Abstract
The views of thirteenth century Catholic thinker Thomas Aquinas and twentieth century economist Milton Friedman on the social responsibility of business are contrasted by probing the foundations of their positions. The basis of Aquinas’ normative stance in political economy is found in the metaphysical and moral realism of the classic tradition. The role Descartes and Hobbes played in overturning this philosophical starting point and ushering in an age of ideology is traced out. Friedman’s commitment to Comte’s vision of positivism is revealed and what this entails for metaphysics, ethics, and economics is given.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alford, H., C. M. A. Clark, S. A. Cortright and M. J. Naughton (eds.): 2006, Rediscovering Abundance (University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, IN)
Alford, H. J., & Naughton, M. J. (2001). Managing as if Faith Mattered: Christian Social Principles in the Modern Organization. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press
Aquinas, St. Thomas: 1948, Summa Theologica, 5 Volumes (Fathers of the English Dominican Province, trans.) (Benziger Brothers, New York) (Original work published in 1911)
Aquinas, St. Thomas: 1955, Summa Contra Gentiles. Book One: God (A. C. Pegis, trans.) (Image Books, Garden City, NY)
Aquinas, St. Thomas: 1956a, Summa Contra Gentiles. Book Two: Creation (J. F. Anderson, trans.) (Image Books, Garden City, NY)
Aquinas, St. Thomas: 1956b, Summa Contra Gentiles. Book Three: Providence (V. J. Bourke, trans.) (Image Books, Garden City, NY)
Aquinas, St. Thomas: 1957, Summa Contra Gentiles. Book Four: Salvation (C. J. O’Neil, trans.) (Image Books, Garden City, NY)
Aquinas, St. Thomas: 1968, On Being and Essence (A. Maurer, trans.) (2nd rev. edition) (Pontifical Institute of Mediaeval Studies, Toronto, ON)
Aristotle: 1980, Aristotle’s Categories and Propositions (H. G. Apostle, trans.) (Peripatetic Press, Grinnell, IA)
Azar, L. (1983). Philosophy and Ideology: An Adventure (2nd ed.). Dubuque, IA: Kendall
Azar, L. (1990). Twentieth Century in Crisis: Foundations of Totalitarianism. Dubuque, IA: Kendall/Hunt Publishing Company
Barrera, A. (2005). Economic Compulsion and Christian Ethics. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press
Barrett, W. (1986). Death of the Soul: From Descartes to the Computer. Garden City, NY: Anchor Press/Doubleday
Becker, G. S.: 1976, The Economic Approach to Human Behaviour (University of Chicago Press, Chicago)
Bellamy, R., & Hollis, M. (1995). Liberal Justice: Political and Metaphysical. The Philosophical Quarterly, 45(178), 1–19. doi:10.2307/2219845
Bowles, S., & Gintis, H. (1993). The Revenge of Homo Economicus: Contested Exchange and the Revival of Political Economy. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 7(1), 83–102
Brandt, F. (1927). Thomas Hobbes Mechanical Conception of Nature. Copenhagen, Denmark: Levin & Munksgaard
Busch, L. (2000). The Eclipse of Morality. New York: Aldine de Guyter
Camenisch, P. F.: 1981, ‹Business Ethics: On Getting to the Heart of the Matter’, Business and Professional Ethics Journal (Fall), 1(1), 59–69
Canavan, F. (1995). The Image of Man in Catholic Thought. In K. L. Grasso, G. V. Bradley, R. P. Hunt (Eds.) Catholicism, Liberalism, and Communitarianism: The Catholic Intellectual Tradition and the Moral Foundations of Democracy (pp. 15–27). Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield
Carson, T. (1993). Friedman’s Theory of Corporate Social Responsibility. Business and Professional Ethics Journal, 12(1), 3–32. Medline
Catechism of the Catholic Church [CCC]: 1992, Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops, Ottawa, ON
Chervin, R., & Kevane, E. (1988). Love of Wisdom. San Francisco: Ignatius Press
Chesterton, G. K. (1956). Saint Thomas Aquinas. Garden City, NY: Doubleday & Company
