Abstract
The United Nations human rights treaty bodies have, from modest beginnings, developed monitoring practices, particularly consideration of States Parties’ reports, individual complaints procedures, and inquiries, which cover a broad range of rights and issues. This development, in particular increasingly participatory procedures, has been lauded as an example of “human rights experimentalism.” The treaty bodies have thereby contributed to the interpretation of international human rights law, though not without some weaknesses, and to the protection of human rights, at least to some extent. While treaty bodies have undoubtedly become an integral part of the UN’s human rights system, they face considerable challenges in terms of their efficiency, effectiveness, and legitimacy. Their proliferation, and the consequent increase in the number of States Parties’ reports and cases, has prompted an ongoing review process. It calls into question the future of the system in its present form and entails that treaty bodies and their record will remain under close scrutiny. Treaty bodies will have to continue navigating conflicting demands and expectations from States Parties, within the United Nations, and civil society organizations. In a world where inequality, conflict, and instability are rife and the very notion of human rights is frequently sidelined if not criticized, treaty bodies face a considerable challenge to ensure effective monitoring and ultimately the protection of human rights. Combining a clear conceptual focus and attention to context with closer institutional alignment and holistic and effective forms of engagement will be critical in meeting this challenge.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution.
References
Abashidze A (2011) The complementary role of general comments in enhancing the implementation of treaty bodies’ recommendations and views (the example of CESCR). In: Bassiouni CM, Schabas W (eds) New challenges for the human rights treaty machinery. Intersentia, Cambridge, pp 137–148
Addo MK (2010) Practice of United Nations human rights treaty bodies in the reconciliation of cultural diversity with universal respect for human rights. Hum Rights Q 32:601–664
Aidoo AA et al (2009) The Dublin statement on the process of strengthening of the United Nations human rights treaty body system, at: www2.ohchr.org/English/bodies/HRTD/docs/DublinStatement.pdf. Accessed 30 Aug 2017
Alston P, Crawford J (eds) (2000) The future of UN human rights treaty monitoring. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Bantekas I, Oette L (2016) International human rights law and practice, 2nd edn. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Bayefsky AF (2001) The UN human rights system: universality at the crossroads. Kluwer Law International, The Hague
Creamer C, Simmons B (2015) Ratification, reporting, and rights: quality of participation in the convention against torture. Hum Rights Q 37:579–608
de Búrca, G (2017) Human rights experimentalism, AJIL 111:277-316
de Gaer F (2011) Implementing treaty body recommendations: establishing better follow-up procedures. In: Bassiouni CM, Schabas W (eds) New challenges for the human rights treaty machinery. Intersentia, Cambridge, pp 107–121
Della Fina V, Cera R, Palmisano G (eds) (2017) The United Nations convention on the rights of persons with disabilities: a commentary. Springer, Cham
Edwards A (2011) Universal suffrage and the international human rights treaty bodies: where are the women? In: Bassiouni CM, Schabas W (eds) New challenges for the human rights treaty machinery. Intersentia, Cambridge, pp 151–170
Evans MD (2017) Co-existence and confidentiality: the experience of the optional protocol to the convention against torture, harmony and human rights: the music of the spheres. In: Buckley CM, Donald A, Leach P (eds) Towards convergence in international human rights law: approaches of regional and international systems. Brill Nijhoff, Leiden, pp 516–542
Heyns C, Viljoen F (2002) The impact of the United Nations human rights treaties on the domestic level. Kluwer Law International, The Hague
International Court of Justice (2010) Case concerning Ahmadou Sadio Diallo, Republic of Guinea v. Democratic Republic of the Congo, Merits, Judgment, ICJ Reports 2010, p 639
International Law Association (2004) Final report on the impact of findings of the United Nations human rights treaty bodies. In International Law Association, Report of the Seventy-First Conference, pp 621–702
Johnstone RL (2006) Feminist influences on the United Nations human rights treaty bodies. Hum Rights Q 28:148–185
Kälin W (2012) Examination of state reports. In: Keller H, Ulfstein G (eds) UN human rights treaty bodies: law and legitimacy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 16–72
Keller H, Grover L (2012) General comments of the human rights committee and their legitimacy. In: Keller H, Ulfstein G (eds) UN human rights treaty bodies: law and legitimacy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 116–198
Keller H, Ulfstein G (2012) UN human rights treaty bodies: law and legitimacy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Kelly T (2009) The UN Committee against torture: human rights monitoring and the legal recognition of cruelty. Hum Rights Q 31:777–800
Kelly T (2015) Two cheers for ritual: the UN committee against torture. Paper delivered at ‘The Rituals of Human Rights’ Workshop, Centre for International Governance and Justice, RegNet, Australian University, Canberra, Australia, 25–27 June 2014, available online at www.regnet.anu.edu.au/research/publications/6121/rituals-human-rights-workshop-working-paper-no-7-two-cheers-ritual. Accessed 29 Nov 2017
