Abstract
There is a lack of reliable data on the role of women in transnational organized crime. So far, the focus of this research has overwhelmingly been on the Italian Mafia. Little is known about women’s roles in other types of organized crime activities. Since there is an ongoing perception that draws on stereotypical imagery of women in organized crime as appendixes to their male counterparts, this article explores whether women are indeed as oppressed in transnational organized crime as they are in other spheres of life. It focuses on the stereotypical constructions of femininity (victims) and masculinity (criminals) and argues that hegemonic gender roles are defined by the dominant European/American culture. The article takes a multicultural feminist approach and studies female criminality in the context of “doing gender,” an approach that assumes that the feminine gender role is something that must be accomplished in the context of specific situations. By studying the roles of women from West Africa and the Balkans in transnational criminal activities, it specifically examines how time and space, as well history and culture, contribute to one’s position in a criminal network.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Then during the mid-1970s, two controversial books, Adler’s (1975) Sisters in Crime and Simon’s (1975) Women and Crime proposed ideas about women’s criminality. Adler argued that lifting restrictions on women’s opportunities in the marketplace gave them the chance to be greedy, violent, and crime prone as men. Simon concluded that women’s increasing share of arrests for property crime might be explained by their increased opportunities at the workplace to commit crime. Simon also examined whether the emancipation of women might encourage law enforcement officials and courts to be more interested in treating women and men equally. This came to be known as the “emancipation thesis:” as women are achieving social equality and equal access to opportunities in the workplace, they will eventually commit the same amount of crimes as men, and there will convergence in male and female crime rates.
By “leaders” and “organizers” we refer to women that are actively involved in the strategic planning of the trafficking/smuggling operations, and are able to bring decisions, and most importantly, have full or partial control over the finances.
One of the authors organized this expert workshop together with the Belgian Federal Police in Brussels in Oct. 2008.
The U.S. database was developed with the help of research assistants Michael Temple and Jeffrey Walden.
This word is most often used to imply a female who controls sex workers/brothels. However, it can also imply an active female criminal, i.e. organizer, involved in the strategic planning of human trafficking activities, however, not necessarily for sexual exploitation.
See the study by Siegel and de Blank (2010) where the roles of women are defined and discussed (e.g. supporters, partners in crime and independent businesswomen/madams/organizers).
For the purpose of this paper, the term ‘Balkan organized crime’ refers to organized crime groups whose members originate mainly from Albania, Kosovo, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Croatia, Macedonia, Moldova, Montenegro, Romania, or Serbia.
Based on personal interviews with law enforcement officials and prosecutors from Albania, Italy, Belgium, Macedonia and Kosovo conducted between 2008 and 2011. Parts of the conclusions are also based on the findings from the expert workshop that took place in Belgium in October 2008 as well as on the analysis of court and police files.
Based on interviews with Interpol’s official working on Balkan organized crime and on intelligence reports from 2008 and 2009. Note: most countries in Western and Central Europe reported females involved in human trafficking at between 10 and 50 % of those investigated/prosecuted (Aronowitz 2009).
These are by no means mutually exclusive groups/categories. There have been cases where Slavic offenders have been cooperating with ethnic Albanian ones. However, these are some common group classification made by police agencies on the basis of the core membership of groups (organized crime) that have been arrested and prosecuted.
In Japan crime levels are significantly lower when compared to other developed nations (Dammer and Fairchild 2006) and female participation in criminal behavior is even lower than in other countries. Women in Japan however also act as “interim” figures in organized gangs in case their companion becomes imprisoned or dies. This is because in Japan, although women are forbidden to become involved with gangs, they tend to be motivated by the matriarchal system which highlights that mothers or spouses should glorify men’s success (Otomo 2003). For example, Yoshiko Matsuda, an interim figure who took the reign of a powerful Japanese gang after the death of her husband, controlled over 300 gangsters and led street fights in Tokyo.
Patsy Sorensen, Victim shelter “Payoke”, ref. to VH case.
According to interviews with Belgian law enforcement officials (case of Sami and Zakim in Verviers)
Read more about the NK case in: “Networking sites—Criminal group expands across the Balkans” (2009) Jane’s Intelligence Review, 21(12): 43–47. See also Center for Investigative Reporting (CIR 2009), From Kosovo Inmate to Sarajevo Businessman, N°18, 2009.
Personal interviews with Macedonian law enforcement officials and with Patsy Sorensen, Director of the Belgian victim shelter Payoke. Sorensen was actively involved in this case and interviewed some of the victims (interviews conducted between 2007 and 2010).
