Skip to main content
SpringerLink
Log in

The AFL-CIO v. CTW: The competing visions, strategies, and structures

  • Articles
  • Published:
Journal of Labor Research Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

As the AFL-CIO approached its twenty-fifth biennial convention in July 2005, seven unions formed a new Change to Win (CTW) coalition to challenge the federation for lead position as the voice of the labor movement. These unions, most of which have disaffiliated from the AFL-CIO, formed the CTW to demonstrate their unsparing discontent with John Sweeney’s leadership of the federation. We examine the reasons for the current breach in the house of labor, the competing visions offered by the AFL-CIO and CTW, and the likelihood that the CTW’s strategy will revive unions. We find that the gulf between the two factions is philosophically deep and practically irreconcilable. The CTW advocates an “engineered breakthrough” approach to revitalize labor whereas the AFL-CIO relies on a more conservative “accelerated evolution” path. There are no guarantees that the CTW’s strategy will work. It presupposes an unmet demand for unions that can be tapped through vast new investments. If the current model of unionism is lacking, as the CTW suggests, a viable replacement must be found. The CTW, with its limited resources, will have to experiment until it finds the right model, if one does indeed exist. The task of rebuilding labor is daunting, but it arguably requires a bold and fundamentally different course from what has been pursued. From this perspective, the breakup seems a logical development.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Log in via an institution

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • American Federation of Labor-Congress of Industrial Organizations. “Sweeping Changes at AFL-CIO.” <www.aflcio.org/mediacenter/prsptm/issues.cfm>, January 24, 1996, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Ensuring a Strong and Continuing Political Voice for America’s Working Families.” <www .aflcio.org/aboutus/thisistheaflcio/ecouncil/ec0226b2002.cfm?RenderForPrint=1>, February 26, 2002, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Constitution.” <www.aflcio.org/aboutus/thisistheaflcio/constitution>, 2005a, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Executive Council Report.” <www.aflcio.org/aboutus/thisistheaflcio/ecouncil/>, 2005b, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Mission Statement.” <www.aflcio.org/aboutus/thisistheaflcio/mission/>, 2005c, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Winning for Working Families.” <www.aflcio.org/aboutus/ourfuture/upload/executive_ officers.pdf>, April 2005d, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Convention Makes Major Change to Leadership Structure, Extra Support for Grass Roots.” <www.aflcio.org/mediacenter/prsptm/issues.cfm>, July 27, 2005e, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Executive Council Statement on AFL-CIO per Capita Tax Obligations.” <www.aflcio.org/ mediacenter/prsptm/issues.cfm>, July 29, 2005f, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “AFL-CIO Rolls Out Solidarity Charter Program to Reunite Local Labor Movement.” <www.aflcio .org/mediacenter/prsptm/issues.cfm>, November 16, 2005g, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • Asher, Herbert B., Eric S. Heberlig, Randall B. Ripley, and Karen Snyder. American Labor Unions in the Electoral Arena. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, 2001.

    Google Scholar 

  • Bernstein, Aaron. “Palace Coup at the AFL-CIO.” Business Week 3824 (March 17, 2003a): 78–79.

    Google Scholar 

  • —. “Is Labor Headed for Splitsville?” Business Week 3935 (May 30, 2003b): 32–33.

    Google Scholar 

  • —. “Breaking Ranks with the AFL-CIO.” Business Week 3849 (September 15, 2003c): 64–67.

    Google Scholar 

  • -. “Pooling Our Resources for Growth.” Business Week Online <www.businessweek.com/magazine/ content/03_37/b3849088.htm>, September 15, 2003d, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • —. “Can This Man Save Labor?” Business Week 3899 (September 13, 2004): 80–88.

    Google Scholar 

  • Bernstein, Aaron and Joseph Weber. “So Long AFL-CIO. Now What?” Business Week 3946 (August 8, 2005): 35.

    Google Scholar 

  • Buhle, Paul. “Why the AFL-CIO Split Is Not Labor’s Biggest Problem.” Tikkun 20 (November/December 2005): 53–55.

