays-bas (1100–1600), Classiques Garnier, Paris, pp 113–149
Boureau A (2018) Privilege in medieval societies from the twelfth to the fourteenth centuries, or: How the exception proves the rule. In: Lineham P, Nelson JL, Costambeys M (eds) The Medieval World. Routledge, London, pp 720–733
Bradley J and B Katz (2013) The metropolitan revolution: how cities and metros are fixing our broken politics and fragile economy. The Brookings Institutions, Washington D.C.
Braekevelt J (2009) Entre profit et dommage: présence et privilèges de la nation Génoise à Bruges sous les ducs de Bourgogne (1384–1477). Publications Du Centre Européen D’études Bourguignonnes 49:117–129
Camenisch C (2019) Cold, rain and famine. Three subsistence crises in the Burgundian Low Countries during the fifteenth century. In: Walton SA (ed) Fifty years of medieval technology and social change. Routledge, New York, pp 187–197
Canevaro M (2017) The rule of law as the measure of political legitimacy in the Greek city States. Hague Journal on the Rule of Law 9:211–236
Cordes A (2013) Litigating abroad: merchants’ expectations regarding procedure before foreign courts according to the Hanseatic privileges. In: Andersen P (ed.), Law and disputing in the Middle Ages: proceedings of the Ninth Carlsberg Academy Conference on medieval legal history 2012, JØF Pub., Copenhagen, pp 281–299
Curtis D, Dijkman J, Lambrecht T, Vanhaute E (2017) Famines in the Low Countries, fourteenth to nineteenth centuries. In: Alfani G, Grada CO (eds) Famines in European History. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 119–140
De Boodt M (2020) In het kader van het algemeen belang. Politieke ideeën in de Laatmiddeleeuwse Nederlanden. Madoc Tijdschrift over De Middeleeuwen 34:130–140
Dumolyn J (2008) Privileges and novelties: the political discourse of the Flemish cities and rural districts in their negotiations with the dukes of Burgundy. Urban History 35:5–23
Dumolyn J (2010) ‘Our land is only founded on trade and industry’: economic discourses in fifteenth-century Bruges. J Mediev Hist 36:374–389
Dumolyn J (2021) The common good. The central ideological signifier in Medieval politics. In D. Napolitano D, Pennington KJ (eds), A cultural history of democracy in the medieval age. Bloomsbury Academic age, London, pp 57 -74
Dumolyn J and Lambert,B (2014) Cities of commerce, cities of constraints. International trade, government institutions and the law of commerce in later medieval Bruges and the Burgundian state. TSEG – The Low Countries Journal of Social and Economic History 11:89–112
Dumolyn J (1997) De Brugse opstand van 1436–1438. UGA, Heule
Dumolyn J, Ryckbosch W, Speecke M (2019) Cycles of urban revolt in medieval Flanders. De economics of political conflict. In: Collavini SM, Petralia G (eds) La mobilià sociale nel Medioevo italiano. Viella, Rome, p 341
Dupuy M (1980) Le chaos d’où sortit la France. Le temps des Armagnacs et des Bourguignons (1380–1435), Perrin, Paris
Fris V (1900) Schets van den economischen toestand van Vlaanderen in het midden der 15de eeuw, Siffer, Gent
Gelderblom O (2013) Cities of commerce. The institutional foundations of international trade in the Low Countries, 1250–1650, Princeton University Press, Princeton
Glaeser E (2011) Triumph of the city: how our greatest invention makes us richer, smarter, greener, healthier, and happier. The Penguin Press, London
Godding P Les ordonnances des autorités urbaines au moyen âge. Leur apport à la technique législative. In Duvosquel JM, Thoen E (eds.), Peasants and townsmen in medieval Europe. Studia in Honorem Adriaan Verhulst Snoeck-Ducaju, Ghent, pp 185–204
Greif A, Milgrom P, Weingast BR (1994) Coordination, commitment and enforcement: the case of the merchant guild. J Polit Econ 102:746–776
Haemers J (2014) De strijd om het regentschap over Filips de Schone. Opstand facties en geweld in Brugge, Gent en Ieper (1482–1488). Academia Press, Gent
Haemers J (2004) De Gentse Opstand (1449–1453), de strijd tussen rivaliserende netwerken om het stedelijke kapitaal. UGA, Kortrijk