More information on this case available at: https://reportingproject.net/PeopleOfInterest/profil.php?profil=57
It is important to acknowledge, however, that after 2010 there have been some positive developments in Kosovo. For example, a woman was elected president in Kosovo in 2011. Also the GDI in 2001 was 0.6.
Read more on the social construction of femininity and masculinity and the way female bodies are displayed in anti-trafficking campaigns in Andrijasevic (2007).
References
Addo P (2006) Cross border criminal activities in West Africa: options for selective responses. KAIPTC, Paper No. 12
Adler F (1975) Sisters in crime: the rise of the new female criminal. McGraw-Hill, NY
Allum F (2003) Women and the Mafia: female roles in organized crime structures. In: Fiandaca G (ed) Women and the Mafia: female roles in organized crime structures. Springer, New York
Anderson LM (1988) Thinking about women, 2nd edn. Macmillan, New York
Andrijasevic R (2007) Beautiful dead bodies: gender, migration and representation in anti-trafficking campaigns. Fem Rev 86:24–44
Aronowitz A (2009) Human trafficking, human misery: the global trade in human beings. Westport: Praeger
Arsovska J, Kostakos P (2007) Cocaine traffickers turn to the Balkans. Jane’s Intell Rev 19(3):50–53
Arsovska J, Lantsman L (2010) Magic touch: West African trafficking networks. Jane Intell Rev 22(10):38–41
Arsovska J, Verduyn P (2008) Globalisation, conduct norms and “culture conflict”: perceptions of violence and crime in an ethnic Albanian context. Br J Criminol 48(2):226–246
Baban A (2004) Domestic violence against women in Albania. UNICEF Report, Tirana
Beneduce R (2003) Sessualità, Corpi “Fuori Luogo”, Cultura.Pratiche e Discorsi su Migrazione e Prostituzione, Pagine. Il sociale da fare e pensare, n. 2, pp 6–63
Binder D (1991) The land of talkative men and toiling women. The New York Times, April 23
Brantingham PJ, Brantingham PL (1990) Environmental criminology. Waveland, NY
Carlen P (1985) Criminal women, myths and misogyny. In: Carlen P (ed) Criminal women: autobiographical accounts. Polity Press, Cambridge
CINS (Center for Investigative Journalism) (2011) “Kriminalne veze Svetlane Raznatovic,” March 13. Available at [http://www.cins.org.rs/?p=8768]
CINS (Center for Investigative Reporting) (2009) “Naser Kelmendi: From Kosovo Inmate to Sarajevo Businessman,” N°18. Available at [http://www.cin.ba/newsletter/pdf/CIN_18_2009-11-20.pdf]
Çiuli D (n.d.) “Women in Albania: opportunities and obstacles,” MEDiterranea MEDIA, No.2. Available at: http://www.medmedia.it/review/numero2/en/art5.htm. Accessed 1 Nov 2013
Dammer HR, Fairchild E (2006) Comparative criminal justice systems, 3rd edn. Thomson/Wadsworth, Belmont
de Andrés AP (2008) West Africa under attack: drugs, organized crime and terrorism as the new threats to global security. United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. United Nations, NY
EAEA (2007) Adult Education and Gender Issues in Serbia. http://www.eaea.org/news.php?aid=13515&%20d=2007-05
Ellis S (2009) West Africa’s international drug trade. Afr Aff 108(431):171–196
European Council (2003) A secure Europe in a better world: European Security Strategy. France: The EU Institute for Security Studies (document adopted at the European Council in Brussels on December 12, 2003)
Ferrell J (2004) Boredom, crime and criminology. Theor Criminol 8(3):287–302
Fiandaca G (ed) (2003) Women and the Mafia: female roles in organized crime structures. Springer, New York
Fox L (1989) The code of Lekë Dukagjini/Kaunui I Lekë Dukagjinit. Comp. (trans: Shtjefën Gjeçov). Gjonlekaj Publishing Company, NY
Gashi GV (2009) Poverty and gender equality - agency for gender equality, UNDP development and transition report. UNDP, Vienna
Gavin R (2011) Albania mob busts in area. Times Union, July 14
Gjipali S, Ruci L (1994) The Albanian woman: hesitation and perspectives, gains and losses: women and transition in Eastern and Central Europe. European Network for Women’s Studies. Bucharest
Government of Serbia (2011) Second periodical report on the international convenient on economic, social and cultural rights. GOV Serbia, Belgrade
Hafizullah E (1993) Development strategies and women in Albania, March, E. Eur., Q., XXVII, No. 1
