Abstract
The well-known game of chess has traditionally been modeled in artificial intelligence studies by search engines with advanced pruning techniques. The models were thus centered on an inference engine manipulating passive symbols in the form of tokens. It is beyond doubt, however, that human players do not carry out such processes. Instead, chess masters instead carry out perceptual processes, carefully categorizing the chunks perceived in a position and gradually building complex dynamic structures to represent the subtle pressures embedded in the positions. In this paper we will consider two hypotheses concerning the underlying subcognitive processes and architecture. In the first hypothesis, a multiple-leveled chess representational structure is presented, which includes distance graphs (with varying levels of quality) between pieces, piece mobilities, and abstract roles. These representational schemes seem to account for numerous characteristics of human player’s psychology. The second hypothesis concerns the extension of the architecture proposed in the Copycat project as central for modeling the emergent intuitive perception of a chess position. We provide a synthesis on how the postulated architecture models chess intuition as an emergent mixture of simultaneous distance estimations, chunk perceptions, abstract role awareness, and intention activations. This is an alternative model to the traditional AI approaches, focusing on the philosophy of active symbols.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
G. Atkinson (1993) Chess and Machine Intuition Ablex Publishing Norwood, NJ
A. Binet (1894) Psychologie des grands calculateurs et joueurs d’echécs Hachette Paris
M.M. Bongard (1970) Pattern Recognition Spartan Books New York
Bolland, S. (2003), A Copycat Java Implementation, available online at http://www2.psy. uq.edu.au/CogPsych/Copycat/, University of Queensland, Australia, April 2003
J. Cagan K. Kotovsky (1997) ArticleTitleSimulated Annealing and the Generation of the Objective Function: A Model of Learning during Problem Solving Computational Intelligence 13 534–581 Occurrence Handle10.1111/0824-7935.00051 Occurrence HandleMR1492294
M. Campbell A. Joseph Hoane SuffixJr. F.-H. Hsu (2002) ArticleTitleDeep Blue Artificial Intelligence 134 57–83 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0004-3702(01)00129-1
W.G. Chase H.A. Simon (1973a) ArticleTitlePerception in Chess Cognitive Psychology 4 55–81 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0010-0285(73)90004-2
W.G. Chase H.A. Simon (1973b) The Mind’s Eye in Chess W.G. Chase (Eds) Visual Information Processing Academic Press New York
N. Charness (1981) ArticleTitleSearch in Chess: Age and Skill Differences Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance 7 467–476 Occurrence Handle10.1037//0096-1523.7.2.467
N. Charness E.M. Reingold M. Pomplun D.M. Stampe (2001) ArticleTitleThe Perceptual Aspect of Skilled Performance in Chess: Evidence from Eye Movements Memory & Cognition 29 1146–1152
M.T.H. Chi (1978) Knowledge Structure and Memory Development R. Siegler (Eds) Children’s Thinking: What Develops? Erlbaum Hillsdale, NJ 73–96
R.M. Church K.W. Church (1983) Plans, Goals, and Search Strategies for the Selection of a Move in Chess P.W. Frey (Eds) Chess Skill in Man and Machine EditionNumber2nd Springer-Verlag New York 131–156
A.D. Groot Particlede (1965) Thought and Choice in Chess Mouton New York
A.D. Groot Particlede (1986) ArticleTitleIntuition in Chess International Computer Chess Association Journal 9 67–75
A.D. Groot Particlede F. Gobet (1996) Perception and Memory in Chess: Studies in the Heuristics of the Professional Eye Assen Van Gorcum
L. Finkelstein S. Markovitch (1998) ArticleTitleLearning to Play Chess Selectively by Acquiring Move Patterns International Computer Chess Association Journal 21 100–119
French, R.M. (1992), Tabletop: An emergent stochastic computer model of analogy making. PhD Thesis, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan
R.M. French (1995) The Subtlety of Sameness MIT Press Cambridge
