Abstract
In this paper I explore the psychology of ritual performance and present a simple graphical model that clarifies several issues in William Irons’s theory of religion as a “hard-to-fake” sign of commitment. Irons posits that religious behaviors or rituals serve as costly signals of an individual’s commitment to a religious group. Increased commitment among members of a religious group may facilitate intra-group cooperation, which is argued to be the primary adaptive benefit of religion. Here I propose a proximate explanation for how individuals are able to pay the short-term costs of ritual performance to achieve the long-term fitness benefits offered by religious groups. The model addresses three significant problems raised by Irons’s theory. First, the model explains why potential free-riders do not join religious groups even when there are significant net benefits that members of religious groups can achieve. Second, the model clarifies how costly a ritual must be to achieve stability and prevent potential free-riders from joining the religious group. Third, the model suggests why religious groups may require adherents to perform private rituals that are not observed by others. Several hypotheses generated from the model are also discussed.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Afshar, H. 1987 Women, Marriage and State in Iran. In Women, State and Ideology, H. Afshar, ed. Pp. 70–89. London: Macmillan.
Ajzen, I. 1988 Attitudes, Personality, and Behavior. Chicago: Dorsey Press.
Alexander, R. 1987 The Biology of Moral Systems. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
Allport, G. 1966 The Religious Context of Prejudice. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 5:447–457.
Allport, G., and J. Ross 1967 Personal Religious Orientation and Prejudice. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 5:432–443.
Appel, W. 1983 Cults in America: Programmed for Paradise. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
Aronson, E. 1997 The Theory of Cognitive Dissonance: The Evolution and Vicissitudes of an Idea. In The Message of Social Psychology, C. McGarty and S. Alexander, eds. Pp. 20–35. London: Blackwell.
Aronson, E., and J. Mills 1959 The Effect of Severity of Initiation on Liking for a Group. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 59:177–181.
Asch, S. 1951 Effects of Group Pressure upon the Modification and Distortion of Judgment. In Groups, Leadership, and Men, H. Guetzkow, ed. Pp. 177–190. Pittsburgh: Carnegie Press.
Austin, J. 1998 Zen and the Brain. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Bainbridge, W. 1984 The Decline of the Shakers: Evidence from the United States Census. Communal Societies 4:19–34.
Balch, R., G. Farnsworth, and S. Wilkins 1983 When the Bombs Drop: Reactions to Disconfirmed Prophecy in a Millennial Sect. Sociological Perspectives 26:137–158.
Balch, R., J. Domitrovich, B. Mahnke, and V. Morrison 1997 Fifteen Years of Failed Prophecy. In Millennium, Messiahs, and Mayhem, T. Robbins and S. Palmer, eds. Pp. 73–90. New York: Routledge.
Baron, S. 1952 The Social and Religious History of the Jews, vol. 1, second ed. New York: Columbia University Press.
Batson, C., and W. Ventis 1982 The Religious Experience: A Social Psychological Perspective. New York: Oxford University Press.
Bem, D. 1965 An Experimental Analysis of Self-persuasion. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 1:199–218.
1966 Inducing Beliefs in False Confessions. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 3:707–710.
1972 Self-perception Theory. In Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, vol. 6, L. Berkowitz, ed., Pp. 1–62. New York: Academic Press.
Berman, E. 2000 Sect, Subsidy and Sacrifice: An Economist’s View of Ultra-Orthodox Jews. Quarterly Journal of Economics 115:905–953.
Boyd, R., and P. Richerson 1992 Punishment Allows the Evolution of Cooperation (Or Anything Else) in Sizable Groups. Ethology and Sociobiology 13:171–196.
Boyer, P. 2001 Religion Explained: The Evolutionary Origins of Religious Thought. New York: Basic Books.
Caplan, L. 1987 Introduction. In Studies in Religious Fundamentalism, L. Caplan, ed. Pp. 1–24. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Chandler, C., and J. Connell 1987 Children’s Intrinsic, Extrinsic and Internalized Motivation: A Developmental Study of Children’s Reasons for Liked and Disliked Behaviors. British Journal of Developmental Psychology 5:357–365.
