Abstract
This article addresses major arguments in the controversy about the “rationality” of moral behavior: can moral behavior be explained by rational choice theory (RCT)? The two positions discussed are the incentives thesis (norms are incentives as any other costs and benefits) and the autonomy thesis claiming that moral behavior has nothing to do with utility. The article analyses arguments for the autonomy thesis by J. Elster, A. Etzioni, and J. G. March and J. P. Olsen. Finally, the general claim is discussed whether norm following and norm emergence are utility maximizing. The conclusion is that the autonomy thesis is not tenable if one applies a wide subjectivist, social psychological version of RCT that includes the assumption of “bounded rationality.” The autonomy thesis is only compatible with a narrow version of RCT that excludes internal outcomes and that refers to norms that do not have external outcomes. It is argued that such a narrow version is not capable of explaining many forms of behavior social scientists are interested in.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aarts H., Dijksterhuis A. (2000) Habits as knowledge structures: Automaticity in goal-directed behavior. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 78(1): 53–63
Aarts H., Dijksterhuis A., Custers R. (2003) Automatic normative behavior in environments: The moderating role of conformity in activating situational norms. Social Cognition 21(6): 447–464
Allan L. G., Jenkins H. M. (1980) The judgment of contingency and the nature of the response alternatives. Canadian Journal of Psychology 34(1): 1–11
Anthony D., Smith S. W., Williamson T. (2009) Reputation and reliability in collective goods. The case of the online encyclopedia WIKIPEDIA. Rationality & Society 21(3): 283–306
Babcock L., Loewenstein G. (1997) Explaining bargaining impasse: The role of self-serving biases. Journal of Economic Perspectives 11(1): 109–126
Bandura A. (1986) Social foundations of thought and action. A social cognitive theory. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
Bargh J. A., Gollwitzer P. M., Lee-Chai A., Barndollar K. (2001) The automated will: Non-conscious activation and pursuit of behavioral goals. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 81(6): 1014–1027
Bargh J. A., Morsella E. (2008) The unconscious mind. perspectives on Psychological Science 3(1): 73–79
Bentham, J. [1982 (first 1789)]. In J. H. Burns & H. L. A Hart (Eds.), An introduction to the principles of morals and legislation. London: Methuen.
Bohman J. (1992) The limits of rational choice explanation. In: Coleman J. S., Fararo T. J. (eds) Rational choice theory. Advocacy and critique. SAGE, Newbury Park, pp 207–228
Boudon R. (1996) The ’cognitivist model.’ A generalized ’rational-choice-model’. Rationality and Society 8(2): 123–150
Boyd R., Richerson P. J. (2005) The origin and evolution of culture. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Breen R. (2009) Game theory. In: Hedström P., Bearman P. (eds) The oxford handbook of analytical sociology. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 619–638
Brennan G., Buchanan J. M. (1985) The reason of rules. Constitutional political economy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Brennan T. J. (1989) A methodological assessment of multiple utility frameworks. Economics and Philosophy 5(2): 189–201
Brown R. (1965) Social psychology. The Free Press, New York
Chaiken S., Trope Y. (1999) Dual-process theories in social psychology. Guilford Press, New York
Coleman J. S. (1990) Foundations of social theory. Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Deci E. L., Koestner R., Ryan R. M. (1999) A meta-analytic review of experiments examining effects of extrinsic rewards on intrinsic motivation. Psychological Bulletin 125: 627–668
Demsetz H. (1967) Toward a theory of property rights. American Economic Review 57(2): 347–359
Ellickson R. C. (1991) Order without law. How neighbors settle disputes. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Elster J. (1989) Social norms and economic theory. Journal of Economic Perspectives 3: 99–117
Elster J. (1989) The cement of society. A study of social order. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Elster J. (1990) Norms of revenge. Ethics 100(4): 862–885
Elster J. (1991) Rationality and social norms. Archives Européennes de Sociologie 32(1): 109–121
Esser H. (1999) Soziologie. Spezielle Grundlagen. Band 1: Situationslogik und Handeln. Campus, Frankfurt