Haggard S, MacIntyre A, Tiede L (2008) The rule of law and economic development. Annual Review of Political Sciences 11:205–234
Maréchal J (1951) Le départ de Bruges des marchands étrangers. Handelingen Van Het Genootschap Voor Geschiedenis 88:26–74
Maréchal J (1953) La colonie espagnole de Bruges du XIVe au XVIe siècle. Revue Du Nord 35:5–40
Mareel S (2018) Mirrors of justice: justice panels in the Netherlands. In: Mareel, S (ed.), Call for justice: art and law in de Low Countries (1450–1650), Kannibal, Veurne, pp 40–62
Meirhenrich J (2021) Rechtsstaat versus the Rule of Law. In: Meierhenrich J, Loughin M (eds) The Cambridge Companion to the Rule of Law. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 39–67
Møller J (2017) Medieval origins of the rule of law: the Gregorian reforms as critical juncture? Hague Journal on the Rule of Law 9:265–282
Møller J, Skaaning SE (2013) Systematizing thin and thick conceptions of the rule of law. Justice Sytem Journal 33:136–153
Møller J, Skaaning SE (2014) The rule of law : definitions, measures, patterns and causes. Palgrave Macmillan, London
Munro J (1995) Anglo-Flemisch competition in the international cloth trade, 1340–1520. Publications Du Centre Européen D’études Bourguignonnes 35:37–60
Paravicini W (2006) Schuld und Sühne. Der Hansenmord zu Sluis in Flandern anno 1436. In: Baum HP, Leng R, Schneider J (eds), Wirtschaft-Gesellschaft-Mentalitäten im Mittelalter. Festschrift zum 75. Geburtstag von Rolf Sprandel, Hans Steiner Verlag, Stuttgart, pp 401–451
Phillips WD (1986) Local integration and long-distance ties: the Castilian community in Sixteenth-century Bruges. Sixteenth Century Journal 17:33–49
Prevenier W (2010) Utilitas communis in the Low Countries (thirteenth – fifteenth centuries), from social mobilisation to legitimation of power. In: Lecuppre-Desjardin E and Van Bruaene A-L (eds.), De Bono Communi. The discourse and practice of the common good in the European city (13th-16th c.), Brepols, Turnhout, pp 205–216
Sassen S (2020) Global insecurity and urban capabilities. In: Sassen S, Kaldor M (eds) Cities at war: global insecurity and urban resistance. Columbia University Press, New York, pp 1–24
Schnerb B (2005) Jean sans peur: le prince meurtrier. Paviot, Paris
Sicking L and De Klerk J (2022) The law of wrek in Flanders, Holland and Zeeland in the Late Middle Ages. In : Weede C, Stein R and Sicking L (eds), Communities, environment and regulation in the premodern world, Brepols, Turnhout, pp 201–232
Stein R (2017) Magnanimous dukes and rising states: the unification of the Burgundian Netherlands, 1380–1480. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Tamanaha B (2004) On the rule of law: history, politics, theory. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Tamanaha B (2012) The history and elements of the rule of law Singapore Journal for. Leg Stud 2012:237–247
Thielemans MR (1966) Bourgogne et Angleterre: relations politiques et économiques entre les Pays-Bas bourguignons et l’Angleterre, 1435–1467. Presses universitaires de Bruxelles, Brussels
Van Caenegem RC (1976) Le problème des chartes de libertés. In: Lousse E (ed) Etudes présentées à la commission pour l’histoire des assemblées d’Etats LVI. Les éditions de la librairie encyclopédique, Brussels, pp 3–15
Van Houtte JA (1982) De geschiedenis van Brugge. Lannoo, Tielt
Van Uytven R (1995) Stages of economic decline: late medieval Bruges. In: Duvosquel JM, Thoen E (eds), Peasants & townsmen in medieval Europe. Studia in honorem Adriaan Verhulst, Snoeck-Ducaju & zoon, Gent, pp 259–271
Vaughan R (1979) John the Fearless: the growth of Burgundian power. Longman, London
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Fieremans, N. A Primacy of Privileges? Urban Constitutionalism, the Rule of Law and Late Medieval Bruges. Hague J Rule Law 15, 243–262 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40803-023-00193-1
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40803-023-00193-1