Abstract
This article considers the reception of British cytogeneticist C.D. Darlington’s controversial 1932 book, Recent Advances in Cytology. Darlington’s cytogenetic work, and the manner in which he made it relevant to evolutionary biology, marked an abrupt shift in the status and role of cytology in the life sciences. By focusing on Darlington’s scientific method – a stark departure from anti-theoretical, empirical reasoning to a theoretical and speculative approach based on deduction from genetic first principles – the article characterises the relationships defining the “disciplinary landscape” of the life sciences of the time, namely those between cytology, genetics, and evolutionary theory.
Similar content being viewed by others
Change history
17 December 2018
A Correction to this paper has been published: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-018-9551-x
References
Garland Allen (1969) ArticleTitle“Hugo de Vries and the Reception of the “Mutation Theory” Journal of the History of Biology 2 55–87 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00137268
Garland Allen (1975) Life Sciences in the Twentieth Century Wiley New York
Garland Allen (1979) Thomas Hunt Morgan: the Man and His Science Princeton University Press Princeton
Bacon, Francis. 1968. “Novum Organum,” In J. Spedding, R. L. Ellis, D. D. Heath, (eds.), The Works of Francis Bacon., Vol. NewYork: VIII. Garrett Press.
William Bateson (1922) ArticleTitle“Evolutionary Faith and Modern Doubts” Science 55 55–61
William Bateson (1926) ArticleTitle“Segregation” Journal of Genetics 16 201–235
John Belling (1928) ArticleTitle“A Working Hypothesis for Segmental Interchange Between Homologous Chromosomes in Flowering Plants” University of California Publications in Botany 14 283–291
John Belling (1933) ArticleTitle“Critical Notes on Darlington’s Recent Advances in Cytology” (a posthumous paper) University of California Publications in Botany 17 75–110
J. Belling A.F. Blakeslee (1924) ArticleTitle“The Configurations and Sizes of the Chromosomes in the Trivalents of 25-Chromosomes Daturas” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 47 403–415
S. Brown D. Zohari (1955) ArticleTitle“The Relationship of Chiasmata and Crossing-over in Lilium formosanum” Genetics 40 850–873
Elof Axel Carlson (1981) Genes, Radiation, and Society: The Life and Work of H.J. Muller Cornell University Press Ithaca
Carson, Hampton L. 1998. “Cytogenetics and the Neo-Darwinian Synthesis,” in Mayr and Provine, op. cit.
F.B. Churchill (1974) ArticleTitle“William Johannsen and the Genotype Concept” Journal of the History of Biology 7 5–30 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00179291
Fred Churchill (1985) ArticleTitle“Weismann’s Continuity of the Germ-Plasm in Historical Perspective” Freiburger Universitätsblätter 24 107–124
Fred Churchill (1987) ArticleTitle“From Heredity Theory to Vererbung, the Transmission problem, 1850–1915” Isis 78 337–364
Ralph E. Cleland (1972) Oenothera: Cytogenetics and Evolution Academic Press London
William Coleman (1965) ArticleTitle“Cell Nucleus and Inheritance: An Historical Study” Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 109 124–158
William Coleman (1970) ArticleTitle“Bateson and the Chromosomes: Conservative Thought in Science” Centaurus 15 228–314
Harriet Creighton Barbara McClintock (1931) ArticleTitle“A Correlation of Cytological and Genetical Crossing Over in Zea Mays” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 17 492–497
Darlington, C. D. 1926. “Chromosome Studies in the Scilleae,” pp. 237–251.
C.D. Darlington (1929) ArticleTitle“Ring Formation in Oenothera and other Genera” Journal of Genetics 20 245–363
Darlington, C. D. 1930. “Chiasma Formation and Chromosome Pairing in Fritillaria,” In Proceedings of the 5th International Botanical Congress, Cambridge, pp. 189–191.
