Abstract
This paper examines the use of ethnic-specific crime data by law enforcement authorities as an instrument to formulate policies. The focus is on Bulgaria – one of the few East European countries whose criminal justice system keeps data on ethnicity – and the country’s Roma population. During the 1990s, Bulgaria’ s deep economic and social crisis impacted significantly on Bulgaria’ s Roma minority and, arguably, led to an increase in crime rates amongst the Roma. To date, however, the Bulgarian government has failed to adequately address this situation. The main argument that this paper puts forward is that over-policing of the Roma minority is a consequence of lack of adequate data on the Roma’ s involvement in crime, coupled with a crime-fighting strategy that is largely based on ethnic prejudice. As a result, a disproportionate number of Roma end-up in prisons or in long-term detention. Former inmates, in turn, influence their communities and establish a ‘revolving cycle’ of crime and social marginalisation, which is manifested in an increasing critical mass of the Roma male population in the criminal justice system.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alpha Research (2002). State of society: A nationally representative survey. Alpha Research:Sofia p.49
Amnesty International (1993). Bulgaria: Torture and ill-treatment of Roma. Amnesty International:London
Amnesty International (1994), Bulgaria; Turning a blind eye to racism. Amnesty International:London
Analytical Creative Group (1998). Analysis of Crime in Bulgaria during 1993–1997 Period: Crime of the Roma Ethnic Group: Short Criminological Survey. Center for Marketing and Social Studies:Sofia
Beck, A. (1999). Prisoners in 1999. Bureau of Justice Statistics Bulletin. U.S. Department of Justice, NCJ 183476
Bezlov T., Gounev P. (2005). Crime Trends in Bulgaria: Police Statistics and Victimization Surveys. Center for the Study of Democracy:Sofia
Bezlov T., Gounev P., Hristov H. (2006). Crime Trends in Bulgaria 2000–2005, Center for the Study of Democracy:Sofia
Bishop D., Frazier C. (1984). The effects of gender on charge reduction. The Sociological Quarterly 25:385–396
Bosworth, M. (2004). Theorizing race and imprisonment: Towards a new penality. Critical Criminology 12: 221–242, at 225
Bowling B., Phillips C. (2002a). Racism, Crime and Justice. Longman,:London p. 128–129
Bowling B. and Phillips C. (2002b) Racism, Ethnicity, Crime, and Criminal Justice. In M. Maguire, R. Morgan, and R. Reiner (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Criminology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 579–619
Brown I., Hullen R. (1992) A study of sentencing in the leeds magistrates’ courts. British Journal of Criminology 32, (1), 41–53
Bulgarian Helsinki Committee (1998). Human Rights in Bulgaria in 1997, Bulgarian Helsinki Committee:Sofia
Bulgarian Helsinki Committee (2002). Bulgaria’ s Prisons, Sofia: Bulgarian Helsinki Committee:Sofia
Bulgarian Helsinki Committee (2003). Human Rights in Bulgaria in 2002, Bulgarian Helsinki Committee:Sofia
Bulgarian Helsinki Committee (2004). Human Rights in Bulgaria in 2003, Bulgarian Helsinki Committee:Sofia
Bulgarian Helsinki Committee (2005). Human Rights in Bulgaria in 2004, Bulgarian Helsinki Committee:Sofia
Bulgarian Helsinki Committee (2006a). Five Years Later: The Non-Governmental Projects for Desegregation of Roma Education in Bulgaria, Bulgarian Helsinki Committee:Sofia
Bulgarian Helsinki Committee (2006b). Human Rights in Bulgaria in 2005, Bulgarian Helsinki Committee:Sofia
Dimova L. et al. (2003). Roma on the Job Market and in the Social Security System: The New Challenges. ASA:Sofia
Economist Intelligence Unit Country Data[0], online database www.eiu.com
European Commission (2004). The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities:Luxembourg
Farrell R., Swigert V. (1986). Adjudication in homicide: An interpretive analysis of the effects of defendant and victim social characteristics. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 23:349–369
