Skip to main content

Advertisement

SpringerLink
Log in

Occurrence and problems of high fluoride waters in Turkey: an overview

  • Original Paper
  • Published:
Environmental Geochemistry and Health Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

Endemic dental fluorosis was first observed in Turkey in Isparta Province, located in the SW of Anatolia, with mottled enamel related to the high levels of fluoride (1.5–4.0 ppm) in drinking waters, about 55 years ago. The origin of fluoride was attributed to the contents of minerals in volcanic rocks, consisting of pyroxene, hornblende, biotite, fluorapatite and glassy groundmass minerals. It was also reported about 35 years ago that severe dental and skeletal fluorosis has been observed in human beings and livestock in Dogubeyazıt and Caldiran areas, located around Tendurek Volcano in eastern Turkey, where natural waters contained fluoride levels between 2.5 and 12.5 ppm. It was hypothesised that fluoride, which might be transported by fumaroles or escaped from devitrified lavas, could be held on the surface of some minerals and then exchanged with OH- in ground waters with high pH at the foothills of the young Tendurek Volcano. Endemic dental and skeletal fluorosis was also observed in the inhabitants in Kizilcaoren Village of Beylikova Town in Eskişehir Province situated in the midwest of Turkey, where the fluoride content of the drinking waters ranged from 3.9 to 4.8 ppm. The origin of high fluoride in the natural waters was related to the fluorspar deposits, occurring in the catchment area near the village. During the survey in the Güllü Village of Esme-Usak, located in south-midwest of Turkey, it was observed that most of the inhabitants born and raised in the village and aged between 10 and 30 years, showed mild to moderate levels of mottled enamel. The fluoride contents of the deep well waters used for drinking in the village, varied from 0.7 to 2.0 ppm. Amorphous microscopic fluorite existing in the Pliocene lake limestones was considered as a possible origin of fluoride in the waters.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Log in via an institution

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Fig. 1
Fig. 2
Fig. 3
Fig. 4
Fig. 5
Fig. 6
Fig. 7
Fig. 8
Fig. 9
Fig. 10
Fig. 11
Fig. 12

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • Aksit, M. A., Tel, E., & Bilir, S. (1980). Kizilcaoren—a health survey in an endemic fluorosis village. Fluoride, 13, 81–85.

    Google Scholar 

  • Ata, P. (1966). Fluor Hipoplazisi (Fluoroz), Konservatif Dis Tedavisi, Ders Kitabi. Yenilik Basimevi, Istanbul, Sahife 102–146.

  • Azbar, N., & Turkman, A. (2000). Defluoridation in drinking waters. Water Science and Technology, 1:42(1–2), 403–407.

    Google Scholar 

  • Babacan, E. (1979). Agri Ili Dogubeyazit Ilcesi Koylerinde Kronik Flor Zehirlenmesi Gorulen Koyun ve Sigirlarda Kan Bulguları Uzerinde Calismalar (Abstract in English), Firat Uni. Veteriner Fak. Yayinlari No: 23, Calismalari 12, Elazig.

  • Bilgin, A., Koseoglu, M., & Ozkan, G. (1990). Isparta-Golcuk Yoresi Kayaclarinin Mineroloji Petrografive Jeokimyasi (Abstract in English), Doga, TR.T. of Engineering and Environmental Sciences, 14, 342–361, Tubitak.

  • Celik, E. (1983). Kizilcaoren, (Eskisehir-Sivrihisar) Toryum-Fluorit (Kompleks Cevher) Yataginin Maden Yatagi Acisından Degerlendrilmesi, Anadolu Uni. Muh.-Mim. Fak. Maden Muh. Bl. Bitirme Odevi, Eskisehir.

  • Edmunds, W. M., & Smedley, P. L. (2005). Fluorine in natural waters—occurrence, controls and health aspectes. In O. Selinus, B. Alloway, J. A. Centeno, R. B. Finkelman, R. Fuge, U. Lindh, S. Smedley (Eds.), Essentials of medical geology (pp. 301–329). Academic Press.

  • Ergun, H. S., Russel-Sinn, H. H., Baysu, N., & Dundar, Y. (1987). Studies on the fluoride contents in water and soil, urine, bone and teeth of sheep and urine of human from eastern and western parts of Turkey, Dtsch tierarztl Wschr, 94, 341–440, July/August, 1987.

  • Fidanci, U. R., Baysu, N., Ergun, H. (1994). The fluorine content of water sources in Kizilcaoren village in Eskisehir, Tr. Journal of Medical Sciences, 20, 15–17, Tubitak.

    Google Scholar 

  • Fluorides and Human Health (1970). WHO, Geneva, 1970.

