Abstract
This study identifies characteristic features in scalp EEG that simultaneously give the best discrimination between epileptic seizures and background EEG in minimally pre-processed scalp data; and have minimal computational complexity to be suitable for online, real-time analysis. The discriminative performance of 65 previously reported features has been evaluated in terms of sensitivity, specificity, area under the sensitivity–specificity curve (AUC), and relative computational complexity, on 47 seizures (split in 2,698 2 s sections) in over 172 h of scalp EEG from 24 adults. The best performing features are line length and relative power in the 12.5–25 Hz band. Relative power has a better seizure detection performance (AUC = 0.83; line length AUC = 0.77), but is calculated after the discrete wavelet transform and is thus more computationally complex. Hence, relative power achieves the best performance for offline detection, whilst line length would be preferable for online low complexity detection. These results, from the largest systematic study of seizure detection features, aid future researchers in selecting an optimal set of features when designing algorithms for both standard offline detection and new online low computational complexity detectors.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Agostinho PR, Haddad S, De Lima JA, Serdijn WA, Saotome O (2008) An ultra low power CMOS pA/V transconductor and its application to wavelet filters. Analog Integr Circ Sig Process 57:19–27
Badawy RAB, Pillay N, Jettec N, Wiebec S, Federico P (2011) A blinded comparison of continuous versus sampled review of video-EEG monitoring data. Clin Neurophysiol 122:1086–1090
Casson AJ, Yates DC, Smith SJ, Duncan JS, Rodriguez-Villegas E (2010) Wearable electroencephalography. IEEE EMBS Mag 29:44–56
Casson AJ, Rodriguez-Villegas E (2011) A 60 pW gmC continuous wavelet transform circuit for portable EEG systems. J Solid-State Circuits 46:1406–1415
DeClercq W, Vergult A, Vanrumste B, Van Paesschen W, Van Huffel S (2006) Canonical correlation analysis applied to remove muscle artifacts from the electroencephalogram. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 53:2583–2587
Faul S, Temko A, Marnane W (2009) Age-independent seizure detection. In: Proceedings of the 31st international conference of IEEE Engineering Medicine Biology Society, Minnesota. IEEE, Piscataway, pp 6612–6615
Goncharova II, McFarland DJ, Vaughan TM, Wolpaw JR (2003) EMG contamination of EEG: spectral and topographical characteristics. Clin Neurophysiol 114:1580–1593
Gotman J, Ives JR, Gloor P (1981) Frequency content of EEG and EMG at seizure onset: possibility of removal of EMG artefact by digital filtering. Electroenceph Clin Neurophysiol 52:626–639
Gotman J (1999) Automatic detection of seizures and spikes. J Clin Neurophysiol 16:130–140
Greene BR, Faul S, Marnane WP, Lightbody G, Korotchikova I, Boylan GB (2008) A comparison of quantitative EEG features for neonatal seizure detection. Clin Neurophysiol 119:1248–1261
Guerrero-Mosquera C, Trigueros AM, Fraco JI, Navia-Vàzquez A (2010) New feature extraction approach for epileptic EEG signal detection using time-frequency distributions. Med Biol Eng Comput 48:321–333
Hall CW Jr, Sarkar A (2011) Mutual information in natural position order of electroencephalogram is significantly increased at seizure onset. Med Biol Eng Comput 49:133–141
Harreby KR, Sevcencu C, Struijik JJ (2011) Early seizure detection in rats based on vagus nerve activity. Med Biol Eng Comput 49:143–151
Hongmin L, Yigang H, Sun Y (2008) Detection of cardiac signal characteristic point using log-domain wavelet transform circuits. Circuits Syst Signal Process 27:683–698
Kamboh AM, Raetz M, Oweiss KG, Mason A (2007) Area-power efficient VLSI implementation of multichannel DWT for data compression in implantable neuroprosthetics. IEEE Trans Biomed Circ Syst 1:128–135
Kelly KM, Shiaud DS, Kernd RT, Chiend JH, Yang MCK, Yandora KA, Valeriano JP, Halford JJ, Sackellares JC (2010) Assessment of a scalp EEG-based automated seizure detection system. Clin Neurphysiol 121:1832–1843
Kim H, Rosen J (2010) Epileptic seizure detection—an AR model based algorithm for implantable device. In: Proceedings of the 32nd international conference of IEEE Engineering Medicine Biology Society, Buenos Aires. IEEE, Piscataway, p 5541
