Abstract
To assess strategies for mitigating Pb and As transfer into leafy vegetables from contaminated garden soils, we conducted greenhouse experiments using two field-contaminated soils amended with materials expected to reduce metal phytoavailability. Lettuce and mustard greens grown on these soils were analyzed by ICP-MS, showing that some Pb and As transfer into the vegetables occurred from both soils tested, but plant Pb concentrations were highly variable among treatment replicates. Soil-to-plant transfer was more efficient for As than for Pb. Contamination of the leaves by soil particles probably accounted for most of the vegetable Pb, since plant Pb concentrations were correlated to plant tissue concentrations of the immobile soil elements Al and Fe. This correlation was not observed for vegetable As concentrations, evidence that most of the soil-to-plant transfer for this toxic metal occurred by root uptake and translocation into the above-ground tissues. A follow-up greenhouse experiment with lettuce on one of the two contaminated soils revealed a lower and less variable foliar Pb concentration than observed in the first experiment, with evidence of less soil particle contamination of the crop. This reduced transfer of Pb to the crop appeared to be a physical effect attributable to the greater biomass causing reduced overall exposure of the above-ground tissues to the soil surface. Attempts to reduce soil Pb and As solubility and plant uptake by amendment at practical rates with stabilizing materials, including composts, peat, Ca phosphate, gypsum, and Fe oxide, were generally unsuccessful. Only Fe oxide reduced soluble As in the soil, but this effect did not persist. Phosphate amendment rapidly increased soil As solubility but had no measurable effect on either soil Pb solubility or concentrations of Pb or As in the leafy vegetables. The ineffectiveness of these amendments in reducing Pb transfer into leafy vegetables is attributed in this study to the low initial Pb solubility of the studied soils and the fact that the primary mechanism of Pb transfer is physical contamination.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Boisson, J., Ruttens, A., Mench, A. M., & Vangronsveld, J. (1999). Evaluation of hydroxyapatite as a metal immobilizing soil additive for the remediation of polluted soils. Part 1. Influence of hydroxyapatite on metal exchangeability in soil, plant growth and plant metal accumulation. Environmental Pollution, 104, 225–233.
Bothe, J. V., & Brown, P. W. (1999). Arsenic immobilization by calcium arsenate formation. Environmental Science and Technology, 33, 3806–3811.
Capar, S. G., Tanner, J. T., Friedman, M. H., & Boyer, K. W. (1978). Multielement analysis of animal feed, animal wastes, and sewage sludge. Environmental Science and Technology, 12, 785–790.
Chamberlain, A. C. (1983). Fallout of lead and uptake by crops. Atmospheric Environment, 17, 693–706.
Cherney, J. H., & Robinson, D. L. (1983). A comparison of plant digestion methods for identifying soil contamination of plant tissue by Ti analysis. Agronomy Journal, 75, 145–147.
Chrysochoou, M., Dermatas, D., & Grubb, D. G. (2007). Phosphate application to firing range soils for Pb immobilization: the unclear role of phosphate. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 144, 1–14.
Davis, A., Drexler, J. W., Ruby, M. V., & Nicholson, A. (1993). Micromineralogy of mine wastes in relation to lead bioavailability, Butte, Montana. Environmental Science and Technology, 27, 1415–1425.
Epstein, A. L., Gussman, C. D., Blaylock, M. J., Yermiyahu, U., Huang, J. W., Kapulnik, Y., & Orser, C. S. (1999). EDTA and Pb-EDTA accumulation in Brassica juncea grown in Pb-amended soil. Plant and Soil, 208, 87–94.
Finster, M. E., Gray, K. A., & Binns, H. J. (2003). Lead levels of edibles grown in contaminated residential soils: a field survey. Science of the Total Environment, 320, 245–257.
Hashimoto, Y., Yamaguchi, N., Takaoka, M., & Shiota, K. (2011). EXAFS speciation and phytoavailability of Pb in a contaminated soil amended with compost and gypsum. Environmental Science and Technology, 409, 1001–1007.
Hibben, C. R., Hagar, S. S., & Mazza, C. P. (1984). Comparison of cadmium and lead content of vegetable crops grown in urban and suburban gardens. Environmental Pollution (Series B), 7, 71–80.
Hough, R. L., Breward, N., Young, S. D., Crout, N. M. J., Tye, A. M., Moir, A. M., & Thornton, I. (2004). Assessing potential risk of heavy metal exposure from consumption of home-produced vegetables by urban populations. Environmental Health Perspectives, 112, 215–221.
Jorhem, L., Engman, J., Lindestrom, L., & Schroder, T. (2000). Uptake of lead by vegetables grown in contaminated soil. Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 31, 2403–2411.
Kenyon, D. J., Elfving, D. C., Pakkala, I. S., Bache, C. A., & Lisk, D. J. (1979). Residues of lead and arsenic in crops cultured on old orchard soils. Bulletin of Environment Contamination and Toxicology, 22, 221–223.
Kumpiene, J., Lagerkvist, A., & Maurice, C. (2007). Stabilization of Pb- and Cu-contaminated soil using coal fly ash and peat. Environmental Pollution, 145, 365–373.
