Abstract
Past interpretations of the debate between Confucian meritocrats and Confucian democrats tend to center around abstract discussions of meritocratic versus democratic values. Yet, given the difficulties involved in settling on a common definition of “democracy” or “meritocracy,” such abstract discussions often end up talking past each other. In this article, I seek to offer a more precise framing of the debate by surveying the preferred institutional arrangement of one Confucian democrat, Sungmoon Kim, and that of two Confucian meritocrats, Daniel Bell and Tongdong Bai. What I find is that contrary to the claim made by Kim’s theory of pragmatic Confucian democracy, the electoral representative government he favors does not enjoy a legitimacy premium over the kind of hybrid regime envisioned by Bell or Bai under pluralistic societal circumstances. I further demonstrate that it is also difficult for Confucian democrats to justify electoral representative government through either the Confucian ideal of political relationship marked by the public’s willing endorsement of their rulers, or a notion of political equality reconstructed from Mencius’s inclusionary ideal of sagehood.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Albertus, Michael, and Victor Menaldo. 2016. “Capital in the Twenty-First Century—in the Rest of the World.” Annual Review of Political Science 19: 49–66.
Ames, Roger, and David Hall. 1999. The Democracy of the Dead: Dewey, Confucius, and the Hope for Democracy in China. Chicago: Open Court.
Angle, Stephen. 2012. Contemporary Confucian Political Philosophy. Cambridge: Polity.
Bai, Tongdong. 2008. “A Mencian Version of Limited Democracy.” Res Publica 14: 19–34.
______. 2013. “A Confucian Version of Hybrid Regime.” In The East Asian Challenge for Democracy: Political Meritocracy in Comparative Perspective, edited by Daniel A. Bell and Chenyang Li. New York: Cambridge University Press.
______. 2019. Against Political Equality: The Confucian Case. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Bell, Daniel A. 2006. Beyond Liberal Democracy: Political Thinking for an East Asian Context. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
______. 2015. The China Model: Political Meritocracy and the Limits of Democracy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Bell, Daniel A., and Wang Pei. 2020. Just Hierarchy: Why Social Hierarchies Matter in China and the Rest of the World. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Brennan, Jason. 2016. Against Democracy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Cammack, Daniela. 2021. “Representation in Ancient Greek Democracy.” History of Political Thought 42.4: 567–601.
Chan, Joseph. 2007. “Democracy and Meritocracy: Toward a Confucian Perspective.” Journal of Chinese Philosophy 34.2: 179–193.
______. 2014. Confucian Perfectionism: A Political Philosophy for Modern Times. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
______. “Kim, Sungmoon, Public Reason Confucianism: Democratic Perfectionism and Constitutionalism in East Asia.” Dao: A Journal of Comparative Philosophy 17.2: 291–295.
Distelhorst, Greg, and Yue Hou. 2017. “Constituency Service under Nondemocratic Rule: Evidence from China.” The Journal of Politics 79.3: 1024–1040.
Elstein, David. 2016. “The Future of Confucian Politics in East Asia.” Dao: A Journal of Comparative Philosophy 15.3: 437–445.
Ferejohn, John, and Francis Rosenbluth. 2009. “Electoral Representation and the Aristocratic Thesis.” In Political Representation, edited by Ian Shapiro, Susan C. Stokes, Elizabeth Jean Wood, and Alexander S. Kirshner. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Fishkin, James S. 2018. Democracy When the People Are Thinking. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Gallie, Walter B. 1956. “Essentially Contested Concepts.” Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 56: 167–198.
Green, Jeffrey. 2016. The Shadow of Unfairness: A Plebian Theory of Liberal Democracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Guerrero, Alex. 2014. “Against Elections: The Lottocratic Alternative.” Philosophy and Public Affairs 42.2: 135–178.
______. 2021. “The Epistemic Pathologies of Elections and the Epistemic Promise of Lottocracy.” In Political Epistemology, edited by Elizabeth Edenberg and Michael Hannon. New York: Oxford University Press.
Hansen, Mogens Herman. 1991. The Athenian Democracy in the Age of Demosthenes: Structures, Principles and Ideology. Oxford and Cambridge: Blackwell.
Huang, Yong. 2019. “Bell’s Model of Meritocracy for China: Two Confucian Amendments.” Philosophy East and West 69.2: 559–568.