Esser H. (2001) Soziologie. Spezielle Grundlagen. Band 6: Sinn und Kultur. Campus, Frankfurt
Etzioni A. (1986) The case for a multiple-utility conception. Economics and Philosophy 2: 159–183
Etzioni A. (1988) The moral dimension. Toward a new economics. Free Press, New York
Falk A., Gächter S., Kovács J. (1999) Intrinsic motivation and extrinsic incentives in a repeated game with incomplete contracts. Journal of Economic Psychology 20(3): 251–284
Fazio R. H. (1990) Multiple processes by which attitudes guide behavior: The mode model as an integrative framework. In: Zanna M. P. (ed.) Advances in experimental social psychology. Academic Press, San Diego, pp 75–109
Fazio R. H., Towles-Schwen T. (1999) The MODE model of attitude-behavior processes. In: Chaiken S., Trope Y. (eds) Dual process theories in social psychology. Guilford, New York, pp 97–116
Fehr E., Falk A. (2002) Psychological foundations of incentives. European Economic Review 46(4–5): 687–724
Fehr E., Fischbacher U. (2003) The nature of human altruism. Nature 425: 785–791
Fehr E., Fischbacher U., Gächter S. (2002) Strong reciprocity, human cooperation and the enforcement of social norms. Human Nature 13(1): 1–25
Fehr E., Gächter S. (2000) Cooperation and punishment in public goods experiments. American Economic Review 90(4): 980–994
Fehr E., Gächter S. (2000) Fairness and retaliation: The economics of reciprocity. Journal of Economic Perspectives 14(3): 159–181
Fehr E., Gintis H. (2007) Human motivation and social cooperation: Experimental and analytical foundations. Annual Review of Sociology 33: 43–64
Festinger L. (1957) A theory of cognitive dissonance. Stanford University Press, Stanford
Finkel S. E. (2008) In defense of the “wide” rational choice model of collective political action. In: Diekman A., Eichner K., Schmidt P., Voss T. (eds) Rational Choice: Theoretische Analysen und empirische Befunde [Rational Choice. Theoretical Analyses and Empirical Findings]. VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, Wiesbaden, pp 23–36
Frey B. S. (1999) Economics as a science of human behaviour. Towards a new social science paradigm (second extended edition). Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston
Frey B. S., Jegen R. (2001) Motivation crowding theory. Journal of Economic Surveys 15(5): 589–611
Grusec, J. E., Hastings, P. E. (eds) (2007) Handbook of socialization: Theory and research. The Guilford Press, New York
Hamlin A. P. (1991) Rational revenge. Ethics 101(2): 374–381
Hayek F. A. (1973) Law, legislation and liberty. Vol. 1: Rules and order. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Hechter, M., Opp, K.-D. (eds) (2001) Social norms. Russell Sage Foundation, New York
Heckathorn D. (1988) Collective sanctions and the creation of prisoner’s dilemma norms. American Journal of Sociology 94: 535–562
Heckathorn D. D. (1990) Modelling the second-order free-rider problem: Reply to Oliver. Rationality and Society 2(1): 123–127
Hempel C. G. (1952) Fundamentals of concept formation in empirical science. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Henrich, J., Boyd, R., Bowles, S., Camerer, C., Fehr, E., Gintis, H. (eds) (2004) Foundations of human sociality. Economic experiments and ethnographic evidence from fifteen small-scale societies. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Herne K., Setälä M. (2004) A response to the critique of rational choice theory: Lakatos’ and Laudan’s conceptions applied. Inquiry 47(1): 67–85
Hirschman A. O. (1977) The passions and the interests. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
Hirschman A. O. (1984) Against parsimony: Three easy ways of complicating some categories of economic discourse. The American Economic Review (Papers and Proceedings of the Ninety-Sixth Annual Meeting of the American Economic Association) 74(2): 89–96
Horne C. (2009) The rewards of punishment. A relational theory of norm enforcement. Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA
Kagan J. (1987) Introduction. In: Kagan J., Lamb S. (eds) The emergence of morality in young children. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Kagan, J., Lamb, S. (eds) (1987) The emergence of morality in young children. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Kahneman, D., Tversky, A. (eds) (2000) Choices, values and frames. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Kroneberg C., Yaish M., Stocké V. (2010) Norms and rationality in electoral participation and in the rescue of Jews in WWII: An application of the model of frame selection. Rationality & Society 22(1): 3–36
