Abstract
This review discusses contemporary river history literature of the past two decades. It presents an introduction to the evolution of river history literature and discusses its relation to the scholarly field of environmental history. The review argues that the study of river histories is increasingly sophisticated methodologically, particularly in interdisciplinary breadth and comparative approaches. This article concentrates on selected studies of European and North American rivers during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries and discusses the recent literature on river histories within three thematic frames. First, this paper discusses the spatial dimensions and different spatial scales of river histories, especially rivers as connectors and dividers. The second theme presents three different types of power relations in human–river interaction. Third, this paper will touch upon the temporal questions of river biographies. This review will pay special attention to the growing literature addressing the attempts to re-establish environmentally sound human–riverine relationships and improve the status of rivers through restorative activities. This article shows that a thematic analysis of contemporary river history offers a fruitful frame to understand the complex and intertwined nature of the temporal, spatial, and power-related dimensions in the narratives.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Some monographs and edited volumes on river histories include more rigorous introductory or concluding chapters with reflections on conceptual and thematic choices and their methodological implications in the historiography (Mauch and Zeller 2008; Pritchard 2011; Castonguay and Evenden 2012a, b; Coates 2013). But they draw mainly on the work presented in the edited volumes in question or the thematic subfield of the respective book.
I prefer the term field rather than discipline as a divergence from the institutional connotations of discipline. Scholarly field better includes the multiplicity of possible approaches and scholarly traditions applicable in environmental history, which, despite the flourishing scholarship, is still not an academically established discipline in many countries. See Huutoniemi et al. (2010). For the development of the field in general, see e.g. Hughes (2006).
This dynamism is reflected in the amount of non-western river history publications. As a key contribution, Volume 1 in the Water History Series (Eds. Tvedt and Jakobsson 2006a) offers an extensive selection of river history cases from all inhabited continents, and predominantly from the non-western world. For the Latin American perspective, see Cleary (2001) for a review of the environmental history of the Amazon.
The main sources have been the major journals in the field, Water History, Environmental History, and Environment & History. While the thematic foci of this paper guided the choice of monographs for the analysis, it was to some degree influenced by the significance of some works within the field, indicated by citations, and occasionally limited due to resources and availability. Additionally, I have included some works published in less common languages (Finnish and Swedish).
For the sake of clarity, I use river as an overarching term, including main rivers, tributaries, and smaller creeks as well, while being aware that river terminology is variable and differently defined according to linguistic, scientific, or historical contexts. The appropriate terms may vary by the discharge of the river, the navigability of the river, the size of its catchment area, its geographical location (e.g. in the Swedish language rivers north of the Göta älv and Dalälven are called älv, south of them å or ström, and rivers outside of Scandinavia are called flod), or other criteria.
European scholars with their linguistic diversity balance local significance and audience and international accessibility to their research against international academic publishing with an English language dominance. Since article-length contributions can cover only a very small and specific part of river history, terming them “environmental history of river X”, which implies comprehensive coverage of complex histories, may seem inaccurate to scholars. Special journal issues focusing on one river and successfully exemplified by the “Danube-issue” of Water History (Vol 5, issue 2, 2013), proves to be one recommendable alternative to bridge these challenges.
I use the term interdisciplinarity as an overarching term for different kinds of research activities that include at least two research fields, in whatever degree of interaction and relatedness, and I will not elaborate on the distinct conceptualizations of interdisciplinarity (e.g. multidisciplinarity, transdisciplinarity, etc.) See Huutoniemi et al. (2010). For a discussion on the possibilities and challenges of interdisciplinarity in environmental history see Hamilton et al. (2011).
Massa (1991) classifies the political sphere as a distinct, fourth category that also includes changes in the institutional structures.
Henshaw (2011) used the term “River of Inspiration” in his work on the Hudson River somewhat earlier but lacked more detailed elaboration on the nature of this “inspiration”.
Science, Technology and Society-studies, which itself is an interdisciplinary subject.
Special Issue of Water History Vol 5, issue 2 (2013).
