Abstract
Gilbert et al. argue that the neuroethics literature discussing the putative effects of Deep Brain Stimulation on personality largely ignores the scientific evidence and presents distorted claims that personality change is induced by the DBS stimulation. This study contributes to the first-hand primary research on the topic exploring DBS clinicians’ views on post-DBS personality change among their patients and its underlying cause. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with sixteen clinicians from various disciplines working in Australian DBS practice for movement disorders and/or psychiatric conditions. Thematic analysis of the interviews revealed five primary themes: 1) types, frequency and duration of personality change, 2) causes of personality change, 3) impact on patient and family, 4) communication, comprehension and awareness, and 5) management. Clinicians described a variety of personality changes in Parkinson’s disease following DBS including irritability, impulsivity and impaired decision-making. The frequency of personality change seen in patients varied amongst clinicians, but changes were overwhelmingly transient. Clinicians considered both DBS stimulation and additional factors (response to treatment, disease pathology, pharmacological changes) as inducing personality change. For DBS patients with major depressive disorder, a restoration of pre-morbid personality was associated with alleviation of illness. Considerations for future research of personality change following DBS include selecting suitable tools for quantitative examination and developing a common language between the scientific and ethics communities. Clinical implications including recommendations for the informed consent process for patients and families and clinicians’ management of personality change are discussed.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Gilbert, F., J.N.M. Viaña, and C. Ineichen. 2018. Deflating the “DBS causes personality changes” bubble. Neuroethics 1–17.
Agid, Y., et al. 2006. Neurosurgery in Parkinson's disease: The doctor is happy, the patient less so? Journal of Neural Transmission. Supplementum 70: 409–414.
Schüpbach, W.M., et al. 2006. Neurosurgery in Parkinson disease: A distressed mind in a repaired body? Neurology 66 (12): 1811–1816.
Bittlinger, M. 2017. The patient's voice in DBS research: Advancing the discussion through methodological rigor. AJOB Neuroscience 8 (2): 118–120.
Müller, S., M. Bittlinger, and H. Walter. 2017. Threats to neurosurgical patients posed by the personal identity debate. Neuroethics 10 (2): 299–310.
Gilbert, F., E. Goddard, J.N.M. Viaña, A. Carter, and M. Horne. 2017. I miss being me: Phenomenological effects of deep brain stimulation. AJOB Neuroscience 8 (2): 96–109.
Christen, M., M. Bittlinger, H. Walter, P. Brugger, and S. Müller. 2012. Dealing with side effects of deep brain stimulation: Lessons learned from stimulating the STN. AJOB Neuroscience 3 (1): 37–43.
Synofzik, M. 2007. Intervening in the neural basis of one's personality: A practice-oriented ethical analysis of neuropharmacology and deep-brain stimulation. Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift 132 (50): 2711–2713.
Synofzik, M., and T.E. Schlaepfer. 2008. Stimulating personality: Ethical criteria for deep brain stimulation in psychiatric patients and for enhancement purposes. Biotechnology Journal 3 (12): 1511–1520.
Glannon, W. 2009. Stimulating brains, altering minds. Journal of Medical Ethics 35 (5): 289–292.
Fassino, S., G. Abbate Daga, C. Gramaglia, A. Pierò, M. Zibetti, L. Castelli, A. Cinquepalmi, M. la Notte, and L. Lopiano. 2010. Novelty-seeking in Parkinson's disease after deep brain stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus: A case-control study. Psychosomatics 51 (1): 62–67.
Lewis, C.J., F. Maier, N. Horstkötter, A. Zywczok, K. Witt, C. Eggers, T.D. Meyer, T.A. Dembek, M. Maarouf, E. Moro, M. Zurowski, C. Woopen, J. Kuhn, and L. Timmermann. 2015. Subjectively perceived personality and mood changes associated with subthalamic stimulation in patients with Parkinson's disease. Psychological Medicine 45 (1): 73–85.
Lhommee, E., et al. 2017. Personality, dopamine, and Parkinson's disease: Insights from subthalamic stimulation. Movement Disorders 32 (8): 1191–1200.
Pham, U., et al. 2015. Personality changes after deep brain stimulation in Parkinson's disease. Parkinson's Disease 2015: 490507.
Christen, M., C. Ineichen, M. Bittlinger, H.W. Bothe, and S. Müller. 2014. Ethical focal points in the international practice of deep brain stimulation. AJOB Neuroscience 5 (4): 65–80.
