Background

Tuberculosis (TB) remains one of the leading infectious diseases worldwide. The outcome of infection with Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) is determined by a complex and dynamic interaction between the host immune system and properties of the pathogen. Exploring the mechanisms of mycobacteria-phagocyte interactions is crucial to understanding the pathogenesis of TB. Aerosolized Mtb, once inhaled into the lung and internalized by alveolar macrophages can induce phagocyte activation leading to control of bacillary growth and establishment of a state of non-replicating persistence [1–3]. Alternatively, as seen in 10% of the infected immune competent humans, the bacilli can survive the hostile environment of the phagosome through interference with a range of cellular processes, including subversion of activation of bactericidal responses and blocking phagosome acidification and fusion with lysosomes [4, 5]. Thus, when the activation of host immunity is optimal, infection by Mtb is controlled and lung pathology is minimal [6]. However, when macrophage activation is suboptimal, the bacilli continue to grow inside macrophages, additional cells are recruited from the circulation to the site of infection in the lungs and granulomas are formed [7–9].

The host immune responses to Mtb clinical strains CDC1551 and HN878 have previously been characterized in vitro and in vivo[10–14]. While infection by CDC1551 elicited an early and more vigorous pro-inflammatory cytokine response in human monocytes and stronger T cell activation in the lungs of infected mice, infection by HN878 induced reduced production by monocytes of Th1-type cytokines and diminished protective immunity in infected mice [10]. Moreover, in rabbit lungs, infection by HN878 was not controlled, resulting in progressive cavitary disease [6, 11], while growth of infecting CDC1551 was limited by the immune response and cultivable bacilli were fully cleared from the lungs by 3-4 months post infection [12]. The hyper-virulent phenotype of Mtb HN878 has been shown to be associated with the production of phenolic glycolipid (PGL), one of a number of lipid components of the mycobacterial cell wall that may subvert Th1-type host protective immunity [13–16]. However, the early cellular and molecular events occurring in infected macrophages that are associated with differential outcome following infection with HN878 versus CDC1551 are not fully understood.

In the present study, using genome-wide transcriptome analysis, we examined the early changes in gene expression in bone marrow-derived macrophages (BMM) following infection with either HN878 or CDC1551. In addition, we analyzed the transcriptional response of selected genes of the intracellular bacteria, including those involved in the stress response and lipid metabolism. Our findings suggest that infection by CDC1551 of BMM elicits a rapid and strong immune activation program as early as 6 hours, compared to infection by HN878. In contrast, while the activation of BMM upon infection by HN878 was suboptimal at earlier time points, the response was more prolonged and included the induction of genes involved in host cell lipid and small molecule metabolism. Moreover, compared to HN878, intracellular CDC1551 showed a significantly increased level of expression of bacillary stress response genes involved in hypoxia/anaerobiosis. Dysregulation of macrophage lipid metabolism has been reported in surgically removed lung specimens from TB patients, with severe caseating granulomatous disease [17].

Results

Global changes in macrophage transcriptional response to infection by Mtb

Mouse BMM were infected with either CDC1551 or HN878 for up to 48 hours and the intracellular growth of the two Mtb strains was evaluated by the colony forming units (CFU) assay. Similar to our previous reports, there was no significant difference in the intracellular growth and total bacillary load between CDC1551 and HN878 during infection of BMM (Figure 1A) [12, 16]. To study the changes in global transcriptome of host cells during infection by Mtb, levels of expression of BMM genes at 6 and 24 hours post-infection (hpi) were compared to the corresponding transcriptome from uninfected cells. Based on our selection criteria (at least 2 fold change in expression and P ≤ 0.05), among the 28,853 genes represented in the microarray, expression of only 10.6% (3,054 genes) and 4.4% (1,268 genes) was significantly affected in BMM infected with the two Mtb strains at 6 and 24 hpi respectively (Figure 1B). In addition, expression of a higher number of shared host genes was significantly modulated by both strains at 6 hours (1,951 genes), compared to 24 hours of infection (831 genes). At 6 hpi, the number of differentially expressed host genes exclusively affected during infection by CDC1551 was about 3.5 fold higher (865 genes) than by HN878 infection (238 genes). However, while the total number of differentially expressed BMM genes following infection by HN878 was comparable between 6 and 24 hours (238 and 280 genes), a larger number of genes was induced at 24 hours by HN878, compared to CDC1551 infection (280 vs. 157 genes). The fold change in BMM gene expression between CDC1551 and HN878 infection at 6 hours ranged from +192.83 to -24.32 and from +157.62 to -21.95, respectively (Figure 1C and 1D). At 24 hpi, the expression levels were from +167.72 to -55.93 and from +172.62 to -40.62 in CDC1551 or HN878 infected BMM, respectively (Figure 1E and 1F). This robust modulation in gene expression by both Mtb strains indicated an early dynamic reprogramming of host cellular machinery upon infection of BMM by Mtb. Importantly, among the ten most highly up-regulated BMM genes, 6 and 7 genes were commonly expressed during infection by CDC1551 and HN878 at 6 and 24 hpi, respectively. Similarly, 7 and 6 genes out of the 10 most highly down-regulated host genes were common to infection with both CDC1551 and HN878 at 6 and 24 hpi, respectively (Additional file 1). This suggested that differential expression of the majority of macrophage genes was in response to the common determinants shared by both Mtb strains and only a subset of host genes were differentially expressed depending on the specific phenotype of the infecting bacilli. Overall, the global transcriptional analysis of the Mtb-infected BMM revealed that infection by CDC1551 induced a stronger macrophage response at 6 hpi, compared to HN878 which induced a lower but more protracted response that lasted at least 24 hpi.