    Google Scholar 

  • Burger, Anna. “Statement of Anna Burger.” <www.unitetowin.com/index.asp?Type=B_BASIC & SEC = (E1714683-A5C4-4103-BE93-26A7AD32385A)>, July 24, 2005a, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Change to Win Convention Remarks by SEIU Secretary-Treasurer Anna Burger.” <www.unite towin.com/index.asp?Type=B_BASIC& SEC= 714683-A5C4-4103-BE93-26A7AD32385A >, September 27, 2005b, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Statement on Solidarity Charters with the AFL-CIO.” October 17, 2005c. <www.unitetowin.com/ index.asp?Type=B_BASIC& SEC=714683-A5C4-4103-BE93-26A7AD32385A>, October 17, 2005c, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • Change to Win. “Constitution and Bylaws of the Change to Win Coalition.” <www.unitetowin.com/ vertical/Sites/306EEF-1464-40FF-8BE1-10B3679B179C/uploads/4B0F38-6151-46FE-8206 -96871A5EC76F.PDF>, 2005a, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Restoring the American Dream: Building A 21st Century Labor Movement That Can Win.” <www.unitetowin.com/vertical/Sites/306EEF-1464-40FF-8BE1-10B3679B179C/uploads/54 521A-2084-4E0A-83F9-531DFF898EE6.PDF>, May 16, 2005b, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Carpenters Union Joins Change to Win Coalition.” <www.unitetowin.com/index.asp?Type =B_BASIC& SEC=714683-A5C4-4103-BE93-26A7AD32385A>, June 27, 2005c, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Statement by the Change to Win Coalition in Response to AFL-CIO Officers’ Press Event.” <www.unitetowin.com/index.asp?Type=B_BASIC& SEC=714683-A5C4-4103-BE93-26A7AD32385A> June 20, 2005d, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Statement by the Change to Win Coalition in Response to AFL-CIO Officers’ Press Event.” <www.unitetowin.com/index.asp?Type=B_BASIC& SEC=714683-A5C4-4103-BE93-26A7AD32385A> June 20, 2005d, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Change to Win Leadership Says AFL-CIO ‘Has Yet to Embrace Real Change,’” <www.unite towin.com/index.asp?Type=B_BASIC& SEC=714683-A5C4-4103-BE93-26A7AD32385A>, July 13, 2005e, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “New Labor Federation Pledges to Carry Out Most Aggressive Organizing Campaign in 50 Years.” <www.unitetowin.com/index.asp?Type=B_BASIC& SEC=714683-A5C4-4103-BE93-26A7AD32385A>, September 27, 2005f, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • Dark, Taylor E. The Unions and the Democrats: An Enduring Alliance. Ithaca, NY: ILR Press, 1999.

    Google Scholar 

  • Early, Steve. “Labor Debates How to Rebuild Its House.” Tikkun 20 (May/June 2005a): 45–49.

    Google Scholar 

  • Edsall, Thomas A. “AFL-CIO Has Money Problems.” Washington Post, April 29, 2005b.

  • -. “Anna Burger to Head Breakaway Labor Group.” Washington Post, September 27, 2005.

  • Fields, Gary, Timothy Aeppel, Kris Maher, and Janet Adamy. “Reinventing the Union.” Wall Street Journal, July 27, 2005.

  • Galenson, Walter. The CIO Challenge to the AFL: A History of the American Labor Movement, 1935-1941. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1960.

    Google Scholar 

  • Gerard, Leo. “Our Commitment to Workers Rights Is Undivided.” <www.uswa.org>, 2005, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • Goldberg, Arthur, J. AFL-CIO Labor United. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1956.

    Google Scholar 

  • Greenhouse, Steven. “AFL-CIO Is Urged to Oust Its Leader.” New York Times, May 17, 2005.

  • Hansen, Joseph. “Statement of Joe Hansen International President United Food and Commercial Workers International Union.” <www.ufcw.org/press_room/index.cfm>, June 15, 2005a, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Letter from UFCW International President Joe Hansen to AFL-CIO.” <www.ufcw.org/press_ room/index.cfm>, July 29, 2005b, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • Hart, Peter D. “Labor Day 2005: The State of Working America.” <www.aflcio.org/aboutus/laborday/ upload/ld2005_report.pdf#search=‘Labor%20Day%202005%3A%20The%20State%20of%20Work ing%20America’>, August 2005, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • Hoffa, James P. “Statement by James P. Hoffa Teamsters General President.” <www.teamster.org/ 05news/hn_050616_4.htm>, June 15, 2005a, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Letter to President John Sweeney.” <www.teamster.org/05news/nr_050725_l.htm>, July 25, 2005b, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • Hurd, Richard. “The Failure of Organizing, The New Unity Partnership, and the Future of the Labor Movement.” Working USA 8 (September 2004.): 5–25.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • International Brotherhood of Teamsters. “Which Way for the AFL-CIO? The Teamster View.” <www.team ster.org/about/hoffa/pdfs/TeamsterViewReport_3.pdf>, 2004, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • Kelber, Harry. “AFL-CIO’s 50-year Organizing Record Under Meany, Kirkland, and Sweeney.” The Labor Educator, <www.laboreducator.org/orgrec50.pdf>, March 30, 2005a, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Will More Money and Mega-Unions Solve Problems of Past Organizing Failures?” The Labor Educator, May 16, 2005b, <www.laboreducator.org/labfuturel.htm>, May 16, 2005b, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • Lerner, Stephen. “Three Steps to Reorganizing and Rebuilding the Labor Movement.” <labornotes.org/ archives/2002/12/e.html>, December 2002, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • Marquez, Jessica. “5 Questions for Andy Stern; Andy Stern International President of the Service Employees International Union. Workforce Management 84 (May 2005): 10.

    Google Scholar 

  • Meyerson, Harold. “Time’s Up for the NUP.” American Prospect Online Edition <www.prospect.org/web/ page.ww?section=root& name=ViewWeb& articleId=9054>, January 28, 2005a, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Cuts and Fissures.” American Prospect Online Edition <www.prospect.org/web/page.ww? section=root& name=ViewWeb& articleId=9650>, May 5, 2005b, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • —. “Labor’s Civil War.” American Prospect 16 (June 2005c): 45–50.

