Abstract
Groundwater vulnerability assessment is an important task in water resources and land management. The most sophisticated among the vulnerability assessment techniques is the GIS-based DRASTIC model. However, despite its popularity, it is marred with excessive subjectivity glitches; little research has been conducted to address the shortcomings associated with this method. This study investigates various issues regarding the application of the GIS-based DRASTIC model through a critical review of relevant literatures. It is revealed that all the DRASTIC parameters are equally significant irrespective of their assigned weights. On the contentious quantile classifications, however, a categorical classification defined by ‘very low’, ‘low’, ‘medium’, ‘high’, and ‘very high’ was suggested for standardization. Based on the studied literatures, it was established that 46 % of 977 million km2 of land assessed globally fell within moderate to high vulnerability category—a land cover bigger than the cultivated lands obtainable in all the countries around the world except the United States, India, China, Russia, Brazil, Canada and Australia.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adams B, Foster SSD (1992) Land-Surface Zoning for Groundwater Protection. Water Environ J 6:312–319
Ahmed A (2009) Using Generic and Pesticide DRASTIC GIS-based models for vulnerability assessment of the Quaternary aquifer at Sohag. Egypt Hydrogeol J 17:1203–1217
Al-Adamat RAN, Foster IDL, Baban SMJ (2003) Groundwater vulnerability and risk mapping for the Basaltic aquifer of the Azraq basin of Jordan using GIS Remote sensing and DRASTIC. Applied Geography 23:303–324
Aller L, Bennett T, Lehr J, Petty R (1985) DRASTIC: a standardized system for evaluating groundwater pollution using hydrogeologic settings.-US EPA/Robert S. Kerr Environmental Research Laboratory. EPA/600/2-85/018, p 163
Al-Zabet T (2002) Evaluation of aquifer vulnerability to contamination potential using the DRASTIC method. Environ Geol 43:203–208
Antonakos AK, Lambrakis NJ (2007) Development and testing of three hybrid methods for the assessment of aquifer vulnerability to nitrates, based on the drastic model, an example from NE Korinthia. Greece J Hydrol 333:288–304
Anwar AF, Yunus A (2010) Pesticide leaching potential in a shallow unconfined aquifer. J Water Environ Technol 8(1):1–16
Anwar AF, Yunus A (2013) Groundwater vulnerability to pesticides in Northwest Bangladesh. Environ Earth Sc 70(5):1971–1981
Awawdeh M, Jaradat R (2010) Evaluation of aquifers vulnerability to contamination in the Yarmouk River basin Jordan, based on DRASTIC method. Arab J Geosci 3:273–282
Baalousha H (2006) Vulnerability assessment for the Gaza Strip Palestine using DRASTIC. Environ Geol 50:405–414
Baalousha H (2011) Mapping groundwater contamination risk using GIS and groundwater modelling A case study from the Gaza Strip, Palestine. Arab J Geosci 4:483–494
Baba A, Tayfur G (2011) Groundwater contamination and its effect on health in Turkey. Environ Monit Assess 183:77–94
Babiker IS, Mohamed MAA, Hiyama T, Kato K (2005) A GIS-based DRASTIC model for assessing aquifer vulnerability in Kakamigahara Heights Gifu Prefecture, central Japan. Sci Total Environ 345:127–140
Bachmat Y, Collin M (1990) Management-oriented assessment of groundwater vulnerability to pollution Israel Hydrological Service Report. Jerusalem 6:30
Bai L, Wang Y, Meng F (2012) Application of DRASTIC and extension theory in the groundwater vulnerability evaluation. Water Environ J 26:381–391
Barber C, Bates LE, Barron R, Allison H (1993) Assessment of the relative vulnerability of groundwater to pollution: a review and background paper for the conference workshop on vulnerability assessment. J Aust Geol Geophys 14:1147–1154