  • Fluorine and Fluorides (1984). Environmental Health Criteria 36, WHO, Geneva, 1984.

  • Hobbs, C. S., et al. (1954). Fluorosis in cattle and sheep, Bulletin No: 235, The University of Tennessee Agricultural Experiment Station.

  • Kirikoglu, M. S. (1988). Maden Yataklarindan Kaynaklanan Dogal Cevre Kirlenmesinin Fluorit Orneginde incelenmesi (Abstract in English), Sayi: 32–33, s. 49–53, Mayis-Kasim, 1988, Ankara.

  • Mermutlu, B. (1977). Endemik Fluoroz Bolgesinde Distaslarinin Kimyasal Analizi (Doktora Tezi), Istanbul Uni. Dis Hekimligi Fak., Istanbul.

  • Oktay, C. (1977). Effect of fluoride containing drinking water on skeletal and dental age, In, Seminar on Problems of High Fluoride Waters, CENTO Scientific Programme, Report, No: 28, Erzurum Ataturk Uni., 6–10 June, 1977.

  • Olmez, E., Ercan. T., & Yildirim, T. (1994). Tendurek (Dogu Anadolu) Jeotermal Alaninin (Diyadin, Zilan, Caldiran) Volkanolojisi ve Jeotermal Enerji Olanaklari (Abstract in English), Turkiye Jeoloji Kurumu Bulteni, Sayi: 9, 48–55, Ankara.

  • Ornek, S. (1955). Dis Curuklerinde ve Dis Fluorozisinde Memleket Sularinin Ihtiva Ettikleri Fluorun Rolu, Ankara Uni. Tip Fak. Mecmuasi. Cilt: VII-VIII Sayi: 1–4, s. 129–137.

  • Oruc, N. (1972). Agri Dogubeyazit Koylerinde Gorulen Fluorosis Vakasi ile igili On Rapor, Ataturk Universitesi, Halkla Iliskiler ve Yayin Mudurlugu, Rapor No: 250, Erzurum.

  • Oruc, N. (1973). Dogubeyazit Kazasi ve Koylerinde Kullanilan Sularda Fluorur Konsantrasyonu ve Onemi (Abstract in English), Ataturk Uni. Ziraat Fak. Ziraat Dergisi Cilt: 4. Sayi: 1, Erzurum.

  • Oruc, N. (1976). Van Golu ve Cevresindeki Bazi Doga Sularinda Fluorur Konsantrasyonu ve Onemi (Abstract in English), Ataturk Uni. Ziraat Fak. Ziraat Dergisi. Cilt: 7, Sayi: 3, s. 25–32, Erzurum.

  • Oruc, N. (1977a). A preliminary study on the effect of water-borne fluoride on the fluoride content of soils and plants: In Seminar on Problems of High Fluoride Waters, CENTO Scientific Programme, Report No: 28, Erzurum Ataturk Uni. 6–10 June 1977.

  • Oruc, N. (1977b). Fluoride content of some spring waters and fluorosis in the eastern Anatolia. In Seminar on Problems of High Fluoride Waters, CENTO Scientific Programme, Report No: 28, Erzurum Ataturk Uni., 6–10 June, 1977.

  • Oruc, N., (1983). Dogubeyazit Yoresindeki Bazi Su Kaynaklarinda Spektrofotometrik ve Potentiometrik Yontemlerie Fluorur Miktarlarinin Arastirilmasi (Abstract in English), Doga ve Cevre Bilim Dergisi: Muh/Cevre, Cilt: 7, 1983.

  • Oruc, N. (2001). Turkiye’de Yuksek Duzeyde Fluorur Iceren Kaynak Sulari ve Onemi (Abstract in English), 1. Turkiye Su Kongresi, 8–10 Ocak 2001, Istanbul, Istanbul Technical Uni. and Greater Municipality of Istanbul Organization, pp. 629–638.

  • Oruc, N., & Aksit, M. A. (1989). A health survey in a village with endemic fluorosis, 1978–1988, Cevre’89, Cevre Genel Mudurlugu, Cukurova Uni., Adana, 7–9 Haziran, 1989, s. 443.

  • Oruc, N., & Sansarci, H. (1983). Isparta Sehir Merkezi lcme Sularinda Fluorur Miktarinin Azaltilmasi, Akdeniz Uni. Isparta Muh. Fak. 1.Muh. Haftasi, Bildiriler, 7–10 Haziran 1983, Isparta, s. 35–43.

  • Oruc, N., Vicil, M. (2001). Usak Esme Gullu Koyu Icme Sularinda Fluorur Duzeyi ve Kokeni (Abstract in English), Yeralti Sulari ve Cevre Sempozyumu, TMMOB Jeoloji Muh. Odasi, Izmir, 21–23 Mart 2001.