Figure 1
figure 1

Intracellular growth of CDC1551 and HN878 and global transcriptome of BMM during infection. (A) Growth of CDC1551 and HN878 in macrophages up to 48 hpi. The cells were infected with a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 5 (bacteria per phagocyte) for 3 hours. Equal numbers of BMM were seeded at the start of infection with CDC1551 and HN878. At 3 (T = 0), 24 and 48 hpi, cells were lysed and serial dilutions of the homogenates were plated to determine the CFU. The viability of the infected cells, measured by trypan blue exclusion, did not change significantly till the end of the experiment (48 hours). (B) Venn diagram of microarray data showing macrophage genes significantly differentially expressed (at least 2 fold change in expression and P ≤ 0.05) by CDC1551 and HN878 at 6 and 24 hpi. (C and D) Transcriptional profile of individual host genes differentially expressed by CDC1551 (C) and HN878 (D) infection at 6 hpi. (E and F) Total number of differentially expressed macrophage genes by CDC1551 (E) and HN878 (F) infection at 24 hpi. The data presented in (C-F) is derived from microarray analysis of differentially expressed macrophage genes during infection by Mtb . Each spot represents a gene and all genes are ranked based on their relative expression ratio (Mtb-infected vs. uninfected cells). The microarray results were obtained from three independent RNA samples per experimental group (infected or uninfected).

Full size image

Biologic ontology analysis of differentially expressed macrophage genes during infection by Mtb

To gain insight into the cellular and molecular functions of the Mtb-induced host genes, differentially expressed macrophage genes from the microarray analysis were subjected to functional categorization using Ingenuity Pathway Analysis software (IPA; version 7.5) (Table 1) [18]. At 6 hpi, infection by CDC1551 of BMM modulated the expression of a higher number of host genes involved in the cell inflammatory response, cellular growth and proliferation, cell-to-cell signaling and interaction, cell death, gene expression, cell cycle, DNA replication and repair, compared to infection by HN878. However, by 24 hpi, HN878 modulated the expression of similar or even slightly higher numbers of host genes in the above mentioned functional categories (Table 1). Interestingly, similar numbers of host genes involved in antigen presentation were differentially expressed at 6 and 24 hpi of BMM by both HN878 and CDC1551. In addition, expression of a significantly higher number of host genes involved in lipid metabolism and small molecule biochemistry, including uptake of long chain fatty acids, synthesis of lipids, fatty acids and prostaglandins as well as cholesterol metabolism, was induced by HN878, compared to CDC1551 infection of BMM at 24 hours. The relative transcript levels of selected differentially expressed host genes, during infection of BMM by both Mtb strains and the respective functional category, can be found in Additional file 2.