Bazimenyera JDD, Zhonghua T (2008) A GIS based DRASTIC model for assessing groundwater vulnerability in shallow aquifer in Hangzhou-Jiaxing-Huzhou Plain. China Res J Appl Sci 3:550–559
Bedessem ME, Casey B, Frederick K, Nibbelink N (2005) Aquifer prioritization for ambient ground water monitoring. Ground Water Monit Rem 25:150–158
Bojórquez-Tapia LA, Cruz-Bello GM, Luna-González L, Juárez L, Ortiz-Pérez MA (2009) V-DRASTIC: using visualization to engage policymakers in groundwater vulnerability assessment. J Hydrol 373:242–255
Boughriba M, Barkaoui A-e, Zarhloule Y, Lahmer Z, Houadi B, Verdoya M (2010) Groundwater vulnerability and risk mapping of the Angad transboundary aquifer using DRASTIC index method in GIS environment Arab. J Geosci 3:207–220
Chen W, Lu S, Peng C, Jiao W, Wang M (2013) Accumulation of Cd in agricultural soil under long-term reclaimed water irrigation. Environ Pollut 178:294–299
Chitsazan M, Akhtari Y (2009) A GIS-based DRASTIC Model for Assessing Aquifer Vulnerability in Kherran Plain. Khuzestan, Iran Water Resources Management 23:1137–1155
Connell LD, Daele Gvd (2003) A quantitative approach to aquifer vulnerability mapping. J Hydrol 276:71–88
Corniello A, Ducci D, Napolitano P (1997) Comparison between parametric methods to evaluate aquifer pollution vulnerability using GIS: an example in the “Piana Campana”, southern Italy Engineering geology and the environment Balkema, Rotterdam: 1721–1726
Denny S, Allen D, Journeay J (2007) DRASTIC-Fm: a modified vulnerability mapping method for structurally controlled aquifers in the southern Gulf Islands, British Columbia. Can Hydrogeol J 15:483–493
Dixon B (2005) Groundwater vulnerability mapping: a GIS and fuzzy rule based integrated tool. Appl Geogr 25:327–347
El-Naqa A, Hammouri N, Kuisi M (2006) GIS-based evaluation of groundwater vulnerability in the Russeifa area. Jordan Revista mexicana de ciencias geológicas 23:277–287
Evans BM, Myers WL (1990) A GIS-based approach to evaluating regional groundwater pollution potential with DRASTIC. J Soil Water Conserv 45:242–245
Fritch TG, McKnight CL, Yelderman JC Jr, Arnold JG (2000) An Aquifer Vulnerability Assessment of the Paluxy Aquifer Central Texas, USA, Using GIS and a Modified DRASTIC. Approach Environ Manag 25:337–345
Gerth J, Förstner U (2004) Part IV: fitness for Aquatic Systems Long-term Forecast: Key to groundwater protection. Environ Sci Pollut Res 11:49–56
Gogu RC, Dassargues A (2000) Current trends and future challenges in groundwater vulnerability assessment using overlay and index methods. Environ Geol 39:549–559
Hamza MH, Added A, Rodríguez R, Abdeljaoued S, Ben Mammou A (2007) A GIS-based DRASTIC vulnerability and net recharge reassessment in an aquifer of a semi-arid region (Metline-Ras Jebel-Raf Raf aquifer, Northern Tunisia). J Environ Manage 84:12–19
Harris GCMB, Hatzinger P, Root K (1988) Mapping groundwater recharge areas for land use planning: a case study in northern New York, USA Land Use Policy
Hasiniaina F, Zhou J, Guoyi L (2010) Regional assessment of groundwater vulnerability in Tamtsag basin, Mongolia using drastic model. J Am Sci 6:65–78
Herlinger R Jr, Viero A (2007) Groundwater vulnerability assessment in coastal plain of Rio Grande do Sul State Brazil, using drastic and adsorption capacity of soils. Environ Geol 52:819–829
Hua J, Hu L, Linwei F, Shuyan X (2011) Research progress of a GIS-based DRASTIC model. In: Mechanic automation and control engineering (MACE), 2011 Second International Conference on 2524–2526
Huan H, Wang J, Teng Y (2012) Assessment and validation of groundwater vulnerability to nitrate based on a modified DRASTIC model: a case study in Jilin City of northeast China. Sci Total Environ 440:14–23
Jamrah A, Al-Futaisi A, Rajmohan N, Al-Yaroubi S (2008) Assessment of groundwater vulnerability in the coastal region of Oman using DRASTIC index method in GIS environment. Environ Monit Assess 147:125–138
