Abstract
This paper revisits the historical aspects of the contributions made into the elastic stability theory from the structural engineering point of view.Extensive quotations are brought in order to substantiate the claims made. It is hoped that the review constitutes a contribution to the identification of the main ideas pertinent to engineering mechanics.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
D. Acheson (1997) From Calculus to Chaos: An Introduction to Dynamics Oxford University Press Oxford
W. Addis (1983) ArticleTitle‘A new approach to the history of structural engineering’ Hist.Techn 8 1–13
Agnon Sh.Y.The Crooked Shall Be Made Straight 1912 (in Hebrew).
J. Arbocz (1981) ArticleTitle‘Past, present and future of shell stability analysis’ Zeitschrift für Flugwissenschaften und Weltraumforschung 5 335–348
Ari-Gur J. Personal communication March 251999.
I. Asimov (1964) Asimov’s Biographical Encyclopedia of Science and Technology Doubleday &Company Garden City New York 23
D. Aubin A.D. Dalmedico (2002) ArticleTitle‘Writing the history of dynamical systems and chaos: Longue Durée and revolutiondisciplines and cultures’ Hist.Math 29 273–339
Augusti G.(1974).‘Probabilistic treatment of column buckling problems’in: Stochastic Problems in Mechanics University of Waterloo Presspp.256 –274.
C.D. Babcock (1983) ArticleTitle‘Shell stability’ J.Appl.Mech. 50 935–940
I. Babuška OdenJ.T. (2001) ‘Computational mechanics: where is it going’ B. Engquist W. Schmid (Eds) Mathematics Unlimited – 2001 and Beyond Springer-Verlag Berlin
G. Baker F.A. McRobie J.M.T. Thompson (1997) ArticleTitle‘Implications of chaos theory for engineering science’ Proc.Instrum.Mech.Eng 211 349–363
Z.P. Bažant L. Cedolin (1991) Stability of Structures Oxford University Press Oxford I.
A. Becchi M. Corradi O.() Pedemonte (Eds) (2003) Essays on the History of Mechanics Birkhäuser Basel
P. Beckmann (1971) A History of π St. Martin Press New York 147
E.T. Bell (1965) Men of Mathematics Simon and Schuster New York 406
R. Bellman (1953) Stability Theory of Differential Equations McGraw-Hill New York VIII
Benvenuto E.La Scienza delle costruzioni e il suo sviluppo storico SansoniFirenze1981 (in Italian)
E. Benvenuto (1991a) An Introduction to the History of Structural Mechanics Part I: Statics and Resistance of Solids Springer-Verlag New York
E. Benvenuto (1991) An Introduction to the History of Structural Mechanics Part II: Vaulted Structures and Elastic Systems Springer-Verlag New York
A. Berry (1993) The Book of Scientific Anecdotes Prometheus Books NY Buffalo 69–70
V.V. Bolotin (1964) Non-Conservative Problems in the Theory of Elastic Stability Pergamon Press New York
V.V. Bolotin (1965) aspects in the theory of structural stability’ G. Herrmann (Eds) Dynamic Stability of Structures Pergamon Press New York 67–81
P. Bourdieu (1991) ArticleTitlepeculiar history of scientific reason’ Sociological Forum 6 IssueID(1 3–26
A. Boutot (1993) ArticleTitle‘Catastrophe theory and its critics’ Synthese 96 167–200
J.A. Broek Particlevan den (1947) ArticleTitle‘Euler’s classic paper “On the Strength of Columns”,’ J.Phy 15 309–318
B. Budiansky (1974) ArticleTitle‘Theory of buckling and post-buckling behavior of elastic structures’ Adv.Appl.Mech. 14 1–65
Budiansky B. and Hutchinson J.W. ‘Buckling: progress and challenge’ in: Besseling J.F.and van der Heijden A.M.A.(eds.) Trends in Solid Mechanics Sijthoff & Noordhoff International Publishers Alphen van den Rijn1979 pp.93 –116.