Table 1 Ontology analysis of the differentially expressed macrophage genes by Mtb infection
Full size table

Distinct gene networks modulated by CDC1551 and HN878 infection of macrophages

Since the comparative transcriptome and gene ontology analysis of BMM infected with CDC1551 or HN878 suggested that at 6 hpi, CDC1551 modulated the expression of a higher number of genes involved in early immune activation pathways, and at 24 hpi, HN878 altered the expression of higher number of genes involved in host cell lipid metabolism, we focused on Mtb strain-specific networks within these two pathways. From the list of differentially expressed macrophage genes (at least 2-fold change in expression and P ≤ 0.05), we identified using IPA, two networks that were specifically modulated in response to infection by one of the two Mtb strains. Expression of all the genes in the early immune activation network (EIAN) was up-regulated preferentially in CDC1551 infected BMM as early as 6 hours (Figure 2A and 2B), while expression of the EIAN genes was not significant in the HN878 infected BMM at 6 hours (Figure 2B and Additional file 3). The EIAN is a branch-network of the main host immune response pathway that is commonly activated upon infection by both Mtb strains. The genes in EIAN encode immune regulatory and cell signaling molecules, such as STAT3, STAT5A, ATF3, HDAC1, PTK2B, CISH and TYK2, as well as cytokine and chemokine receptors, including IL4R, IL12RB1, NOTCH1, ITGA4 and CCR7. The second network, comprised of a subset of genes involved in host lipid metabolism, was up-regulated specifically during HN878 infection of BMM at 24 hours (Figure 2C and 2D). The majority of the genes in this network are involved in cholesterol metabolism (Fasn, Insig1, Stard4, Hmgcr, Nsdhl, Dhcr24, Dhcr7, Acss2, Sc4mol, Gbp5 and Scd). However, subsets of these genes are also involved in 25-hydroxycholesterol metabolism (Fasn, Insig1, Stard4, and Hmgcr) and triacylglycerol metabolism (Fasn and Gbp5). Importantly, though four genes of this network, (Pparg, Igf1, Ccnd1 and Tnf) that are part of the general lipid metabolism pathway, were expressed similarly in both CDC1551 or HN878 infected BMM at 24 hours, the absence of significant regulation of other key genes in this lipid metabolism network in CDC1551 infected BMM was striking.

Figure 2
figure 2

Strain-specific host gene networks activated in Mtb -infected BMM. Significantly differentially expressed host genes upon infection by CDC1551 or HN878 of BMM at 6 and 24 hpi were used to construct strain-specific networks by IPA. (A) Early immune activation network (EIAN); genes in this network were significantly up-regulated only in CDC1551 infected BMM at 6 hours. (B) Insignificant expression of EIAN genes during HN878 infection of BMM at 6 hours. (C and D) A subset of lipid metabolism pathway genes significantly activated only in HN878 infected BMM at 24 hours. (D) The majority of genes in the lipid metabolism pathway were not significantly expressed during CDC1551 infection of BMM at 24 hours. Up-regulated genes are marked red and down-regulated genes are marked green with their absolute level of expression under respective gene symbols (also described in Additional file 3). Solid lines indicate direct interaction and broken lines represent indirect interaction between the genes in the network.

Full size image

Validation of differentially expressed host genes by qRT-PCR

To validate the microarray gene expression profile of BMM during infection by Mtb , we performed qRT-PCR for selected genes encoding mediators of host immunity, including pro-inflammatory cytokines (IL-1β and IL-6), chemokines (CXCL9 and CCL8), cell adhesion and tissue remodeling (MMP9 and CD209F) and host lipid metabolism genes (Figure 3 and Table 2). Expression of Cxcl9 and Ccl8 was significantly up-regulated in CDC1551-infected cells at both 6 and 24 hpi, compared to infection by HN878, while Il1β was more highly up-regulated at 6 hours than at 24 hours (Figure 3). In contrast, while Il6 and Mmp9 were significantly highly expressed in HN878-infected cells at both time points, the level of expression of Cd209g was similar at 6 hours and higher in HN878-infected BMM at 24 hours of infection. Similar to the microarray data, the relative expression ratio between HN878 and CDC1551, of several host genes involved in lipid metabolism, measured by qRT-PCR was higher in HN878 infected BMM at 24 hpi (Table 2). Taken together, the results from qRT-PCR analysis were consistent with the microarray data and confirm our conclusion that CDC1551 infection of BMM selectively triggers EIAN at 6 hours, while infection by HN878 selectively up-regulates a host cell lipid metabolism network at 24 hpi.

Figure 3
figure 3

Expression of cytokine, chemokine and inflammatory genes during Mtb infection of BMM. Total RNA from BMM infected with CDC1551 or HN878 at 6 and 24 hpi was used to quantify the transcript levels of cytokines (Il1β and Il6), chemokines (Cxcl9 and Ccl8), and inflammatory molecules (Mmp9 and Cd209g) by qRT-PCR. The threshold cycle (Ct) of each test gene was normalized against that of the house-keeping gene, Gapdh and the relative fold change in gene expression was calculated by comparing Mtb-infected and uninfected samples. The data presented are average ± standard deviation of values obtained from three independent infections per experimental group assayed at least in duplicate. * P ≤ 0.05.