R.M. French (1999) ArticleTitleInteractively Converging on Context-sensitive Representations: A Solution to the Frame Problem Revue Internationale de Philosophie 3 365–385
Gobet, F. (1993), A computer model of chess memory, XV annual conference of the cognitive science society
F. Gobet (1997) ArticleTitleA Pattern-recognition Theory of Search in Expert Problem Solving Thinking and Reasoning 3 291–313 Occurrence Handle10.1080/135467897394301
F. Gobet (1998) ArticleTitleExpert Memory: A Comparison of Four Theories Cognition 66 115–152 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0010-0277(98)00020-1 Occurrence Handle9677761
F. Gobet S. Jackson (2002) ArticleTitleIn Search of Templates Cognitive Systems Research 3 35–44 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S1389-0417(01)00042-0
F. Gobet P.C.R. Lane S. Croker P.C-H. Cheng G. Jones I. Oliver J.M. Pine (2001) ArticleTitleChunking Mechanisms in Human Learning Trends in Cognitive Sciences 5 236–243 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S1364-6613(00)01662-4 Occurrence Handle11390294
F. Gobet H.A. Simon (1996) ArticleTitleRecall of Rapidly Presented Random Chess Positions is a Function of Skill Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 3 159–163
F. Gobet H.A. Simon (1996) ArticleTitleTemplates in Chess Memory: A Mechanism for Recalling Several Boards Cognitive Psychology 31 1–40 Occurrence Handle10.1006/cogp.1996.0011 Occurrence Handle8812020
F. Gobet H.A. Simon (1996) ArticleTitleRecall of Random and Distorted Chess Positions: Implications for the Theory of Expertise Memory and Cognition 24 493–503
F. Gobet H.A. Simon (1998) ArticleTitleExpert Chess Memory: Revisiting the Chunking Hypothesis Memory 6 225–255 Occurrence Handle9709441
F. Gobet H.A. Simon (2000) ArticleTitleFive Seconds or Sixty? Presentation Time in Expert Memory Cognitive Science 24 651–582 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0364-0213(00)00031-8
D.R. Hofstadter (1979) Gödel, Escher, Bach: an Eternal Golden Braid Basic Books New York
D.R. Hofstadter (1985) Metamagical Themas Basic Books New York
D. Hofstadter InstitutionalAuthorName and FARG (1995) Fluid Concepts and Creative Analogies: Computer Models of the Fundamental Mechanisms of Thought Basic Books New York
Kurzweil, R. (2002) Deep Fritz Draws: Are Humans Getting Smarter, or Are Computers Getting Stupider? Published online at www.KurzweilAI.net, October 19, 2002
A. Linhares J.R.A. Torreão (1998) ArticleTitleMicrocanonical Optimization Applied to the Traveling Salesman Problem International Journal of Modern Physics C9 133–146 Occurrence Handle10.1142/S012918319800011X
A. Linhares H.H. Yanasse J.R.A. Torreão (1999) ArticleTitleLinear Gate Assignment: A Fast Statistical Mechanics Approach IEEE Transactions on Computer Aided Design of Integrated Circuits and Systems 18 1750–1758 Occurrence Handle10.1109/43.811324
A. Linhares (2000) ArticleTitleA Glimpse at the Metaphysics of Bongard Problems Artificial Intelligence 121 251–270 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0004-3702(00)00042-4 Occurrence HandleMR1783519
Linhares, A. (2002), ‘Data Mining, Bongard Problems, and the Concept of Pattern Conception’, in A. Zanazi, C.A. Brebbia, N.F.F. Ebecken and P. Melli, eds., Data Mining III, pp. 603–611
Linhares, A., (2003), ‘Impulsive models of intelligence’, Unpublished manuscript
G. Lories (1984) ArticleTitleLa mémoire de joueurs d’echécs: revue critique L’Année Psychologique 84 95–122
G. Lories (1987) ArticleTitleRecall of Random and Non-random Chess Positions in Strong and Weak Chess Players Psychologica Belgica 27 153–159
G. McGraw (1995) Letter Spirit (Part one): Emergent High-level Perception of Letters using Fluid Concepts Indiana University Bloomington
Margolis, E. and Laurence, S. (eds) (1999), Concepts: Core Readings, MIT Press
J. Marshall (1999) Metacat: A Self-watching Cognitive Architecture for Analogy-making and High Level Perception Indiana University Bloomington
G.A. Miller (1956) ArticleTitleThe Magical Number Seven, Plus or Minus Two: Some Limits on our Capacity for Processing Information Psychological Review 63 71–97