Clark, C. M. A. (2006). Christian Morals and the Competitive System Revisited. Journal of Economic Issues, 40(2), 261–275
Coelho, P. R., McClure, J. E., & Spry, J. A. (2003). The Social Responsibility of Corporate Management: A Classical Critique. Mid-American Journal of Business, 18(1), 15–24
Copelston, F. C. (1955). Aquinas. Middlesex, Great Britain: Penguin Books
Danley, J. R. (1991). Polestar Refined: Business Ethics and Political Economy. Journal of Business Ethics, 10(12), 915–933. doi:10.1007/BF00383797
Eschmann, I. T. (1956). A Catalogue of St. Thomas’ Works: Bibliographical Notes. In E. Gilson (Ed.), The Christian Philosophy of Saint Thomas Aquinas (pp. 381–439). Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame
Etzioni, A. (1996). A Moderate Communitarian Proposal. Political Theory, 24(2), 155–171. doi:10.1177/0090591796024002001
Fleckenstein, M. P. (2002). The “Right to Associate” in Catholic Social Thought. Journal of Business Ethics, 38(1/2), 55–64. doi:10.1023/A:1015773013528
Friedman, M. (1953). Essays in Positive Economics. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago
Friedman, M. (1962). Capitalism and Freedom. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
Friedman, M.: 1970, ‹The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase Its Profits’, New York Times Magazine, pp. 32, 33, 122, 124, 126
Friedman, M. (1991). Essay on Centisimus Annus. National Review, 43(11), S3–S4
Gallagher, S.: 2005, A Strategic Response to Friedman’s Critique of Business Ethics, Journal of Business Strategy 26(6), 55–60. doi:10.1108/02756660510633028
Gannon, T. M. (ed.). (1987). The Catholic Challenge to the American Economy. New York: Macmillan
Gilson, E. (1937). The Unity of Philosophical Experience. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons
Gilson, E. (1952). Being and Some Philosophers. Toronto, ON: Pontifical Institute of Mediaeval Studies
Gilson, E. (1956). The Christian Philosophy of St. Thomas Aquinas. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame
Goodpaster, K. E. (1998). Ethical Frameworks for Management. In K. E. Goodpaster & L. Nash (Eds.), Policies and Persons: A Casebook in Business Ethics (pp. 516–529). New York: McGraw-Hill
Grant, C. (1991). Friedman Fallacies. Journal of Business Ethics, 10(12), 907–914. doi:10.1007/BF00383796
Hutchins, R. M. (ed.): 1952, ‹Descartes, Spinoza’, in Great Books of the Western World (Encyclopaedia Britannica, Chicago), pp. 1–463
John Paul II: 1981, Laborem Exercens (On human work) (St. Paul Books & Media, Boston) [LE]
John Paul II: 1987, Sollicitudo rei socialis (On Social Concern) (St. Paul Books & Media, Boston) [SRS]
John Paul II: 1991, Centissimus Annus (One Hundred Years) (St. Paul Books & Media, Boston) [CA]
John Paul II: 2005, Memory and Identity (Rizzoli, New York)
Keynes, J. M. (1936). The General Theory of Interest, Employment and Money. London, UK: MacMillan
Koehn, D. (1996). The Ethics of Business: Moving Beyond Legalism. Ethics & Behavior, 6(1), 1–16. doi:10.1207/s15327019eb0601_1
Laing, J. A. (2004). Law, Liberalism, and the Common Good. In D. Oderberg & T. Chappell (Eds.), Human Values: New Essays on Ethics and Natural Law. London, England: Palgrave Macmillan
Lee, D. R., & McKenzie, R. B. (1994). Corporate Failure as a Means to Corporate Responsibility. Journal of Business Ethics, 13(12), 969–978. doi:10.1007/BF00881666
Leijenhorst, C. (2007). Sense and Nonsense About Sense: Hobbes and the Aristotelians on Sense Perception and Imagination. In P. Springborg (Ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Hobbes Leviathan (pp. 82–108). New York: Cambridge University Press
Leo XIII: 1891, Rerum Novarum (Daughters of St. Paul, Boston) [RN]
Lewis, C. S. (1947). The Abolition of Man. New York: MacMillan
Liechty, D. (1985). On the Social Responsibilities of Business: Contra Milton Friedman. Management Decision, 23(4), 54–63. doi:10.1108/eb001385
