Abstract
At the beginning of the twentieth century, the biologist Joseph Grinnell made a distinction between science and sentiment for producing fact-based generalizations on how to conserve biodiversity. We are inspired by Grinnellian science, which successfully produced a century-long impact on studying and conserving biodiversity that runs orthogonal to some familiar philosophical distinctions such as fact versus value, emotion versus reason and basic versus applied science. According to Grinnell, unlike sentiment-based generalizations, a fact-based generalization traces its diverse commitments and thus becomes tractable for its audience. We argue that foregrounding tractability better explains Grinnell’s practice in the context of his time as well as in the context of current discourse among scientists over the political “biases” of biodiversity research and its problem of “reproducibility.”
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alagona, P. S. 2012. “A Sanctuary for Science: The Hastings Natural History Reservation and the Origins of the University of California’s Natural Reserve System.” Journal of the History of Biology 45: 651–680.
Baker, M. 2015. “Reproducibility Crisis: Blame It on the Antibodies.” Nature 521: 274–276.
Becker, H. S. 1998. Tricks of the Trade: How to Think About Your Research While You’re Doing It. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
Bock, C. H. 1997. “The Role of Ornithology in Conservation of the American West.” The Condor 99: 1–6.
Barrow, M. V. 2009. Nature’s Ghosts: Confronting Extinction from the Age of Jefferson to the Age of Ecology. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.
Botkin, D. B. et al. 2007. “Forecasting the Effects of Global Warming in Biodiversity.” BioScience 57: 227–236.
Brown, J. H. and Sax, D. F. 2005. “Biological Invasions and Scientific Objectivity: Reply to Cassey et al. 2005.” Austral Ecology 30: 481–483.
Butterworth, D. S. 1992. “Science and Sentimentality.” Nature 357: 532–534.
Californians Inc. 1922. California, Where Life is Better. San Francisco, CA: Taylor & Taylor.
Convention on Biological Diversity (with Annexes). Concluded at Rio de Janeiro June 5 1992, No. 30619, vol. 1760, I-30619. http://www.cbd.int/convension/convention/shtml. Accessed 12 October 2010.
Cartwright, N. 2007. “Causal Powers: What are They? Why Do We Need Them? What Can and Cannot be Done with them?” D. Fennell (ed.), Contingency and Dissent in Science Series. London, UK: Centre for Philosophy of Natural and Social Science, LSE.
Coates, P. A. 2006. American Perceptions of Immigrant and Invasive Species: Strangers on the Land. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Coues, E. and Prentiss, D. W. 1877. “Remarks on Birds of the District of Columbia.” Field and forest 2: 191–193.
Editorial. 2014. “Journals Unite for Reproducibility.” Nature 515(7525): 7.
Elgin, C. Z. 1996. Considered Judgment. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Farber, P. L. 2000. Finding Order in Nature: The Naturalist Tradition from Linnaeus to E. O. Wilson. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
Fine, G. A. and Christoforides, L. 1991. “Dirty Birds, Filthy Immigrants, and the English Sparrow War: Metaphorical Linkage in Constructing Social Problems.” Symbolic Interaction 14: 375–393.
Gannett, L. and Griesemer, J. R. 2004. “The ABO Blood Groups: Mapping the History and Geography of Genes in Homo sapiens.” H.-J. Rheinberger and J.-P. Gaudilliere (eds.), Mapping Cultures of Twentieth Century Genetics. New York, NY: Routledge, pp. 119–172.
Gerson, E. M. 1998. The American System of Research: Evolutionary Biology 1890–1950. PhD. Dissertation, University of Chicago.
Goethe, C. M. 1930. “Immigration from Mexico.” M. Grant and C. S. Davison (eds.), The Alien in Our Midst. New York: Galton, pp. 122–130.
Griesemer, J. R. 1990. “Modeling in the Museum: On the Role of Remnant Models in the Work of Joseph Grinnell.” Biology & Philosophy 5(1): 3–36.
Griesemer, J. R. 1992. “Niche: Historical Perspectives.” E. F. Keller and E. S. Lloyd (eds.), Key Words in Evolutionary Biology. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, pp. 231–240.
Griesemer, J. R. and Gerson, E. 1993. “Collaboration in the Museum of Vertebrate Zoology.” Journal of the History of Biology 26: 185–203.
Grinnell, H. 1940. “Joseph Grinnell: 1877–1939.” The Condor 17: 3–34.
Grinnell, H.. 1943. “Bibliography of Clinton Hart Merriam.” Journal of Mammalogy 24: 436–457.
Grinnell, J. 1910. “The Methods and Uses of a Research Museum.” The Popular Science Monthly 77: 163–169.
Grinnell, J.. 1915. “Conserve the Collector.” Science 41: 229–232.
Grinnell, J.. 1917a. “The Niche-Relationships of the California Thrasher.” The Auk 34: 427–433.
Grinnell, J.. 1917b. “Field Tests of Theories Concerning Distributional Control.” The American Naturalist 51: 115–128.