Cialdini, R. 2001 Influence: Science and Practice. Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
Cioffi, D., and R. Garner 1996 On Doing the Decision: The Effects of Active Versus Passive Choice on Commitment and Self-perception. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 22:133–147.
Collins, J. 1991 The Cult Experience. Springfield, Illinois: Charles C. Thomas.
Cook, R. 1954 The North American Hutterites: A Study in Human Multiplication. Population Bulletin 10:97–107.
Cronk, L. 1994a Evolutionary Theories of Morality and the Manipulative Use of Signals. Zygon 29:81–101.
1994b Group Selection’s New Clothes. Behavior and Brain Sciences 17:615–616.
1999 The Complex Whole: Culture and the Evolution of Human Behavior. Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press.
Crook, J. 1970 The Socioecology of Primates. In Social Behavior in Birds and Mammals, J. Crook, ed. Pp. 103–166. New York: Academic Press.
d’Aquili, E., and A. Newberg 1999 The Mystical Mind. Minneapolis: Fortress Press.
Dawes, R. 1980 Social Dilemmas. Annual Review of Psychology 31:169–193.
Deci, E., and R. Ryan 1985 Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in Human Behavior. New York: Plenum Press.
de Waal, F. 1996 Good Natured. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Donahue, M. 1985a Intrinsic and Extrinsic Religiousness: Review and Meta-analysis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 48:400–419.
1985b Intrinsic and Extrinsic Religiousness: The Empirical Research. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 24:418–423.
Durkheim, E. 1995 [1912] The Elementary Forms of Religious Life. New York: Free Press.
Eaton, J., and A. Mayer 1953 The Social Biology of Very High Fertility among the Hutterites. The Demography of a Unique Population. Human Biology 26:206–264.
Eibl-Eibesfeldt, I. 1970 Ethology: The Biology of Behavior. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston.
Ensminger, J. 1997 Transaction Costs and Islam: Explaining Conversion in Africa. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics 153:4–29.
Epstein, L. 1994 Why the Jewish People Should Welcome Converts. Judaism 43:302–312.
Fazio, R. 1987 Self-perception Theory: A Current Perspective. In Social Influence: The Ontario Symposium, vol. 5, M. Zanna, J. Olson, and C. Herman, eds. Pp. 129–150. Hillsdale, New Jersey: Erlbaum.
Fazio, R., M. Zanna, and J. Cooper 1977 Dissonance and Self-perception: An Integrative View of Each Theory’s Proper Domain of Application. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 13:464–479.
Festinger, L. 1954 A Theory of Social Comparison Processes. Human Relations 7:117–140.
1957 A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
1964 Conflict, Decision and Dissonance. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Festinger, L., H. Reicken, and S. Schachter 1956 When Prophecy Fails. New York: Harper and Row.
Finke, R., and R. Stark 1988 Religious Economies and Sacred Canopies: Religious Mobilization in American Cities, 1906. American Sociological Review 53:41–49.
Finke, R., A. Guest, and R. Stark 1996 Mobilizing Local Religious Markets: Religious Pluralism in the Empire State: 1805–1865. American Sociological Review 61:203–218.
Firth, R. 1981 Spiritual Aroma: Religion and Politics. American Anthropologist 83:582–601.
Fishbein, M., and I. Ajzen 1975 Beliefs, Attitudes, Intention, and Behavior: An Introduction to Theory and Research. Reading, Massachusetts: Addison-Wesley.
Frank, R. H. 1988 Passions within Reason: The Strategic Role of the Emotions. New York: W.W. Norton.
Freedman, J. 1965 Long-term Behavioral Effects of Cognitive Dissonance. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 1:103–120.
Freedman, J., and S. Fraser 1966 Compliance without Pressure: The Foot-in-the-Door Technique. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 4:195–202.
Gager, J. 1975 Kingdom and Community. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
Galanter, M. 1999 Cults: Faith, Healing, and Coercion. New York: Oxford University Press.
Geertz, C. 1973 The Interpretation of Cultures. New York: Basic Books.
Gerard, H., and G. Mathewson 1966 The Effects of Severity of Initiation on Liking for a Group: A Replication. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 2:278–287.