P.S. Bulson (1970) The Stability of Flat Plates Chatto and Windus London
A. Calaprice (Eds) (2002) Dear Professor Einstein Prometheus Books New York 174
C.A. Calladine (1972) ArticleTitle‘Structural consequences of small imperfections in elastic thin shells of revolution’ Int.J.Solids Struct 8 679–697
C.R. Calladine (1995) ArticleTitle‘Understanding imperfection-sensitivity in the buckling of thin-walled shells’ Thin-Walled Struct 23 215–235
G. Capriz (2000) ArticleTitle‘Obituary Clifford Ambrose Truesdell’ Meccanica 35 463–465
N.L. Cardozo (2000) Judaism on Trial Urim Publications Jerusalem 192
R. Carlson (1995) Don’t Sweat the Small Stuff Hyperion New York
E.H. Carr (1987) What is History? Penguin New York
J. Casti DePauliW. (2000) Gödel Perseus Publishing Cambridge, MA
A. Chajes (1974) Principles of Structural Stability Theory Prentice Hall Englewood Cliffs, NJ
A.H. Chilver (1976) ‘Design philosophy in structural stability’ B. Budiansky (Eds) Buckling of Structures. Springer-Verlag Berlin 331–345
M Como A. Grimaldi (1975) ArticleTitle‘Stabilitybuckling and post-buckling of elastic structures’ Meccanica 4 254–268
M. Como A. Grimaldi (1995) Theory of Stability of Continuous Elastic Structures CRC Press Boca Raton
A. Corsanego (1999) ArticleTitle‘Obituary: Edoardo Benvenuto (1940 –1998)’ Meccanica 34 295–296
Davis P.Debunking or telling it as it was? In: SIAM News September 2003p.6.
De Borst R.‘Het instabiele hanteerbar W.T. Koiter’in: Wakker K.F. et al (eds.) Delfts Goud Technische Universiteit Delft/Beta Imaginations2002 pp.223 –232(in Dutch).
DinnikA.N.‘Buckling under own weight’ Proc.Don Polytech.Inst. 1 (Part 2)(1912) 19 (in Russian).
DisraeliB.Contarini Fleming Pt.IChapter 23 (see also Cohen J.M.and Cohen M.J.The Penguin Dictionary of Quotations Penguin BooksLondon1980)p.140.
L.H. Donnell (1934) ArticleTitle‘A new theoretic buckling of thin cylinders under axial compression’ ASME Trans 56 795–806
L.H. Donnell C.C. Wan (1950) ArticleTitle‘Effect of imperfections on buckling of thin cylinders and columns under axial compression’ J.Appl.Mech. 17 73–83
DunhamW.Euler: The Master of Us All The Mathematical Association of America1999.
Editorial (1983) ArticleTitle‘Leonhard Euler’ Math Intell. 5 IssueID3 5–6
A. Einstein (1933) On the Method of Theoretical Physics Oxford University Press Oxford
A. Einstein (1936) ArticleTitle‘Physics and reality’ J.Franklin Inst 221 349–356
I. Elishakoff (2000) ArticleTitle‘Elastic stability: from Euler to Koiter there was none like Koiter’ Meccanica 35 375–380
M.S. El Naschie (1990) StressStability and Chaos McGraw-Hill London 312–410
EngelhardtH.‘Die einheitliche Behandlung der Stabknickung mit Berücksichtigung des Stabeigewichte in den Eulerfällen 1 bis 4 als Eigenwertproblem’ Dar Stahlbau 23 (4) (1954) 80 –84 (in German).
S.B. Engelsman (1990) ArticleTitle‘What You Should Know About Euler’s Opera Omnia’ Nieuw Archief voor Wiskunde 4th ser 8 IssueID1 67–79
EulerL.Methodus Inveniendi Lineas Curvas Maximi Minimive Proprietate Gaudentes (AppendixDe Curvis Elasticis)Marcum Michaelaem BousquetLausanne1744.
EulerL.‘Determinatio OnerumQuae Columnae Gestare Valent’ Acta Academiae Scientiarum Petropolitanae 1 121 –147 (see also Leonhardi Euleri Opera Omnia 17 (Part 2)(1778a) Bern1982pp.232 –251) (in Latin).
