Abstract.
Our case studies of the evolution of population policies in Kenya and Malawi offer insights into the interaction between the global population movement and national governments. The comparison is useful because it permits identifying the common strategies of a global movement, strategies that are likely to be evident elsewhere; it also permits identifying differences in national responses related to particular domestic contexts. We find a common repertory of movement strategies to influence the governments of Kenya and Malawi to adopt a neo-Malthusian population policy and to implement a family planning program. However, these strategies were promoted more or less aggressively depending on the national response and the chronological period. National responses were related to differences in the governments’ approaches to nation-building, their willingness to accept foreign influence and the importance they placed on preserving cultural traditions, and to their assessment of benefits they would gain from responding favorably to movement proposals. The data come from written accounts and from interviews with international actors and Kenyan and Malawian elites who participated in the policy development process.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
African Medical and Research Foundation (1979). Field work report on Kirinyaga Family Life Training Centre. Nairobi: Health Behaviour and Education Department, African Medical and Research Foundation.
Ajayi, A. & Kekevole, J. (1998). Kenya’s population policy: From apathy to effectiveness, pp. 113-156 in A. Jain (ed.), Do population policies matter? Fertility and politics in Egypt, India, Kenya and Mexico. New York: The Population Council.
Barrett, D.A. (1995). Reproducing persons as a global concern: The making of an institution. Unpublished PhD Dissertation. Stanford University.
D. Barrett A.O. Tsui (1999) ArticleTitlePolicy as symbolic statement: International response to national population policies Social Forces 78 IssueID1 213–234
R.H. Bates (1981) Markets and states in tropical Africa: The political basis of agricultural politics University of California Press Berkeley
R. Chinyama (1986) ArticleTitleChild spacing in Malawi The Malawian Nurse: Journal of the National Association of Nurses of Malawi 2 IssueID1 10
G Chipande (1988) The impact of demographic changes on rural development inMalawi R.D. Lee (Eds) Population, food and rural development Clarendon Press Oxford 163–174
Demographic Unit, (1989). National seminar on population and development in Malawi, 5-9 June 1989. University of Malawi, Chancellor College, Zomba.
Downing, L. (1975). The population policy of Kenya. Unpublished.
Edwards, M. (1970). A short-term study of patient persistance and acceptability of family planning in three rural clinics in Kericho District, 1968-69. Nairobi: IPPF Regional office.
C.N. Ejioju (1972) The Kenya Programme: Policy and results S.H. Ominde C.N. Ejiogu (Eds) Population growth and economic development in Africa Heinemann. London, Nairobi and Ibadan 386–392
Family Planning Association of Kenya (no date). History: Family Planning Association of Kenya. Discussion Paper. Nairobi, Family Planning Association of Kenya.
Fisher, S. (1974). Briefing for Mr. Oscar Harkavay, May 15-20, 1973. Unpublished.
A. Fowler (1995) NGOs and the globalization of social welfare J. Semboja O. Therkildsen (Eds) Service provision under stress in east Africa: The state NGOs & people’s organizations in Kenya Tanzania and Uganda Centre for Development Research Copenhagen 51–69
J.M. Gachuhi P.E. Kiyanjui (1973) Utilization of cultural information for population planning in east Africa Institute of African Studies and the Ford Foundation Nairobi, Kenya
D.R. Gwatkin (1970) Population and the Ford Foundation in Sub-Sahara Africa. Information Paper Ford Foundation New York
Harkavy O. (1973). Visits to Kenya, Cameroon, Nigeria, Ghana, May 15-30, 1973. Unpublished.
O. Harkavy (1995) Curbing population growth: An insider’s perspective on the population movement Plenum Press New York
D.F. Heisel (1968) ArticleTitleAttitudes and practice of contraception in Kenya Demography 5 IssueID1 632–641
Hooker J.R. (1970). Population review 1970: Malawi, American Universities Field Staff. Central &Southern Africa Series XV(1).
E. Kalipeni (1996) ArticleTitleDemographic response to environmental pressure in Malawi Population and Environment: A Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies 17 IssueID4 285–308
N. Luke S.C. Watkins (2002) ArticleTitleReactions of national elites to international population policy: Enthusiasm and realism Population and Development Review 28 IssueID4 707–733
Malawi Government (1966). Hansard, 4th Session 1966-67. Zomba: Government Printer.
Malawi Government (1986). The National Health Plan of Malawi.Malawi: Ministry of Health.
Malawi Government (1987). Statement of development policies: 1987-1996. Zomba, Malawi: Government Printer, for the Department of Economic Planning and Development.
