Abstract
This chapter provides an overview of theory and empirical evidence on earnings discrimination within the workplace. Earnings discrimination occurs when employees producing work of equal value are differentially remunerated because of their social group. The chapter reviews theories of why employers may discriminate in this way. The chapter then goes on to review research evidence on earnings discrimination as one source of earnings inequality within the workplace. The ability of empirical studies to identify discrimination is discussed, and evidence on the mechanisms through which discrimination may affect earnings is reviewed, covering observational and experimental studies. The research evidence is most plentiful in respect of discrimination by gender. Accordingly, much of the discussion focuses on the role of discrimination in driving a wedge between the wages of men and women. However, the chapter also reviews evidence on earnings discrimination by race or ethnic group. The chapter concludes with a discussion of policy responses.
References
Abowd JM, Kramarz F, Margolis DN (1999) High wage workers and high wage firms. Econometrica 67(2):251–333
Arrow K (1973) The theory of discrimination. In: Ashenfelter O, Rees A (eds) Discrimination in labor markets. Princeton University Press, Princeton/Oxford, pp 3–33
Bachmann E (2022) $70 million verdict against Texas company in employment discrimination case. Forbes, 21st March 2022. Available online at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/ericbachman/2022/03/21/70-million-verdict-against-texas-company-in-employment-discrimination-case/?sh=62775ca32ea8. Retrieved 4th May 2022
Baker M, Halberstam Y, Kroft K, Mas A, Messacar D (2022) Pay transparency and the gender gap. Am Econ J Appl Econ (forthcoming). https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/app.20210141&from=f
Barth E, Bryson A, Davis JC, Freeman R (2016) It’s where you work: increases in the dispersion of earnings across establishments and individuals in the United States. J Labor Econ 34(S2):S67–S97
Bartolucci C (2013) Gender wage gaps reconsidered: a structural approach using matched employer-employee data. J Hum Resour 48(4):998–1034
Bayard K, Hellerstein J, Neumark D, Troske K (2003) New evidence on sex segregation and sex differences in wages from matched employer-employee data. J Labor Econ 21(4):887–922
Becker G (1971) The economics of discrimination, 2nd edn. University of Chicago Press, Chicago/London
Beller AH (1982) The impact of equal opportunity policy on sex differentials in earnings and occupations. Am Econ Rev 72(2):171–175
Benard S, Correll SJ (2010) Normative discrimination and the motherhood penalty. Gend Soc 24(5):616–646
Bennedsen M, Simintzi E, Tsoutsoura M, Wolfenzon D (2022) Do firms respond to gender pay gap transparency? J Financ. https://doi.org/10.1111/jofi.13136. (forthcoming)
Bezrukova K, Spell CS, Perry JL, Jehn KA (2016) A meta-analytical integration of over 40 years of research on diversity training evaluation. Psychol Bull 142(11):1227–1274
Blau FD, DeVaro J (2007) New evidence on gender differences in promotion rates: an empirical analysis of a sample of new hires. Ind Rel: J Econ Soc 46(3):511–550
Blau FD, Kahn L (2017) The gender wage gap: extent, trends, and explanations. J Econ Lit 55(3):789–865
Blundell J (2021) Wage responses to gender pay gap reporting requirements. CEP discussion paper no. 1750. Centre for Economic Performance, London
Bodvarsson ŐB, Papps KL, Sessions JG (2014) Cross-assignment discrimination in pay: a test case of major league baseball. Labour Econ 28:84–95
Bohren JA, Haggag K, Imas A Pope DG (2019a) Inaccurate statistical discrimination: an identification problem. Working paper no. 25935. National Bureau of Economic Research
Bohren JA, Imas A, Rosenberg M (2019b) The dynamics of discrimination: theory and evidence. Am Econ Rev 109(10):3395–3436
Bruns B (2019) Changes in workplace heterogeneity and how they widen the gender wage gap. Am Econ J Appl Econ 11(2):74–113
Card D, Cardoso AR, Kline P (2016) Bargaining, sorting, and the gender wage gap: quantifying the impact of firms on the relative pay of women. Q J Econ 131(2):633–686
Cardoso AR, Winter-Ebmer R (2010) Female-led firms and gender wage policies. ILL Rev 64(1):143–163
Cardoso AR, Guimaraes P, Portugal P (2016) What drives the gender wage gap? A look at the role of firm and job title heterogeneity. Oxf Econ Pap 68(2):506–524
Carrington W, Troske KR (1998) Interfirm segregation and the black/white wage gap. J Labor Econ 16(2):231–260
