Abstract
In recent years, a revisionist process focused on logical positivism can be observed, particularly regarding Carnap’s work. In this paper, I argue against the interpretation that Kuhn’s The Structure of Scientific Revolutions having been published in the International Encyclopedia of Unified Science, co-edited by Carnap, is evidence of the revisionist idea that Carnap “would have found Structure philosophically congenial”. I claim that Kuhn’s book, from Carnap’s point of view, is not in philosophy of science but rather in history of science (in the context of a sharp discovery–justification distinction). It could also explain the fact that, despite his sympathetic letters to Kuhn as editor, Carnap never refers to Kuhn’s book in his work in philosophy of science.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Agassi J. (1996) The philosophy of science today. In: Shanker S. (eds). Philosophy of science, logic and mathematics in the twentieth century. Routledge, London and New York
Andersen H. (2001) On Kuhn. Wadsworth, Belmont, CA
Axtell G. (1993) In the tracks of the historicist movement: Re-assessing the Carnap–Kuhn Connection. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 24: 119–146
Ayer A. (1983) Language, truth and logic. Penguin Books, Harmondsworth
Bird A. (2000) Thomas Kuhn. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Bloor D. (1991) Knowledge and social imagery. Chicago University Press, Chicago
Buchwald, J. et al. (1997) Thomas S. Kuhn, 1922–1996. Philosophy of Science 64, 361–376
Carnap R. (1934) On the character of philosophical problems. Philosophy of Science 1: 5–19
Carnap R. (1938) Logical foundations of the unity of science. In: Neurath O. et al. (eds). International encyclopedia of unified science. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Carnap R. (1968) Inductive logic and inductive intuition. In: Lakatos I. (eds). The problem of inductive logic. North-Holland, Amsterdam
Carnap, R. (1969(1928)). The logical structure of the world. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press
Carnap, R. (1995). An introduction to the philosophy of science. N. York: Dover. (Originally published in 1966 as Philosophical foundations of physics).
Earman J. (1993) Carnap, Kuhn, and the philosophy of scientific methodology. In: Horwich P. (eds). World changes. The MIT Press, Cambridge
Feigl H. (1961) Philosophical tangents of science. In: Feigl H. et al. (eds). Current issues in the philosophy of science. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York
Feigl, H., & Morris, C. (1970). Bibliography and index. In International Encyclopedia of Unified Science. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Ferriani M. (1995) Ancora su Enriques e Carnap: le ragioni di un dialogo mancato. In: Pasquinelli A. (eds). L’eredità di Rudolf Carnap. CLUEB, Bologna
Friedman M. (1998) On the sociology of scientific knowledge and its philosophical agenda. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 29(2): 239–271
Friedman M. (2001) Dynamics of reason. CSLI Publications, Stanford
Friedman M. (2002) Kant, Kuhn, and the rationality of science. Philosophy of Science 69: 171–190
Friedman M. (2003) Kuhn and logical empiricism. In: Nickles T. (eds). Thomas Kuhn. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Hempel C. (1965) Aspects of scientific explanation and other essays in the philosophy of science. Free Press, New York
Hempel C. (2000) Carl G. Hempel – selected philosophical essays (edited by R. Jeffrey). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Hempel C. (2001) The philosophy of Carl G. Hempel (edited by J. Fetzer). Oxford University Press, New York
Irzik G., Grunberg T. (1995) Carnap and Kuhn: Arch enemies or close allies?. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 46: 285–307
Kuhn, T. (1970a(1962)). The structure of scientific revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Kuhn T. (1970b) Reflections on my critics. In: Lakatos I., Musgrave A. (eds). Criticism and the growth of knowledge. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Kuhn T. (1971) Notes on Lakatos. In: Buck R., Cohen R. (eds). Boston studies in the philosophy of science, Vol. 8 (PSA 1970). D. Reidel., Dordrecht
Kuhn T. (2000) The road since structure. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Neurath, O. (1937). The new encyclopedia. In B. McGuinness (Ed.), Unified Science. Dordrecht: D. Reidel, 1987.
Newton-Smith W. (eds) (2001) A companion to the philosophy of science. Blackwell, London
Reichenbach H. (1938) Experience and prediction. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Reisch G. (1991) Did Kuhn kill logical empiricism?. Philosophy of Science 58: 264–277
Reisch G. (1994) Planning science: Otto Neurath and the International Encyclopedia of Unified Science. British Journal for the History of Science 27: 153–175
Salmon W. (1999) The spirit of logical empiricism: Carl G. Hempel’s role in twentieth-century philosophy of science. Philosophy of Science 66(3): 333–350
Scheffler I. (1963) The anatomy of inquiry. Knopf, New York
Schilpp P. (eds) (1963) The philosophy of Rudolf Carnap. Open Court, La Salle
Uebel T. (1991) Neurath’s programme for naturalistic epistemology. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 22(4): 623–646
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Pinto de Oliveira, J.C. Carnap, Kuhn, and revisionism: on the publication of Structure in Encyclopedia . J Gen Philos Sci 38, 147–157 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10838-007-9034-9
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10838-007-9034-9