Abstract
Purpose
Biomass provides an attractive solution for residential heating systems based on renewable fuels, even though biomass-based domestic heating systems are recognized as significant particulate matter emitters; thus, a life cycle assessment (LCA) approach was used in the study to compare two different appliances: a wood stove and a pellet stove, both modeled according to the best available technologies definition.
Methods
System boundaries of each scenario refer to a cradle-to-grave approach, including production, use and disposal of the heating appliance, as well as the preparation of biomass feedstock. The assessment of environmental impacts was performed assuming 1 MJ of thermal energy as the reference flow, considering the categories of particulate matter formation, human toxicity, climate change, and fossil fuel depletion, according to the ReCiPe 1.07 method. Finally, the comparison was extended to certain innovative heating systems in order to qualitatively evaluate potential improvements in residential heating performances.
Results and discussion
The results show that the wood stove reaches the highest scores in the categories of particulate matter formation and negative effects for human toxicity, as a consequence of the stove’s lower combustion efficiency, which would lead to a preference for the pellet stove. However, when climate change affecting human health and the ecosystem, and fossil depletion are considered, the choice appears more uncertain due to the energy consumption from the pelletizing step. Alternative technologies (e.g., solar panels in combination with a gas boiler) show better scores related to fine particles emission reduction, even if a worsening in other categories is observed. The results were validated by a sensitivity analysis.
Conclusions
The study suggests that a LCA approach can support the choice of the best domestic heating system, helping to promote policy initiatives on a sound basis and to understand which are the main key levers to act for reducing the total environmental burdens of biomass-based heating appliances.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Acerbi G. (2009) Dossier Pompe di calore-Progetto RES & RUE Dissemination. http://www.ape.fvg.it/fileadmin/generale/cartella_1/ADICONS%20Pompe%20di%20calore.pdf. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
AIEL (2011) La combustione del legno- fattori di emissione e quadro normativo. http://www.aiel.cia.it/easy.php?COD_PAG=997. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
AIEL (2012) Legna Cippato Pellet—Produzione—Requisiti qualitativi—compravendita. AIEL, Italy
APAT-ARPA Lombardia (2008) Stima dei consumi di legna da ardere per risaldamento ed uso domestico in Italia, (In Italian). http://www.isprambiente.gov.it/contentfiles/00004100/4156-stima-dei-consumi-di-legna-da-ardere.pdf. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
Ardente F, Beccali G, Cellura M, Lo Brano V (2005) Life cycle assessment of a solar thermal collector: sensitivity analysis, energy and environmental balances. Renew Energ 30:109–130
Bäfuer LS, Leckner B, Tullin C, Bernten M (2011) Particle emissions from pellets stoves and modern and old-type wood stoves. Biomass Bioenerg 35:3648–3655
Bidini G, Cotana F, Buratti C, Fantozzi F, Barbanera M (2006) Analisi del ciclo di vita del pellet da srf attraverso misure dirette dei consumi energetici. http://www.crbnet.it/File/Pubblicazioni/pdf/1290.pdf. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
Bonoli A (2007) Applicazione di una metodologia LCA (life cycle assessment) per una valutazione costi/benefici di carattere ambientale nell’impiego di biomasse per la produzione energetica nell’Appennino tosco emiliano. http://www.centrocisa.it/ricerche/archivioB/allegati/MEB_LCA.pdf. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
Caserini S, Livio S, Giuliano M, Grosso M, Rigamonti L (2010) LCA of domestic and centralized biomass combustion: the case of Lombardy (Italy). Biomass Bionerg 34:474–482