Casarico A, Lattanzio S (2019) What firms do: gender inequality in linked employer-employee data. Cambridge-INET working paper series no: 2019/15. Work INPS papers n. 24
Castilla EJ (2008) Gender, race and meritocracy in organizational careers. Am J Sociol 113(6):1479–1526
Correll SJ, Benard S, Paik I (2007) Getting a job: is there a motherhood penalty? Am J Sociol 112(5):1297–1338
Coudin E, Maillard S, To M (2018) Family, firms and the gender wage gap in France. IFS working paper W18/01
Criscuolo C, Hijzen A, Schwellnus C, Barth E, Chen WH, Fabling R, Fialho P, Grabska K, Kambayashi R, Leidecker T, Skans ON, Riom C, Roth D, Stadler B, Upward R, Zwysen W (2020) Workforce composition, productivity and pay: the role of firms in wage inequality. IZA working paper no. 13212
Cullen ZB, Perez-Truglia R (2019) The old boys’ club: schmoozing and the gender gap. Working paper no. 26530. National Bureau of Economic Research
De Paola M, Scoppa V (2015) Gender discrimination and evaluators’ gender: evidence from Italian academia. Economica 82:162–188
De Paola M, Ponzo M, Scoppa V (2018) Are men given priority for top jobs? Investigating the glass ceiling in Italian academia. J Hum Cap 12(3):475–503
Di Addario SL, Kline PM, Saggio R, Sølvsten M (2022) It ain’t where you’re from, it’s where you’re at: hiring origins, firm heterogeneity, and wages. J Econ. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jeconom.2021.12.017
Dittrich M, Knabe A, Leipold K (2014) Gender differences in experimental wage negotiations. Econ Inq 52(2):862–873
Drolet M, Mumford K (2012) The gender pay gap for private-sector employees in Canada and Britain. Br J Ind Relat 50(3):529–553
Egan M, Matvos G, Seru A (2022) When Harry fired Sally: the double standard in punishing misconduct. J Polit Econ 130(5). https://doi.org/10.1086/718964. (forthcoming)
Elvira M, Town R (2001) The effects of race and worker productivity on performance evaluations. Ind Rel J Econ Soc 40(4):571–590
Forth J, Theodoropoulos N, Bryson A (2021) The role of the workplace in ethnic wage differentials. IZA discussion paper 14697
Fryer RG, Pager D, Spenkuch JL (2013) Racial disparities in job finding and offered wages. J Law Econ 56(3):633–689
Gallen Y, Lesner RV, Vejlin R (2019) The labor market gender gap in Denmark: sorting out the past 30 years. Labour Econ 56:58–67
Giuliano L, Leonard J, Levine DI (2011) Racial bias in the manager-employee relationship: an analysis of quits, dismissals and promotions at a large retail firm. J Hum Resour 46(1):26–52
Goldin C (2014) A grand gender convergence: its last chapter. Am Econ Rev 104(4):1091–1119
Goldin C, Katz L (2016) The most egalitarian of all professions: pharmacy and the evolution of family-friendly occupations. J Labor Econ 34(3):705–716
Hara H (2018) The gender wage gap across the wage distribution in Japan: within and between-establishment effects. Labour Econ 53:213–229
Hellerstein J, Neumark D (2008) Workplace segregation in the United States: race, ethnicity, and skill. Rev Econ Stat 90(3):459–477
Hellerstein JK, Neumark D, Troske KR (1999) Wages, productivity, and worker characteristics: evidence from plant-level production functions and wage equations. J Labor Econ 17(3):409–446
Heywood J, Parent D (2012) Performance pay and the black-white wage gap. J Labor Econ 30(2):249–290
Heywood J, Theodoropoulos N (2020) The declining influence of workplace differences on the gender wage gap. Econ Bull 42(2):1194–1200
Holmes P (2011) New evidence of salary discrimination in major league baseball. Labour Econ 18(3):320–331
Hsieh CT, Hurst E, Jones CI, Klenow PJ (2019) The allocation of talent and US economic growth. Econometrica 87(5):1439–1474
Javdani M (2015) Glass ceiling or glass doors? The role of firms in male-female wage disparities. Can J Econ 48(2):529–560
Jewell SL, Razzu G, Singleton C (2020) Who works for whom and the UK gender pay gap. Br J Ind Relat 58(1):50–81
Johnson C, Minuci E (2020) Wage discrimination in the NBA: evidence using free agent signings. South Econ J 87(2):517–539
Kahnemann D (2011) Thinking fast and slow. Macmillan
Kalev A, Dobbin F, Kelly E (2006) Best practices or best guesses? Assessing the efficacy of corporate affirmative action and diversity policies. Am Sociol Rev 71(4):589–617
Kline PM, Rose EK, Walters CR (2022) Systemic discrimination among large U.S. employers. Q J Econ. https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjac024. (forthcoming)
Kunze A, Miller AR (2017) Women helping women? Evidence from private sector data on workplace hierarchies. Rev Econ Stat 99(5):769–775
