Abstract
There is growing concern that current health care services are not sustainable. The compartmental flow model provides the opportunity for improved decision-making about bed occupancy decisions, particularly those of a strategic nature. This modelling can be applied to complement infrastructure and workforce-planning methods.
Discussion about appropriateness of the level of model complexity, the degree of fit and the ability to use compartmental flow models for generalization and forecasting has been lacking. The authors investigated model selection and assessment in relation to hospital bed compartment flow models.
A compartment model for a range of scenarios was created. The training and test data related to the 1998 and 1999 calendar years, respectively. The majority of scenarios tested were based upon commonly used periods that describe periods of time. The goodness-of-fit achieved by optimisation was measured against the training and test data.
Model fit improved with increasing complexity as expected. The analysis of model fit against the test data showed that increasing model complexity did result in over-fitting, and better prediction was achieved with a relatively simple model. In terms of generalisation, the seasonal models performed best.
Single day census type models, which have been used by Millard and his colleagues, were also generated. The performance of these models was similar, but inferior to that of the models generated from a full year of training data. The additional data make the models better able to capture the variation across the year in activity.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
1. World Health Organisation, Active Ageing: A Policy Framework (World Health Organisation, Geneva, Switzerland, 2002).
2. OECD, A Disease-Based Comparison of Health Systems—What is Best and at What Cost? (OECD Publications, France, 2003).
3. Commission of the European Communities, Towards a Europe for All Ages—Promoting Prosperity and Intergenerational Solidarity (Commission of the European Communities, Brussels, 1999).
4. OECD, Health at a Glance (OECD Publications, France, 2001).
5. A. Alijani, G.B. Hanna, D. Ziyaie, S.L. Burns, K.L. Campbell, M.E.T McMurdo and A. Cuschieri, Instrument for objective assessment of appropriateness of surgical bed occupancy: Validation study, BMJ 326 (2003) 1243–1244.
6. A. Bagust, M. Place and J.W. Posnett, Dynamics of bed use in accommodating emergency admissions: Stochastic simulation model, BMJ 319 (1999) 155–158.
7. J. Pengelley, GP overflow ‘does not tax hospitals’, The Advertiser 23 (April 2004) 5.
8. Generational Health Review, Generational Health Review—Progress Report (Generational Health Review, Adelaide, Australia, 2003).
9. G. Hamel and C.K. Prahald, Competing for the Future (Harvard University Press, Boston, 1994).
10. I.J. Myung and M.A. Pitt, Applying Occam’s razor in modelling cognition: A bayesian approach, Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 1 (1997) 79–95.
11. H. Xiao-Ming, A planning model for requirement of emergency beds, IMA Journal of Mathematics Applied in Medicine & Biology 12 (1995) 345–353.
12. R.D.T. Farmer and J. Emami, Models for forecasting hospital bed requirements in the acute sector, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 44 (1990) 307–312.
13. S.A. Jones and M.P. Joy, Forecasting demand of emergency care, Health Care Management Science 5 (2002) 297–305.
14. T.K. Sweeney and J.S.A. Ashley, Forecasting hospital bed needs, British Medical Journal 283 (1981) 331–334.
15. K.S. Bay and L.J Nestman, The use of bed distribution and service population indexes for hospital bed allocation, Health Services Research 19(2) (1984) 140–160.
16. J. Yates, Hospital Beds: A Problem for Diagnosis and Management (William Heinemann, London, 1982).
17. W.E. Sterk and E.G. Shyrock, Modern methods improve hospital forecasting, Healthcare Finance Manager 41(3) (1987) 96–98.
18. J.F. Pendergast and W.B. Vogel, A multistage model of hospital bed requirements, Health Services Research 23 (1988) 381–399.
19. J. Sorensen, Multi-phased bed modelling, Health Services Management Research 9 (1996) 61–67.
20. M. Mackay and P.H. Millard, Application and comparison of two modelling techniques for hospital bed management, Australian Healthcare Review 22 (1999) 118–143.
21. A.X. Costa, S.A. Ridley, A.K. Shahani, P.R Harper, V. De Senna M.S. Nielsen, Mathematical modelling and simulation for planning critical care capacity, Anaesthesia 58(4) (April 2003) 320–327.