Hasluck M (1954) The unwritten law in Albania. Cambridge Uni. Press, Cambridge
Hayward K (2007) Situational crime prevention and its discontents: rational choice theory versus the ‘culture of now.’ Soc Policy Adm 41(3):232–250
Heidensohn F (1985) Women and crime. Macmillan, Basingstoke
Higginbotham A (2004). Beauty and the beast, The Observer, 67, 3 January. Available at: http://www.theguardian.com/theobserver/2004/jan/04/features.magazine67
Hopkins R (2004) Conference on the Albanian OC. Center for Information and Research on Organized Crime, June, CIROC, The Netherlands
Kaufman B (1998) Emotional arousal as a source of bounded rationality. J Econ Behav Organ 38:135–144
Kimmel M (2000) The gendered society. Oxford University Press, New York
Kleemans E, Van de Bunt H (1999) The social embeddedness of organized crime. Transl Organ Crime 5(1):19–36
Laidler KJ, Hunt G (2001) Accomplishing femininity among the girls in the gang. Br J Criminol 41:656–678
Lawson CW, Saltmarshe DK (2002) The psychology of economic transformation: the impact of the market on social institutions, status and values in a Northern Albanian Village. J Econ Psychol 23:487–500
Maher L (1997) Sexed work: gender, race and resistance in Brooklyn drug economy. Clarendon, Oxford
Miller J (1998) “Up it up”: gender and the accomplishment of street robbery. Criminology 36:37–66
Minnesota Advocates for Human Rights (1996) Domestic violence in Albania. MAHR, Minnesota
NAPTIP (Nigerian National Agency for Prohibition of Traffic in Persons and Other Related Matters) (2006) Trafficking in persons. NAPTIP, Nigeria
Otomo R (2003) Women in organized crime in Japan. In: Fiandaca G (ed) Women and the Mafia: female roles in organized crime structures. Springer, NY
Paluca-Baley F (2003) Women in organized crime in Albania. In: Fiandaca G (ed) Women and the Mafia: female roles in organized crime structures. Springer, NY
Rossi A (2003) Women in organized crime in Argentina. In: Fiandaca G (ed) Women and the Mafia: female roles in organized crime structures. Springer, NY
Samuels D (2010) The Pink Panthers; a tale of diamonds, thieves, and the Balkans. The New Yorker 86(8):42–72
Siebert R (1996) Secrets of life and death: women and the Mafia. Verso, London
Siegel D, de Blank S (2010) Women who traffic women: the role of women in human trafficking networks – Dutch cases. Global Crime 11(4):436–447
Simon AH (1972) Theories of bounded rationality, Chapter 8. In: McGuire CB, Radner R (eds) Decision and organization, Amsterdam: North-Holland Publishing Company
Simon RJ (1975) Women and crime. Lexington Books, Lexington
Simpson S (2000) Of crime and criminality: the use of theory in everyday life. Pine Forge Press, Thousand Oaks
Simpson SS, Ellis L (1995) Doing gender: sorting out the caste and crime conundrum. Criminology 33:71
Spender D (1982) Invisible woman. Writers and readers publishing, London
Steady F (2011) Women and Leadership in West Africa: mothering the Nation and Humanizing the State. NYU, NY
Steffensmeier D (1983) Sex-segregation in the underworld: building a sociological explanation of sex differences in crime. Social Forces 61:1010–1032
Steffensmeier D, Allan E (1996) Gender and crime: toward a gendered theory. Ann Rev 22:459–487
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (2005) Transnational organized crime in the West Africa. UN, NY
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (2008) Crime in the Balkans. UNODC, Vienna
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (2009) Global report on trafficking in persons. United Nations, NY
US Department of Justice (2013) 49 members and associates of an international Ethnic-Albanian Organized crime syndicate convicted of drug trafficking crimes. Press Release, Eastern District of New York, August 20
Vasic M (2011) “Poreklo bogatstva Željka Ražnatovića Arkana,” Vreme, No.1057, April 7
Waldmann P (2001) Revenge without rules: on the renaissance of an archaic motif of violence. Stud Confl Terrorism 24:435–450
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Arsovska, J., Begum, P. From West Africa to the Balkans: exploring women’s roles in transnational organized crime. Trends Organ Crim 17, 89–109 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12117-013-9209-1
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12117-013-9209-1