Bell, E., B. Maxwell, M.P. McAndrews, A. Sadikot, and E. Racine. 2011. Deep brain stimulation and ethics: Perspectives from a multisite qualitative study of Canadian neurosurgical centers. World Neurosurgery 76 (6): 537–547.
Bell, E., and E. Racine. 2013. Clinical and ethical dimensions of an innovative approach for treating mental illness: A qualitative study of health care trainee perspectives on deep brain stimulation. Canadian Journal of Neuroscience Nursing 35 (3): 23–32.
Braun, V., and V. Clarke. 2006. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology 3 (2): 77–101.
Schüpbach, W.M., et al. 2013. Neurostimulation for Parkinson's disease with early motor complications. New England Journal of Medicine 368 (7): 610–622.
Kumar, R.M., et al. 1998. Double-blind evaluation of subthalamic nucleus deep brain stimulation in advanced Parkinson's disease. Neurology 51 (3): 850–855.
Houeto, J.L., V. Mesnage, L. Mallet, B. Pillon, M. Gargiulo, S.T. du Moncel, A.M. Bonnet, B. Pidoux, D. Dormont, P. Cornu, and Y. Agid. 2002. Behavioural disorders, Parkinson's disease and subthalamic stimulation. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry 72 (6): 701–707.
Funkiewiez, A. 2004. Long term effects of bilateral subthalamic nucleus stimulation on cognitive function, mood, and behaviour in Parkinson's disease. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry 75 (6): 834–839.
Krause, M., W. Fogel, A. Heck, W. Hacke, M. Bonsanto, C. Trenkwalder, and V. Tronnier. 2001. Deep brain stimulation for the treatment of Parkinson's disease: Subthalamic nucleus versus globus pallidus internus. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry 70 (4): 464–470.
Romito, L.M., M. Raja, A. Daniele, M.F. Contarino, A.R. Bentivoglio, A. Barbier, M. Scerrati, and A. Albanese. 2002. Transient mania with hypersexuality after surgery for high frequency stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus in Parkinson's disease. Movement Disorders 17 (6): 1371–1374.
Krack, P., R. Kumar, C. Ardouin, P.L. Dowsey, J.M. McVicker, A.L. Benabid, and P. Pollak. 2001. Mirthful laughter induced by subthalamic nucleus stimulation. Movement Disorders 16 (5): 867–875.
Mosley, P.E., D. Smith, T. Coyne, P. Silburn, M. Breakspear, and A. Perry. 2018. The site of stimulation moderates neuropsychiatric symptoms after subthalamic deep brain stimulation for Parkinson's disease. NeuroImage: Clinical 18: 996–1006.
Krack, P., A. Batir, N. van Blercom, S. Chabardes, V. Fraix, C. Ardouin, A. Koudsie, P.D. Limousin, A. Benazzouz, J.F. LeBas, A.L. Benabid, and P. Pollak. 2003. Five-year follow-up of bilateral stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus in advanced Parkinson's disease. New England Journal of Medicine 349 (20): 1925–1934.
Herzog, J., J. Volkmann, P. Krack, F. Kopper, M. Pötter, D. Lorenz, M. Steinbach, S. Klebe, W. Hamel, B. Schrader, D. Weinert, D. Müller, H.M. Mehdorn, and G. Deuschl. 2003. Two-year follow-up of subthalamic deep brain stimulation in Parkinson's disease. Movement Disorders 18 (11): 1332–1337.
Voon, V., C. Kubu, P. Krack, J.L. Houeto, and A.I. Tröster. 2006. Deep brain stimulation: Neuropsychological and neuropsychiatric issues. Movement Disorders 21 (Suppl 14): S305–S327.
de Haan, S., E. Rietveld, M. Stokhof, and D. Denys. 2015. Effects of deep brain stimulation on the lived experience of obsessive-compulsive disorder patients: In-depth interviews with 18 patients. PLoS One 10 (8): e0135524.
Haq, I.U., K.D. Foote, W.K. Goodman, N. Ricciuti, H. Ward, A. Sudhyadhom, C.E. Jacobson, M.S. Siddiqui, and M.S. Okun. 2010. A case of mania following deep brain stimulation for obsessive compulsive disorder. Stereotactic and Functional Neurosurgery 88 (5): 322–328.