Minsky, M. (1986), The Society of Mind, Simon & Schuster
M. Mitchell (1993) Analogy-making as Perception MIT Press Cambridge
Mitchell, M. (2003), (available online) letter string analogy problems available online from http://www.cse.ogi.edu/∼ mm/analogy-problems.html, March 2003
M. Mitchell D.R. Hofstadter (1990) ArticleTitleThe Emergence of Understanding in a Computer Model of Concepts and Analogy-making Physica D 42 322–334
A. Möbius A. Neklioudov A. Díaz-Sanchez K.H. Hoffmann A. Fachat M. Schreiber (1997) ArticleTitleOptimization by Thermal Cycling Physical Review Letters 79 4297–4301 Occurrence Handle10.1103/PhysRevLett.79.4297
E. Morales (1994) ArticleTitleLearning Patterns for Playing Strategies International Computer Chess Association Journal 17 15–26
E. Morales (1996) ArticleTitleLearning Playing Strategies in Chess Computational Intelligence 12 65–87
A. Newell (1980) ArticleTitlePhysical Symbol Systems Cognitive Science 4 135–183 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0364-0213(80)80015-2
Rehling, J.A. (2001), Letter Spirit (Part two): Modeling Creativity in a Visual Domain. PhD Thesis, Indiana University, Bloomington
E.M. Reingold N. Charness R.S. Schultetus D.M. Stampe (2001a) ArticleTitlePerceptual Automaticity in Expert Chess Players: Parallel Enconding of Chess Relations Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 8 504–510
E.M. Reingold N. Charness M. Pomplun D.M. Stampe (2001b) ArticleTitleVisual Span in Expert Chess Players: Evidence from Eye Movements Psychological Science 12 48–55 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-9280.00309
P. Saariluoma (1992) ArticleTitleError in Chess: Apperception Restructuring View Psychological Research 54 17–26 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF01359219 Occurrence Handle1603886
P. Saariluoma (1995) Chess Players’ Thinking Routledge London
P. Saariluoma M. Hohlfeld (1994) ArticleTitleApperception in Chess Players Long-range Planning European Journal of Cognitive Psychology 6 1–22
P. Saariluoma (2001) ArticleTitleChess and Content-oriented Psychology of Thinking Psicológica 22 143–164
C.E. Shannon (1950a) ArticleTitleA Chess-playing Machine Scientific American 182 48–51
C.E. Shannon (1950b) ArticleTitleProgramming a Computer for Playing Chess Philosophical Magazine 41 256–275
H. Simon (1980) ArticleTitleCognitive Science: The Newest Science of the Artificial Cognitive Science 4 33–46 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0364-0213(81)80003-1
Simon, H.A. (1995), ‘Explaining the Ineffable: AI on the Topics of Intuition, Insight, and Inspiration’, Paper presented at the proceedings of the fourteenth international joint conference in artificial intelligence
H.A. Simon W.G. Chase (1973) ArticleTitleSkill in Chess American Scientist 61 394–403
H.A. Simon A. Newell (1958) ArticleTitleHeuristic Problem Solving: The Next Advance in Operations Research Operations Research 6 1–10
Simon, H. and Schaeffer, J. (1992), ‘The Game of Chess’, in R. Aumann and S. Hart, eds., Handbook of Game Theory with Economic Applications, North Holland
Turing, A.M. (1953), ‘Chess. Digital Computers Applied to Games’, Bowden, ed., Faster than Thought, pp. 286–310
D. Wilkins (1980) ArticleTitleUsing Patterns and Plans in Chess Artificial Intelligence 14 165–203 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0004-3702(80)90039-9
F.-G. Winkler J. Fürnkranz (1997) On Effort in AI Research: A Description Along Two Dimensions R. Morris (Eds) Deep Blue Versus Kasparov: The Significance for Artificial Intelligence: Papers from the 1997 AAAI Workshop AAAI Press Providence 56–62
F.-G. Winkler J. Fürnkranz (1998) ArticleTitleA Hypothesis on the Divergence of AI Research International Computer Chess Association Journal 21 3–13
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Linhares, A. An Active Symbols Theory of Chess Intuition. Mind Mach 15, 131–181 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11023-005-5045-7
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11023-005-5045-7