C.D. Darlington (1931a) ArticleTitle“Meiosis in Diploid and Tetraploid Primula sinensis” Journal of Genetics 24 65–96
C.D. Darlington (1931b) ArticleTitle“Meiosis” Biological Reviews 6 221–252
C.D. Darlington (1932) Recent Advances in Cytology Churchill London
C.D. Darlington (1939) The Evolution of Genetic Systems Cambridge University Press London
Darlington, C. D. 1952. “Recent Advances in Cytology: a retrospective, 1952–1932,” a recorded seminar at the John Innes, 7.11.1952, DP:C.85:f.21.
C.D. Darlington (1956) ArticleTitle“Natural Populations and the Breakdown of Classical Genetics” Proceedings of the Royal Society Series B 145 350–64
C.D. Darlington (1960) ArticleTitle“The Chromosomes and the Theory of Heredity” Nature 187 892–895
C.D. Darlington (1962) ArticleTitle“Otto Renner: 1885–1960” Bib. Mem. Roy. Soc. Lon 7 207–220
Theodosius Dobzhansky (1937) Genetics and the Origin of Species Columbia University Press New York
Dunn, L. C. and Dobzhansky, Theodosius. 1987. “Reminiscences,” Columbia University Oral History Project, typescripts, pp. 865–867, 345.
R. Falk S. Schwartz (1993) ArticleTitle“Morgan’s Hypothesis of the Genetic Control of Development” Genetics 134 671–674
J.B. Farmer L. Digby (1912) ArticleTitle“On the Dimensions of Chromosomes Considered in Relation to Phylogeny” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 205 1–25
R.R. Gates (1922) ArticleTitle“Some Points on the Relation of Cytology and Genetics” Journal of Heredity 13 75–76
Bently Glass (1963) “The Establishment of Modern Genetical Theory as an Example of the Interaction of Different Models, Techniques, and Inferences” A.C. Crombie (Eds) Scientific Change: Historical Studies in the Intellectual, Social, and Technical Conditions for Scientific Discovery and Technical Invention, from Antiquity to the Present Heinemann London 521–541
S.J. Gould (1980) Hen’s Teeth and Horse’s Toes Norton New York
Joel B. Hagen (1984) ArticleTitle“Experimentalists and Naturalists in Twentieth-Century Botany: Experimental Taxonomy 1920–1950” Journal of the History of Biology 17 249–270 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00143734
A. Håkansson (1928) ArticleTitle“Die Reduktionsteilung in de Samenanlagen einiger Oenotheren” Hereditas 11 225–304
A. Håkansson (1930) ArticleTitle“Zur Zytologie trisomatischer Mutanten aus Oenothera lamarckiana” Hereditas 14 1–32
J.B.S. Haldane (1932) The Causes of Evolution Harper and Brothers London
Oren Solomon Harman (2003) ArticleTitle“C.D. Darlington and the British and American Reaction to Lysenko and the Soviet Conception of Science” Journal of the History of Biology 36 IssueID2 309–352 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1024483131660
Oren Solomon Harman (2004) The Man Who Invented the Chromosome: A Life of C.D. Darlington Harvard University Press Cambridge
Jonathan Harwood (1993) Styles of Scientific Thought: The German Genetics Community 1900–1933 Chicago University Press Chicago
Hogben, Lancelot. 1921. “Studies on Synapsis, I, II, III,” Proceedings of the Royal Society of London on Series B 91: 268–293, 305–329 and 92: 60–80.
Adrian Hogben Anne (Eds) (1998) Lancelot Hogben, Scientific Humanist Merlin Press Woodbridge, Suffolk
T.J. Horder (2001) ArticleTitle“The Organizer Concept and Modern Embryology: Anglo-American Prespectives” International Journal of Developmental Biology 45 97–132
Arthur Hughes (1959) A History of Cytology Abelard-Schuman London
C.L. Huskins (1945) ArticleTitle“Contrasts in Cytology” Journal of Heredity 36 43–46
Julian Huxley (1942) Evolution: the Modern Synthesis Allen and Unwin London
F.A. Janssens (1909) ArticleTitle“La Théorie de la Chiasmatypie” Cellule 25 387–411
Kamrat Lang, Debra. 1993. “Genetics Humanized: H.J. Muller Between Science and Politics 1915–1932,” unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, Hebrew University of Jerusalem.