Full size image
Table 2 Transcript levels of macrophage genes involved in lipid metabolism altered by Mtb infection
Full size table

Nitrite (NO2-) production by Mtb infected macrophages

We observed that the level of expression of nitric oxide synthase (Nos2), a marker of macrophage activation, was significantly higher in CDC1551-infected BMM, compared to infection by HN878 (Figure 4A and Additional file 1). Therefore, we measured the NO2- accumulation in the culture supernatants of BMM infected with both Mtb strains. Consistent with the microarray results, the concentration of NO2- at 24 hpi was more than two-fold higher in response to infection by CDC1551, compared to HN878 (Figure 4B). However, there was no change in the nitrite production upon infection by HN878 and CDC1551 at 6 hpi. These results suggest that, compared to HN878, CDC1551-infected BMM were more effectively activated. This observation also suggests that the more activated BMM generate higher levels of the anti-microbial mediators and thus impose a more hostile intracellular environment on the bacteria.

Figure 4
figure 4

Transcript levels of Nos2 and production of nitric oxide by Mtb -infected BMM. (A) Total host RNA from CDC1551 or HN878- infected BMM at 6 and 24 hpi was used to quantify the levels of Nos2 mRNA levels. The expression levels were normalized to Gapdh levels from the same sample and relative fold change was calculated by comparing uninfected with 6 and 24 hpi samples. (B) Production of nitric oxide measured as dissolved nitrite (NO2-) using Griess reagent as described in methods. The culture supernatants from BMM infected with CDC1551 or HN878 were collected 24 hpi and the amount of NO2- was measured in triplicate samples per infection. Relative NO2- concentrations were calculated by extrapolation of values from test samples on standard curves generated using sodium nitrite. Data represent mean ± standard error from two independent experiments performed in triplicate for each experimental group.

Full size image

Transcription of mycobacterial stress response genes during infection of macrophages

We next analyzed the intracellular bacterial transcriptional response during CDC1551 or HN878 infection of BMM (Figure 5). Previous studies have described the host and bacterial transcriptional profiles of diverse lineages of clinical Mtb isolates in response to macrophage infection [19–21]. From those reports, we selected a subset of Mtb genes and determined their level of expression by qRT-PCR. These Mtb genes are known to be modulated in response to intracellular stress, such as hypoxia/anaerobiosis (narX, narK2, devR (also known as dosR), sodA, hspX and fdxA), acid shock (Rv0955 and Rv3671) and general stress (sigA, sigB, sigF, sigH, relA, dnaE2 and mprA) as well as cell wall biosynthesis/lipid metabolism (icl, fadD26, pcaA, mmpL8, lipF and pckA), and iron metabolism/storage genes (mbtB and bfrA) [21–24]. In both Mtb strains, the intracellular transcription of the majority of the tested genes from all categories was up-regulated at 24 hours and either stayed at similar levels or was slightly reduced at 48 hpi of BMM. However, intracellular expression of mmpL8 in CDC1551 and sigB and sigH in HN878 were gradually up-regulated from 24 to 48 hpi. In addition, the transcript levels of four (narK2, devR, sodA and hspX) and three (narK2, devR and hspX) out of six tested Mtb genes, induced by anaerobic stress were significantly higher in intracellular CDC1551 than HN878 at both 24 and 48 hpi (Figure 5). In contrast, the transcript levels at 24 and 48 hpi, of narX, fdxA and sodA at 48 hpi were similar between CDC1551 and HN878 (Figure 5A and 5B). The transcripts of all tested cell wall biosynthesis/lipid metabolism genes, except for icl and mmpL8, were also higher in intracellular CDC1551 than in HN878 (Figure 5C and 5D). While the levels of icl transcripts were similar, the kinetics of expression of mmpL8 was different for the two Mtb strains. In addition, the expression of Mtb genes encoding alternative sigma factors (sigB, sigF and sigH) and general stress response (relA, dnaE2 and mprA) were similarly regulated at 24 hpi in both Mtb strains, while higher sigB and sigH transcripts were expressed by intracellular HN878 at 48 hpi, compared to CDC1551 (Figure 5E and 5F). Finally, the intracellular expression of Mtb genes involved in iron uptake/storage (mbtB and bfrA) and acid shock response (Rv0955 and Rv3671) were also significantly up-regulated in CDC1551, compared to HN878 at both 24 and 48 hpi (Figure 5G and 5H). There was no significant difference in the basal level expression of most of the tested genes between CDC1551 and HN878 (Additional file 4). However, the basal levels of narX, narK2, bfrA, fdxA, sigB, sodA, Rv3671 and Rv0955 transcripts in CDC1551, and devR (dosR) levels in HN878 was significantly higher compared to their counter parts. Thus, in the more extensively activated BMM (those infected with CDC1551), the intracellular stress on the bacilli was greater, resulting in significantly higher expression of several Mtb stress response genes.