Grafen, A. 1990 Biological Signals as Handicaps. Journal of Theoretical Biology 144:517–546.
Hamberg, E., and T. Petersson 1994 The Religious Market: Denominational Competition and Religious Participation in Contemporary Sweden. Journal of the Scientific Study of Religion 33:205–216.
Hames, R. 1992 Time Allocation. In Evolutionary Ecology and Human Behavior, E. A. Smith and B. Winterhalder, eds. Pp. 203–235. New York: Aldine.
Hayden, B. 1987 Alliances and Ritual Ecstasy: Human Responses to Resource Stress. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 26:81–91.
Hefner, P. 1993 The Human Factor: Evolution, Culture, and Religion. Minneapolis: Fortress Press.
Heilman, S. 1992 Defenders of the Faith. Los Angeles: University of California Press.
Heschel, A. 1955 God in Search of Man: A Philosophy of Judaism. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Hostetler, J. 1997 Hutterite Society. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Huxley, J. 1923 Courtship Activities in the Red-Throated Diver (Colymbus stellatus Pontopp), Together with a Discussion of the Evolution of Courtship in Birds. Journal of the Linnean Society of London: Zoology 53:253–292.
Iannaccone, L. 1991 The Consequences of Religious Market Structure: Adam Smith and Economics of Religion. Rationality and Society 29:297–314.
1992 Sacrifice and Stigma: Reducing Free-riding in Cults, Communes, and Other Collectives. Journal of Political Economy 100:271–291.
1994 Why Strict Churches Are Strong. American Journal of Sociology 99:1180–1211.
Irons, W. 1996a In Our Own Self-image: The Evolution of Morality, Deception, and Religion. Skeptic 4:50–61.
1996b Morality as an Evolved Adaptation. In Investigating the Biological Foundations of Morality, J. P. Hurd, ed. Pp. 1–34. Lewiston: Edwin Mellon Press.
1996c Morality, Religion, and Human Nature. In Religion and Science: History, Method, and Dialogue, W. Richardson and W. Wildman, eds. Pp. 375–399. New York: Routledge.
2001 Religion as a Hard-to-Fake Sign of Commitment. In Evolution and the Capacity for Commitment, R. Nesse, ed. Pp. 292–309. New York: Russell Sage.
James, W. 1961 [1903] The Varieties of Religious Experience. New York: Collier Books.
Janis, I., and B. King 1954 The Influence of Role Playing on Opinion Change. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 49:211–218.
Janzen, R. 1999 The Prairie People: Forgotten Anabaptists. London: University Press of New England.
Johnstone, R. 1997 The Evolution of Animal Signals. In Behavioural Ecology: An Evolutionary Approach, fourth ed., J. Krebs and N. Davies, eds. Pp. 155–178. Oxford: Blackwell Scientific.
1998 Game Theory and Communication. In Game Theory and Animal Behavior, L. Dugatkin and H. Reeve, eds. Pp. 94–117. New York: Oxford University Press.
Kaplan, L. 1992 Introduction. In Fundamentalism in Comparative Perspective, L. Kaplan, ed. Pp. 3–14. Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press.
Katz, L., ed. 2000 Evolutionary Origins of Morality: Cross-Disciplinary Perspectives. Exeter, UK: Imprint Academic.
Kelley, D. 1972 Why Conservative Churches Are Growing. New York: Harper and Row.
Kelman, H. 1958 Compliance, Identification, and Internalization: Three Processes of Attitude Change. Journal of Conflict Resolution 2:51–60.
Klass, M. 1995 Ordered Universes: Approaches to the Anthropology of Religion. Boulder: Westview Press.
Latane, B. 1997 Dynamic Social Impact: The Societal Consequences of Human Interaction. In The Message of Social Psychology, C. McGarty and S. Alexander, eds. Pp. 20–35. London: Blackwell.
Landau, D. 1993 Piety and Power: The World of Jewish Fundamentalism. New York: Hill and Wang.
Laughlin, C., and J. McManus 1979 Mammalian Ritual. In The Spectrum of Ritual, E. d’Aquili, C. Laughlin, J. McManus, eds. Pp. 80–116. New York: Columbia University Press.