Grinnell, J.. 1919 [1943]. “The English Sparrow Has Arrived in Death Valley: An Experiment in Nature.” A. H. Miller (ed.), Joseph Grinnells Philosophy of Nature. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Grinnell, J.. 1922 [1943]. “The Trends of Avian Populations in California.” A. H. Miller (ed.), Joseph Grinnell’s Philosophy of Nature. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Grinnell, J.. 1924a [1943]. “Geography and Evolution.” A. H. Miller (ed.), Joseph Grinnell’s Philosophy of Nature. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Grinnell, J.. 1924b [1943]. “Bird Netting as a Method in Ornithology.” A. H. Miller (ed.), Joseph Grinnell’s Philosophy of Nature. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Grinnell, J.. 1925 [1943]. “A Conservationist's Creed as to Wild-life Administration.” A. H. Miller (ed.), Joseph Grinnell’s Philosophy of Nature. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
Grinnell, J.. 1933. “Review of the Recent Mammal Fauna of California.” University of California Publications in Zoology 40: 71–234.
Grinnell, J. and Storer, T. I. 1916. “Animal Life as an Asset of National Parks.” Science 44: 375–380.
Grinnell, J. and Storer, T. I.. 1917. “The Yosemite Cony – A Chapter in the Natural History of the Yosemite National Park.” Sierra Club Bulletin 10: 159–164.
Grinnell, J. and Storer, T. I.. 1924. Animal Life in the Yosemite, an Account of the Mammals, Birds, Reptiles and Amphibians in a Cross-Section of the Sierra Nevada. Oakland, CA: University of California Press.
Grinnell, J., Dixon, J. and Linsdale, J. M. 1930. “Vertebrate Natural History of a Section of Northern California Through the Lassen Peak Region.” University of California Publications in Zoology 35: 1–594.
Hays, S. 1959. Conservation and the Gospel of Efficiency: The Progressive Conservation Movement 1890–1920. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Johnson, K. 2004. “The Ibis: Transformations in a Twentieth Century British Natural History Journal.” Journal of the History of Biology 37: 515–555.
Johnson, K.. 2005. “Type-Specimens of Birds as Sources for the History of Ornithology.” Journal of the History of Collections. 17: 173–188.
Johnson, K.. 2012. Ordering Life: Karl Jordan and the Naturalist Tradition. Baltimore, Maryland: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Jordan, D. S. 1908. “The Law of Germinate Species.” The American Naturalist 24: 73–80.
Kohler, R. E. 2002. Landscapes and Labscapes. Exploring the Lab-Field Border in Biology. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
Kohler, R. E.. 2006. All Creatures: Naturalists, Collectors, and Biodiversity, 1850–1950. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Kohler, R. E.. 2012. “Practice and Place in Twentieth-Century Field Biology: A Comment.” Journal of the History of Biology 45: 579–586.
Larson, B. M. H. 2005. “The War of the Roses: Demilitarizing Invasion Biology.” Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 3: 495–500.
Larson, B. M. H.. 2007. “An Alien Approach to Invasive Species: Objectivity and Society in Invasion Biology.” Biological Invasions 9: 947–956.
Leonelli, S. 2009. “On the Locality of Data and Claims About Phenomena.” Philosophy of Science 76: 737–749.
Leonelli, S.. 2010. “Packaging Data for Re-Use: Databases in Model Organism Biology.” P. Howlett and M. S. Morgan (eds.), How Well Do Facts Travel? The Dissemination of Reliable Knowledge. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press, pp. 325–349.
Latour, B. 1987. Science in Action. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Latour, B.. 1999. Pandora’s Hope, Essays on the Reality of Science Studies. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Longino, H. E. 1990. Science as Social Knowledge: Values and Objectivity in Scientific Inquiry. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Longino, H. E.. 2004. “How Values can be Good for Science.” P. Machamer and G. Wolters (eds.), Science, Values and Objectivity. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press, pp. 127–142.
Lutts, R. H. 1990. The Nature Fakers: Wildlife, Science and Sentiment. Goldon, CO: Fulcrum.
Maclaurin, J. and Sterelny, K. 2008. What is Biodiversity?. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
Martin, J. W. 2010. “Compatibility of Major U.S. Christian Denominations with Evolution.” Evolution: Education and Outreach 3(3): 420–431.
Mcnutt, M. 2014. “Journals Unite for Reprodocibility.” Science 326(6210): 679.
Moritz, Craig. et al. 2008. “Impact of a Century of Climate Change on Small-Mammal Communities in Yosemite National Park, USA.” Science 332: 261–264.
Odenbaugh, J. 2003. “Value, Advocacy, and Conservation Biology.” Environmental Values 12: 55–69
Oelschlaeger, B. D. 1996. “A Science for Survival: Values and Conservation Biology.” Conservation Biology 10: 905–911.