Lowi, T. J. (2001). Our Millennium: Political Science Confronts the Global Corporate Economy. International Political Science Review, 22(2), 131–150. doi:10.1177/0192512101222001
Maritain, J. (1958). St. Thomas Aquinas. New York: Meridian Books
Marsden, C. (2005). In Defense of Corporate Responsibility. ZFWU, 6(3), 359–373
McAleer, S. (2003). Friedman’s Stockholder Theory of Corporate Moral Responsibility. Teaching Business Ethics, 7(4), 437–451. doi:10.1023/B:TEBE.0000005711.70399.51
Médaille, J. (2007). The Vocation of Business. New York: Continuum
Michel, V. (1939a). Ownership and the Human Person. The Review of Politics, 1(2), 155–178
Michel, V. (1939b). Liberalism Yesterday and Tomorrow. Ethics, 49(4), 417–434. doi:10.1086/290105
Molesworth, Sir W. (ed.): 1839, The English Works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Vol. 1 (John Bohn, London) [Originally published 1655] [DeCorpore]
Mulligan, T.: 1986, ‹A Critique of Milton Friedman’s Essay “The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase Its Profits’”, Journal of Business Ethics 5, 265–269. doi:10.1007/BF00383091
Mulligan, T. (1990). Justifying Moral Initiative by Business, with Rejoinders to Bill Shaw and Richard Nunan. Journal of Business Ethics, 9(2), 93–103. doi:10.1007/BF00382658
Myers, M. L. (1983). The Soul of Modern Economic Man. Chicago: University of Chicago Press
Naughton, M. J. (1995). Participation in the Organization: An Ethical Analysis from the Papal Social Tradition. Journal of Business Ethics, 14(11), 923–935. doi:10.1007/BF00882070
Nichols, A. (2002). Discovering Aquinas. Grand Rapids, MI: Wm. B. Eerdmans
Nunan, R. (1988). The Libertarian Conception of Corporate Property: A Critique of Milton Friedman’s Views on the Social Responsibility of Business. Journal of Business Ethics, 7(12), 891–906
Nussbaum, M. C. (1997). Flawed Foundations: The Philosophical Critique of (A Particular Type of) Economics. The University of Chicago Law Review, 64(4), 1197–1214. doi:10.2307/1600214
O’Boyle, E. J. (2004). Getting the Hard-Core Concepts of Economics Right. Logos, 7(1), 147–173. doi:10.1353/log.2004.0007
Persky, J. (1995). Retrospectives: The Ethology of Homo Economicus. The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 9(2), 221–231
Pesch, H.: 1998, Heinrich Pesch on Solidarist Economics: Excerpts from the Lehrbuch der Nationalökonomie (R. J. Erderer, trans.) (University Press of America, Lanham, MD)
Pesch, H. S. J.: 2002, Lehrbuch der nationalökonomie/Teaching guide to economics, Vols. 1–5 (R. J. Erderer, trans.) (Lewiston, NY: Mellen Press) (Original work published 1905–1926)
Pesch, H. S. J.: 2004, Ethics in the National Economy (R. J. Erderer, trans.) (IHS Press, Norfolk, VA) (Original work published 1918)
Peterson, D. J. (1999). Revoking the Moral Order. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books
Pontifical Council for Social Communications: 1997, Ethics in advertising. Retrieved March 20, 2008 from http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_coun-cils/pccs/documents/rc_pc_pccs_doc_2
Post, F. R. (2003). A Response to “The Social Responsibility of Corporate Management: A Classical Critique” Mid-American Journal of Business, 18(1), 25–35
Rawls, J. (1971). A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press
Redpath, P. A. (1997a). Cartesian Nightmare: An Introduction to Transcendental Sophistry. Atlanta, GA: Rodopi
Redpath, P. A. (1997b). Wisdom’s Odyssey: From Philosophy to Transcendental Sophistry. Atlanta, GA: Rodopi
Redpath, P. A. (1998). Masquerade of the Dream Walkers: Prophetic Theology from the Cartesians to Hegel. Atlanta, GA: Rodopi
Rommen, H. A. (1965). Natural Law: Man and Society. Fordham Law Review, 24(1), 128–140
Schneider, H. W. (ed.): 1958, Leviathan (Liberal Arts Press, New York) [Originally published 1651] [Lev.]