22. K. Wang, K.K.W. Yau and A.H. Lee, A hierarchical Poisson mixture regression model to analyse maternity length of hospital stay, Statistics in Medicine 21 (2002) 3639–3654.
23. G.W. Harrison and P.H. Millard, Balancing acute and long term care: The mathematics of throughput in departments of geriatric medicine, Methods of Information in Medicine 30 (1991) 221–228.
24. G.W Harrison, Compartmental models of hospital patient occupancy patterns, in: Modelling Hospital Resource Use: A Different Approach to the Planning and Control of Health Care Systems, ed. P.H. Millard and S.I. McClean, (Royal Society of Medicine, London, 1994).
25. S.I. McClean and P.H. Millard, Go with the flow: Modelling bed occupancy and patient flow through a geriatric department, OR Insight 7(3) (1994) 2–4.
26. S.I. McClean and P.H. Millard, A decision support system for bed-occupancy management and planning hospitals, IMA Journal of Mathematics Applied in Medicine & Biology 12 (1995) 225–234.
27. S.I. McClean and P.H. Millard, A three compartmental model of the patient flows in a geriatric department: A decision support approach, Health Care Management Science 1 (1998) 159–163.
28. F. Gorunescu, S.I. McClean and P.H. Millard, A queueing model for bed-occupancy management and planning of hospitals, Journal Operational Research Society 53 (2002) 19–24.
29. T.M. Mills, A mathematician goes to hospital, Australian Mathematical Society Gazette 31(5) (2004) 320–327.
30. E. El-Darzi, C. Vasilakis, T. Chaussalet and P.H. Millard, A simulation modelling approach to evaluating length of stay, occupancy, emptiness and bed blocking in a hospital geriatric department, Health Care Management Science 1 (1998) 143–149.
31. K. Godfrey, Compartmental Models and Their Application (Academic Press Inc., London, 1983).
32. M. Mackay, Practical experience with bed occupancy management and planning systems: An Australian view, Health Care Management Science 4 (2001) 47–56.
33. G. Taylor, S. McClean and P. Millard, Geriatric-patient flow-rate modeling, IMA Journal of Mathematics Applied in Medicine & Biology 13 (1996) 297–307.
34. D. St George, How many beds? Helping consultants to estimate their requirements, BMJ 297(6650) (1988) 729–31.
35. S. MacStravic, Need new beds? Throw out your old formulas, Health Care Strategic Management 19(10) (2001) 16–19.
36. S.I. McClean and P.H. Millard, Modelling in-patient bed usage behaviour in a department of geriatric medicine, Methods of Information in Medicine 32 (1993) 79–81.
37. G.W. Harrison, Implications of mixed exponential occupancy distributions and patient flow models for health care planning, Health Care Management Science 4 (2001) 37–45.
38. S. Roberts and H. Pashler, How persuasive is a good fit? A comment on theory testing, Psychological Review 107(2) (2000) 358–367.
39. M.D. Lee, A Bayesian analysis of retention functions, Journal of Mathematical Psychology 48(5) (2004) 310–321.
40. T. Hastie, R. Tibshirani and J. Friedman, The Elements of Statistical Learning; Data Mining, Inference and Prediction (Springer, Canada, 2001).
41. H. Kohler, Statistics for Business and Economics (Scott Foresman and Company, USA, 1985).
42. J. Xiao, A.H. Lee and S.R. Vemuri, Mixture distribution analysis of length of hospital stay for efficient funding, Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 33 (1999) 39–59.
43. S. Karlin S (1983) cited by I.J. Myung, website http://quantrm2.psy.ohio-state.edu/injae/respub.html accessed Jan 2004.
44. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Active Aging: A Shift in the Paradigm (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, United States of America, 1997).
45. Commission of the European Communities, Towards a Europe for All Ages—Promoting Prosperity and Intergenerational Solidarity (Commission of the European Communities, Brussels, 1999).
46. World Health Organisation, Active Ageing: A Policy Framework (World Health Organisation, Spain, 2002).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mackay, M., Lee, M. Choice of Models for the Analysis and Forecasting of Hospital Beds. Health Care Manage Sci 8, 221–230 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10729-005-2013-y
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10729-005-2013-y