Abstract
The Wason card selection and the Tversky & Kahneman frame anomaly are examined in the context of a probabilistic, constructivist biological model of decision-making. Rational choice requires that decision-makers understand the meaning of the choices they confront. In fact, the determination of meaning and the process of rational choice represent two sides the same coin. Further, perception, cognition and action are ill-posed problems. To solve these problems ‘missing data’ must be supplied by the brain. This data is acquired by both ontogenetic and phylogenetic processes. These evolutionary processes facilitate the determination of meaning and as a product of that process also facilitate the construction of rationality. Two interrelated brain systems involved in this construction process are examined: an emotional system that rapidly and non-consciously assigns reward expectancy values to objects in the environment and a sensory-motor system that participates in the discovery of more general information that facilitates environment/body interactions. Jointly, these systems help a naïve agent to find ‘meaning in an unlabeled world’ and to predict the outcomes of future interactions with that world by supplying ‘background’ information, i.e., by supplying the missing data necessary for rational choice. This ‘background’ represents the imprint of the statistical structure of the world on the brain and, as such, embodies the individual’s Bayesian priors. Lack of sufficient background capacities can result in systematic judgment errors and seemingly irrational decisions. Complex culture is a key aspect of the environment that facilitates the construction of rationality, in part, by becoming internalized as background. Culture facilitates the creation of complex social constructs that contribute to cultural evolution, reduce uncertainty, and increase rationality; however, cultural evolution can get ahead of itself—potentially leading to background failure and errors in judgment and choice. Finally, it is not simply complexity or lack of hands-on experience that lead to error: an additional component that might be called semantic opacity is necessary.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bechara Antoine Damasio Hanna Tranel Daniel R. Damasio. Antinio (1997) ArticleTitleDeciding advantageously before knowing the advantageous strategy Science 275 1293–1295 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.275.5304.1293 Occurrence Handle9036851
Derek. Bikerton (2002) ArticleTitleLanguage in the modular mind? It’s a no-brainer Behavioral and Brain Sciences 25 677–678 Occurrence Handle10.1017/S0140525X02250128
Jeremy I.M. Carpendale Lewis. Charlie (2004) ArticleTitleConstructing an understanding of mind: the development of childern’s social understanding within social interaction. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 27 79–151 Occurrence Handle15481944
Linda L. Chao Martin. Alex (2000) ArticleTitleRepresentation of manipulable man-made objects in the dorsal stream Neuroimage 12 478–484 Occurrence Handle10.1006/nimg.2000.0635 Occurrence Handle10988041
Noam. Chomsky (1965) Aspects of the theory of syntax The MIT Press Cambridge, Massachusetts
Leda Cosmides Tooby. John (1992) Cognitive adaptations for social exchange J.H. Barkow L. Cosmides J. Tooby (Eds) The Adapted Mind. Oxford University Press Oxford 163–228
Christopher Fiorillo D. Tobler N. Philippe Schultz. Wolfram (2003) ArticleTitleDiscrete coding of reward probability and uncertainty Science 299 1898–1902 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.1077349 Occurrence Handle12649484
Gerald M. Edelman (1992) Bright air, brilliant fire: on the matter of the mind Basic Books New York
Joaquín M. Fuster (1995) Memory in the cerebral cortex The MIT Press Cambridge, Massachusetts
Vittorio. Gallese (2001) ArticleTitleThe ‘shared manifold’ hypothesis: from mirror neurons to sympathy Journal of Consciousness Studies 8 33–50
Vittorio Gallese Fadiga Luciano Fogassi Leonardo Rizzolatti. Giacomo (1996) ArticleTitleAction recognition in the premotor cortex Brain 119 593–609 Occurrence Handle8800951
Wilson S. Geisler L.Diehl. Randy (2003) ArticleTitleA bayesian approach to the evolution of perceptual and cognitive systems Cognitive Science 27 379–402 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0364-0213(03)00009-0
William J. Gehring R. Willoughby. Adrian (2002) ArticleTitleThe medial frontal cortex and the rapid processing of monetary gains and losses Science 295 2279–2282 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.1066893 Occurrence Handle11910116
Paul W. Glimcher (2003) Decisions, uncertainty, and the brain: the science of neuroeconomics The MIT Press Cambridge, Massachusetts
E. Mark Gold (1967) ArticleTitleLanguage identification in the limit Information and Control 16 447–474 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0019-9958(67)91165-5
Jay A. Gottfried O’Doherty John J. Dolan. Raymond (2003) ArticleTitleEncoding predictive reward value in human amygdala and oribitofrontal cortex Science 301 1104–1107 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.1087919 Occurrence Handle12934011
Friedrich A. Hayek (1952) The sensory order The University of Chicago Press Chicago
Friedrich A. Hayek (1979) Law legislation and liberty, Vol. 1 The University of Chicago Press Chicago
Donald D. Hoffman (1998) Visual intelligence: how we create what we see W.W.Norton &Company New York
Ulrich Hoffrage Lindsey Samuel Hertwig Ralph Gigerenzer. Gerd (2000) ArticleTitleCommunicating statistical information Science 290 2261–2262 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.290.5500.2261 Occurrence Handle11188724
Scott A. Huettel B. Mack Peter McCarthy. Gregory (2002) ArticleTitlePerceiving patterns in random series: dynamic processing of sequence in prefrontal cortex Nature Neuroscience, advanced online version 5 485–490
Jana M. Iverson Thelen. Ester (1999) ArticleTitleHand, mouth and brain: the dynamic emergence of speech and gesture Journal of Conscious Studies 6 19–40
Ray. Jackendoff (2002) Foundations of language: brain, meaning, grammar, evolution Oxford University Press Oxford
Timothy Ketelar Todd. Peter (2001) Framing our thoughts: ecological rationality as evolutionary psychology’s answer to the frame problem H.R. Holcomb SuffixIII (Eds) Conceptual Challenges in Evolutionary, Psychology: Innovative Research Strategies. Kluwer Academic Publishers Norwell, MA 179–211
Landa Janet T. 1978. The economics of the ethnically homogeneous Chinese middleman group: a property rights-public choice approach. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation. Virginia Polytechnic & State University.
