Quality control of Utermöhl-based phytoplankton counting and biovolume estimates—an easy task or a Gordian knot?

Abstract

The most suitable way for standardizing biovolume based assemblage analysis using the Utermöhl technique for counting combined with biomass conversion has not yet been found even though this method has been successfully used in plankton studies for many years. Due to the complexity of the approach easily applicable steps to initially meet primary standard end point or target counts for intra-laboratory standardization tested here seem promising. Examples from count validation and biometric data from the large datasets of three laboratories are given. The first two examples initially intended to quantify the taxon specific scatter of counts by (A) using identical replica of field samples combined with a half-chamber count (scan of every second transect) and the 30 random field approach, respectively, and (B) the replication of transect counts in one sample. Both examples identified relatively low minimum count thresholds to delimit counting errors for single cell counts. The third example identifies shape variability and allometric relationships of the main axes and shows a way to improve taxon specific biomass estimates with special reference to cell thickness. However improved precision of quantitative phytoplankton analysis requires optimization of combined counting strategy and biovolume assessment methods.