Jiang, Qing. 2013. A Confucian Constitutional Order: How China’s Ancient Past Can Shape Its Political Future, edited by Daniel A. Bell and Ruiping Fan, and translated by Edmund Ryden. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Jin, Yutang. 2021a. “Classic Confucian Thought and Political Meritocracy: A Text-based Critique.” Dao: A Journal of Comparative Philosophy 20.3: 433–458.
______. 2021b. “Confucian Leadership Democracy: A Roadmap.” Comparative Philosophy 12.2: 79–102.
Kim, Sungmoon. 2013. “To Become a Confucian Democratic Citizen: Against Meritocratic Elitism.” British Journal of Political Science 43: 579–599.
______. 2014. Confucian Democracy in East Asia: Theory and Practice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
______. 2016. Public Reason Confucianism: Democratic Perfectionism and Constitutionalism in East Asia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
______. 2017. “Confucian Authority, Political Right, and Democracy.” Philosophy East and West 67.1: 3– 14.
______. 2018. Democracy After Virtue: Toward Pragmatic Confucian Democracy. New York: Oxford University Press
______. 2022. “Service, Reciprocity, and Remedy: From Confucian Meritocracy to Confucian Democracy.” European Journal of Political Theory. https://doi.org/10.1177/14748851221127689 (last accessed on October 12, 2023).
Knight, Jack, and James Johnson. 2011. The Priority of Democracy: Political Consequences of Pragmatism. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Landemore, Hélène. 2013. Democratic Reason: Politics, Collective Intelligence, and the Rule of the Many. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
______. 2020. Open Democracy: Reinventing Popular Rule for the Twenty-First Century. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Lei, Ya-Wen. 2018. The Contentious Public Sphere: Law, Media, and Authoritarian Rule in China. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Li, Chenyang. 2012. “Equality and Inequality in Confucianism.” Dao: A Journal of Comparative Philosophy 11.3: 295–313.
______. 2019. “Missing Links in the China Model.” Philosophy East and West 69.2: 568–576.
Macedo, Stephen. 2013. “Meritocratic Democracy: Learning from the American Constitution.” In The East Asian Challenge for Democracy: Political Meritocracy in Comparative Perspective, edited by Daniel A. Bell and Chenyang Li. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Manin, Bernard. 1997. The Principles of Representative Government. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Montanaro, Laura. 2012. “The Democratic Legitimacy of Self-Appointed Representatives.” Journal of Politics 74.4: 1094–1107.
Przeworski, Adam. 2010. Democracy and the Limits of Self-Government. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Przeworski, Adam, Michael Alvarez, Jose Cheibub, and Fernando Limongi. 2000. Democracy and Development. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sabl, Andrew. 2017. “Realist Liberalism: An Agenda.” Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 20.3: 349–364.
Saward, Michael. 2010. The Representative Claim. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Shin, Doh Chull. 2011. Confucianism and Democratization in East Asia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sintomer, Yves. 2018. “From Deliberative to Radical Democracy? Sortition and Politics in the Twenty-First Century.” Politics and Society 46.3: 337–357.
Sintomer, Yves, and Yunyun Zhou. 2019. “‘Representation’ and Daibiǎo: A Comparative Study of the Notions of Political Representation in France and China.” Journal of Chinese Governance 4.4: 362–389.
Snyder, Jack. 2000. From Voting to Violence: Democratization and Nationalist Conflict. New York: W. W. Norton.
Tan, Sor-hoon. 2004. Confucian Democracy: A Deweyan Reconstruction. Albany: SUNY Pres.
Urbinati, Nadia. 2006. Representative Democracy: Principles and Genealogy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Van Reybrouck, David. 2016. Against Elections: The Case for Democracy. London: Bodley Head.
Waldron, Jeremy. 1999. Law and Disagreement. Oxford: Oxford University Pres.
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank Yutang Jin, Jiafeng Zhu, Yutao Zhao and two anonymous reviewers for their critical comments. The research for this essay was supported by National Social Science Fund of China (Grant number: 21CZZ010).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Declaration
The author declares that there is no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Tong, Z. Can Pragmatic Confucian Democracy Justify Electoral Representative Government?. Dao 23, 1–24 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11712-023-09917-4
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11712-023-09917-4