Figure 5
figure 5

Differential expression of Mtb genes during BMM infection. Total Mtb RNA was isolated from CDC1551 or HN878-infected BMM at 24 and 48 hpi and the level of expression of Mtb genes involved in pathways including hypoxia, general stress response and fatty acid/lipid metabolism was determined by qRT-PCR. The amount of transcripts for each Mtb gene was normalized to 16S rRNA levels and relative fold change in gene expression was calculated by comparing the expression level at 24 and 48 hpi with T0 levels. (A and B) Intracellular mRNA levels of Mtb genes involved in mycobacterial survival during hypoxia expressed by CDC1551 or HN878 at 24 (A) and 48 (B) hpi. (C and D) Transcript levels of Mtb genes involved in fatty acid/lipid metabolism expressed by CDC1551 or HN878 at 24 (C) and 48 (D) hpi of BMM. (E and F) mRNA levels of Mtb genes involved in general stress response expressed by intracellular CDC1551 or HN878 at 24 (E) and 48 (F) hpi. (G and H) Intracellular mRNA levels of Mtb genes involved in iron metabolism and peptidases involved in acid shock response expressed by CDC1551 or HN878 at 24 (G) and 48 (H) hpi. The results are means ± standard deviation from three independent samples per experimental group per time point repeated at least twice. * P ≤ 0.05.

Full size image

Discussion

In this study, we explored the transcriptional response of BMM to infection by Mtb CDC1551 or HN878 to elucidate the molecular basis for their differential response in the mouse and rabbit models of pulmonary TB [6, 12, 25]. The global transcriptome of Mtb-infected BMM showed distinct patterns of gene expression. Compared to HN878, a more robust and rapid change in the host transcriptional response was elicited upon infection by CDC1551 as early as 6 hours; thereafter the number of differentially expressed BMM genes induced by CDC1551 infection was reduced by 24 hpi. In contrast, the transcriptional response of BMM to infection with HN878 was sub-optimal at the early time-point (6 hours) and showed a more protracted profile at 24 hpi.

The differential activation of BMM by CDC1551 infection was associated with the specific up-regulation of genes that constitute EIAN which is part of the global host immune response. The majority of EIAN genes, such as Stat3, Stat5a, Atf3, Hdac1, Ptk2b, Cish and Tyk2 are transcriptional regulators that control immune cell functions including cell maturation, proliferation, survival, migration and antimicrobial defense [26–32]. For example, STAT3 and STAT5A, activated by different types of cytokines in a cell-specific manner, affect the differentiation, growth and apoptosis of host cells by controlling the expression of key genes in respective cellular pathways; STAT3 activation down-regulates IGFBP5, a growth factor binding protein that interacts with IGF1 and promotes apoptosis of T cells. In addition, activation of STAT3 enhances proliferation of various immune cells through a gp130-mediated pathway [26, 33, 34]. Mice that harbor a conditional disruption of Stat3 in macrophages and neutrophils were shown to have elevated levels of inflammatory cytokines in the serum and were more vulnerable to the effects of lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-induced shock [26]. Tyrosine kinase-2 (TYK2), one of the interacting partners of STAT3, also plays a crucial role in macrophage activation by various stimulants such as cytokines and LPS [27, 28, 35]. Accordingly, Tyk2 knockout (KO) mice were defective for IFN-γ signaling and for protective T-cell responses against lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus infection [28]. Moreover, macrophages of the Tyk2-KO mice neither expressed Nos2 nor produced NO in response to LPS stimulation [28, 35]. In addition, these mutant mice displayed reduced production of IL-12 and STAT3 activation [28]. Furthermore, a proline-rich tyrosine kinase (PTK2B alias PYK2) in the EIAN, up-regulated during CDC1551 infection of BMM, has been shown to mediate the NADPH oxidase-dependent generation of reactive oxygen intermediates (ROI) and Pyk2-KO mice showed defective ROI production and associated host pro-inflammatory molecules, including TNF-α and MCP-1 [36]. Similarly, NO production by highly activated macrophages has been shown to mediate mycobacterial killing by direct toxicity and indirect interference with Mtb virulence determinants [37, 38].