Fitzgerald M. (1993). Ethnic Minorities in the Criminal Justice System, Home Office:London
Free M. (2001). Racial bias and the American criminal justice system: Race and pre-sentencing revisited, Critical Criminology 10:195–223
Foote C. (1959). The bail system and equal justice Federal Probation 23:43–48
Hood R. (1992) Race and Sentencing. Clarendon Press:Oxford
Home Office (2000). Statistics on Race and Criminal Justice System 2000: A Home Office Publication under Section 95 of the Criminal Justice Act 1991. Home Office:London
Human Rights Watch (1991). Destroying Ethnic Identity: The Gypsies of Bulgaria. Human Rights Watch:New York
Interviews with Police Officers (July 2005). unpublished
Interview with a police official in National Police Service Directorate (04/11/2005). Sofia
Interviews with judges Evgeni Georgiev and Ivailo Majurov (June–July 2005). Sofia
Lamberth, J. (1999). Driving While Black: A Statistician Proves that Prejudice Still Rules the Road. Washington Post, 08/16, 1999, p. 3
Ministry of Labor and Social Policy (2004). Program for Social Integration of the Roma by Providing Equal Chances for Access to the Labor Market and by Decreasing the Dependency on Social Assistance. Sofia:Ministry of Labor and Social Policy, 12–52
Ministry of Interior (1997). Social Changes and the Criminogenic Situation in Regions with Traditionally Low Crime Rate. quoted in Analytical Creative Group (1998) Analysis of Crime in Bulgaria during 1993–1997 Period: Crime of the Gypsy Ethnic Group: Short Criminological Survey. Sofia: Center for Marketing and Social Studies
Ministry of Interior, (01/08/2002). Memorandum of the National Police Directorate: Regarding Specific Elements of the Situation Regarding the Roma Population, unpublished
Ministry of Interior (08/10/2004). Regarding more Specific Elements of the Situation Regarding the Roma Population, unpublished
Mhlanga B. (1999). Race and Crown Prosecution Service Decisions. The Stationery Office:London
Monitor Daily (12/14/2005)
Murray C. (1984). Losing Ground, Basic Books:New York
Murray C. (1990). The Emerging British Underclass, London: Institute of Economic Affairs
National Statistics Institute (2005a). Crime and Sentenced Individuals. NSI:Sofia
National Statistics Institute (2005b). Statistical Yearbook. NSI:Sofia
New York Attorney General (1999) New York City Police. “Stop and Frisk” Practices: A Report to the People of New York From the Office of the Attorney General. New York: New York Attorney General, at 95
Parenti C. (2000). Lockdown America, Verso:London
Patterson E. and Lynch M. (1992). Bias in Formalized Bail Procedures. In M. Lynch andE. Patterson (eds.), Race and Criminal Justice. Albany, NY: Harrow and Heston, pp. 36–53
Phillips C., Brown D. (1998). Entry into the Criminal Justice System: a Survey of Police Arrests and Their Outcomes. Home Office Research Study No. 185, Home Office:London
Ringold D., Orensten M.,Wilkens E. (2003). Roma in an Expanding Europe: Breaking the Poverty Cycle, conference edition. World Bank: Washington
Spohn C., Holleran D. (2000). The imprisonment penalty paid by young, unemployed black and hispanic male offenders Criminology 38:281–306
United Nations Development Program (2002). Avoiding the Dependency Trap. Sofia: UNDP Bulgaria
U.S. Customs Service (1998). Personal Searches of Air Passengers Results: Positive and Negative. Washington DC, 1998, at 1
Vitosha Research (2004). Transcript of focus groups (unpublished)
Vitosha Research (2005). Relations between the Police and Minorities, household survey (unpublished)
World Bank (2001). Bulgarian Integrated Household Survey. Washington: World Bank, http://www.worldbank.org/lsms/country/bg01/bg01docs.html
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gounev, P., Bezlov, T. The Roma in Bulgaria’ s Criminal Justice System: From Ethnic Profiling to Imprisonment. Crit Crim 14, 313–338 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10612-006-9015-z
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10612-006-9015-z