Jones F, Watkins J (1985) The water cycle as a source of pathogens. J Appl Microbiol 59:27S–36S
Kabera T, Zhaohui L (2008) A GIS Based DRASTIC Model for Assessing Groundwater in Shallow Aquifer in Yuncheng Basin, Shanxi. China Res J Appl Sci 3:195–205
Kazakis N, Voudouris K (2011) Comparison of three applied methods of groundwater vulnerability mapping: a case study from the Florina basin, Northern Greece. In: Lambrakis N, Stournaras G, Katsanou K (eds) Advances in the research of aquatic environment. Environmental Earth Sciences, Springer, Berlin Heidelberg, pp 359–367
Kim YJ, Hamm S-Y (1999) Assessment of the potential for groundwater contamination using the DRASTIC/EGIS technique, Cheongju area. South Korea Hydrogeol J 7:227–235
Lapworth D, Baran N, Stuart M, Ward R (2012) Emerging organic contaminants in groundwater: a review of sources, fate and occurrence. Environ Pollut 163:287–303
Lee S (2003) Evaluation of waste disposal site using the DRASTIC system in Southern Korea. Environ Geol 44:654–664
Leone A, Ripa MN, Uricchio V, Deák J, Vargay Z (2009) Vulnerability and risk evaluation of agricultural nitrogen pollution for Hungary’s main aquifer using DRASTIC and GLEAMS models. J Environ Manage 90:2969–2978
Llamas M, Custodio E (2003) Intensive use of groundwater: a new situation which demands proactive action Intensive Use of Groundwater: Challenges and Opportunities:13–31
Lodwick WA, Monson W, Svoboda L (1990) Attribute error and sensitivity analysis of map operations in geographical informations systems: suitability analysis. Int J Geogr Info Syst 4:413–428
Mádl-Szőnyi J, Füle L (1998) Groundwater vulnerability assessment of the SW Trans-Danubian Central Range. Hungary Environ Geol 35:9–18
McLay CDA, Dragten R, Sparling G, Selvarajah N (2001) Predicting groundwater nitrate concentrations in a region of mixed agricultural land use: a comparison of three approaches. Environ Pollut 115:191–204
Mendoza JA, Barmen G (2006) Assessment of groundwater vulnerability in the Río Artiguas basin. Nicaragua Environ Geol 50:569–580
Merchant JW (1994) GIS-based groundwater pollution hazard assessment: a critical review of the DRASTIC model, vol 9. American Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing Bethesda, MD, ETATS-UNIS
Metni M, El-Fadel M, Sadek S, Kayal R, Lichaa El Khoury D (2004) Groundwater resources in Lebanon: a vulnerability assessment. Int J Water Resour D 20:475–492
Moghaddam AA, Fijani E (2008) Distribution of fluoride in groundwater of Maku area, northwest of Iran. Environ Geol 56:281–287
Mohammadi K, Niknam R, Majd V (2009) Aquifer vulnerability assessment using GIS and fuzzy system: a case study in Tehran-Karaj aquifer. Iran Environ Geol 58:437–446
Moratalla Á, Gómez-Alday J, Sanz D, Castaño S, Heras J (2011) Evaluation of a GIS-Based Integrated Vulnerability Risk Assessment for the Mancha Oriental System (SE Spain). Water Resour Manage 25:3677–3697
Napolitano P, Fabbri A (1996) Single-parameter sensitivity analysis for aquifer vulnerability assessment using DRASTIC and SINTACS IAHS Publications-Series of Proceedings and Reports-Intern. Assoc Hydrol Sci 235:559–566
Nobre RCM, Rotunno Filho OC, Mansur WJ, Nobre MMM, Cosenza CAN (2007) Groundwater vulnerability and risk mapping using GIS, modeling and a fuzzy logic tool. J Contam Hydrol 94:277–292
Pathak D, Hiratsuka A, Awata I, Chen L (2009) Groundwater vulnerability assessment in shallow aquifer of Kathmandu Valley using GIS-based DRASTIC model. Environ Geol 57:1569–1578
Perrin J, Jeannin P-Y, Zwahlen F (2003) Epikarst storage in a karst aquifer: a conceptual model based on isotopic data Milandre test site. Switz J Hydrol 279:106–124