Lawrence, B. 1989 Defenders of God. San Francisco: Harper and Row.
Leach, E. 1954 Political Systems of Highland Burma. Boston: Beacon Press.
1976 Culture and Communication: The Logic by Which Symbols Are Connected. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Levin, J. 1994 Religion and Health: Is There an Association, Is it Valid, Is it Causal? Social Science Medicine 38:1475–1482.
Levin, M. 1986 Journey to Tradition. Hoboken: Ktav.
Marty, M. 1992 Fundamentals of Fundamentalism. In Fundamentalism in Comparative Perspective, L. Kaplan, ed. Pp. 15–23. Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press.
Marty, M., and R. Appleby 1991 Conclusion: An Interim Report on a Hypothetical Family. In Fundamentalisms Observed, M. Marty and R. S. Appleby, eds. Pp. 814–842. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Moghadam, V. 1992 Fundamentalism and the Woman Question in Afghanistan. In Fundamentalism in Comparative Perspective, L. Kaplan, ed. Pp. 126–151. Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press.
Murray, J. 1995a Determinants of Membership Levels and Duration in a Shaker Commune, 1780–1880. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 34:35–48.
1995b Human Capital in Religious Communes: Literacy and Selection of Nineteenth-Century Shakers. Explorations in Economic History 32:217–235.
Olson, M. 1965 The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
O’neill, P., and L. Petrinovich 1998 A Preliminary Cross-Cultural Study of Moral Intuitions. Evolution and Human Behavior 19:349–367.
Pesternak, V. 1988 Recruitment and Commitment. Society 25:48–51.
Peter, K. 1987 The Dynamics of Hutterite Society. Edmonton: University of Alberta Press.
Radcliffe-Brown, A. 1952 Structure and Function in Primitive Society. London: Cohen and West.
Rappaport, R. 1968 Pigs for the Ancestors. New Haven: Yale University Press.
1979 The Obvious Aspects of Ritual. In Ecology, Meaning and Religion, R. Rappaport, ed. Pp. 173–221. Richmond, California: North Atlantic Books.
1999 Ritual and Religion in the Making of Humanity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Reynolds, V., and R. Tanner 1995 The Social Ecology of Religion. New York: Oxford University Press.
Richerson, P., and R. Boyd 1987 The Role of Evolved Predispositions in Cultural Evolution, or Human Sociobiology Meets Pascal’s Wager. Ethology and Sociobiology 10:195–219.
Robbins, T. 1988 Cults, Converts, and Charisma: The Sociology of New Religious Movements. London: Sage.
Robbins, T., and D. Anthony 1982 Religious Movements and the Brainwashing Issue. In Violence and Religious Commitment, K. Levi, ed. Pp. 133–138. University Park: Penn State University Press.
Roof, W., and W. McKinney 1987 American Mainline Religion: Its Changing Shape and Future. New Brunswick, New Jersey: Rutgers University Press.
Rowe, C. 1999 Receiver Psychology and the Evolution of Multicomponent Signals. Animal Behaviour 58:921–931.
Schelling, T. 1960 The Strategy of Conflict. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Shaffir, W. 1998 Hasidic Jews: Social Boundaries and Institutional Development as Mechanisms of Identity Control. In Jewish Survival: The Identity Problem at the Close of the Twentieth Century, Ernest Krausz and Gitta Tulea, eds. Pp. 169–187. New Brunswick, New Jersey: Transaction.
Sherif, M. 1958 Group Influences upon the Formation of Norms and Attitudes. In Readings in Social Psychology, T. Newcomb and E. Hartley, eds. Pp. 219–232. New York: Henry Holt.
Singer, M. 1995 Cults in Our Midst. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.
Smith, E. 2000 Three Styles in the Evolutionary Analysis of Human Behavior. In Adaptation and Human Behavior: An Anthropological Perspective, L. Cronk, N. Chagnon, and W. Irons, eds. Pp. 27–46. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
Smith, H. 1991 The World’s Religions. San Francisco: Harper.
Sosis, R. 2000 Religion and Intra-group Cooperation: Preliminary Results of a Comparative Analysis of Utopian Communities. Cross-Cultural Research 34: 70–87.