Little D. (1991) Varieties of social explanation. An introduction to the philosophy of social science. Westview Press, Boulder
Lyons B. (1992) Game theory. In: Heap S. H., Hollis M., Lyons B., Sugden R., Weale A. (eds) The theory of choice. A critical guide. Blackwell, Oxford, pp 93–129
Mahoney J. (2000) Path dependence in historical sociology. Theory and Society 29(4): 507–548
March J. G., Olsen J. P. (1989) Rediscovering institutions. The organizational basis of politics. Free Press, New York
March J. G., Olsen J. P. (2006) The logic of appopriateness. In: Moran M., Rein M., Goodin R. E. (eds) The Oxford handbook of public policy. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 689–709
Mehlkop G., Graeff P. (2010) Modelling a rational choice theory of criminal action: Subjective expected utilities, norms, and interaction. Rationality & Society 22(2): 189–222
Monroe K. R. (2004) The hand of compassion. Portraits of moral choice during the Holocaust. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
Monroe K. R., Barton M. C., Klingemann U. (1991) Altruism and the theory of rational action: An analysis of rescuers of Jews in Nazi-Europe. In: Monroe K. R. (ed.) The economic approach to politics. A critical reassessment of the theory of rational action. HarperCollins, New York, pp 317–352
Mühler K. (2005) Sozialisation, Konfliktwahrnehmung und regionale Identifikation. In: Fach W., Luutz W. (eds) Region und Vision: Regionalprogramme im Vergleich. Leipziger Universitätsverlag, Leipzig, pp 193–206
Olsson-Yaouzis N. (2010) Revolutionaries, despots, and rationality. Rationality & Society 22(3): 283–299
Opp K.-D. (1997) Can identity theory better explain the rescue of Jews in Nazi Europe than rational actor theory?. Research in Social Movements, Conflict and Change 20: 223–253
Opp K.-D. (1999) Contending conceptions of the theory of rational action. Journal of Theoretical Politics 11(2): 171–202
Opp K.-D. (2001) Norms. In: Smelser N. J., Baltes P. B. (eds) International encyclopedia of the social and behavioral sciences. Elsevier, Oxford, pp 10714–10720
Osman M. (2004) An evaluation of dual-process theories of reasoning. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 11(6): 988–1010
Ostrom E. (2005) Understanding institutional diversity. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
Riker W. H., Ordeshook P. C. (1968) A theory of the calculus of voting. American Political Science Review 65: 25–42
Riker W. H., Ordeshook P. C. (1973) An introduction to positive political theory. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
Rommetveit R. (1954) Social norms and roles. Universitetsforlaget, Oslo
Simon H. A. (1991) Bounded rationality and organizational learning. Organization Society 2(1): 125–134
Stark R. (2007) Sociology, 10th ed. Thomson, Belmont, CA
Stroebe W. (2008) Warum und wie beeinflussen Normen das Verhalten: Eine sozial-kognitive Analyse. In: Diekman A., Eichner K., Schmidt P., Voss T. (eds) Rational Choice: Theoretische Analysen und empirische Resultate. Festschrift für Karl-Dieter Opp zum 70. Geburtstag. VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, Wiesbaden, pp 101–118
Tyler T. R. (1990) Why people obey the law. Yale University Press, New Haven, CT
Udéhn L. (1996) The limits of public choice. A sociological critique of the economic theory of politics. Routledge, London
Vanberg V. (2002) Rational choice vs. program-based behavior: Alternative theoretical approaches and their relevance for the study of institutions. Rationality & Society 14(1): 7–54
Vanberg V. (2009) Rationalität, Regelbefolgung und Emotionen: Zur Ökonomik moralischer Präferenzen. In: Tscheulin D. K., Schüpbach H. (eds) Verhaltenswissenschaftliche Grundlagen in ökonomischen Systemen. BWV—Berliner Wissenschafts-Verlag, Berlin, pp 46–74
Varese F., Yaish M. (2000) The importance of being asked: The rescue of Jews in Nazi Europe. Rationality and Society 12(3): 307–334
Yee A. S. (1997) Thick rationality and the missing “brute fact”: The limits of rationalist incorporations of norms and ideas: Rejoinder. The Journal of Politics 59(4): 1048–1050
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Opp, KD. Norms and rationality. Is moral behavior a form of rational action?. Theory Decis 74, 383–409 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11238-012-9315-6
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11238-012-9315-6