In a rare example from non-western rivers, Hoag (2013) uses the insights from several African rivers (Rufiji, Gambia, Volta, Niger) to explore and explain continuities in African development and the related colonial legacies.
The adjacent articles on each case comprise a special edition of Water History 8(3):2016.
Several histories of earlier periods show that human induced alterations of riverine environments are by no means an invention of the late modern period nor exclusive to the North American or European spheres (see Wilson 2010; Hoffmann 2010). However, the scale and geographical extent of human activity constitute a landmark of the modern exploitation of rivers.
She credits Steinberg’s (1991) work for influence in the development of the concept.
A panel at the congress of the American Society for Environmental History in 2014 was titled ‘Rivers with bad habits’.
See special issue of Environment and History 19 (2), 2013.
See also Reuss and Cutcliffe (2010).
For an introduction to the roots and differences of historical environmental justice scholarship, see Massard-Guilbaud and Rodger 2011). Questions of justice has resonated in river history scholarship as well, and the perspective of the less-powerful in these struggles has become more present in the narratives. This is a significant theme in river histories of the non-western world, as well, as colonial legacies remain influential in present day challenges.
With the exception of Mark Cioc’s “Eco-Biography of the Rhine” (2002), scholars have passed over specifying what they mean, or what temporal specifications they attribute to ‘river biography.’ See the section entitled “River biographies” in Tvedt and Jakobsson (2006a, b), where river biography as a term is neither introduced by the editors nor by the individual contributors; see also Coates (2013, p. 86).
From a practical point of view, sudden exceptional events are also often the historical repositories of evidence and important source bases for the analysis.
Jakobsson (2008, pp. 55–56) see the references for examples.
This critique concerns the field of environmental history. See e.g. McNeill (2003, p. 35).
This is an important feature in non-western river historiography as highlighted by Hoag (2013) in a study on African rivers. The many sides of river management to development of the global South is a topical theme.
The Big Dam Era is often said to have started with the construction of the Hoover Dam (early 1930s) and it depicts the construction boom of large dams in North America, which lasted until the second half of the twentieth century (see e.g. Melosi 2011 for more). The (global) history of damming rivers is a vast and complex field as such, and deserves its own review.
I refrain from labeling the current time as post-industrial since, despite some shifts in emphasis, industrial production and the exploitative use of rivers remains a backbone of economic success in the global north.
For the historical baseline problem of ecological restoration in general, see e.g. Hall (2005).
Environmental history has been found to be to single most increased sub-field within history during the past 4 decades, see http://historians.org/publications-and-directories/perspectives-on-history/december-2015/the-rise-and-decline-of-history-specializations-over-the-past-40-years.
References
Ackroyd P (2007) Thames: sacred river. Chatto & Windus, London
Armstrong C, Evenden M, Nelles HV (2009) The river returns: an environmental history of the bow. McGill-Queen’s University Press, Montreal
Backouche I (2008) From Parisian river to national waterway: the social functions of the Seine, 1750–1850. In: Mauch C, Zeller T (eds) Rivers in history: perspectives on waterways in Europe and North America. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 26–40
Bagle E (2012) An urban industrial river: the multiple uses of the Akerselva river, 1850–1900. In: Castonguay S, Evenden M (eds) Urban rivers: remaking rivers, cities, and space in Europe and North America. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 57–74
Barles S (2007) Urban metabolism and river systems: an historical perspective—Paris and the Seine, 1790–1970. Hydrol Earth Syst Sci 11(6):1757–1769