Janet T. Landa (1981) ArticleTitleA theory of the ethnically homogeneous middleman group: an institutional alternative to contract law Journal of Legal Studies 10 349–362 Occurrence Handle10.1086/467685
Janet T Landa Wang. Xiao Tian (XT) (2001) ArticleTitleBounded rationality of economic man: decision making under ecological, social, and institutional constraints Journal of Bioeconomics 3 217–235 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1020597813814
Richard. Langlois (1986) The new institutional economics: an introductory essay R. Langlois (Eds) Economics as a Process: Essays in the New Institutional Economics. The University of Chicago Press Chicago 1–25
Barbara J. McNeil G. Pauker Stephen C. Sox Harold Tversky. Amos (1982) ArticleTitleOn the elicitation of preferences for alternative therapies The New England Journal of Medicine 306 1259–1262 Occurrence Handle7070445
Axel Mecklinger Gruenewald Christen Besson Mirelle Magnie Marie-Noelle D. Cramon Yves Particlevon (2002) ArticleTitleSeparable neuronal circuitries for manipulable and nonmanipulable objects in working memory Cerebral Cortex 12 1115–1123 Occurrence Handle10.1093/cercor/12.11.1115 Occurrence Handle12379600
P.Read Montague Dayan Peter J.Sejnowski. Terrence (1996) ArticleTitleA framework for mesencephalic dopamine systems based on predictive Hebbian learning Journal of Neuroscience 16 1936–1947 Occurrence Handle8774460
P.Read Montague Dayan Peter Person Christophe J.Sejnowski. Terrence (1995) ArticleTitleBee foraging in uncertain environments using predictive Hebbian learning Nature 377 725–730 Occurrence Handle10.1038/377725a0 Occurrence Handle7477260
P.Read Montague E.Hayman Steven D.Cohen. Jonathan (2004) ArticleTitleComputational roles for do- pamine in behavioural control Nature 431 760–676 Occurrence Handle10.1038/nature03015 Occurrence Handle15483596
Martin A. Nowak L. Komarova Natalia Niyogi. Partha (2002) ArticleTitleComputational and evolutionary aspects of language Nature 417 611–617 Occurrence Handle10.1038/nature00771 Occurrence Handle12050656
Giuseppe Pagnoni F. Zink Caroline P. Read Montague S. Berns. Gregory (2002) ArticleTitleActivity in human ventral striatum locked to errors of reward prediction Nature Neuroscience, advanced online version 5 97–98
Steven. Pinker (1997) How the mind works W. W. Norton & Company New York
Steven. Pinker (2002) The blank slate: the modern denial of human nature Viking Penguin New York
M.L. Platt P.W. Glimcher (1999) ArticleTitleNeural correlates of decision variables in parietal cortex Nature 400 233–238 Occurrence Handle10.1038/22268 Occurrence Handle10421364
Stephanie D. Preston B. M. Waal. Frans Particlede (2002) ArticleTitleEmpathy: its ultimate and proximate basis Behavioral and Brain Sciences 25 1–20 Occurrence Handle10.1017/S0140525X02000018 Occurrence Handle12625087
Giacomo Rizzolatti Fadiga Luciano Fogassi Leonardo Gallese. Vittorio (1996) ArticleTitlePremotor cortex and the recognition of motor actions Cognitive Brain Research 3 131–141 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0926-6410(95)00038-0 Occurrence Handle8713554
Edmund T. Rolls (1999) The brain and emotion Oxford University Press Oxford
Jenny R. Saffran (2001) ArticleTitleWords in a sea of sound: the output of infant statistical learning Cognition 81 149–169 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0010-0277(01)00132-9 Occurrence Handle11376640
Jenny R. Saffran N. Aslin Richard L. Newport. Elissa (1996) ArticleTitleStatistical learning by 8-month-old infants Science 274 1926–1928
Wolfram Schultz Dayan Peter Montague P. Read (1997) ArticleTitleA neural substrate of prediction and reward Science 275 1593–1599 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.275.5306.1593 Occurrence Handle9054347
John R. Searle (1992) The rediscovery of the mind The MIT Press Cambridge, Massachusetts
John R. Searle (1995) The construction of social reality The Free Press New York
John R. Searle (1998) Mind, language and society Basic Books New York
John R. Searle (2001) Rationality in action The MIT Press Cambridge, Massachusetts
Jitendra Sharma Dragoi Valentin B. Tenenbaum Joshua K. Miller Earl Sur Mriganka (2003) ArticleTitleV1 neurons signal acquisition of an internal representation of stimulus location Science 300 1758–1763 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.1081721 Occurrence Handle12805552
Shepard Roger N., peer commentary. (2001). Perceptual-cognitive universals as reflections of the world. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 24:579–791.