We also observed increased level of expression of DC-SIGN (dendritic cell-specific ICAM-3 grabbing non-integrin; also designated as CD209) upon infection of BMM with HN878 compared to CDC1551. CD209 has been shown to play a key role in the dissemination of HIV-1 by dendritic cells (DCs) [39]. In addition, DC-SIGN mediates adherence of Mtb to human macrophages and DCs and interferes with the cellular inflammatory response to infection by Mtb[40, 41]. DC-SIGN binding to ManLAM, a virulence factor secreted by Mtb- infected DCs, prevents DC maturation by compromising Toll-like receptor (TLR)-mediated signaling [40]. These observations, combined with the lower NO produced by HN878 infected BMM support our conclusion that HN878 is less efficient at inducing macrophage activation and bactericidal responses. Our present findings are also supported by a recent report from Portevin et.al, that showed differential cytokine and inflammatory responses of human macrophages upon infection by ancient versus modern lineage clinical Mtb strains; variable early inflammatory responses induced by these Mtb strains were suggested to contribute to the difference in their pathogenicity [42]. Taken together, the early macrophage activation in response to infection by CDC1551 may explain the observation made in infected rabbits where CDC1551 reached a relatively low maximal bacillary load (5.5-6 log10) in the lungs and the CFU declined gradually to complete clearance at 3-4 months. In contrast, infection by HN878 of rabbits led to extensive Mtb growth reaching a higher and sustained bacillary load (7-9 log10) in the lungs. Thus, early and robust macrophage activation appears to be essential for effective control of infection by Mtb and for prevention of progression to active granulomatous disease [6, 12].

In our study, we noted that infection of BMM with HN878 up-regulated the expression of a larger number of host lipid metabolism genes, including Acsl1, Dhcr24, Acat2, Scd1 and Fads2. Recent studies from others and our laboratory have shown that infection by Mtb induces lipid droplet formation in human macrophages [43], and that elevated host lipid metabolism correlates with caseation in human TB granulomas [7, 17]. Moreover, only pathogenic Mtb could induce the differentiation of phagocytes into foamy macrophages (FMs) [43]. The association between altered lipid metabolism and pathogenesis has also been reported in infection by other microbes, such as Toxoplasma gondii[44]. In mouse stromal vesicular cells that displayed foam cell morphology, expression of Acsl1, coding for an acyl-CoA synthase, which mediates fatty acid homeostasis and cell apoptosis, was up-regulated [45]. Similarly, Dhcr24 encoding dihydroxy cholesterol reductase has been shown to facilitate replication of hepatitis C virus in mouse hepatocytes and Acat, coding for acyl-CoA thioesterase, involved in cholesterol biosynthesis, has been reported to be required for the replication of novovirus in HG23 cells [46, 47]. However, a role for DHCR24 and ACAT in bacterial infections has not been reported before. It has been shown that cholesterol is essential for the uptake of Mtb by primary human and mouse macrophages [48] and catabolism of cholesterol has been reported to be essential for the persistence of Mtb during chronic infection of mice [49]. In addition, elevated levels of host cholesterol and/or fatty acids have been shown to be essential for the persistence of Mtb in granulomas presumably by preventing phagosome maturation [50]. High levels of prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) have a significant immunosuppressive effect, such as inhibition of lymphocyte proliferation and production of Th1 type cytokines as well as interference with macrophage activation [51, 52]. Strong PGE2 immunostaining was seen in the FMs of H37Rv-infected mouse lungs [53]. Consistent with these results, the up-regulation of Ptgs2 expression in HN878-infected BMM could lead to suppression of macrophage-mediated innate responses and enhance FM formation during chronic HN878 infection in vivo. Taken together, these studies may help explain our findings in the rabbit model of pulmonary TB, where infection by CDC1551 was efficiently controlled while infection by HN878 progressed to chronic granulomatous disease [6, 11, 12, 18].