InstitutionalAuthorNameMalawi Government (1994a) The Malawi National Family Planning Strategy 1994-1998 National Family Welfare Council of Malawi Lilongwe
Malawi Government (1994b). Population and development in Malawi: Country position paper for the International Conference on Population and Development (ICPD), 5-13 September, Cairo, Egypt. Lilongwe, Malawi: ICPD National Committee.
Mhone, G. (1992). The political economy of Malawi: An overview, pp. 1-33 in Malawi at the crossroads: The post-colonial political economy. Harare: Sapes Books.
Ministry of Health of Malawi (1979). Moyo Magazine, January 1979.
InstitutionalAuthorNameMinistry of Health of Malawi (1981) Fertility and family size preferences and child spacing. Ministry of Health Lilongwe
Ministry of Health of Malawi (1984). Report of the inter-ministerial/sectoral orientation seminar on child spacing, Salima 11-13 December 1984. Unpublished.
InstitutionalAuthorNameMinistry of Health of Malawi (1992) Child spacing programme 1992-1996 Ministry of Health Lilongwe
J.R.N. Mlia E. Kalipeni (1987) ArticleTitlePopulation growth and national development in Malawi Malaysian Journal of Tropical Geography 15 39–48
Molnos, A. (1968). Attitudes toward family planning in East Africa: An investigation in schools around Lake Victoria and in Nairobi, with introductory chapters on the position of women and the population problem in East Africa. Munich: Weltforum Verlag for Ifo-Institute of Economic Research, African Studies Center.
Morton, K. (1975). Aid and dependency: British aid to Malawi. Discussion Paper. Croom Helm and Overseas Development Institute.
Mudoga, F.M. (1972). Kenya: Training a family planning communicator. Unpublished.
W. Mulwafu A. Muula (2001) The first medical school in Malawi Sunrise Publications Lilongwe
National Family Welfare Council of Malawi (1994). The Malawi national family planning strategy 1994-1998. Lilongwe: Government Printer.
K. Ndeti C. Ndeti K. Horsely (1980) Cultural values and population policy in Kenya Nairobi Kenya Literature Bureau
A. Krystall J. Berger A. Maleche (1973) Report on evaluation of family planning training of community development, social workers and others working with families FAO Programmes for Better Family Living Nairobi
Radel, D.J. (1973). Elite perceptions of population problems and potential solutions: Research to guide an elite oriented population education program in Kenya. Discussion Paper. University of Minnesota.
InstitutionalAuthorNameRepublic of Kenya (1984) Population policy guidelines. Sessional Paper No. 4 of 1984 National Committee on Family Planning and Development. Nairobi
Rockefeller Family Archives (1965). RG5 John D. Rockefeller 3rd Papers, Series 3 (Office and Home Files), Box 68, Folder 455, “Population Interests - Kenya”.
D. Rothschild (1969) ArticleTitleEthnic inequalities in Kenya Journal of Modern African Studies 7 IssueID4 689–711
Saunders, L. (1965). Kenya: Log notes and reports of Population Council Mission to Kenya. Unpublished.
Sutton, F.X. (1996). A history of the Ford Foundation’s international activities. Unpublished.
United Nations (1989). World population policies. Population Studies No. 11. New York: Department of International Economic and Social Affairs.
S.C. Watkins (2000) ArticleTitleLocal and foreign models of reproduction in Nyanza Province, Kenya, 1930-1998 Population and Development Review 26 IssueID4 725–759
Watkins, S.C. &Hodgson, D. (1998). From mercantilists to Neo-Malthusians: The international population movement and the transformation of population ideology in Kenya. Paper presented at the Workshop on Social Processes Underlying Fertility Change in Developing Countries, 29–30 January 1998, National Academy of Sciences.
A. Weinreb (2001) ArticleTitleFirst politics, then culture: Accounting for ethnic differences in demographic behavior Population and Development Review 27 IssueID3 437–467
J.A. Widner (1992) The rise of a party-state in Kenya: From “Harambee!” to “Nyayo!” University of California Press Berkeley
Wilks, Y. (1970). Family planning or tribal planning, Cambridge Review 8: 10.
World Bank (1986). Population sector review. Washington, D.C.: Population Health and Nutrition Department, The World Bank.
World Bank (1992). Population and the World Bank: Implications from eight case studies. Washington, D.C.: Operations Evaluation Department, The World Bank.
InstitutionalAuthorNameWorld Health Organization (1978) Country profile (health): Republic of Malawi. World Health Organization Lilongwe
Zulu, E.M. (1996). Social and cultural factors affecting reproductive behavior in Malawi. Unpublished PhD Dissertation. University of Pennsylvania, Graduate Group in Demography.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Chimbwete, C., Watkins, S.C. & Zulu, E.M. The evolution of population policies in Kenya and Malawi. Popul Res Policy Rev 24, 85–106 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11113-005-0328-5
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11113-005-0328-5