Abstract
Prior research shows that mutual fund investors are often aware of up-front charges like sales loads, but they are less mindful of annual operating expenses, even though both types of fees lower overall performance. This study documents the historical trend and recent abuse of annual mutual fund expenses. As the industry becomes more adept at segmenting customers by level of investment sophistication, we claim that load mutual fund companies take advantage of this ability and charge higher expenses to their target customer: the less-knowledgeable investor. No-load fund companies, which tend to attract the more sophisticated investor, offer lower expenses. For example, over 2000–2004 the average annual expense ratio of load equity funds was 50 basis points higher than no-load equity funds. We show evidence of this widening cost disparity since the early 1990s among new and existing equity, bond, and index funds. We also document a growing abuse of sales distribution or 12b-1 fees among funds that are closed to new investors, almost all of which are load funds. Thus, load fund investors are more susceptible to paying higher expenses and receiving lower returns over time.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alexander G. J., Jones J. D., Nigro P. J. (1998). Mutual Fund Shareholders: Characteristics, Investor Knowledge, and Sources of Information. Financial Services Review 7:301–316
Barber B. M., Odean T., Zheng L. (2005). Out of Sight, Out of Mind: The Effects of Expenses on Mutual Fund Flows. Journal of Business 78(6):2095–2119
Ferris S. P., Chance D. M. (1987). The Effect of 12b-1 Plans on Mutual Fund Expense Ratios: A Note. Journal of Finance 42(4):1077–1082
General Accounting Office: 2000, ‘Mutual Fund Fees: Additional Disclosure Could Encourage Price Competition,’ Washington, D.C. (GAO/GGD-00-126).
Houge, T. and T. Loughran: 2006, ‘Do Investors Capture the Value Premium?’ Financial Management, forthcoming.
Investment Company Institute: 2005, Investment Company Fact Book, 45th edition. Washington, DC
Livingston M., O’Neal E. S. (1998). The Cost of Mutual Fund Distribution Fees. Journal of Financial Research 21(2):205–218
Malhotra D. K., McLeod R. W. (1997). An Empirical Analysis of Mutual Fund Expenses. Journal of Financial Research 20(2):175–190
McLeod R. W., Malhotra D. K. (1994). A Re-Examination of the Effect of 12B-1 Plans on Mutual Fund Expense Ratios. Journal of Financial Research 17(2):231–240
Sirri E. R., Tufano P. (1998). Costly Search and Mutual Fund Flows. Journal of Finance 53(5):1589–1622
Walsh, L.: 2004, ‘The Costs and Benefits to Fund Shareholders of 12b-1 Plans: An Examination of Fund Flows, Expenses, and Returns,’ Office of Economic Analysis, United States Securities and Exchange Commission Working Paper.
Acknowledgements
We thank Ann Tenbrunsel, a referee, and seminar participants at the Ethical Dimensions in Business: Reflections from the Business Academic Community conference at the University of Notre Dame for helpful comments and suggestions.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Todd Houge is an Assistant Professor of Finance at the University of Iowa.
Jay Wellman is an Assistant Professor of Finance at Binghamton University.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Houge, T., Wellman, J. The Use and Abuse of Mutual Fund Expenses. J Bus Ethics 70, 23–32 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-006-9077-6
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-006-9077-6