Lee, S. H., Lee, J. S., Choi, Y. J., & Kim, J. G. (2009). In situ stabilization of cadmium-, lead-, and zinc-contaminated soil using various amendments. Chemosphere, 77, 1069–1075.
Ma, L. Q., Hardison, D. W., Jr., Harris, W. G., Cao, X., & Zhou, Q. (2007). Effect of soil property and soil amendment on weathering of abraded metallic Pb in shooting ranges. Water, Air, & Soil Pollution, 178, 297–307.
MacLean, K. S., & Langille, W. M. (1981). Arsenic in orchard and potato soils and plant tissue. Plant and Soil, 61, 413–418.
McBride, M. B. (1998). Growing food crops on sludge-amended soils: problems with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency method of estimating toxic metal transfer. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 17, 2274–2281.
Melamed, R., Cao, X. D., Chen, M., & Ma, L. Q. (2003). Field assessment of lead immobilization in a contaminated soil after phosphate application. Science of the Total Environment, 305, 117–127.
Nali, C., Balducci, E., Frati, L., Paoli, L., Loppi, S., & Lorenzini, G. (2009). Lettuce plants as bioaccumulators of trace elements in a community of central Italy. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 149, 143–149.
Nwachukwu, O. I., & Pulford, I. D. (2009). Soil metal immobilization and ryegrass uptake of lead, copper and zinc as affected by application of organic materials as soil amendments in a short-term greenhouse trial. Soil Use Management, 25, 159–167.
Peryea, F. J., & Kammereck, R. (1997). Phosphate-enhanced movement of arsenic out of lead arsenate-contaminated topsoil and through uncontaminated subsoil. Water, Air, & Soil Pollution, 93, 243–254.
Pillay, V., & Jonnalagadda, S. B. (2007). Elemental uptake by edible herbs and lettuce (Latuca sativa). Journal of Environmental Science and Health Part B. Pesticides, Food Contaminants, and Agricultural Wastes, 42, 423–428.
Prasad, L. R., & Nazareth, B. (2000). Contamination of allotment soil with lead: managing potential risks to health. Journal of Public Health Medicine, 22, 525–530.
Preer, J. R., Sekhon, H. S., Stephens, B. R., & Collins, M. S. (1980). Factors affecting heavy metal content of garden vegetables. Environmental Pollution (Series B), 1, 95–104.
Preer, J. R., Sekhon, H. S., Weeks, J., Jr., Stephens, B. R. (1980b). Heavy metals in garden soil and vegetables in Washington, D.C. In D. D. Hemphill (Ed.), Trace substances in environmental health—XIV, (pp. 516–521). Columbia, MO: University of Missouri.
Rosborg, I., Gerhardsson, L., & Nihlgard, B. (2009). Mineral element concentrations in vegetables cultivated in acidic compared to alkaline areas of south Sweden. Air, Soil Water Research, 2, 15–29.
Samsoe-Petersen, L., Larsen, E. H., Larsen, P. B., & Bruun, P. (2002). Uptake of trace elements and PAHs by fruit and vegetables from contaminated soils. Environmental Science and Technology, 36, 3057–3063.
Sauve, S., McBride, M. B., & Hendershot, W. (1998). Soil solution speciation of lead (II): effects of organic matter and pH. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 62, 618–621.
Schooley, T., Weaver, M. J., Mullins, D., & Eick, M. (2008). The history of lead arsenate use in apple production: comparison of its impact in Virginia with other states. Journal of Pesticide Safety Education, 10, 22–53.
Sneddon, I. R., Orueetxebarria, M., Hodson, M. E., Schofield, P. F., & Valsami-Jones, E. (2008). Field trial using bone meal amendments to remediate mine waste derived soil contaminated with zinc, lead and cadmium. Applied Geochemistry, 23, 2414–2424.
Thornton, I., & Jones, T. H. (1984). Sources of lead and associated metals in vegetables grown in British urban soils: uptake from the soil versus air deposition. Trace Substances in Environmental Health, 18, 303–310.
Tjell, J. C., Hovmand, M. F., & Mosbaek, H. (1979). Atmospheric lead pollution of grass grown in a background area in Denmark. Nature, 280, 425–426.
Veneman, P. L. M., Murray, J. R., & Baker, J. H. (1983). Spatial distribution of pesticide residues in a former apple orchard. Journal of Environmental Quality, 12, 101–114.
Xenidis, A., Stouraiti, C., & Papassiopi, N. (2010). Stabilization of Pb and As in soils by applying combined treatment with phosphates and ferrous iron. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 177, 929–937.
Acknowledgments
This research was supported by the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences grant number 1R21ES017921-01. We wish to thank Dr. Joshua Cheng at Brooklyn College for the soil water analyses by ICP-MS.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
McBride, M.B., Simon, T., Tam, G. et al. Lead and Arsenic Uptake by Leafy Vegetables Grown on Contaminated Soils: Effects of Mineral and Organic Amendments. Water Air Soil Pollut 224, 1378 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11270-012-1378-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11270-012-1378-z