Barles S (2012) The Seine and Parisian metabolism: growth of capital dependencies in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. In: Castonguay S, Evenden M (eds) Urban rivers: remaking rivers, cities, and space in Europe and North America. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 95–112
Berg R, Jakobsson E (2006) Nature and diplomacy: the struggle over the scandinavian border rivers in 1905. Scand J Hist 31(3–4):270–289. doi:10.1080/03468750600930795
Blackbourn D (2006) The conquest of nature: water, landscape, and the making of modern Germany, 1st American edn. Norton, New York
Blackbourn D (2008) “Time is a violent torrent”: constructing and reconstructing rivers in modern German history. In: Mauch C, Zeller T (eds) Rivers in history: perspectives on waterways in Europe and North America. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 11–25
Bonnell JL (2014) Reclaiming the don: an environmental history of Toronto’s Don River Valley. University of Toronto Press, Toronto
Carse A (2012) Nature as infrastructure: making and managing the Panama Canal watershed. Soc Stud Sci 42(4):539–563
Castonguay S, Evenden M (2012a) Introduction. In: Castonguay S, Evenden M (eds) Urban rivers: remaking rivers, cities, and space in Europe and North America. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 1–13
Castonguay S, Evenden M (2012b) Conclusion. In: Castonguay S, Evenden M (eds) Urban rivers: remaking rivers, cities, and space in Europe and North America. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 237–242
Cioc M (2002) The Rhine: an eco-biography, 1815–2000. University of Washington Press, Seattle
Cleary D (2001) Towards an environmental history of the Amazon: from prehistory to the nineteenth century. Lat Am Res Rev 36(2):65–96. http://www.jstor.org/stable/2692088
Closman CE (2008) Holding the line: pollution, power, and rivers in Yorkshire and the Ruhr, 1850–1990. In: Mauch C, Zeller T (eds) Rivers in history: perspectives on waterways in Europe and North America. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 89–109
Coates P (2013) A story of six rivers: history, culture and ecology. Reaktion Books, London
Collins TM, Muller EK, Tarr JA (2008) Pittsburgh’s three rivers: from industrial infrastructure to environmental asset. In: Mauch C, Zeller T (eds) Rivers in history: perspectives on waterways in Europe and North America. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 41–62
Cooke GD (2005) Restoration and management of lakes and reservoirs, 3rd edn. CRC Press, Boca Raton
Cronon W (1992) A place for stories: nature, history, and narrative. J Am Hist 78(4):1347–1376
Cusack T (2010) Riverscapes and national identities, Kindle-edition. Syracuse University Press, Syracuse
Deligne C (2012) Brussels and its Rivers, 1770–1880: reshaping an urban landscape. In: Castonguay S, Evenden M (eds) Urban rivers: remaking rivers, cities, and space in Europe and North America. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 17–33
Doyle M, Havick DG (2009) Infrastructure and the environment. Annu Rev Environ Resour 34:349–373
Evenden M (2004) Fish versus power: an environmental history of the Fraser River. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Evenden M (2015) Allied power: mobilizing hydroelectricity during Canada’s Second World War. University of Toronto Press, Toronto
Fougeres D (2011) Surface water in the early nineteenth century. In: Castonguay S, Dagenais M (eds) Metropolitan natures: environmental histories of Montreal. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 85–100
Garcier RJ (2007) Rivers we can’t bring ourselves to clean—historical insights into the pollution of the Moselle River (France), 1850–2000. Hydrol Earth Syst Sci 11(6):1731–1745. doi:10.5194/hess-11-1731-2007
Gierlinger S, Haidvogl G, Gingrich S, Krausmann F (2013) Feeding and cleaning the city: the role of urban waterscape in provision and disposal in Vienna during the industrial transformation. Water Hist 5(2):219–239
Graham S, Marvin S (2001) Splintering urbanism: networked infrastructures, technological mobilities and the urban condition. Routledge, London