Sosis, R., and E. Bressler 2003 Cooperation and Commune Longevity: A Test of the Costly Signaling Theory of Religion. Cross-Cultural Research, 37:211–239.
Sosis, R., and B. Ruffle 2003 Religious Ritual and Cooperation: Testing for a Relationship on Israeli Religious and Secular Kibbutzim. Current Anthropology, in press.
Spiro, M. 1966 Religion: Problems of Definition and Explanation. In Anthropological Approaches to the Study of Religion, M. Banton, ed. Pp. 85–126. London: Tavistock.
Stark, R. 1987 How New Religions Succeed. In The Future of New Religious Movements, D. Bromley and P. Hammond, eds. Pp. 11–29. Macon, Georgia: Mercer University Press.
1994 Sociology, fifth ed. Belmont, California: Wadsworth.
Stillman, N. 1979 The Jews of Arab Lands. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society.
Telushkin, J. 1991 Jewish Literacy. New York: William Morrow.
Tietze, C. 1957 Reproductive Span and Rate of Reproduction among Hutterite Women. Fertility and Sterility 8:89–97.
Tillich, P. 1951 Systematic Theology, vol. 1. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
1952 The Courage To Be. New Haven: Yale University Press.
1957 The Protestant Era. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Turner, V. 1967 The Forest of Symbols: Aspects of Ndembu Ritual. Ithaca, New York: Cornell University Press.
1969 The Ritual Process. Chicago: Aldine.
Tuzin, D. 1982 Ritual Violence among the Ilahita Arapesh. In Rituals of Manhood: Male Initiation in Papua New Guinea, G. H. Herdt, ed. Pp. 321–356. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Tyler, T., and S. Blader 2000 Cooperation in Groups. Philadelphia: Psychology Press.
Vallacher, R., and D. Wegner 1985 A Theory of Action Identification. London: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
van den Berghe, P., and K. Peter 1988 Hutterites and Kibbutzniks: A Tale of Nepotistic Communism. Man 23:522–539.
Wallace, A. 1966 Religion: An Anthropological View. New York: Random House.
Wilson, B. 1987 Factors in the Failure of New Religious Movements. In The Future of New Religious Movements, D. Bromley and P. Hammond, eds. Pp. 30–45. Macon, Georgia: Mercer University Press.
Wilson, D. S. 2002 Darwin’s Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, and the Nature of Society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Wilson, E. O. 1998a The Biological Basis of Morality. Atlantic Monthly (April):53–70.
1998b Consilience. New York: Vintage Books.
Wilson, L. 2000 Hutterites of Montana. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Winterhalder, B., and E. Smith 2000 Analyzing Adaptive Strategies: Human Behavioral Ecology at Twenty-five. Evolutionary Anthropology 9:51–72.
Whiting, J., R. Kluckholn, and A. Anthony 1958 The Function of Male Initiation Ceremonies at Puberty. In Readings in Social Psychology, E. Maccoby, T. Newcomb, E. Hartley, eds. Pp. 359–370. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston.
Young, F. 1965 Initiation Ceremonies. New York: Bobbs-Merrill.
Zahavi, A. 1975 Mate Selection—A Selection for a Handicap. Journal of Theoretical Biology 53:205–214.
1977 The Cost of Honesty (Further Remarks on the Handicap Principle). Journal of Theoretical Biology 67:603–605.
Zimbardo, P., A. Cohen, M. Weisenburg, L. Dworkin, and I. Firestone 1969 The Control of Experimental Pain. In The Cognitive Control of Motivation, P. Zimbardo, ed. Pp. 100–125. Glenview, Illinois: Scott Foresman.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Richard Sosis is an assistant professor of anthropology at the University of Connecticut. His research interests include the evolution of cooperation, utopian societies, and the behavioral ecology of religion. In collaboration with Bradley Ruffle (Ben Gurion University) he is currently investigating the impact of privatization and religiosity on intra-group trust within Israeli Kibbutzim.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sosis, R. Why aren’t we all hutterites?. Hum Nat 14, 91–127 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12110-003-1000-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12110-003-1000-6