Mallet, L., M. Polosan, N. Jaafari, N. Baup, M.L. Welter, D. Fontaine, S.T. Montcel, J. Yelnik, I. Chéreau, C. Arbus, S. Raoul, B. Aouizerate, P. Damier, S. Chabardès, V. Czernecki, C. Ardouin, M.O. Krebs, E. Bardinet, P. Chaynes, P. Burbaud, P. Cornu, P. Derost, T. Bougerol, B. Bataille, V. Mattei, D. Dormont, B. Devaux, M. Vérin, J.L. Houeto, P. Pollak, A.L. Benabid, Y. Agid, P. Krack, B. Millet, and A. Pelissolo. 2008. Subthalamic nucleus stimulation in severe obsessive–compulsive disorder. New England Journal of Medicine 359 (20): 2121–2134.
Pugh, J., L. Pycroft, H. Maslen, T. Aziz, and J. Savulescu. 2018. Evidence-based Neuroethics, deep brain stimulation and personality - deflating, but not bursting, the bubble. Neuroethics 1–12.
Schüpbach, W.M., et al. 2014. Myths and facts about the EARLYSTIM study. Movement Disorders 29 (14): 1742–1750.
Pillon, B. 2002. Neuropsychological assessment for management of patients with deep brain stimulation. Movement Disorders 17 (S3): S116–S122.
Stout, J.C., R.E. Ready, J. Grace, P.F. Malloy, and J.S. Paulsen. 2003. Factor analysis of the frontal systems behavior scale (FrSBe). Assessment 10 (1): 79–85.
Denheyer, M., Z.H. Kiss, and A.M. Haffenden. 2009. Behavioral effects of subthalamic deep brain stimulation in Parkinson's disease. Neuropsychologia 47 (14): 3203–3209.
Barrash, J., D. Tranel, and S.W. Anderson. 2000. Acquired personality disturbances associated with bilateral damage to the ventromedial prefrontal region. Developmental Neuropsychology 18 (3): 355–381.
Cervone, D., and L.A. Pervin. 2015. Personality, binder ready version: theory and research. Wiley. United States.
Saint-Cyr, J.A., et al. 2000. Neuropsychological consequences of chronic bilateral stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus in Parkinson's disease. Brain 123 (10): 2091–2108.
Boel, J.A., V.J.J. Odekerken, G.J. Geurtsen, B.A. Schmand, D.C. Cath, M. Figee, P. van den Munckhof, R.J. de Haan, P.R. Schuurman, R.M.A. de Bie, and the NSTAPS study group. 2016. Psychiatric and social outcome after deep brain stimulation for advanced Parkinson's disease. Movement Disorders 31 (3): 409–413.
Thomson, C., et al. 2019. Patients’ weighing of the long-term risks and consequences associated with deep brain stimulation in treatment-resistant depression. AJOB Neuroscience 9 (4): 243–245.
Mosley, P.E., et al. 2019 ‘Woe betides anybody who tries to turn me down.’ A Qualitative Analysis of Neuropsychiatric Symptoms Following Subthalamic Deep Brain Stimulation for Parkinson’s Disease. Neuroethics 1–17.
Festinger, D.S., K.L. Dugosh, J.R. Croft, P.L. Arabia, and D.B. Marlowe. 2010. Corrected feedback: A procedure to enhance recall of informed consent to research among substance abusing offenders. Ethics and Behavior 20 (5): 387–399.
Widdershoven, G., G. Meynen, L. Hartman, and D. Denys. 2014. Ethical dilemmas in the practice of DBS. AJOB Neuroscience 5 (4): 83–85.
Bell, E., et al. 2011. A review of social and relational aspects of deep brain stimulation in Parkinson's disease informed by healthcare provider experiences. Parkinsons Disorder 2011: 871874.
Kubu, C.S., and P.J. Ford. 2012. Beyond mere symptom relief in deep brain stimulation: An ethical obligation for multi-faceted assessment of outcome. AJOB Neuroscience 3 (1): 44–49.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
ESM 1
(DOCX 16 kb)
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Thomson, C.J., Segrave, R.A. & Carter, A. Changes in Personality Associated with Deep Brain Stimulation: a Qualitative Evaluation of Clinician Perspectives. Neuroethics 14 (Suppl 1), 109–124 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12152-019-09419-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12152-019-09419-2