Gumbrecht B (2000) The Los Angeles river: its life, death, and possible rebirth, Paperback edn. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore
Hall M (2005) Earth repair: a transatlantic history of environmental restoration. University of Virginia Press, Charlottesville
Hamilton A, Watson F, Davies AL, Hanley N (2011) Interdisciplinary conversations: the collective model. In: Sörlin S, Warde P (eds) Nature’s end: history and the environment, Paperback edn. Palgrave Macmillan, Hampshire, pp 162–187
Hasenöhrl U (2008) Postwar perceptions of German rivers: a study of the lech as energy source, nature preserve, and tourist attraction. In: Mauch C, Zeller T (eds) Rivers in history: perspectives on waterways in Europe and North America. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 137–148
Henshaw RE, Dunwell F (eds) (2011) Environmental history of the Hudson River: human uses that changed the ecology, ecology that changed human uses. State University of New York Press, New York
Hoag H (2013) Developing the rivers of east and west Africa: an environmental history. Bloomsbury Academic, London
Hoffmann RC (2010) Elemental resources and aquatic ecosystems: medieval europeans and their rivers. In: Tvedt T, Coopey R (eds) A history of water: vol 2, Rivers and society: from early civilizations to modern times, I.B. Tauris, London, pp 165-202
Hohensinner S, Jungwirth M (2016) The unknown third dimension: terrain elevations, water depths and fluvial dynamics of Austrian Danube river landscapes prior to regulation. Österreichische wasser- abfallwirtschaft 68(7):324–341. doi:10.1007/s00506-016-0323-6
Hohensinner S, Sonnlechner C, Schmid M, Winiwarter V (2013) Two steps back, one step forward: reconstructing the dynamic Danube riverscape under human influence in Vienna. Water Hist 5(2):121–143. doi:10.1007/s12685-013-0076-0
Hughes JD (2006) What is environmental history? Polity Press, Cambridge
Huutoniemi K, Klein JT, Bruun H, Hukkinen J (2010) Analyzing interdisciplinarity: typology and indicators. Res Policy 39(1):79–88. doi:10.1016/j.respol.2009.09.011
Jakobsson E (1996) Industrialisering av älvar: Studier kring svensk vattenkraftutbyggnad 1900–1918. Dissertation, Historiska Institutionen i Göteborg
Jakobsson E (2002) Industrialization of rivers: A water system approach to hydropower development. Knowl, Technol Policy, 14(4), 41. Retrieved from http://www.search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=ehh&AN=7707533&site=ehost-live&scope=site
Jakobsson E (2008) Narratives about the river and the dam. In: Seminarrapport Utstein Kloster (ed) Technological society—multidisciplinary and long-time perspectives, Haugaland Akadem, Haugaland, pp 53–61
Kelman A (2006) A river and its city: the nature of landscape in New Orleans, 2nd edn. University of California Press, Berkley
Kibel PS (ed) (2007) Rivertown: rethinking urban rivers. MIT Press, Cambridge
Kinnersley D (1988) Troubled water: rivers, politics and pollution. Hilary Shipman Ltd., London
Korjonen-Kuusipuro K (2011) Critical water: negotiating the Vuoksi river in 1940. Water Hist 3(3):169–186. doi:10.1007/s12685-011-0035-6
Korjonen-Kuusipuro K (2012) Yhteinen Vuoksi: Ihmisen ja ympäristön kulttuurinen vuorovaikutus Vuoksen jokilaaksossa 1800-luvulta nykypäiviin. Dissertation, Oulun yliopisto
Korjonen-Kuusipuro K, Kohvakka M (2010) Vuoksi historiallisena tilana. Hist Aikak 108(1):73–84
Lehmkuhl U (2007) Historicizing nature: time and space in German and American environmental historiography. In: Lehmkuhl U, Wellenreuther H (eds) Historians and nature: comparative approaches to environmental history, The Krefeld Historical Symposia edn. Berg, Oxford, pp 17–44
Lübken U (2012) Rivers and risk in the city: the urban floodplain as a contested space. In: Castonguay S, Evenden M (eds) Urban rivers: remaking rivers, cities, and space in Europe and North America. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 130–144
Lübken U (2014) Die natur der gefahr: überschwemmungen am Ohio River im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert, Vandenhoek & Ruprecht, Göttingen
