Heritability is not Evolvability

Abstract

Short-term evolutionary potential depends on the additive genetic variance in the population. The additive variance is often measured as heritability, the fraction of the total phenotypic variance that is additive. Heritability is thus a common measure of evolutionary potential. An alternative is to measure evolutionary potential as expected proportional change under a unit strength of selection. This yields the mean-scaled additive variance as a measure of evolvability. Houle in Genetics 130:195–204, (1992) showed that these two ways of scaling additive variance are often inconsistent and can lead to different conclusions as to what traits are more evolvable. Here, we explore this relation in more detail through a literature review, and through theoretical arguments. We show that the correlation between heritability and evolvability is essentially zero, and we argue that this is likely due to inherent positive correlations between the additive variance and other components of phenotypic variance. This means that heritabilities are unsuitable as measures of evolutionary potential in natural populations. More generally we argue that scaling always involves non-trivial assumptions, and that a lack of awareness of these assumptions constitutes a systemic error in the field of evolutionary biology.

Appendix

List of papers used in the literature review: Agrawal et al. (2002), Arnold and Phillips (1999), Ashman (2003), Asteles et al. (2006), Bacigalupe et al. (2004), Beraldi et al. (2007), Berwaerts et al. (2008), Birkhead et al. (2006), Boake and Konigsberg (1998), Brandt and Greenfield (2004), Brodie (1993), Bryant and Meffert (1995), Cadee (2000), Campbell (1996, 1997), Caruso (2004), Caruso et al. (2005), Charmantier et al. (2004a, b), Cheetham et al. (1993, 1994), Cheverud (1996), Coltman et al. (2001, 2005), Conner and Via (1993), Conner et al. (2003, Cotter et al. 2004), Czesak and Fox (2003a, b), De Winter (1992), Evanno et al. (2006), Evans and Marshall (1996), Evans et al. (2006), Fenster and Carr (1997), Fernandez et al. (2003), Fox (1993), Fox et al. (1999), Friberg et al. (2005), Garant et al. (2004), Garcia-Gonzales and Simmons (2005), Gardner and Latta (2008), Gomez et al. (2009), Gomez-Mestre et al. (2008), Gray and Cade (1999), Groeters and Dingle (1996), Han and Lincoln (1994), Hansen et al. (2003b), Hawthorne (1997), Hegyi et al. (2002), Hendrickx et al. (2008), Hoffman et al. (2006), Hoffmann and Schiffer (1998), Horne and Ylönen (1998), House and Simmons (2005), House et al. (2008), Hughes (1995), Ivy (2007), Jensen et al. (2003, 2008), Jia et al. (2000), Johnson et al. (2009), Juenger and Bergelson (2000), Kaczorowski et al. (2008), Karoly and Conner (2000), Kause et al. (1999, 2001), Kellermann et al. (2006), Ketola and Kotiaho (2009), Kilpimaa et al. (2005), Kobayashi et al. (2003), Koelwijn and Hunscheid (2000), Kontiainen et al. (2008), Kruuk et al. (2002, 2003), Larsson (1993), Lauteri et al. (2004), Le Galliard et al. (2006), Leamy (1999), Lew et al. (2006), Linder and Rice (2005), Long et al. (2009), Lynch et al. (1999), MacColl and Hatchwell (2003), Magalhaes et al. (2007), Manier et al. (2007), Mappes and Koskela (2004), Mazer et al. (1999), McAdam and Boutin (2003), Merilä (1997), Merilä and Gustafsson (1993), Merilä et al. (1998), Messina and Fry (2003), Miller and Sinervo (2007), Milner et al. (2000), Morrow et al. (2008), Nespolo et al. (2003, 2005), Nilsson et al. (2009), Noach et al. (1996), ONeil (1997), Ostrowski et al. (2002), Parker and Garant (2004), Pélabon et al. (2004), Pelletier et al. (2007), Perez and Garcia (2002), Perry et al. (2004), Pettay et al. (2008), Platenkamp and Shaw (1992), Platenkamp and Shaw (1993), Podolsky et al. (1997), Polak and Starmer (2001), Radwan (1998), Rauter and Moore (2002), Reale and Festa-Bianchet (2000), Reale et al. (2003), Ritland and Ritland (1996), Rodriguez and Greenfield (2003), Roff (1995), Rolff et al. (2005), Rønning et al. (2007), Routley and Husband (2005), Ryder and Siva-Jothy (2001), Sakai et al. (2008), Santos (1996, 2001, 2002), Santos et al. (1992), Sarkissian and Harder (2001), Sgro and Hoffmann (1998), Shaw and Platenkamp (1993), Shaw et al. (1995), Sherrard et al. (2009), Simmons (2003), Simmons and Garcia-Gonzalez (2007), Simmons and Kotiaho (2002), Simons and Johnston (2006), Simons and Roff (1994), Simons et al. (1998), Steigenga et al. (2005), Teplitsky et al. (2009), Theriault et al. (2007), Thessing and Ekman (1994), Thiede (1998), Thomas and Simmons (2008), Tonsor and Goodnight (1997), Tucic and Stojkovic (2001), Van Kleunen and Ritland (2004), Verhoeven et al. (2004), Watkins (2001), Wayne et al. (1997), Weber and Scheiner (1992), Weller et al. (2006), Wilson et al. (2003), Wilson et al. (2005), Windig (1994), Winn (2004), Woods et al. (1998), Worley and Barrett (2000).