Lazear EP, Rosen S (1990) Male-female wage differentials in job ladders. J Labor Econ 8(1, Part 2):S106–S123
Le Barbanchon T, Rachelot R, Roulet A (2021) Gender differences in job search: trading off commute against wage. Q J Econ 136(1):381–426
Leibbrandt A, List JA (2015) Do women avoid salary negotiations? Evidence from a large-scale natural field experiment. Manag Sci 61(9):2016–2024
Lerner JS, Tetlock PE (1999) Accounting for the effects of accountability. Psychol Bull 125(2):255–275
Longhi S (2020) Racial wage differentials in developed countries. World of Labor
Lucifora C, Vigani D (2022) What if your boss is a woman? Evidence on gender discrimination at the workplace. Rev Econ Househ 20:389–417
Madden JF (2012) Performance-support bias and the gender pay gap among stockbrokers. Gend Soc 26(3):488–518
Madden JF, Vekker A (2017) Output-based performance pay, performance-support bias, and the racial pay gap within a large retail stock brokerage. Ind Rel: J Econ Soc 56(4):662–687
Makepeace G, Paci P, Joshi H, Dolton P (1999) How unequally has equal pay progressed since the 1970s? A study of two British cohorts. J Hum Resour 34(3):534–556
Mas A, Pallais A (2017) Valuing alternative work arrangements. Am Econ Rev 107(12):3722–3759
Meng X (2004) Gender earnings gap: the role of firm specific effects. Labour Econ 11:555–573
Moss R (2019) City banker wins sexism case for unequal pay and victimisation. Personnel today, 12th September. Available online at: https://www.personneltoday.com/hr/city-banker-wins-sexism-case-for-unequal-pay-and-victimisation/. Retrieved 4th May 2022
Moss-Racusin CA, Dovidio JF, Brescoll VL, Graham MJ, Handelsman J (2012) Science faculty’s subtle gender biases favor male students. Proc Natl Acad Sci 109(41):16474–16479
Niederle M, Vesterlund L (2007) Do women shy away from competition? Do men compete too much? Q J Econ 122(3):1067–1101
Pekkarinen T, Vartiainen J (2006) Gender differences in promotion on a job ladder: evidence from Finnish metalworkers. ILR Rev 59(2):285–301
Pendakur K, Woodcock SD (2010) Glass ceilings or glass doors? Wage disparity within and between firms. J Bus Econ Stat 28(1):181–189
Phelps E (1972) The statistical theory of racism and sexism. Am Econ Rev 62(4):659–661
Ransom M, Oaxaca RL (2005) Intrafirm mobility and sex differences in pay. ILR Rev 58(2):219–237
Rich J (2014) What do field experiments of discrimination in markets tell us? A meta-analysis of studies conducted since 2000. IZA discussion paper no. 8584
Rosen B, Jerdee TH (1974) Influence of sex role stereotypes on personnel decisions. J Appl Psychol 59(1):9–14
Saygin PO, Weber A, Weynandt MA (2021) Coworkers, networks, and job-search outcomes among displaced workers. ILR Rev 74(1):95–130
Sorkin I (2017) The role of firms in gender earnings inequality: evidence from the United States. Am Econ Rev Pap Proc 107(5):384–387
Stuhlmacher AF, Walters AE (1999) Gender differences in negotiation outcome: a meta-analysis. Pers Psychol 52(3):653–677
Szymanski S (2000) A market test for discrimination in the English professional soccer leagues. J Polit Econ 108(3):590–603
Tate G, Yang L (2015) Female leadership and gender equity: evidence from plant closure. J Financ Econ 117:77–97
Tetlock PE (1983) Accountability and the perseverance of first impressions. Soc Psychol Q 46(4):285–292
Theodoropoulos N, Forth J, Bryson A (2022) Are women doing it for themselves? Gender segregation and the gender wage gap. Oxf Bull Econ Stat. https://doi.org/10.1111/obes.12509. (forthcoming)
Woodcock SD (2008) Wage differentials in the presence of unobserved worker, firm, and match heterogeneity. Labour Econ 15:772–794
Acknowledgments
Responsible Section Editor: Klaus Zimmermann
The article has benefited from valuable comments of the editors and anonymous referees. We also gratefully acknowledge comments from Carl Singleton.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Section Editor information
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2022 Springer Nature Switzerland AG
About this entry
Cite this entry
Forth, J., Theodoropoulos, N. (2022). Earnings Discrimination in the Workplace. In: Zimmermann, K.F. (eds) Handbook of Labor, Human Resources and Population Economics. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-57365-6_366-1
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-57365-6_366-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-319-57365-6
Online ISBN: 978-3-319-57365-6
eBook Packages: Springer Reference Economics and FinanceReference Module Humanities and Social SciencesReference Module Business, Economics and Social Sciences