Kennedy D (2002) The international human rights movement: part of the problem. Harv Hum Rights J 15:101–126
Kletzel G, Barretto Maia C, Zwaig M (2011) Strengthening of the UN treaty bodies’ complaints procedures: elements for a reform agenda from an NGO perspective. In: Bassiouni CM, Schabas W (eds) New challenges for the human rights treaty machinery. Intersentia, Cambridge, pp 193–236
Lauterpacht H (1945) An international bill of the rights of man. Oxford University Press, Oxford
LeBlanc LJ et al (2010) Compliance with the reporting requirements of human rights conventions. Int J Hum Rights 14:789–807
Levin A (2016) The reporting cycle to the United Nations human rights treaty bodies: creating a dialogue between the state and civil society- the Israeli case study. George Washington Int Law Rev 48:315–376
Lynch P, Schokman B (2011) Taking human rights from the grassroots to Geneva … and back: strengthening the relationship between UN treaty bodies and NGOs. In: Bassiouni CM, Schabas W (eds) New challenges for the human rights treaty machinery. Intersentia, Cambridge, pp 173–192
Mechlem K (2009) Treaty bodies and the interpretation of human rights. Vanderbilt J Transl Law 42:905–947
Morijn J (2011) Reforming United Nations human rights treaty monitoring system. Neth Int Law Rev LVIII:295–333
Mutua M (2001) Savages, victims, and saviors: the metaphor of human rights. Harv Int Law J 42:201–245
Mutua M (2016) Human rights standards: hegemony, law and politics. State University of New York Press, New York
Nowak M, McArthur E (2008) The United Nations convention against torture: a commentary. Oxford University Press, Oxford
O’Flaherty M (2006) The concluding observations of United Nations human rights treaty bodies. Hum Rights Law Rev 6:27–52
O’Flaherty M (2011) The United Nations human rights treaty bodies as diplomatic actors. In: O’Flaherty M et al (eds) Human rights diplomacy: contemporary perspectives. Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, Leiden, pp 155–171
O’Flaherty M, O’Brien C (2007) Reform of UN human rights treaty monitoring bodies: a critique of the concept paper on the high Commissioner’s proposal for a unified standing treaty body. Hum Rights Law Rev 7:147–172
O’Flaherty M, Tsai P-L (2011) Periodic reporting: the backbone of the UN treaty body review procedures. In: Bassiouni CM, Schabas W (eds) New challenges for the human rights treaty machinery. Intersentia, Cambridge, pp 37–56
Oberleitner G (2007) Global human rights institutions: between remedy and ritual. Polity, Cambridge
Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (2006) Concept Paper on the High Commissioner’s Proposal for a Unified Standing Treaty Body. UN Doc. HRI/MC/2006/2
Pillay N (2012) Strengthening the United Nations Human Rights Treaty Bodies: A report by the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, at: www2.ohchr.org/English/bodies/HRTD/docs/HCreportTBStrengthening.pdf. Accessed 29 Aug 2017
Rajagopal B (2003) International law from below: development, social movements, and third world resistance. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Rodley N (2009) The United Nations human rights council, its special procedure, and its relationship with the treaty bodies: complementarity or competition? In: Boyle K (ed) New institutions for human rights protection. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 49–73
Rodley N (2012) UN treaty bodies and the human rights council. In: Keller H, Ulfstein G (eds) UN human rights treaty bodies: law and legitimacy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 320–355
Schlütter B (2012) Aspects of human rights interpretation by the UN treaty bodies. In: Keller H, Ulfstein G (eds) UN human rights treaty bodies: law and legitimacy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 261–319
Thornberry P (2016) The international convention on the elimination of all forms of racial discrimination: a commentary. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Ulfstein G (2012) Individual complaints. In: Keller H, Ulfstein G (eds) UN human rights treaty bodies: law and legitimacy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 73–115
United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner (2015) Handbook for human rights treaty body members. United Nations, New York
United Nations Secretary-General (2016) Status of the human rights treaty body system. UN Doc. A/71/118
Van Alebeek R, Nollkaemper A (2012) The legal status of decisions by human rights treaty bodies in national law. In: Keller H, Ulfstein G (eds) UN human rights treaty bodies: law and legitimacy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 356–413
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2018 Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd.
About this entry
Cite this entry
Oette, L. (2018). The UN Human Rights Treaty Bodies: Impact and Future. In: Oberleitner, G. (eds) International Human Rights Institutions, Tribunals, and Courts. International Human Rights. Springer, Singapore. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-4516-5_5-1
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-4516-5_5-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Singapore
Print ISBN: 978-981-10-4516-5
Online ISBN: 978-981-10-4516-5
eBook Packages: Springer Reference Law and CriminologyReference Module Humanities and Social SciencesReference Module Business, Economics and Social Sciences