Luckin B (2001) Pollution in the city. In: Daunton M (ed) Cambridge urban history of Britain, volume 3, 1849–1950, Online edn. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 207–228
MacFarlane D (2014) Negotiating a river: Canada, the US, and the creation of the St. Lawrence Seaway. UBC Press, Vancouver
Massa I (1991) Ympäristöhistoria tutkimuskohteena. Hist Aikak 98(4):294–301
Massard-Guildbaud G (forthcoming) The city whose rivers disappeared. Nantes, 1850–1950. In: Schott D, Knoll M, Lübken U (eds) Cities and rivers. Historical interactions. Pittsburgh University Press, Pittsburgh
Massard-Guilbaud G, Rodger R (2011) Reconsidering justice in past cities: when environmental and social dimensions meet. In: Massard-Guilbaud G, Rodger R (eds) Environmental and social justice in the city: historical perspectives. White Horse Press, Cambridge, pp 1–40
Mauch C, Zeller T (2008) Rivers in history and historiography: an introduction. In: Mauch C, Zeller T (eds) Rivers in history: perspectives on waterways in Europe and North America. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 1–10
McCool D (2010) Implementing river restoration projects. In: Hall M (ed) Restoration and history: the search for a usable environmental past. Routledge, New York, pp 275–283
McCool D (2012) River republic: the fall and rise of America’s rivers. Columbia University Press, New York
McCully P (2001) Silenced Rivers: The Ecology and Politics of Large Dams. Enl. and updated edn., Zed, London.
McNeill JR (2003) Observations on the nature and culture of environmental history. Hist Theory 42:5–43
Melosi MV (2011) Precious commodity: providing water for America’s cities. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh
Morris C (2012) The big muddy: an environmental history of the Mississippi and its peoples from Hernando de Soto to Hurricane Katrina. Oxford University Press, New York
Mosley S (2010) The environment in world history. Routledge, Abingdon
Pawson E, Dovers S (2003) Environmental history and the challenges of interdisciplinarity: an Antipodean perspective. Environ Hist 9(1):53–75
Pritchard SB (2011) Confluence: the nature of technology and the remaking of the Rhône. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Pritchard SB, Zeller T (2010) The nature of industrialization. In: Reuss M, Cutcliffe SH (eds) The illusory boundary: environment and technology in history. University of Virginia Press, Charlottesville, pp 69–100
Reuss M, Cutcliffe SH (2010) Introduction. In: Reuss M, Cutcliffe SH (eds) The illusory boundary: environment and technology in history. University of Virginia Press, Charlottesville, pp 1–6
Ritter C (1865) Comparative geography (transl. Gage WL ed) J.B. Lippincott & Co, Philadelphia
Rosenberg E (2015) Water infrastructure and community building: the case of Marvin Gaye park. J Urban Des 20(2):193–211. doi:10.1080/13574809.2015.1009011
Rueck D (2011) When bridges become barriers: montreal and kahnawake mohawk territory. In: Castonguay S, Dagenais M (eds) Metropolitan natures: environmental histories of Montreal. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 228–244
Russell E, Tucker RP (2004) Introduction. In: Tucker R, Russell E (eds) Natural enemy, natural ally: toward an environmental history of Warfare. Oregon State University Press, Corvallis, pp 1–14
Saikku M (2005) This delta, this land: an environmental history of the Yazoo-Mississippi floodplain. University of Georgia Press, Athens
Schneer J (2005) The Thames. Yale University Press, New Haven
Schönach P (2004) Saippuakuplista suojeluun: Vantaanjoen ympäristöhistoriaa 1945–1963. Tutkimuskatsauksia 6. Helsingin kaupungin tietokeskus, Helsinki
Schönach P (2015) Expanding sanitary infrastructure and the shaping of river history: River Vantaa (Finland), 1876–1982. Environ Hist 21(2):201–226
Showers KB (2009) Congo River’s Grand Inga hydroelectricity scheme: linking environmental history, policy and impact. Water Hist 1(1):31–58. doi:10.1007/s12685-009-0001-8
Steinberg T (1991) Nature incorporated: industrialization and the waters of New England. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Summitt AR (2013) Contested waters: an environmental history of the Colorado river. University Press of Colorado, Boulder
