Abstract
The formal methods of the representational theory of measurement (RTM) are applied to the extensive scales of physical science, with some modifications of interpretation and of formalism. The interpretative modification is in the direction of theoretical realism rather than the narrow empiricism which is characteristic of RTM. The formal issues concern the formal representational conditions which extensive scales should be assumed to satisfy; I argue in the physical case for conditions related to weak rather than strong extensive measurement, in the sense of Holman 1969 and Colonius 1978. The problem of justifying representational conditions is addressed in more detail than is customary in the RTM literature; this continues the study of the foundations of RTM begun in an earlier paper. The most important formal consequence of the present interpretation of physical extensive scales is that the basic existence and uniqueness properties of scales (representation theorem) may be derived without appeal to an Archimedean axiom; this parallels a conclusion drawn by Narens for representations of qualitative probability. It is concluded that there is no physical basis for postulation of an Archimedean axiom.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adams, E.: 1979, ‘Measurement Theory’, in P. Asquith and H. Kyburg, (eds.), Current Research in Philosophy of Science, Philosophy of Science Association, East Lansing, Michigan, 207–227.
Behrend, F. A.: 1962, ‘A Characterization of Vector Spaces over Fields of Real Numbers’, Mathematische Zeitschrift 78, 298–304.
Bell, J. L. and A. B. Slomson: 1969, Models and Ultraproducts, North-Holland Publ. Co., Amsterdam.
Campbell, N.: 1920, Physics: the Elements, Harvard University Press, Cambridge. (Reprinted by Dover as Foundations of Science, 1957.)
Colonius, H.: 1978, ‘On Weak Extensive Measurement’, Philosophy of Science 45, 303–308.
Field, H.: 1980, Science Without Numbers, Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton.
Fishburn, P. C.: 1985, Interval Orders and Interval Graphs, Wiley, New York.
Fuchs, L.: 1963, Partially Ordered Algebraic Systems, Addison Wesley, Reading, Massachusetts.
Helmholtz, H.: 1887, ‘Numbering and Measuring from an Epistemological Viewpoint’, English translation in Helmholtz, H., Epistemological Writings, Reidel, Dordrecht, 1977.
Hölder, O.: 1901, ‘Die Axiome der Quantität und die Lehre vom Mass’, Berichte über die Verhandlungen der Königliche Sachsischen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Leipzig, Matematisch-Physische Klasse 53, 1–64.
Holman, E. W.: 1969, ‘Strong and Weak Extensive Measurement’, Journal of Mathematical Psychology 6, 286–293.
Krantz, D.: 1967, ‘Extensive Measurement in Semiorders’, Philosophy of Science 34, 348–62.
Krantz, D.: 1973, ‘Fundamental Measurement of Force and Newton's First and Second Laws of Motion’, Philosophy and Science 40, 481–495.
Krantz, D., R. D. Luce, P. Suppes and A. Tversky: 1971, Foundations of Measurement, Vol. 1, Academic Press, New York.
Luce, R. D.: 1956, ‘Semiorders and a Theory of Utility Discrimination’, Econometrica 24, 178–191.
Luce, R. D.: 1971, ‘Similar Systems and Dimensionally Invariant Laws’, Philosophy of Science 38, 157–169.
Luce, R. D.: 1973, ‘Three Axiom Systems for Additive Semiordered Structures’, SIAM Journal of Applied Mathematics 25, 41–53.
Luce, R. D.: 1978, ‘Dimensionally Invariant Numerical Laws Correspond to Meaningful Qualitative Relations’, Philosophy of Science 45, 1–16.
Mundy, B.: (a), 1986, ‘On the General Theory of Meaningful Representation’, Synthese 67, 391–437.
Mundy, B.: (b) ‘Extensive Measurement and Ratio Functions’, forthcoming in Synthese.
Mundy, B.: (c) ‘The Metaphysics of Quantity’, forthcoming in Phil. Studies.
Narens, L.: 1974a, ‘Minimal Conditions for Additive Conjoint Measurement and Qualitative Probability’, Journal of Mathematical Psychology 11, 404–430.
Narens, L.: 1974b, ‘Measurement without Archimedean Axioms’, Philosophy of Science 41, 374–93.
Narens, L.: 1980, ‘On Qualitative Axiomatizations for Probability Theory’, Journal of Philosophical Logic 9, 143–151.
Narens, L.: 1985, Abstract Measurement Theory, MIT Press, Cambridge.
Roberts, F.: 1979, Measurement Theory, Encyclopedia of Mathematics and its Applications, vol. 7, Addison Wesley, Reading, Massachusetts.
Roberts, F. and R. D. Luce: 1968, ‘Axiomatic Thermodynamics and Extensive Measurement’, Synthese 18, 311–326.
Scott, D. and P. Suppes: 1958, ‘Foundational Aspects of Theories of Measurement’, Journal of Symbolic Logic 23, 113–128.
Shoenfield, J. P.: 1967, Mathematical Logic, Addison Wesley, Reading. Mass.
Stevens, S. S.: 1946, ‘On the Theory of Scales of Measurement’, Science 103, 677–680.
Van Fraassen, B.: 1980, The Scientific Image, Oxford.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mundy, B. Faithful representation, physical extensive measurement theory and Archimedean axioms. Synthese 70, 373–400 (1987). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00414156
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00414156