EulerL.‘Examen Insignio Paradoxi in Theoria Columnarum Occurentio’ Acta Academiae Scientiarum Petropolitanae 1 142 –162 (see also Leonhardi Euleri Opera Omnia 17 (Part 2)(1778b) Bern1982pp.252 –265) (in Latin).
EulerL.‘De altitudine columnarum sub proprio pondere corruentium’ Acta Academiae Scientiarum Petropolitanae 1(1778c) 163 –193 (see also Leonhard Euler: Opera Omnia 17Part 2Bern1982pp.266 –293) (in Latin).
EulerL.Letters of Euler on Different Subjects of Natural Philosophy Arno Press1975P.26.
C. Fadiman (Eds) (1985) Anecdotes LittleBrown and Co. Boston 26
FeodosievV.I.Ten Lectures-Conservations On Strength of Materials “Nauka” Publishers, Moscow 1969p.106 (in Russian).
P. Feyerabend (1970) ArticleTitle‘Experts in a free society’ Critic 30 58–69
FeyerabendP.Against Method 3rd ed.Verso1993.
P. Feyerabend (1995) Killing Time – The Autobiography of Paul Feyerabend The University of Chicago Press Chicago
D.H. Fischer (1970) Historian’s Fallacies: Toward a Logic of Historical Thought Harper Torchbooks New York
Foce F.“Bit by BitLacuna by Lacuna” in the name of Edoardo Benvenuto”in: BecchiA.CorradiM.FoceF.and PedemonteO.(eds.) Towards a History of Construction BirkhäuserBasel2002pp.551 –565.
R. Fosdick G. Royer-Carfagni (2002) ArticleTitle‘In recognition of the 70th birthday of Piero Villaggio’ J.Elasticity 68 3–6
F. Fukuyama (1989) ArticleTitle‘The end of history?’ Nat.Interest 16 3–18
FukuyamaF.‘The end of history? Wellcertainly the end of humans’ The Independent June 161999p.4.
Y.C. Fung E.E. Sechler (1965) ‘Instability of thin elastic shells’ J.N. Goodier N.J. Hoff (Eds) Structural Mechanics. Pergamon Press New York
GalileiG.Discorsi e Demostrazioni Matematicheintorno à due nuove scienze Attenenti all Mecanica & Movimenti Locali ElsevierLeyden1638 (English translation: Dialogues Concerning Two New Sciences Northwestern University Press1914; McGraw-HillNew York1963; Two New Sciences The University of Wisconsin Press1974).
L.A. Godoy (1996) Thin Walled Structures with Structural Imperfections Pergamon Press New York
Godoy L.A.(2000).Theory of Elastic Stability Taylor and Francis.Philadelphia PA
GodoyL.A.‘On the path of progress in the theory of elastic stability’ Mechanics Sept./Oct.(2002) XIII –XIV.
A.G. Greenhill (1881) ArticleTitle‘Determination of the greatest height consistent with stability that a vertical pole or mast can be made and of the greatest height to which a tree of given proportions can grow’ Proc.Camb.Philos.Soc. 4 765–774
GrigoliukE.I.‘S.P.Timoshenko and his works in the field of stability of deformed bodies’in: GrigoliukE.I.(ed.)TimoshenkoS.P.Stability of ColumnsPlates and Shells NaukaMoscow1971 (in Russian)pp.732 –800.
J. Guckenheimer (1978) ArticleTitle‘The catastrophe controversy’ Math.Intell. 1 15–20
S.B. Hamilton (1944) ArticleTitle‘Why engineers should study history’ Trans.– Newcomer Soc.Study Hist.Eng.and Tech. 25 1–10
HayesB.‘The end of science writing?’ Amer.Sci. September –October 1996.
J. Heyman (1998) Structural Analysis: A Historical Approach Cambridge University Press Cambridge
J. Heyman (2003) and the history of structures’ BecchiA. M. Corradi F. Foce O. Pedemonte (Eds) Essays on the History of Mechanics. Birkhäuser Basel 9–19
N.J. Hoff (1954) ArticleTitle‘Buckling and stability’ J.R.Aeronautical Soc. 58 3–52
N.J. Hoff (1966) ArticleTitle‘The perplexing behavior of thin circular cylindrical shells in axial compression’ Isr.J.Tech 4 IssueID(1 1–28
Hoff N.J.(1967).‘Thin shells in aerospace structures’ Aeronautics and Astronautics Feb.pp.26 –45.
