Abstract
Structural health monitoring (SHM) techniques have been studied for several years. An effective approach for SHM is to choose the parameters that are sensitive to the damage occurring in the structure but not sensitive to operational or environmental damages. This paper deals with a comparative study among the different vibration-based damage detection methods: fundamental modal examination, local diagnostic method, non-probabilistic methodology and the time series method. All these strategies contemplate different parameters of a structure to recognize damage. Out of the study made, time series analysis proves to more successfully in damage identification than the rest of the methods.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Xu YL, Chen B (2008) Integrated vibration control and health monitoring of building structures using semi-active friction dampers: Part I—methodology. Eng Struct 30:1789–1801
Khoshnoudian F, Esfandiari A (2011) Structural damage diagnosis using modal data. Sharif Univ Technol. 18:853–860
Dessi D, Camerlengo G (2015) Damage identification techniques via modal curvature analysis: overview and comparison. Mech Syst Signal Process 52–53:181–205
Modares M, Waksmanshi N (2013) Overview of structural health monitoring for steel bridges. Am Soc Civil Eng. 18:187–191
Jiang X, Mahadevan S (2008) Bayesian Probabilistic Inference for Nonparametric Damage Detection of Structures. J Eng Mech 134(10):820–831
Nakamura M, Masri SF, Chassiakos AG, Caughey TK (1998) A method for non-parametric damage detection through the use of neural networks. Earthq Eng Struct Dynam 27(9):997–1010
Fang X, Luo H, Tang J (2005) Structural damage detection using neural network with learning rate improvement. Comput Struct 83(25–26):2150–2161
Chatfield C (ed) (2004) The analysis of time series: an introduction, 6th edn, Chapman and Hall/CRC, Boca Raton
Elkordy MF, Chang KC, Lee GC (1993) Neural networks trained by analytically simulated damage states. J Comput Civil Eng 7(2):130–145
Barroso LR, Rodriguez R (2004) Damage detection utilizing the damage index method to a benchmark structure. J Eng Mech. 130(2):142–151
Doebling SW, Farrar CR, Prime MB (1998) A summary review of vibration-based damage identification methods. Shock Vib Digest. 30(2):91–105
Huang NE, Shen Z, Long SR, Wu MC, Shih HH, Zheng Q, Yen N-C, Tung CC, Liu HH (1998) The empirical mode decomposition and the Hilbert spectrum for nonlinear and non-stationary time series analysis. In: The Royal Society of London
Pines D, Salvino L (2006) Structural health monitoring using empirical mode decomposition and the Hilbert phase. J Sound Vib 294:97–124
Yu L, Lin JC (2015) Cloud computing based time series analysis for structural damage detection. J Eng Mech
Whalen TM (2008) The behavior of higher order mode shape derivatives in damaged, beam-like structures. J Sound Vib 309:426–464
West WM (1986) Illustration of the use of modal assurance criterion to detect structural changes in an orbiter test specimen. In: The Fourth International Modal Analysis Conference. Los Angeles, CA
Yuen MMF (1985) A numerical study of the eigen parameters of a damaged cantilever. J Sound Vib 103:301–310
Pandey AK, Biswas M, Samman MM (1991) Damage detection from changes in curvature mode shapes. J Sound Vib 145:321–332
Cawley P, Adams RD (1979) The location of defects in structures from measurements of natural frequencies. J Strain Anal. 14(2):49–57
Stubbs N, Kim JT, Topole K (1992) An efficient and robust algorithm for damage localization in offshore platforms. In: The ASCE Tenth Structures Congress. San Antonio, TX
Law SS, Waldron P, Taylor C (1992) Damage detection of a reinforced concrete bridge deck using the frequency response function. In: The 10th International Modal Analysis Conference. San Diego, CA
Yu L, Zhu JH, Yu LL (2013) Structural damage detection in a truss bridge model using fuzzy clustering and measured FRF data reducing by principal component projection. Adv Struct Eng. 16(1):207–217
Safak E (1997) New directions in seismic monitoring of multi-story buildings. In: Chang F-K (ed) Structural health monitoring, current status and perspective. Technomic Publishing, Lancaster, pp 418–430
Modena C, Sonda D, Zonta D (1999) Damage localization in reinforced concrete structures by using damping measurements, damage assessment of structures. The International Conference on Damage Assessment of Structures (DAMAS ‘99). Dublin, Ireland, pp 132–141
Sohn H, Farrar CR (2000) Statistical process control and projection techniques for damage detection. In: European COST F3 Conference on System Identification and Structural Health Monitoring. Madrid, Spain