Schumacher, E. F. (1977). A Guide for the Perplexed. New York: Harper and Row
Shorris, E. (1981). Scenes from Corporate Life: The Politics of Middle management. New York: Penguin Books
Smith, A.: 1981, The Theory of Moral Sentiments (Liberty Classics, Indianapolis, IN) [Originally published 1759]
Smith, A.: 1982, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (Liberty Classics, Indianapolis, IN) [Originally published 1776]
Spragens, T. A. (1973). The Politics of Motion: The World of Thomas Hobbes. Lexington: University of Kentucky Press
Sullivan, D. J. (1992). An Introduction to Philosophy. Rockford, IL: Tan Books and Publishers
Tönnies, F. (ed.): 1969, The Elements of Law: Natural and Politic, 2nd Edition (Barnes & Noble, New York) [Originally published 1640]
Torrell, J.-P.: 2003, Saint Thomas Aquinas: Spiritual Master (R. Royal, trans.) (Catholic University of America Press, Washington, DC)
Torrell, J.-P.; 2005, Saint Thomas Aquinas: The Person and His Work (R. Royal, trans) (Catholic University of America Press, Washington, DC)
Verdon, M. (1982). On the Laws of Physical and Human Nature: Hobbes’ Physical and Social Cosmologies. Journal of the History of Ideas, 43(4), 653–663. doi:10.2307/2709348
Warrender, H. (ed.): 1983, De Cive (Oxford University Press, New York) [Originally published 1642; First English Translation, 1651]
Waters, W. R. (1988). Social Economics: A Solidarist Perspective. Review of Social Economy, XLVI, (2), 113–143. doi:10.1080/00346768800000024
Watkins, J. W. N. (1955). Philosophy and Politics in Hobbes. The Philosophical Quarterly, 5(19), 125–146. doi:10.2307/2217139
Whiteside, K. H. (1988). Hobbes Ultranominalist Critique of Natural Right. Polity, 20(3), 457–478. doi:10.2307/3234871
Wilcke, R. W. (2004). An Appropriate Ethical Model for Business and a Critique of Milton Friedman’s Thesis. The Independent Review, 9(2), 187–209
Wishloff, J. (2003). Responsible Free Enterprise: What It is and Why We Don’t Have it. Teaching Business Ethics, 7, 229–263. doi:10.1023/A:1025021203317
Yuengert, A.: 2007, ‹Free Markets and the Culture of Consumption’, in Catholic Social Teaching and the Market Economy (The Institute of Economic Affairs, London, UK), pp. 145–163
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wishloff, J. The Land of Realism and the Shipwreck of Idea-ism: Thomas Aquinas and Milton Friedman on the Social Responsibilities of Business. J Bus Ethics 85, 137–155 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-008-9753-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-008-9753-9