J. Horgan (1996) The End of Science : Facing the Limits of Knowledge in the Twilight of the Scientific Age Addison-Wesley Publishing Company Reading MA
W.H. Horton S.C. Durham (1965) ArticleTitle‘Imperfections, main contributor to scatter in experimental values of buckling load’ Int.J.Solids and Struct. 1 59–72
HutchinsonJ.W.‘Life as a mechanician: 1956 ASME Appl.Mech.Newslet. October 2003.
K. Ikeda K Murota (2002) Imperfect Bifurcation in Structures and Materials Springer-Verlag Berlin 8
W. Johnson (1997) ArticleTitle‘The students of the “systematic deviations from ordinary rectilineal construction” in the Athenian Parthenon’ Int.J.Mech.l Sci. 39 IssueID(8 957–963
B.G. Johnson (1983) ArticleTitle‘Column buckling theory: Historic highlights’ J.Struct.Eng. 109 IssueID(9 2086–2096
KoiterW.T.‘Purpose and achievements of research in elastic stability’Proc.4th Techn.Conf.Soc.Eng.Sci.North Carolina State UniversityRaleigh NC1966 (London1968)pp.197 –218.
W.T. Koiterm (1976) ‘Current trends in the theory of buckling’ B. Budiansky (Eds) Buckling of Structures. Springer-Verlag Berlin 1–16
W.T. Koiter (1982) ‘The application of the initial post-buckling analysis of shells’ E. Ramm (Eds) Buckling of Shells. Springer-Verlag Berlin 3–17
T.S. Kuhn (1970) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions EditionNumber2 The University of Chicago Press Chicago
K-E. Kurrer (2003) ‘The development of the deformation method’.In: Becchi A M. Corradi F. Foce O. Pedemonte (Eds) Essays on the History of Mechanics. Birkhäuser Basel 57–86
H.S. Kushner (1996) How Good Do We Have to Be? LittleBrown & Co. Boston 180
R. Latham (1997) The Liberal Moment Columbia University Press New York
N. Leibowitz (1972) New Studies in Genesis Eliner Library Hemed Press Jerusalem 108
H.I. Leiman (1978) Koheleth: Life and Its Meaning Feldheim Publishers Jerusalem
(). Lieber M. (Eds) (1996) Pirkei Avot (Ethics of the Fathers) Mesorah Publications New York
J. Lighthill (1986) ArticleTitle‘The recently recognized failure of predictability in newtonian mechanics’ Proc.R.Soc.Lond. Ser.A 407 35–50
LorenzR.‘Achsensymmetrische Verzerrungen in dünnwandigen Hohlzylindern’ Zeitschrift VDI 52 (1908) 1706 –1713 (in German).
LundquistE.E.‘Strength tests on thin-walled duraluminum cylinders in compression’ NACA Report 473 1933.
MacleodI.‘Sayings of the week’ Observer 16 July 1961 (see also Cohen J.M.and M.J.Cohen The Penguin Dictionary of Modern Quotations Penguin BooksLondon1981p.217).
G. Maier (1999) ArticleTitle‘Book review Mathematical Models for Elastic Structures by P.Villaggio’ Meccanica 34 IssueID1 64–65
R.J. Mainstone (1977) ArticleTitle‘The uses of history’ Arch.Sci.Rev. 20 IssueID2 30–35
E. Maor (1994) e: The Story of Mathematics Princeton University Press Princeton NJ 153
McDonaldD.G.‘The Nobel Laureate versus the graduate student’ Phys.Today July (2001)p.46.
W. Mieder (1986) Encyclopedia of World Proverbs Prentice HallEnglewood Cliffs NJ 434
G.K. Mikhailov (2003) ‘Development of studies in the history of elasticity and structural mechanics’ A. Becchi A. Corradi F. Foce O. Pedemonte (Eds) Essays on the History of Mechanics. Birhäuser Basel 21–37
Moore M.(2003).‘South African author wins literature Nobel’ Fort Lauderdale’s Sun-Sentinel Oct.