CTI Energia e Ambiente, TCVVV S.p.A., FIER, CFAV, KOBA s.r.l., Università Politecnica delle Marche, VTT Energy, Regione Lombardia (2004), BIOCEN Gestione e valorizzazione delle ceneri di combustione nella filiera Legno-Energia. www.cti2000.it/solidi.htm. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
Cocchi M, Capaccioli S, Vivarelli F (2009) IEA Bioenergy Task 40 Sustainable International Bioenergy Trade Country Report 2009 Italy. http://www.bioenergytrade.org/downloads/italycrtask40.pdf. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
Directive 2008/98/EC of the European Parliament and of the council of 19 November 2008 on waste and repealing certain Directives. OJ L 312, 22.11.2008, pp 3–30
Directive 2009/28/EC of the European Parliament and of the council of 23 April 2009 on the promotion of the use of energy from renewable sources and amending and subsequently repealing Directives 2001/77/EC and 2003/30/EC. OJ L 140, 5.6.2009, pp. 16–62
Ecoinvent Centre (formerly Swiss Centre for Life Cycle Inventories) (2009) Ecoinvent 2.2 Database
EMPA (2001) Emissionen und Stofflüsse von (Rest-) Holzfeuerungen. EMPA, Dübendorf (CH) Rapporto Nr. 880’002/1 http://www.empa.ch/plugin/template/*/5632. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
ENEA (2009) Dossier-Usi termici delle fonti rinnovabili. http://old.enea.it/produzione_scientifica/pdf_dossier/D20-Usi-termici-fonti-rinnovabili.pdf. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
European Commission, DG TREN (2009a) Preparatory studies for eco-design requirements of EuPs(II), Lot 15- Solid fuel small combustions installations- Task 5: Base Cases. http://www.ecosolidfuel.org/. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
European Commission, DG TREN (2009b) Preparatory Studies for Eco-design Requirements of EuPs(II), Lot 15- Solid fuel small combustions installations- Task 6: Technical analysis of BATs. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
FAO (2011) State of the world’s forests 2011. http://www.fao.org/docrep/013/i2000e/i2000e00.htm. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
Fiedler F (2004) The state of the art of small-scale pellet-based heating systems and relevant regulations in Sweden, Austria and Germany. Renew Sust Energ Rev 8:201–21
Gmur C (2000) Pelletheizungen. Energiepraxis nr. 1
Goedkoop M, Heijungs, Huijbregts M, De Schryver A, Struijs J, van Zelm R (2012) ReCiPe 2008 – A life cycle impact assessment method which comprises harmonised category indicators at the midpoint and the endpoint level, First edition (revised). Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning and the Environment (VROM), Netherland
Gustavsson L, Karlsson Å (2001) CO2 mitigation cost: a system perspective on the heating of detached houses with bioenergy or fossil fuels. EFI Procedings 39
Hellrigl B (2004) Il pellet: notizie ed informazioni sulla produzione e l’impiego. http://www.rivistasherwood.it/component/content/article/57-il-pellet-notizie-ed-informazioni-sulla-produzione-e-limpiego.html. Accessed in Sept 2012
Heschel W, Rweyemamu L, Scheibner T, Meyer B (1999) Abatement of emissions in small-scale combustors through utilization of blended pellet fuels. Fuel Process Technol 61(3):223–42
INFC (2007) Le stime di superficie 2005—Prima parte. G. Tabacchi, F. De Natale, L. Di Cosmo, A. Floris, C. Gagliano, P. Gasparini, L. Genchi, G. Scrinzi, V. Tosi. Inventario Nazionale delle Foreste e dei Serbatoi Forestali di Carbonio. MiPAF—Corpo Forestale dello Stato—Ispettorato Generale, CRA—ISAFA, Trento. http://www.infc.it. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
ISTAT (2008) Utilizzazioni legnose forestali per tipo di bosco e per destinazione (in metri cubi). Dettaglio per provincia. Tavole. http://www.istat.it/. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
Istituto di Ricerche Ambiente Italia (2006) Il riciclo ecoefficiente. Potenzialità ambientali, economiche ed energetiche. Edizioni Ambiente srl, Milan
Istituto Superiore per la Protezione e la Ricerca Ambientale (ISPRA) Rapporti http://www.isprambiente.gov.it/it/pubblicazioni/rapporti.html. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