Evelyn Fox Keller (1998) A Feeling For the Organism: The Life and Work of Barbara McClintock W.H. Freeman New York
Ernst Mayr William Provine (1998) The Evolutionary Synthesis: Perspectives on the Unification of Biology Harvard University Press Cambridge
Ernst Mayr (1985) ArticleTitle“Weismann and Evolution” Journal of the History of Biology 18 295–329 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00138928
H.J. Muller (1939) ArticleTitle“How Genetic Systems Come About” Nature 144 648
Muller H.J. (1943). “Edmund B. Wilson – an Appreciation,” American Naturalist 77: 5–37, 142–172.
W.C.F. Newton C.D. Darlington (1927) ArticleTitle“Meiosis in a Triploid Tulip” Nature 120 13
Michael Polanyi (1967) The Tacit Dimension Doubleday Garden City, NY
William B. Provine (1978) ArticleTitle“The Role of Mathematical Population Geneticists in the Evolutionary Synthesis of the 1930s and 1940s” Studies in History of Biology 2 167–192
E. Reuter (1930) ArticleTitle“Beiträge zu einer einheitlichen Auffassung gewiser Chromosomen-fragen” Act. Zool. Fenn. 9 1–487
Jan Sapp (1987) ArticleTitle“What Counts as Evidence or Who was Franz Moewus and Why Was Everybody Saying Such Terrible Things About Him” History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 9 277–308
Karl Sax (1932) ArticleTitle“Meiosis and Chiasma Formation in Paeonia suffruticosa” Journal of the Arnold Arboretum XIII 375–385
Schrader, Franz. 1948. “Three Quarter-Centuries of Cytology,” In Address by the vice-president and chairman of the Section of Zoological Sciences (F), AAAS, delivered at the Zoologists’ Dinner, December 30, 1947, Chicago, Illinois. Science 107: 155–159.
Vassiliki Betty Smocovitis (1996) Unifying Biology: The Evolutionary Synthesis and Evolutionary Biology Princeton University Press Princeton
Stebbins, G. L. 1941. Review in Chronica Botanica VI 17/18: 429–430.
Curt Stern (1931) ArticleTitle“Zytologische-genetische Untersuchungen als Beweise für die Morgansche Theorie des Faktorenaustausch” Biologisches Zentralblatt 51 547–587
A.H Sturtevant (1965) A History of Genetics Harper and Row New York
A.H. Sturtevant G.W. Beadle (1939) An Introduction to Genetics W.B. Saunders Company Philadelphia
August Weismann (1886) Die Bedeutung der sexuellen Fortpflanzung für die Selektionstheorie Verlag von Gustav Fisher Jena
August Weismann (1887) ArticleTitle“On the Significance of the Polar Globules” Nature 36 607–609
Weismann, August. 1975. Studies in the Theory of Descent, Mendola, R. (trans. and ed.). New York: AMS Press.
M.J.D. White (1945) Animal Cytology and Evolution Cambridge University Press London
E.B. Wilson (1925) The Cell In Development and Heredity EditionNumber3 Macmillan New York
Hans Winiwarter Particlevon (1900) ArticleTitle“Recherches sur l’ovogenèse et l’orgenogenèse de l’ovaire des mammifères (Lapin et Homme) Archives de Biologie 17 33–200
D. Zickler N. Kleckner (1999) ArticleTitle“Meiotic Chromosomes: Integrating Structure and Function” Annual Review of Genetics 33 603–754 Occurrence Handle10.1146/annurev.genet.33.1.603
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Harman, O.S. Method as a Function of “Disciplinary Landscape”: C.D. Darlington and Cytology, Genetics and Evolution, 1932–1950. J Hist Biol 39, 165–197 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-004-2085-4
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-004-2085-4