N. Morris (1996) ArticleTitle‘Shell stability: the long road from theory to practice’ Eng.Struct 18 IssueID(10 801–806
MusschenbroekP.van Physicae experimentales et geometricae Dissertationes Leyden1729.
NavonH.‘Tower of Babel and the Trojans’ Makor Rishon (First Source) Oct.32003 (in Hebrew).
P.L. Nervi (1956) Structures F.W.Dodge Corporation New York
J. Neusner N.M.M. Neusner (1996) The Book of Jewish Wisdom Introduction Continuum New York 13
R.B. Nye (1975) ForewardIn History: Meaning and Method by Gawronski D.V.Scott Toresman & Co. GlenviewIllinois
Obituary and Merton R. ‘The Economist March’ 15 2003.
W.A. Oldfather C.A. Ellis D.M. Brown (1933) (translators)Leonhard Euler’s elastic curves’. Isis 20 58
J.P.M. Pannell (1964) An Illustrated History of Civil Engineers Frederick Ungar Publishing Co. New York 323
PanovkoYa.G. I. Gubanova (1965) Stability and Oscillations of Elastic Systems: ParadoxesFallacies and New Concepts Consultants Bureau New York
PignataroM.‘ObituaryW.T.Koiter (1914 –1997)’ Meccanica 33 (1998)605 –606.
Pugsley A.(1969).‘The engineering climatology of structural accidents’.International Conference on Structural Safety and Reliability Washington 335 –340.
RammE.‘Form und Tragverhalten’in: Ramm E. and Schunck E.(eds.) Heinz Isler Schalen Karl Krämer VerlagStuttgart1986 (in German)pp.29 –34.
RammE.and WallW.A.‘Shells in advanced computational environment’in: MangH.A.RamerstorferF.G.and EberhardsteinerJ.(eds) Fifth World Congress on Computational Mechanics July 7–12, 2000, Vienna.
M. Rees (2003) Final Hour A Scientist’s Warning: How TerrorError and Environmental Disasters Threaten Humankind’s Future in This Century – On Earth and Beyond. Basic Books New York
G. Rega (2000) ArticleTitle‘Editor’s Note’ Meccanica 35 373
G. Rega (2001) ArticleTitleNote’ Meccanica 36 588
RiksE.‘Development of an improved analysis capability of the STAGS computer code with respect to the collapse behavior of shell structures’ Memorandum SC-79-054 National Aerospace Laboratory NLRThe Netherlands1979.
Rosenberg S.‘The marketplace of ideas’Course “In the Footsteps of Kuzari”available from yhe@virtual.co.il (downloaded on March 10 1999).
L. Rosten (1977) Treasury of Jewish Quotations Bantam Books New York 482
T. Rothman G. Sudarshan (1998) Doubt and Certainty Perseus Books Cambridge,MA
RubinsteinR.E.Aristotle’s Children Harcourt Inc.Orlando2003.
RustaveliS.The Knight in the Panther’s Skin (translated by V.Urushadze)“Sabchota Sakartvels” Publishing HouseTbilisiGeorgia1971p.16.
N. Scherman (1986) The Complete Makhzor for Yom Kippur Mesorah Publications Brooklyn New York 643
SechlerE.E.‘On the role of experimentation in shell research (Mirabile Dictu-Mirabile Visa)’in: Nemat-NasserS.(ed.) Mechanics Today Vol.3PergamonOxford1980pp.439 –450).
W.L. Shirer (1990) The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich Simon and Schuster Inc. New York XI.
SingerJ.ArboczJ.and WellerT.Buckling Experiments Vol.1WileyNew York1998.
R.V. Southwell (1914) ArticleTitlethe general theory of elastic stability’ Phil.Trans.R.Soc.Lond. Ser.A 213 187–244
Speiser D.(2002).‘Architecturemathematics and theology in Raphael’s Lo Sposalizio and L’Incoronazione della Vergine’.In: Becchi A., Corradi M., Foce F., Pedemonte O.(eds).Towards a History of Construction 747 –756.