Swyngedouw E (2004) Social power and the urbanization of water: flows of power. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Swyngedouw E (2015) Liquid power: contested hydro-modernities in twentieth-century Spain. MIT Press, Cambridge
Talbott H (2009) River of dreams: the story of the Hudson River. G.P. Putnam’s Sons Books for Young Readers, New York
Tarr JA (2002) The metabolism of the industrial city: the case of Pittsburgh. J Urban Hist 28(5):511–545
Tarr JA (2010) The city as an artifact of technology and the environment. In: Reuss M, Cutcliffe SH (eds) The illusory boundary: environment and technology in history. University of Virginia Press, Charlottesville, pp 145–170
Tvedt T (2004) The River Nile in the age of the British: political ecology and the quest for economic power. I. B Tauris, London
Tvedt T, Coopey R (2010) A ‘water systems’ perspective on history. In: Tvedt T, Coopey R (eds) A history of water: vol 2, Rivers and society: from early civilizations to modern times, I.B. Tauris, London, pp 3-26
Tvedt T, Jakobsson E (2006a) Introducttion: water history is world history. In: Tvedt T, Jakobsson E (eds) A history of water: volume 1: water control and river biographies. I.B. Tauris, London, pp ix–xxiii
Tvedt T, Jakobsson E (2006b) A history of water: volume 1: water control and river biographies. I. B. Tauris, London
Tvedt T, Oestgaard T (2006) Introduction. In: Tvedt T, Oestgaard T (eds) A history of water. volume 3: the world of water. I.B. Tauris, London, pp ix–xxii
Uekötter F (2007) Enzyklopädie deutscher geschichte. bd. 81, umweltgeschichte im 19. und 20. jahrhundert. Oldenbourg, Münch
van Dam P, Verstegen SW (2009) Environmental history: object of study and methodology. In: Boersma JJ, Reijnders L (eds) Principles of environmental sciences. Springer, Dordrecht, pp 25–31
Warren LS (2003) Introduction. In: Warren LS (ed) American environmental history. Blackwell, Malden, pp 1–3
White R (1995) The organic machine: the remaking of the Columbia River. Hill and Wang, New York
Williams JC (2010) Understanding the place of humans in nature. In: Reuss M, Cutcliffe SH (eds) The illusory boundary: environment and technology in history. University of Virginia Press, Charlottesville, pp 9–25
Wilson RI (2010) Changing river regimes on the Kanto Plain, Japan, 1600–1900. In: Tvedt T, Coopey R (eds) A history of water, vol 2, Rivers and society: from early civilizations to modern times, I.B. Tauris, London, pp. 287–311
Winiwarter V, Schmid M, Hohensinner S, Haidvogl G (2013) The environmental history of the Danube river basin as an issue of long-term socio-ecological research. In: Singh SJ, Haberl H, Chertow M, Mirtl M, Schmid M (eds) Long term socio-ecological research: studies in society-nature interactions across spatial and temporal scales. Springer, Dordrecht, pp 103–122. doi:10.1007/978-94-007-1177-8_5
Winiwarter V, Haidvogl G, Hohensinner S, Hauer F, Bürkner M (2016) The long-term evolution of urban waters and their nineteenth century transformation in European cities. A comparative environmental history. Water Hist 8(3):209–233. doi:10.1007/s12685-016-0172-z
Worster D (1985) Rivers of empire: water, aridity and the growth of the American West. Pantheon Books, New York
Zeisler-Vralsted D (2008) The cultural and hydrological development of the Mississippi and Volga rivers. In: Mauch C, Zeller T (eds) Rivers in history: perspectives on waterways in Europe and North America. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 63–77
Zeisler-Vralsted D (2015) Rivers, memory, and nation-building: a history of the Volga and Mississippi rivers. Berghahn Books, New York
Acknowledgements
This study was funded by the Helsinki University Centre for Environment (Multidom-project) and the Academy of Finland (Grant Nos. 263305 and 286676).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Schönach, P. River histories: a thematic review. Water Hist 9, 233–257 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12685-016-0188-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12685-016-0188-4