Both the host and pathogen response during infection contribute to the balance that determines the outcome in TB [2, 54, 55]. The level of intracellular expression of Mtb stress-response genes upon infection has been shown to reflect the extent of immune pressure exerted by the host immune response. Whereas the early and highly activated BMM induced by CDC1551 infection triggered a rapid and robust Mtb stress response, the sub-optimal activation of BMM upon infection by HN878 resulted in diminished environmental pressure on the bacteria [19, 21]. We observed higher expression levels of hypoxia/anaerobiosis-induced genes (narK2, devR, hspX, sodA, fdxA and icl) during intracellular infection with CDC1551 compared to HN878. Several in vitro and in vivo studies have examined the role of these genes in Mtb pathogenesis and persistence [56–58]. It is well documented that DosR, the master regulator of "DosR regulon" regulates the expression of several genes, including narX, narK2, hspX, fdxA, pcaA and devR that are induced when Mtb encounters hypoxic conditions [59, 60]. Earlier reports have shown that the level of expression of many DosR regulon genes, including dosR itself, is up-regulated during the bacterial adaptation to dormancy and/or microaerophilic growth and that mutations in these genes resulted in increased bacillary growth both in vitro and in the lungs and spleens of infected mice, highlighting the essentiality of these genes for intracellular mycobacterial adaptation in the host [21, 61–64]. However, growth of dosR mutant in the lungs of Mtb-infected experimental animals is highly variable, ranging from attenuated (in mice and guinea pigs) to no change in growth (in rabbits and mouse "hollow-fiber" model), compared to wild type controls [65]. Similarly, pcaA, encoding cyclopropane synthase is reported to be essential and sufficient for early activation of mouse BMM and growth of the pcaA mutant was exacerbated in the infected mouse lungs [66, 67]. Moreover, Mtb genes Rv3671c and Rv0955 were shown to protect the intracellular bacilli from acid shock and oxidative stress during infection of activated macrophages and a mutation in these genes renders the bacilli severely attenuated for growth in infected mouse lungs [68, 69]. Thus, up-regulation of the DosR regulon genes in CDC1551 clearly supports our conclusion that, in contrast with HN878, this strain is exposed to enhanced intracellular pressure, exerted by the highly activated BMM.

Conclusions

Our data on the modulation of host and bacterial gene expression upon CDC1551 versus HN878 infection of BMM suggest that even relatively subtle differences in the expression of genes that regulate immune cell activation, induced very early in infection by CDC1551 was significant enough to impact the intracellular stress of the bacilli. Our results support the link between specific host-derived, intracellular signals and the modulation of bacterial gene expression [20, 70–72]. We propose that an early induction of the immune activation network and stronger BMM activation by CDC1551 infection can ultimately result in efficient control of the bacilli by host cells. In contrast, sub-optimal BMM activation, associated with elevated host lipid metabolism that contributes to FM formation, enables better intracellular survival of the infecting HN878. Future studies will dissect in more detail the association between Mtb virulence and host lipid metabolism.

Methods

Bacterial culture

Mycobacterium tuberculosis CDC1551 and HN878 were grown in Middlebrook 7H9 medium supplemented with Middlebrook 10% oleic acid albumin dextrose catalase (OADC) enrichment (Difco BD, Franklin Lakes, NJ), 0.5% glycerol and 0.05% Tween 80 (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO) at 37°C to logarithmic phase (OD540 = 0.6-0.7). Bacterial stocks were stored at -80°C until use. Bacillary clumping was prevented by probe sonication for 10 sec before infection.

Macrophage infection and bacterial load determination

BMM were generated from the marrow of femur bones of 8 week old female B6D2F1 mice (Jackson Laboratories, Bar Harbor, ME) as described earlier [73]. Briefly, BMM were differentiated in Dulbecco's Modified Eagle Medium (Gibco, Grand Island, NY) supplemented with 10% Fetal Bovine Serum, sodium pyruvate, 1% L-glutamine, 20% L929 cell-conditioned medium and 1% penicillin/streptomycin and cultured in a 5% CO2 incubator for 7 days. Differentiated BMM were infected with CDC1551 or HN878 at a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 5:1 (bacteria: BMM). After 3 hours incubation at 37°C, extracellular bacteria were removed by washing three times with sterile phosphate buffered saline (PBS). Uninfected and Mtb-infected cell cultures were incubated up to 48 hours and supernatants were harvested at 24 and 48 hpi for further analysis. For bacterial load enumeration, infected cells were lysed by sonication and serial dilutions in sterile PBS-Tween 80 were spread on Middlebrook 7H10 agar plate (Difco BD, Franklin Lakes, NJ) and number of bacterial colonies (CFU) were counted after 3-4 weeks of incubation at 37°C [18].