  • Oruc, N., Alpman. N., & Karamanderesi, I. H. (1976). Tendurek Volkani Cevresindeki Yuksek Fluorur Icerikli Kaynak Sularinin Hidrojeolojisi (Abstract in English), Turkiye Jeoloji Kurumu Bulteni, c. 19, 1–8 Subat, 1976, Ankara.

  • Ozgur, N., Pekdeger, A., & Schneider, H-J. (1992). High fluorine contents in the Pliocene volcanic rocks of the Golcuk area. Isparta, SW Turkey: Bull. Geol. Greece XXVIII/2, pp. 417–427.

  • Ozkan, G., Koseoglu, M., & Bilgin, A. (1988). Isparta Icme Suyundaki Fluorurun Cevre Kayaclarla Iliskisi (Abstract in English), Ulusal 1. Hidrojeoloji Sempozyumu, Bildiriler, 28–29 Eylul, 1988, Ankara, pp. 247–256.

  • Oztopcular, M. (1977). Evaluation of the chronic fluoride intoxication in the Dogubeyazit region from the neurological stand point. In Seminar on Problems of High Fluoride Waters, CENTO Scientific Programme, Report No: 28, Erzurum Ataturk Uni., 6–10 June, 1977.

  • Pekdeger, A., Ozgur, N., Schneider, H.-J.,& Bilgin, A. (1990). High fluorine contents in aqueous systems of the Golcuk area, Isparta/W-Taurides, Inl. Earth Sci. Congress on Aegean Regions, 1–6 Oct. 1990, Izmir, Turkey.

  • Samsar, E. (1983). Fluoroz, Akdeniz Uni. Isparta Muh. Fak. 1. Muh. Haftasi, 7–10 Haziran 1983, Bildiriler, Sahife 45–48.

  • Sendil, C., & Baysu, N. (1973). Insan ve Hayvanlarda Agri Ili Dogubeyazit Ilcesi Koylerinde Gorulen Flor Zehirlenmesi ve Bunu Van Ili Muradiye Ilcesi Koylerinde Saptamamizla Ilgili Ilk Teblig (Abstract in English), Ankara Uni. Veteriner Fak. Dergisi. Cilt: 20, No: 4.

  • Suttle, J. W. (1977). Effects of fluoride on Livestock, Journal of Occupational Medicine, 19, No:1/January, 40–48.

    Google Scholar 

  • Tuncel, E. (1980). Endemic Fluorosis Olgularında Monckeberg Sklerozu Kalsifikasyonlarının Gorulme Sikligi (Abstract in English), Cerrahpasa Tip Fak. Dergisi, Cilt: II, Sayi: 3, Temmuz 1980, Istanbul.

  • Uslu, B., & Gogus, T. (1981). Endemic fluorosis (Clinical, roentgenological and biochemical study of chronic fluorine intoxication in Kizilcaoren), Hacettepe Bulletin of Medicine/Surgery, Vol 4/Numbers 3–4/July-Oct. 1981. Ankara: Hacettepe Uni. Press.

  • Usmen, E. (1975). Isparta II, Ilce ve Koylerinde Dis Fluorosisi (Abstract in English), Istanbul Uni. Dis. Hekimligi Fak. Dergisi. Cilt: 10, Sayi: 4, Aralik, 1976, Sahife: 285–296.

  • Velicangil, S., & Demirhindi, O. (1955). Dis Curugu—Fluor Profilaksisi Uzerinde Arastirmalar (Abstract in English), Turk Mikrobiyoloji Dergisi, 3–4, s. 113–135, 1955.

  • Velicangil, S., & Demirhindi. O, (1957). Isparta’da Endemik Dental Fluorosis ve Bu Mevzu ile Alakali Bazi Problemler Uzerinde Arastirmalar [Abstract in English), Istanbul Uni.Tip Fak. Mec., Cilt: 20, Sayi: 1, pp. 94–110.

Download references

Acknowledgements

I would like to thank Fatma Belen and Fatih Ince for preparation of the manuscript in digital form.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

  1. Eskisehir Environmentai Protection Association (NGO), 2510 F Blok D.8 Yenikent, 26050, Eskisehir, Turkey

    Nazmi Oruc

Authors
  1. Nazmi Oruc
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Nazmi Oruc.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Oruc, N. Occurrence and problems of high fluoride waters in Turkey: an overview. Environ Geochem Health 30, 315–323 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10653-008-9160-2

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Revised:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10653-008-9160-2

Keywords

Search

Navigation