D. Speiser (2003) ‘What can the historian of science learn from the historian of the fine arts?’ A. Becchi M. Corradi F. Foce O. Pedemonte (Eds) Essays on the History of Mechanics. Birkhäuser Basel 235–249
D. Speiser (2003) ArticleTitleimportance of concepts for science’ Meccanica 38 483–492
SteeleC.R.‘Asymptotic analysis and computation of shells’in: NoorA.K.BelytschkoT.and SimoJ.C.(eds.) Analytical and Computational Models of Shells ASME CED – Vol.31989.
J.M.T. Thompson G.W. Hunt (1973) A General Theory of Elastic Stability John Wiley London
TimoshenkoS.‘Einige Stabilitätsprobleme der Elastizitätstheorie’ Zeitschrift Math.Phys. 58 (1910) 337 –385 (in German).
TimoshenkoS.P.Stabilitätsprobleme der Elastizität in: Handbuch der physikalischen und technischen Mechanik Band IVLieferung 1LeipzigVerlag von Johann Barthpp.81 –1451921 (in German).(see also the Russian translation Stability of ColumnsPlates and Shells p.553Nauka PublishersMoscow1971).
S.P. Timoshenko (1953) History of Strength of Materials McGraw-Hill New York
TodhunterI.and PiersonK.A History of the Theory of Elasticity and the Strength of Materials from Galilei to Lord Kelvin Dover PublicationsNew York1960 (republication of the Cambridge University Press edition1893).
E. Torroja (1967) Philosophy of Structures University of California Press Berkeley CA 28
TruesdellC.‘The rational mechanics of flexible or elastic bodies 1638 –1788’in: Leonhardi Euleri Opera Omnia Second SeriesVol.XI(2)“Orell Füssli” PublishersZurich1960.
C.A. Truesdell (1980) The Tragicomical History of Thermodynamics 1822 – 1854 Springer New York
C. Truesdell (1984a) ‘Leonard Eulersupreme geometer’ L. Euler (Eds) Elements of Algebra. Springer-Verlag New York
C.A. Truesdell (1984b) An Idiot’s Fugitive Essays on Science: MethodsCriticismTrainingCircumstances Springer-Verlag New York
Truesdell C., Noll W.(1965).‘The non-linear field theories of mechanics’ In: Handbuch der Physik Band III/3Section 68bSpringer-VerlagNew York
VakulenkoA.A.and MikhailovG.K.‘Clifford Truesdell and modern history of mechanics’ Voprosy Istorii Estestvoznania i Tekhniki 3 (2000) 59 –66 (in Russian).
D.H. Van Campen (1999) ArticleTitle‘Warner Tjardus Koiter’ Biog.Mems.Fell.R.Soc.Lond 45 269–273
Viana M.(2001).‘Dynamical systems: moving into the next century’.In: Engquist B., Schmid W.(eds).Mathematics Unlimited – 2001 and Beyond Springer-Verlag
P. Villaggio (2000) ArticleTitle‘Book review Impact Mechanics by W.J.Stronge’ Meccanica 35 470–471
P. Villaggio (1993) ArticleTitle‘How to write a paper on a subject of mechanics’ Meccanica 28 163–167
P. Villaggio (1997) Mathematical Models for Elastic Structures Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Villaggio P.‘The roots of trees’ Continuum Mech.and Thermodyn 10 (1998).
P. Villaggio (2001) ArticleTitle‘Distortions in the history of mechanics’ Meccanica 36 589–592
P. Villaggio (2002) ArticleTitle‘Book review“Cosserat Theories: ShellsRods and Points” by M.B.Rubin Meccanica 37 313–314
VirchenkoN.A.Mathematics Vischa ShkolaKiev1983 (in Russian).
WechterD.‘How to write history’in: A Sense of History (introductory note by Dobell B.)American HeritageNew York1985pp.38–45.
G. Wempner (1989) ArticleTitle‘Mechanics and finite elements of shells’ Appl.Mech.Rev. 42 IssueID(5 129–142
WillersF.A.‘Das Knicken schwerer Gestänge’ ZAMM 21 (1941) 43–51 (in German).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Elishakoff, I. Essay on the Contributors to the Elastic Stability Theory. Meccanica 40, 75–110 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11012-004-2199-y
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11012-004-2199-y