A constraint programming formulation for planning: from plan scheduling to plan generation

Abstract

Planning research is recently concerned with the resolution of more realistic problems as evidenced in the many works and new extensions to the Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL) to better approximate real problems. Researchers’ works to push planning algorithms and capture more complex domains share an essential ingredient, namely the incorporation of new types of constraints. Adding constraints seems to be the way of approximating real problems: these constraints represent the duration of tasks, temporal and resource constraints, deadlines, soft constraints, etc., i.e. features that have been traditionally associated to the area of scheduling. This desired expressiveness can be achieved by augmenting the planning reasoning capabilities, at the cost of slightly deviating the planning process from its traditional implicit purpose, that is finding the causal structure of the plan. However, the resolution of complex domains with a great variety of different constraints may involve as much planning effort as scheduling effort (and perhaps the latter being more prominent in many problems). For this reason, in this paper we present a general approach to model those problems under a constraint programming formulation which allows us to represent and handle a wide range of constraints. Our work is based on the original model of $\mathsf{CPT}$ , an optimal temporal planner, and it extends the $\mathsf{CPT}$ ’s formulation to deal with more expressive constraints. We will show that our general formulation can be used for planning and/or scheduling, from scheduling a given complete plan to generating the whole plan from scratch. However, our contribution is not a new planner but a constraint programming formulation for representing highly-constrained planning + scheduling problems.