Chen LJ, Yu L (2013) Structural nonlinear damage identification algorithm based on time series ARMA/GARCH model. Adv Struct Eng 16(9):1597–1609
Choudhury AR (1996) Damage detection in structures using measured frequency response function data. In: Department of Mechanical Engineering. 1996, Victoria University of Technology
Adams DE (2007) Health monitoring of structural materials and components. Wiley, Chichester
Abdalla M, Grigoriadis KM, Zimmerman DC (1998) Enhanced damaged detection using linear matrix inequalities. In: 16th International Modal Analysis Conference, Santa Barbara, CA
Hwang HY, Kim C (2004) Damage detection in structures using a few frequency response measurements. J Sound Vib 270:1–14
Fugate ML, Sohn H, Farrar CR (2001) Vibration-based damage detection using statistical process control. Mech Syst Signal Process 16(4):707–721
Su WC, Huang CS, Hung SL, Chen LJ, Lin WJ (2012) Locating damaged storeys in a shear building based on its sub-structural natural frequencies. Eng Struct 39:126–138
Huang Q, Xu YL, Li JC, Su ZQ, Liu HJ (2012) Structural damage detection of controlled building structures using frequency response functions. J Sound Vib 331:3476–3492
Ewins DJ (1984) Modal testing: theory and practice. In: Research Studies Press, Letchworth, Hertfordshire, England
Salawu OS (1997) Detection of structural damage through changes in frequency: a review. Eng Struct 19(9):718–723
Chen B, Xu YL (2008) Integrated vibration control and health monitoring of building structures using semi-active friction dampers : Part II—Numerical investigation. Eng Struct 30(3):573–587
da Silva S, Dias JM, Lopes JV, Brennan MJ (2008) Structural damage detection by fuzzy clustering. Mech Syst Signal Process. 22(7):1636–1649
Askegaard V, Mossing P (1988) Long-term observation of RC-bridge using changes in natural frequencies. Nordic Concr Res. 7:20–27
Yu L, Zhu JH (2015) Nonlinear damage detection using higher statistical moments of structural responses. Struct Eng Mech. 54(2):221–237
Figueriedo E, Park G, Figuerias J, Farrar C, Worden K (2009) Structural health monitoring algorithm comparisons using standard data sets. Rep. LA-14393, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM
Chen J, Garba JA (1988) On-orbit damage assessment for large space structures. AIAA J. 26(9):1119–1126
Li H, Hyang Y, Ou J, Bao Y (2011) Fractal dimension based damage detection method for beams with a uniform cross-section. Comput Aided Civil Infrastruct Eng. 26(3):190–206
Wang J, Qiao P (2007) Improved damage detection of beam type structures using uniform load surface. Struct Health Monit. 6(2):99–110
Zhu H, Li L, He XQ (2011) Damage detection method for shear buildings using the changes in the first mode shape slopes. Comput Struct 89:733–748
Roy K, Chaudhuri SR (2013) Fundamental mode shape and its derivatives in structural damage localization. J Sound Vib 332:5584–5593
Fan W, Qiao P (2011) Vibration-based damage identification methods : a review and comparative study. Struct Health Monit. 10(1):83–111
Wang S (2013) Damage detection in offshore platform structures from limited modal data. Appl Ocean Res 41:48–56
Shi ZY, Law SS, Zhang LM (1998) Structural damage localization from Modal strain energy change. J Sound Vib 218(5):825–844
Alvandi A, Cremona C (2005) Assessment of vibration-based damage identification techniques. J Sound Vib 292:179–202
Stubbs N, Kim JT, Farrar CR (1995) Field verification of a non-destructive damage localization and severity estimation algorithm. In: Proceedings of 13th international modal analysis conference 1995
Cornwell P (1999) Application of the strain energy damage detection method to plate-like structures. J Sound Vib 224(2):359–374
Dawari VB, Kamble PP, Vesmawala GR (2015) Structural damage identification using modal strain energy method. Adv Struct Eng. 3:2599–2607
Shih HW, Thambiratnam DP, Chan THT (2009) Vibration based structural damage detection in flexural members using multi-criteria approach. J Sound Vib 323:645–661
Park S, Kim YB, Stubbs N (2002) Nondestructive damage detection in large structures via vibration monitoring. Electron J Struct Eng. 2:359–374
Radzien´ski M, Krawczuk M, Palacz M (2011) Improvement of damage detection methods based on experimental modal parameters. Mech Syst Signal Process 25:2169–2190
Fukunaga H, Hu N, Chang FK (2002) Structural damage identification using piezoelectric sensors. Int J Solids Struct 39:393–418
Okafor AC, Chandrashekhara K, Jiang YP (1996) Delamination prediction in composite beams with built-in piezoelectric devices using modal analysis and neural network. Smart Mater Struct 5:338–347