Munetaka Shidara J. Richmond Barry (2002) ArticleTitleAnterior cingulate: single neural signals related to degree of reward expectancy Science 296 1709–1711 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.1069504 Occurrence Handle12040201
Richard M. Shiffrin (2003) ArticleTitleModeling memory and perception Cognitive Science 27 341–378 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0364-0213(03)00027-2
Keith E. Stanovich West. Richard (2000) ArticleTitleIndividual differences in reasoning: implications for the rationality debate? Behavioral and Brain Sciences 23 645–726 Occurrence Handle10.1017/S0140525X00003435 Occurrence Handle11301544
Keith Stenning Lambalgen. Michiel Particlevan (2004) ArticleTitleA little logic goes a long way: basing experiment on semantic theory in the cognitive science of conditional reasoning Cognitive Science 28 481–529 Occurrence Handle10.1016/j.cogsci.2004.02.002
Emanuel. Todorov (2004) ArticleTitleOptimality principles in sensorimotor control Nature Neuroscience 7 907–715 Occurrence Handle10.1038/nn1309 Occurrence Handle15332089
John Tooby Cosmides. Leda (1992) The psychological foundations of culture J.H. Barkow Cosmides Leda Tooby John (Eds) The Adapted Mind Oxford University Press Oxford 19–136
Léon Tremblay Schultz. Wolfram (1999) ArticleTitleRelative reward preference in primate orbitofrontal cortex Nature 398 704–708 Occurrence Handle10.1038/19525 Occurrence Handle10227292
Amos Tversky Kahneman. Daniel (1981) ArticleTitleThe framing of decisions and the psychology of choice Science 211 453–458 Occurrence Handle7455683
Amos Tversky Kahneman. Daniel (1992) ArticleTitleAdvances in prospect theory: cumulative representative of uncertainty Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 5 297–323 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00122574
Xiao Tian (XT). Wang (1996a) ArticleTitleDomain-specific rationality in human choices: violations of utility axioms and social context Cognition 60 31–63 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0010-0277(95)00700-8
Xiao Tian (XT). Wang (1996b) ArticleTitleFraming effects: dynamics and task domains Organizational behavior and Human Decision Processes 68 145–157 Occurrence Handle10.1006/obhd.1996.0095
Jonathan A. Waskan (2003) ArticleTitleIntrinsic cognitive models Cognitive Science 27 259–283 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0364-0213(02)00119-2
Peter. Wason (1986) ArticleTitleReasoning about a rule Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 20 273–281
Masataka. Watanabe (1996) ArticleTitleReward expectancy in primate prefrontal neurons Nature 382 629–632 Occurrence Handle10.1038/382629a0 Occurrence Handle8757133
Watt, Douglas F. 1998. Emotion and consciousness: implications of affective neuroscience for example tended reticular thalamic activating system theories of consciousness. The Association for the Scientific Study of Consciousness Electronic Seminar on Emotion and Consciousness, http://www.phil.vt.edu/assc/esem.html.
Timothy D. Wilson (2002) Strangers to ourselves: discovering the adaptive unconscious Belknap Press of Harvard University Press Cambridge, Massachusetts
Timothy D. Wilson J.Lisle Douglas W.Schooler Jonathan D.Hodges Sara J.Klaaren Kristen J.LaFleur. Suzanne (1993) ArticleTitleIntrospecting about reasons can reduce post-choice satisfaction Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 19 331–339
Timothy D. Wilson D.Hodges Sara J.LaFleur Suzanne (1995) ArticleTitleEffects of introspection about reasons: inferring attitudes from accessible thoughts Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 69 16–28 Occurrence Handle10.1037/0022-3514.69.1.16 Occurrence Handle7643298
Ludwig. Wittgenstein (1955) Philosophical investigations Basil Blackwell Oxford
Zhiyong Yang Purves. Dale (2003) ArticleTitleA statistical explanation of visual space Nature Neuroscience 6 632–640 Occurrence Handle10.1038/nn1059 Occurrence Handle12754512
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gifford, A. The Role of Culture and Meaning in Rational Choice. J Bioecon 7, 129–155 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10818-005-0495-9
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10818-005-0495-9