Phan K et al (2013) Assessing mixed trace elements in groundwater and their health risk of residents living in the Mekong River basin of Cambodia. Environ Pollut 182:111–119
Piscopo G (2001) Groundwater vulnerability map explanatory notes-Castlereagh catchment Parramatta NSW: Australia NSW Department of Land and Water Conservation
Polemio M, Dragone V, Limoni PP (2009) Monitoring and methods to analyse the groundwater quality degradation risk in coastal karstic aquifers (Apulia, Southern Italy). Environ Geol 58:299–312
Prasad R, Singh VS, Krishnamacharyulu SKG, Banerjee P (2011) Application of drastic model and GIS: for assessing vulnerability in hard rock granitic aquifer. Environ Monit Assess 176:143–155
Rahman A (2008) A GIS based DRASTIC model for assessing groundwater vulnerability in shallow aquifer in Aligarh. India Appl Geogr 28:32–53
Ranjan P, Gupta AD, Kazama S, Sawamoto M (2007) Assessment of aquifer-land use composite vulnerability in Walawe River Basin. Sri Lanka Asian J Water Environ Pollut 4:1–10
Rao SM, Mamatha P (2004) Water quality in sustainable water management. Curr Sci India 87:942
Rezaei F, Safavi H, Ahmadi A (2013) Groundwater Vulnerability Assessment Using Fuzzy Logic: a Case Study in the Zayandehrood Aquifers. Iran Environ Manage 51:267–277
Saidi S, Bouri S, Ben Dhia H (2010) Groundwater vulnerability and risk mapping of the Hajeb-jelma aquifer (Central Tunisia) using a GIS-based DRASTIC model. Environ Earth Sci 59:1579–1588
Saidi S, Bouri S, Ben Dhia H, Anselme B (2011) Assessment of groundwater risk using intrinsic vulnerability and hazard mapping: application to Souassi aquifer. Tunisian Sahel Agr Water Manage 98:1671–1682
Samey AA, Gang C (2008) A GIS Based DRASTIC Model for the Assessment of Groundwater Vulnerability to Pollution in West Mitidja: blida City. Algeria Res J Applied Sci 3:500–507
Scott H, Smith P, Spradley P (1992) Using DRASTIC and pesticide usage to determine potential locations of pesticides in ground water in Arkansas Fayetteville. Arkansas Association of Pesticide Applicators, AR
Secunda S, Collin ML, Melloul AJ (1998) Groundwater vulnerability assessment using a composite model combining DRASTIC with extensive agricultural land use in Israel’s Sharon region. J Environ Manage 54:39–57
Sener E, Sener S, Davraz A (2009) Assessment of aquifer vulnerability based on GIS and DRASTIC methods: a case study of the Senirkent-Uluborlu Basin (Isparta, Turkey) Hydrogeol J 17:2023-2035
Shirazi SM, Imran HM, Akib S (2012) GIS-based DRASTIC method for groundwater vulnerability assessment: a review. J Risk Res 15:991–1011
Shukla S, Mostaghimi S, Shanholt VO, Collins MC, Ross BB (2000) A County-Level Assessment of Ground Water Contamination by Pesticides Ground Water Monitoring & Remediation 20:104–119
Sinan M, Razack M (2009) An extension to the DRASTIC model to assess groundwater vulnerability to pollution: application to the Haouz aquifer of Marrakech (Morocco) Environ Geol 57:349-363
Srinivasamoorthy K, Vijayaraghavan K, Vasanthavigar M, Sarma VS, Rajivgandhi R, Chidambaram S, Anandhan P, Manivannan R (2011) Assessment of groundwater vulnerability in Mettur region Tamilnadu, India using drastic and GIS techniques. Arab J Geosci 4:1215–1228
Tesoriero A J IEL (1998) Assessing groundwater vulnerability using logistic regression. proceedings for the Source Water Assessment and Protection 98 Conference, Dallas TX:157-165
Tesoriero AJ, Inkpen EL, Voss FD (1998) Assessing groundwater vulnerability using logistic regression. Proceedings for the Source Water Assessment and Protection 98 Conference. Dallas, TX, pp 157–165
Thirumalaivasan D, Karmegam M, Venugopal K (2003) AHP-DRASTIC: software for specific aquifer vulnerability assessment using DRASTIC model and GIS. Environ Modell Softw 18:645–656
Tilahun K, Merkel B (2010) Assessment of groundwater vulnerability to pollution in Dire Dawa Ethiopia using DRASTIC. Environ Earth Sci 59:1485–1496