    Google Scholar 

  • -. “The Second Front: Change to Win’s Plan Come into Focus.” American Prospect Online Edition <www.prospect.org/web/page.ww?section=root& name=ViewWeb& articleId=10357>, September 28, 2005d, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • O’Sullivan, Terence M. “Statement of Terence M. O’Sullivan, General President, Laborers International Union of North America, On the Founding of the Change to Win Coalition.” <www.liuna.org/pubsnews/ pdfs/tmoctwstatement.pdf>, June 15, 2005, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • Prah, Pamela. “Labor Unions’ Future.” Congressional Quarterly Researcher 15 (September 2, 2005): 709–32.

    Google Scholar 

  • Robinson, Archie. George Meany and His Times. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1981.

    Google Scholar 

  • Schramm, Jennifer. “The Future of Unions.” Visions 4 (2005), <www.shrm.org/trends/visions/4issue2005/ visionsl005.pdf>, 2005, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • Service Employees International Union. “United We Win: A Discussion of the Crisis Facing Workers and the Labor Movement.” <www.seiu.org/>, February 2003, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Unite to Win: A 21st Century Plan to Build New Strength for Working People.” <www.seiu.org/>, November 2004, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Five Leading Unions Form New Coalition To Rebuild American Labor Movement.” <www.seiu.org/>, June 15, 2005a, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Carpenters Union Joins Change to Win Coalition.” <www.seiu.org/>, June 27, 2005b, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Change to Win Coalition Submits Amendments for AFL-CIO Convention.” <www.seiu.org/>, June 30, 2005c, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Change to Win Coalition Announces Election of Top Officers.” <www.seiu.org/>, July 6, 2005d, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Change to Win Coalition Chair Anna Burger Sets Direction for New Labor Movement.” <www.seiu.org/>, July 8, 2005e, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Change to Win Leadership Says AFL-CIO ‘Has Yet to Embrace Real Change?’” <www.seiu.org/>, June 13, 2005f, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “United Farm Workers of America Joins Change to Win Coalition.” <www.seiu.org/>, July 22, 2005g, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “SEIU Disaffiliates from National AFL-CIO to Concentrate on Strategies to Unite Millions More Working People.” <www.seiu.org/>, July 25, 2005h, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “New AFSCME-SEIU Pact to Help More Workers Win Voice at Work.” <www.seiu.org/>, September 19, 2005i, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • Stern, Andrew L. “Letter to John Sweeney.” <www.seiu.org/>, July 25, 2005a, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Statement by SEIU President.” <www.seiu.org/media/pressreleases.cfm?pr_id=1238>, July 25, 2005b, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Change to Win Convention Statement by SEIU President Andy Stern.” <www.workinglife.org/ FOL/news/SternCTWconvpreparedremarks.doc>, September 27 2005c, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • Sweeney, John. “Statement by AFL-CIO President John Sweeney on Formation of Union of Union Coalition Outside the AFL-CIO.” <www.aflcio.org/mediacenter/prsptm/pr07242005.cfm>, June 15, 2005a, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Statement by AFL-CIO President John Sweeney On SEIU, UNITE/HERE, IBT, and UFCW’s Decision to Not Attend AFL-CIO Convention.” <www.aflcio.org/mediacenter/prsptm/pr07242005 .cfm>, July 24, 2005b, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “Keynote Remarks by AFL-CIO President John J. Sweeney, 50th Anniversary AFL-CIO Constitutional Convention, Chicago.” <www.aflcio.org/mediacenter/prsptm/sp07252005a.cfm>, July 25, 2005c, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • -. “John J. Sweeney, AFL-CIO President, Acceptance Speech, 50th Anniversary AFL-CIO Constitutional Convention, Chicago.” <www.aflcio.org/mediacenter/prsptm/sp07272005d.cfm>, July 27, 2005d, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • Troy, Leo. “Farce and Greek Tragedy.” Labor Watch. Washington, DC: Capital Research Center, September 2005, pp. 5–7.

    Google Scholar 

  • UNITE-HERE. ”UNITE-HERE Executive Board Votes to Disaffiliate from AFL-CIO.” <www.unitehere .org/presscenter/release.asp?ID=988>, September 14, 2005, last visited February 20, 2006.

  • U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. “Union Members in 2004.” <http://www.bls.gov/news.release/ archives/ union2_01272005.pdf>, January 27, 2005, last visited February 20, 2006.

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

  1. University of Pittsburgh, 15260, PA

    Marick F. Masters & Ray Gibney

  2. Clemson University, 29634, Clemson, SC

    Tom Zagenczyk

Authors
  1. Marick F. Masters
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  2. Ray Gibney
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  3. Tom Zagenczyk
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Masters, M.F., Gibney, R. & Zagenczyk, T. The AFL-CIO v. CTW: The competing visions, strategies, and structures. J Labor Res 27, 473–504 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12122-006-1016-x

Download citation

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12122-006-1016-x

Keywords

Search

Navigation