Koubeissi MZ, Syed TU (2011) Inpatient video-EEG monitoring: how much shall we review? Clin Neurophysiol 122:1065–1066
Kuhlmann L, Cook MJ, Fuller K, Grayden DB, Burkitt AN, Mareels IMY (2008) Correlation analysis of seizure detection features. In: Proceedings of the international conference on intelligent sensors, sensor networks and information processing, Sydney. IEEE, Piscataway, pp 309–314
Kuhlmann L, Burkitt AN, Cook MJ, Fuller K, Grayden DB, Seiderer L, Mareels IMY (2009) Seizure detection using seizure probability estimation: comparison of features used to detect seizures. Ann Biomed Eng 37:2129–2145
Lesser RP (2009) Epilepsy: does continuous EEG monitoring improve seizure control? Nat Rev Neurol 5:581–582
McEvoy RP, Faul S, Marnane WP (2010) Ambulatory REACT: real-time seizure detection with a DSP microprocessor. In: Proceedings of the international conference of IEEE Engineering Medicine Biology Society, Buenos Aires. IEEE, Piscataway, pp 2443–2444
Narasimhan S, Chiel HJ, Bhunia S (2010) Ultra-low-power and robust digital-signal-processing hardware for implantable neural interface microsystems. IEEE Trans Biomed Circ Syst 4:1–10
Nuwer MR, Comi G, Emerson R, Fuglsang-Frederiksen A, Guerit J, Hinrichs H, Ikeda A, Luccas FJC, Rappelsburger P (1998) IFCN standards for digital recording of clinical EEG. Electroenceph Clin Neurophysiol 106:259–261
O’Donnell RD, Berkhout J, Adey WR (1974) Contamination of scalp EEG spectrum during contraction of cranio-facial muscles. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 37:145–151
Raghunathan S, Gupta SK, Markandeya HS, Roya K, Irazoqui PP (2010) A hardware-algorithm co-design approach to optimize seizure detection algorithms for implantable applications. J Neurosci Methods 1:106–117
Shiau D, Halford JJ, Kelly KM, Kern RT, Inman M, Chien J, Pardalos PM, Yang MCK, Sackellares JC (2010) Signal regularity-based automated seizure detection system for scalp EEG monitoring. Cybern Syst Anal 46:922–935
Sisodiya S (2007) Etiology and management of refractory epilepsies. Nat Clin Pract Neuro 3:320–330
Tito M, Cabrerizo M, Ayala M, Jayakar P, Adjouadi M (2009) Seizure detection: an assessment of time- and frequency-based features in a unified two-dimensional decisional space using nonlinear decision functions. J Clin Neurophysiol 26:381–391
van Putten MJAM, Kind T, Visser F, Lagerburg V (2005) Detecting temporal lobe seizures from scalp EEG recordings: a comparison of various features. Clin Neurophysiol 116:2480–2489
Vergult A, De Clercq Q, Palmini A, Vanrumste B, Dupont P, Van Huffel S, Van Paesschen W (2007) Improving the Interpretation of Ictal Scalp EEG: BSS-CCA algorithm for muscle artifact removal. Epilepsia 48:950–958
Verma N, Shoeb A, Bohorquez J, Dawson J, Guttag J, Chandrakasan AP (2010) A micro-power EEG acquisition SoC with integrated feature extraction processor for a chronic seizure detection system. J Solid-State Circuits 45:804–816
Wang A, Chandrakasan AP (2005) A 180-mV subthreshold FFT processor using a minimum energy design methodology. IEEE J Solid-State Circuits 40:310–319
Zandi AS, Javidan M, Dumont GA, Tafreshi R (2010) Automated real-time epileptic seizure detection in scalp EEG recordings using an algorithm based on wavelet packet transform. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 57:1639–1651
Zweig MH, Campbell G (1993) Receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) plots: a fundamental evaluation tool in clinical medicine. Clin Chem 39:561–577
Acknowledgments
The research leading to these results has received funding from the European Research Council under the European Community’s 7th Framework Programme (FP7/2007–2013)/ERC grant agreement no. 239749.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
An erratum to this article is available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11517-016-1535-4.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Logesparan, L., Casson, A.J. & Rodriguez-Villegas, E. Optimal features for online seizure detection. Med Biol Eng Comput 50, 659–669 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11517-012-0904-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11517-012-0904-x