Measurement of nitrite (NO2-) production

Nitrite (NO2-) levels were measured to determine the amount of dissolved NO produced by cells in the supernatants of uninfected and Mtb-infected BMM using Griess reagent as described previously [74]. Briefly, 100 μl of supernatant in a 96-well plate was mixed with an equal volume of Griess reagent (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO) and incubated for 10 minutes at room temperature in the dark. The color developed was measured at a wavelength of 540 nm in a spectrophotometer (Versa max; Molecular Devices, Sunnyvale, CA). The concentration of NO2- in the test samples was derived from the standard curves obtained with known concentration of sodium nitrite, run in parallel with the test samples. Each experiment was repeated in triplicate using samples from three independent experiments.

Total RNA isolation and microarray analysis of Mtb infected macrophages

Total BMM RNA was obtained from Mtb-infected cells at 6 and 24 hpi using the Trizol method as mentioned previously [18]. Briefly, BMM were lysed with Trizol reagent (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA) and total RNA was isolated with RNeasy mini kit according to the manufacturer's instruction (Qiagen, Valencia, CA). RNA from uninfected BMM was included as control. Total Mtb RNA was isolated using a modified differential lysis method. Briefly, infected cells were lysed in sterile 0.1% Triton X-100, followed by centrifugation at 13,000 rpm for 10 min at 15°C to pellet the bacteria. The bacterial pellet was re-suspended in Trizol and subjected to bead beating with Ribo-lyser (MP Biosciences, Solon, OH) for 2 min as 30 sec pulses with 1 min ice-incubation in between the pulses. The host and bacterial RNA were subjected to DNaseI digestion before final purification through RNeasy mini kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA). For the microarray experiments, total host RNA (300 ng) was reverse transcribed and labeled with Cy3 and Cy5 using the Fluorescent liner amplification kit according to manufacturer's instructions (Affymetrix, Santa Redwood city, CA). Synthesized cDNA was hybridized to the Affymetrix mouse GeneChip Gene ST 1.0 as described previously [18]. Three independent RNA samples were obtained per experimental group and used for microarray experiments.

Microarray data analysis of macrophage gene expression

Probe-level intensity measurement from the microarray chip composed of 28,853 annotated genes was normalized using the Robust Multi-array Average (RMA) method and summarized using the Partek Genomics Suite platform (Partek Inc., St. Louis, MO). The raw data from microarray experiments (CEL files) contains the expression level (intensity) of probe sets. The signal intensity from each probe set was subtracted from the background values. The gene expression ratio (infected vs. uninfected) was calculated as median-centered values (from 3 independent experiments) and denoted as log2 values. However, when the expression ratio was converted to fold change, the log2 values were transformed to normal (log10) values. The annotated and differentially expressed genes were identified based on changes in average expression levels with a significance of P ≤ 0.05. The genes differentially expressed in response to infection by Mtb were identified by calculating the ratio of gene expression between infected and uninfected, control cells. Genes with P ≤ 0.05 and at least two fold changes in the level of expression were regarded as significantly differentially expressed. Microarray data of this study are available in the Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO) repository (accession number GSE31734). List of significantly differentially expressed host genes at 6 and 24 hpi was uploaded to Ingenuity Pathway Analysis (IPA; version 7.5) software (Ingenuity Systems, Redwood city, CA) for gene ontology analysis, functional classification and network derivation of differentially expressed genes.

Quantitative real time RT-PCR (qRT-PCR) analysis

Differential expression of the selected host and bacterial gene expression was determined by qRT-PCR using SYBR Green-ER two-step qRT-PCR kit (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA). The cDNA was amplified with gene specific primers. The nucleotide sequences of primers specific to mouse genes were obtained from http://pga.mgh.harvard.edu/primerbank/. The DNA sequences of the mycobacterial primers used for qRT-PCR have been reported earlier [21]. The qRT-PCR was performed in the MxPro4000 Multiplex quantitative PCR System (Stratagene, Santa Clara, CA). The threshold cycle (Ct value) for each amplified target gene was calculated using MxPro4000 software. Uniform baseline fluorescence was set for all the genes in each experiment and across different experiments. The transcripts of glyceraldehyde phosphate dehydrogenase (Gapdh) for mouse genes and 16S rRNA for the Mtb genes were used to normalize the Ct values of the target genes. Fold change in gene expression was calculated using the formula 2-ΔΔCt and represented as relative expression after normalization to uninfected group. The experiments were repeated three times with RNA samples from two to three wells per experimental group and time point.

Statistical analysis

All values are presented as mean ± standard deviation or mean ± standard error of means of two to three independent experiments with multiple samples. Comparisons between experimental conditions were analyzed by the Student's t- test. Differences were considered statistically significant when P ≤ 0.05.