Abstract
Plagiarism strikes at the heart of academe, eroding the fundamental value of academic research. Recent evidence suggests that acts of plagiarism and awareness of these acts are on the rise in academia. To address this issue, a vein of research has emerged in recent years exploring plagiarism as an area of academic inquiry. In this new academic subject, case studies and analysis have been one of the most influential methodologies employed. Case studies provide a venue where acts of plagiarism can be discussed and analyzed in a constructive manner, and that is the primary purpose of this article. Unlike previous studies, however, we focus on the role of the publisher, a key player in dealing with acts of plagiarism, but one who has received little attention in the academic literature. Specifically, we examine how an academic publisher addressed allegations of plagiarism and how the publisher’s decision-making affected the outcome. We analyze the case by applying the guidelines from different frameworks and ethical theory and develop recommendations from the lessons evidenced, the second main objective of our article. This analysis advances the dialog on academic plagiarism by exploring the role of the publisher from a deontological perspective of ethical absolutism.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Amanullah, M.: 2006, ‘Author’s Copyright: An Islamic Perspective’, The Journal of World Intellectual Property 9(3), 301-315.
Arce, D.G., W. Enders, and G.A. Hoover: 2008, ‘Plagiarism and Its Impact on the Economics Profession’, Bulletin of Economic Research 60(3), 231-243.
Bartlett, T. and S. Smallwood: 2004, ‘Four Academic Plagiarists You’ve Never Heard Of: How Many More Are Out There?’, The Chronicle of Higher Education 15(17), A8.
Baume, G.L.: 2008, ‘Retraction: Unveiling the Galactic Structure by Looking Through a Region of Puppis’, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 390, 465.
Boisvert, R.F. and M.J. Irwin: 2006, ‘Plagiarism on the Rise’, Communications of the Association for Computing Machinery 49(6), 23-24.
Bouysson, D., S. Martello, F. Plastria (2006) A Case of Plagiarism: Danut Marcu. 4OR 4, 11-13.
Butakov, S. and V. Scherbinin: 2009, ‘The Toolbox for Local and Global Plagiarism Detection’, Computers & Education 52, 781-788.
Cabral-Cardoso, C.: 2004, ‘Ethical Misconduct in the Business School: A Case of Plagiarism that Turned Bitter’, Journal of Business Ethics 49, 75-89.
Clarke, R.: 2006, ‘Plagiarism by Academics: More Complex Than It Seems’, Journal of the Association for Information Systems 7(2), 91-121.
Cokol, M.: 2008, ‘Retraction Rates are on the Rise’, EMBO Reports 9(1), 2.
Corbyn, Z.: 2009, ‘Retractions Up Tenfold’, Times Higher Education Website, August 20, 2009.
Davison, R.M., M.C. Munro, and D.W. Straub: 2004a, ‘Introduction to the AIS Code of Research Conduct’, Communications of the Association for Information Systems 13, 1-8.
Davison, R.M., M.C. Munro, and D.W. Straub: 2004b, ‘AIS Code of Research Conduct’, Communications of the Association for Information Systems 13, 9-16.
Davison, R.M., M.C. Munro, and D.W. Straub: 2004c, ‘Guidelines for a Victim: Dealing with Plagiarism’, Communications of the Association for Information Systems 13, 17-24.
Enders, W. and G. Hoover: 2004, ‘Whose Line Is It? Plagiarism in Economics’, Journal of Economic Literature 42, 487-493.
Enders, W. and G. Hoover: 2006, ‘Plagiarism in the Economics Profession: A Survey’, Challenge 49(5), 92-107.
Forsyth, D.R.: 2006, ‘Judging the Morality of Business Practices’, in K. Gibson (ed.), Business Ethics: People, Profits, and the Planet (McGraw Hill, New York).
Foster A. L. (2004) Elsevier’s Vanishing Act: To the Dismay of Scholars, the Publishing Giant Quietly Purges Articles From Its Database. The Chronicle of Higher Education 49(18): A27.
Frederick, R.E.: 2002, A Companion to Business Ethics (Blackwell Publishing, Oxford).
George, J.F., C. Beath, R.M. Davison, J. Heales, and M.C. Munro: 2003, ‘Report of the Ad Hoc Committee on Member Misconduct to the AIS Council’, Communications of the Association for Information Systems 11, 54-78.
Gibelman, M. and S.R. Gelman: 2003, ‘Plagiarism in Academia: Trends and Implications’, Accountability in Research 10, 229-252.
Gu, Q. and J. Brooks: 2008, ‘Beyond the Accusation of Plagiarism’, System 36, 337-352.
Harms, D.: 2006, ‘Plagiarism, Publishing, and the Academy’, Journal of Scholarly Publishing, October, 1–13.
Hoover, G.A.: 2006, ‘A Game-Theoretic Model of Plagiarism’, Atlantic Economic Journal 34, 449-454.
Kock, N.F.: 1999, ‘A Case of Academic Plagiarism’, Communications of the Association for Computing Machinery 42(7), 96-104.
Kock, N.F. and R.M. Davison: 2003, ‘Dealing with Plagiarism in the IS Research Community: A Look at Factors that Drive Plagiarism and Ways to Address Them’, Management Information Systems Quarterly 27(4), 511-532.
Levai, A. and G. Toth: 2002, ‘How to Use Major Parts of a Paper Previously Published by Others To Write a New One. An Allegation of Plagiarism by Indian Authors’, Synthetic Communications 31(10), 1625-1631.
Li, S.: 2010, ‘Journal Review Process Increasingly Includes Check for Plagiarism’, The Chronicle of Higher Education Website, July 9, 2010.
Martin, B.R.: 2007, ‘Keeping Plagiarism at Bay – A Salutary Tale’, Research Policy 36, 905-911.
Maurer, H. and N. Kulathuramaiyer: 2007, ‘Addressing Plagiarism and IPR Violation’, Information Services and Use 27, 185-191.
Merriam-Webster Dictionary: 2003 (Merriam-Webster, New York).
Micewski, E.R. and C. Troy: 2007, ‘Business Ethics – Deontologically Revisited’, Journal of Business Ethics 72, 17-25.
MLA Style Manual and Guide to Scholarly Publishing: 2008 (Modern Language Association, New York).
Monaghan P. (2004) University Presses Choose Caution in Responding to Accusations of Plagiarism. The Chronicle of Higher Education 51(17): A23.
Pojman, L.P.: 2004, Moral Philosophy (Hackett Publishing, Indianapolis).
‘Retracted: Kinetic Study on Photocatalytic Degradation of Reactive Orange 5 Solution with Phosphotungstic Acid’: 2008, Journal of Molecular Catalysis 283 (1–2), 93–98.
‘Retraction’: 2008, Alimentary Pharmacology & Therapeutic 28(7), 942.
‘Times Reporter Who Resigned Leaves Long Trail of Deception’: 2003, New York Times, May 11, A1.
Titus, S.L., J.A. Wells, and L.J. Rhoades: 2008, ‘Repairing Research Integrity’, Nature 453, 980-982.
Wheeler, G.: 2009, ‘Plagiarism in the Japanese Universities: Truly a Cultural Matter?’, Journal of Second Language Writing 18, 17-29.
Yilmaz, I.: 2007, ‘Plagiarism? No, We’re Just Borrowing Better English’, Nature 449, 658.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lewis, B.R., Duchac, J.E. & Douglas Beets, S. An Academic Publisher’s Response to Plagiarism. J Bus Ethics 102, 489–506 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-011-0827-8
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-011-0827-8