Tseng KKH, Naidu ASK (2002) Non-parametric damage detection and characterization using smart piezoceramic material. Smart Mater Struct 11(3):317
Oppenheim AV, Schafer RW (eds) (1989) Discrete-time signal processing. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs
Altunok E, Taha MMR, Ross TJ (2007) Possibilistic approach for damage detection in structural health monitoring. J Struct Eng 133(9):1247–1256
Sohn H, Law KH (1997) A Bayesian probabilistic approach for structure damage detection. Earthq Eng Struct Dynam 26(12):1259–1281
Katafygiotis LS, Lam HF, Mickleborough N (2004) Application of a statistical model updating approach on phase I of the IASC–ASCE structural health monitoring benchmark study. J Eng Mech. 130(1):34–48
Beck JL, Katafygiotis LS (1998) Updating models and their uncertainties. Part 1: Bayesian statistical framework. J Eng Mech. 124(4):455–461
Beck JL, Au SK, Vanik M (2001) Monitoring structural health using a probabilistic measure. Comput Aided Civil Infrastruct Eng. 16(1):1–11
Beck JL, Yuen KV (2004) Model selection using response measurements: Bayesian probabilistic approach. J Eng Mech. 130(2):192–203
Sohn H, Law KH (2000) Bayesian probabilistic damage detection of a reinforced-concrete bridge column. Earthq Eng Struct Dynam 29:1131–1152
Jeffrey H (ed) (1961) Theory of probability, ed. r. Edition. Oxford University Press, London
Dyke SJ, Bernal D, Beck JL, Ventura C (2001) An Experimental benchmark problem in structural health monitoring. In: Third International Workshop on Structural Health Monitoring. Stanford, CA
Ching J, Beck JL (2004) Bayesian analysis of the phase II IASC–ASCE structural health monitoring experimental benchmark data. J Eng Mech. 130(10):1233–1244
Bao C, Hao H, Li ZX (2013) Integrated ARMA model method for damage detection of subsea pipeline system. Eng Struct 48:176–192
Carden EP, Brownjohn JMW (2008) ARMA modelled time-series classification for structural health monitoring of civil Infrastructures. 2:295–314
Garcia GV, Osegueda R (1999) Damage detection using ARMA model coefficients. In: SPIE, The International Society for Optical Engineering
Pandit SM, Wu SM (eds) (1983) Time series and system analysis with applications. Wiley, NewYork
Mosavi AA, Dickey D, Seracino R, Rizkalla S (2012) Identifying damage locations under ambient vibrations utilizing vector autoregressive models and Mahalanobis distances. Mech Syst Signal Process 26:254–267
Mahalanobis PC (1936) On the generalised distance in statistics. In: The National Institute of Sciences of India
Bishop CM (1995) Neural networks for pattern recognition. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Fassois SD, Sakellariou JS (2007) Time series methods for fault detection and identification in vibrating structures. Philos Trans R Soc A Math Phys Eng Sci. 365:411–448
Kopsaftopoulos FP, Fassois SD (2010) Vibration based health monitoring for a lightweight truss structure: experimental assessment of several statistical time series methods. Mech Syst Signal Process 24:1977–1997
de Lautour OR, Omenzetter P (2010) Damage classification and estimation in experimental structures using time series analysis and pattern recognition. Mech Syst Signal Process 24(5):1556–1569
Trendafilova I, Manoach E (2008) Vibration-based damage detection in plates by using time series analysis. Mech Syst Signal Process 22:1092–1106
Kopsaftopoulos FP, Fassois SD (2013) A functional model based statistical time series method for vibration based damage detection, localization, and magnitude estimation. Mech Syst Signal Process 39:143–161
Balmes E, Wright JR. (1997) Garteur group on ground vibration testing—results from the test of a single structure by 12 laboratories in Europe. In: Proceedings of ASME Design EngineeringTechnical Conferences, Sacramento, USA
Chen K, Zheng WM (2009) Cloud computing: system instances and current research. J. Software. 20(5):1337–1348
Box G, Jenkins G (1976) Time series analysis: forecasting and control. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs
Gul M, Catbas FN (2011) Structural health monitoring and damage assessment using a novel time series analysis methodology with sensor clustering. J Sound Vib 330(6):1196–1210
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Das, S., Saha, P. & Patro, S.K. Vibration-based damage detection techniques used for health monitoring of structures: a review. J Civil Struct Health Monit 6, 477–507 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13349-016-0168-5
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13349-016-0168-5