Tsakiris G (2009) A Paradigm for Applying Risk and Hazard Concepts in Proactive Planning. In: Iglesias A, Cancelliere A, Wilhite D, Garrote L, Cubillo F (eds) Coping with Drought Risk in Agriculture and Water Supply Systems, vol 26., Advances in Natural and Technological Hazards ResearchSpringer, Netherlands, pp 81–91
Uddameri V, Honnungar V (2007) Combining rough sets and GIS techniques to assess aquifer vulnerability characteristics in the semi-arid South Texas. Environ Geol 51:931–939
Vías JM, Andreo B, Perles MJ, Carrasco F (2005) A comparative study of four schemes for groundwater vulnerability mapping in a diffuse flow carbonate aquifer under Mediterranean climatic conditions. Environ Geol 47:586–595
Vías J, Andreo B, Ravbar N, Hötzl H (2010) Mapping the vulnerability of groundwater to the contamination of four carbonate aquifers in Europe. J Environ Manage 91:1500–1510
Voudouris K, Kazakis N, Polemio M, Kareklas K (2010) Assessment of intrinsic vulnerability using DRASTIC model and GIS in Kiti aquifer. Cyprus European Water 30:13–24
Vrba J, Zaporozec A (1994) Guidebook on mapping groundwater vulnerability International contributions to hydrogeology 16
Wen X, Wu J, Si J (2009) A GIS-based DRASTIC model for assessing shallow groundwater vulnerability in the Zhangye Basin, northwestern. China Environ Geol 57:1435–1442
Wikipedia (2013) Land use statistics by country, available at http://www.en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_use_statistics_by_country. Accessed 6 Jul 2013
Hallaq A, Elaish B (2012) Assessment of aquifer vulnerability to contamination in Khanyounis Governorate, Gaza Strip—Palestine, using the DRASTIC model within GIS environment. Arab J Geosci 5:833–847
Różkowski J (2010) Evaluation of intrinsic vulnerability of an Upper Jurassic karst-fissured aquifer in the Jura Krakowska (southern Poland) to anthropogenic pollution using the DRASTIC method. Geol Quat 51(1):17–26 (Warszawa)
Shukia S, Mostaghimi S, Shanholtz VO, Collins MC (1998) A GIS-Based Modeling approach for evaluating groundwater vulnerability to pesticides1. JAWRA J Am Water Resour As 34:1275–1293
Zingoni E, Love D, Magadza C, Moyce W, Musiwa K (2005) Effects of a semi-formal urban settlement on groundwater quality: Epworth (Zimbabwe): Case study and groundwater quality zoning. Phys Chem Earth Parts A/B/C 30:680–688. doi:10.1016/j.pce.2005.08.008
Yang YS, Wang L (2010) Catchment-scale vulnerability assessment of groundwater pollution from diffuse sources using the DRASTIC method: a case study. Hydrol Sci J 55:1206–1216
Yang S, Zhou D, Yu H, Wei R, Pan B (2013) Distribution and speciation of metals (Cu, Zn, Cd, and Pb) in agricultural and non-agricultural soils near a stream upriver from the Pearl River. China Environ Pollut 177:64–70
Yin L, Zhang E, Wang X, Wenninger J, Dong J, Guo L, Huang J (2012) A GIS-based DRASTIC model for assessing groundwater vulnerability in the Ordos Plateau. China Environ Earth Sci: 1–15
Zwahlen F (2004) Vulnerability and risk mapping for the protection of carbonate (karst) aquifers Final report COST action 620
Acknowledgments
The support provided by the University Putra Malaysia, Malaysia under the Research University Grant Scheme (RUGS), 05-02-12-1874RU, 9344400 is acknowledged. In addition, support from Hussaini Adamu Federal Polytechnic, Kazaure and Kano Agricultural Rural Development Authority (KNARDA) is hereby acknowledged.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hamza, S.M., Ahsan, A., Imteaz, M.A. et al. Accomplishment and subjectivity of GIS-based DRASTIC groundwater vulnerability assessment method: a review. Environ Earth Sci 73, 3063–3076 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12665-014-3601-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12665-014-3601-2