Oreskes, N. 1996. “Objectivity or Heroism? On the Invisibility of Women in Science.” Osiris 11: 87–113
Peretti, J. H. 1998. “Nativism and Nature: Rethinking Biological Invasion.” Environmental Values 7: 183–192
Perrine, J. D. and Patton, J. R. 2011. “Letters to the Future: Field Notes and the Grinnell Resurvey Project.” M. R. Canfield (ed.), Field Notes on Science & Nature. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Price, J. 1999. Flight Maps: Adventures with Nature in Modern America. New York, NY: Basic Books.
Provine, W. B. 1979. “Francis B. Sumner and the Evolutionary Synthesis.” Studies in History of Biology 3: 211–240.
Rader, K. A. and Cain, V. E. M. 2008. “From Natural History to Science: Display and the Transformation of American Museums of Science and Nature.” Museum and Society. 6(2): 152–171.
Reiger, J. 1975. American Sportsmen and the Origins of Conservation. New York, NY: Winchester Press.
Runte, A. 1993. “Joseph Grinnell and Yosemite: Rediscovering the Legacy of a California Conservationist.” R. J. Orsi, A. Runte and M. Smith-Baranzini (eds.), Yosemite and Sequoia: A Century of California National Parks. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, pp. 85–95.
Russell, J. F. 2013. “If a Job is Worth Doing, It is Worth Doing Twice.” Nature 496: 7.
Sarkar, S. 2005. Biodiversity and Environmental Philosophy, An Introduction. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
Shavit, A. and Ellison A. M. (eds.). 2017. Stepping in the Same River Twice: Replication in Biological Research. New Haven: Yale University Press
Shavit, A. and Griesemer J.R. 2009. “There and Back, or, The Problem of Locality in Biodiversity Research”, Philosophy of Science 76: 273–294
Shavit, A. and Griesemer, J. R. 2011. “Transforming Objects into Data: How Minute Technicalities of Recording ‘Species Location’ Entrench a Basic Challenge for Biodiversity.” M. Carrier and A. Nordmann (eds.), Science in the Context of Application. Dordrecht: Springer, pp. 169–196.
Shrader-Frechette, K. S. and McCoy, E. D. 1993. Method in Ecology: Strategies for Conservation. Cambrdige, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Smith, M. L. 1987. Pacific Visions: California Scientists and the Environment, 1850–1915. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Star, S. L. and Griesemer, J. R. 1989. “Institutional Ecology, “Translations”, and Boundary Objects: Amateurs and Professionals in Berkeley’s Museum of Vertebrate Zoology.” Social Studies of Science 13: 205–228.
Stein, B. R. 2001. On Her Own Terms: Annie Montague Alexander and the Rise of Science in the American West. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
Strasser, B. J. 2008. “GenBank – Natural History of the 21st Century?” Science 322: 537–538.
Strasser, B. J.. 2010. “Collecting, Comparing, and Computing Sequences: The Making of Margaret O. Dayhoff’s Atlas of Protein Sequence and Structure 1945–1965.” Journal of the History of Biology 43(4): 623–660.
Sunderland, M. E. 2011. “Teaching Natural History at the Museum of Vertebrate Zoology.” British Journal for the History of Science. 46(1): 97–121
Strasser, B. J.. 2012. “Collections-Based Research at Berkeley’s Museum of Vertebrate Zoology.” Historical Studies in the Natural Sciences 42(2): 83–113.
Sunderland, M.. 2013a. “Modernizing Natural History: Berkeley’s Museum of Vertebrate Zoology in Transition.” Journal of the History of Biology 46(3): 369–400.
Sunderland, M.. 2013b. “Computerizing Natural History Collections.” Endeavour 37(3): 150–161.
Takacs, D. 1996. The Idea of Biodiversity: Philosophies of Paradise. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
Tester, K. 2015. Animals and Society: The Humanity of Animal Rights. New York, NY: Routledge.
Tingley, M. W., Monahan, W. B., Beissinger, S. B. and Moritz, C. 2009. “Birds Track Their Grinnellian Niche Through a Century of Climate Change.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 106(supplement 2): 19637–19643.
Walcott, C. D. (ed.). 1897. A Memorial of George Brown Goode, Together with a Selection of his Papers on Museums and on the History of Science in America. Washington: U.S. Government Printing Office.
Wilson, E. O. 1992. The Diversity of Life. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Yandow, L. H., Chalfoun, A. D. and Doak, D. F. 2015. “Climate Tolerances and Habitat Requirements Jointly Shape the Elevation Distribution of the American Pika (Ochotona princeps), with Implications for Climate Change Effects.” PloS ONE 10(8): e0131082.
Yochelson, E. L. 2001. Smithsonian Institution Secretary, Charles Doolittle Walcott. Kent, Ohio: Kent State University Press.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Shavit, A., Griesemer, J.R. Science and Sentiment: Grinnell’s Fact-Based Philosophy of Biodiversity Conservation. J Hist Biol 51, 283–318 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-017-9489-4
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-017-9489-4