Junginger M, van Dam J, Alakangas E, Virkkunen M, Vesterinen P, Veijonen K (2010) EuBionNet3 - Solutions for biomass fuel market barriers and raw material availability—IEE/07/777/SI2.499477. Solutions to overcome barriers in bioenergy markets in Europe—D2.2. Resource, use and market analysis – VTT-R-01700-10. Available in: http://www.eubionet.net/default.asp?SivuID=25484. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
Kemma R, van Elburg M, Li W, van Holsteijn R (2005) Methodology study eco-design of energy-using products, Final Report- Gas & Oil-fired CH boilers VHK
Legislative Decree no. 152 of 3 April 2006. Norme in materia ambientale Gazzetta Ufficiale n. 88 del 14 Aprile 2006—suppl. ord. n. 96
Madlener R, Koller M (2007) Economic and CO2 mitigation impacts of promoting biomass heating systems: an input–output study for Vorarlberg, Austria. Energ Policy 35:6021–6035
Nord-Larsen T, Bergstendt A, Farver O, Heding N (2011) Drying of firewood e the effect of harvesting time, tree species and shelter of stacked wood. Biomass Bioenerg 35:2993–2998
Osservatorio Nazionale sui Rifiuti, ONR (2009) Programma e Rapporto dell’Osseratorio – PRO2 Rapporto 2008, Rome, Italy. http://www.minambiente.it/export/sites/default/archivio/notizie/programma_convegno_rifiuti.pdf. Accessed 19 March 2013
Pastorello C, Dilara P (2010) Estimation of residential wood combustion in the Lombardy Region. European Commission-JRC (Joint Research Centre) . http://ita.arpalombardia.it/ita/qaria/pdf/Full_IX_Report-final.pdf.%20. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
Pauschinger T, Ménard M, Schulz M (2003) Impianti solari termici Manuale per la progettazione e costruzione. http://www.eco-domus.it/index2.php?option=com_docman&gid=34&task=doc_view&Itemid=documenti. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
Pré Consultant (2010) Introduction to LCA with SimaPro 7
Probio CTI (2004) Analisi tecnico economica per una filiera di produzione di pellet da legno. http://www.cti2000.it/solidi/Convegno%20Pellet%202004.pdf. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
Region of Lombardy, Regional Law no. 24 of 11 December 2006
Roedl A (2010) Production and energetic utilization of wood from short rotation coppice—a life cycle assessment. Int J Life Cycle Assess 15:567–578
Solli C, Reenaas M, Strømman AH, Hertwich EG (2009) Life cycle assessment of wood-based heating in Norway. Int J Life Cycle Assess 14:517–528
Stiller H (1999) Material intensity of advanced composite materials. Wuppertal Papers, Nr 90, February 1999, ISSN 0949-5266
UMBERA Editore (2000) Woodpellets in Europe. UMBERA S.r.l., St. Pölten, Austria
UNI EN 14961-2:2011 Solid biofuels—Fuel specifications and classes—Part 2: wood pellets for non-industrial use
UNI EN 14961-5:2011 Solid biofuels—Fuel specifications and classes—Part 5: firewood for non-industrial use
Verma VK, Bram S, De Ruyck J (2009) Small scale biomass heating systems: standards, quality labelling and market driving factors—an EU outlook. Biomass Bioenerg 33:1393–1402
Vivarelli F, Ghezzi L (2009) Development and promotion of a transparent European Pellets Market. Creation of a European real-time Pellets Atlas. http://pelletsatlas.info/pelletsatlas_docs/showdoc.asp?id=100211172354&type=doc&pdf=true. Accessed 7 Sept 2012
Weidema BP, Wesnaes M (1996) Data quality management for life cycle inventories—an example for using data quality indicators. J Cleaner Prod 4(3–4):167–174
Acknowledgments
This research was carried out within the framework of “L.EN.S. (Wood-Energy-Health) project,” funded by the Italian Ministry of Research (PRIN program).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Responsible editor: Jörg Schweinle
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cespi, D., Passarini, F., Ciacci, L. et al. Heating systems LCA: comparison of biomass-based appliances. Int J Life Cycle Assess 19, 89–99 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-013-0611-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-013-0611-3