Skip to main content
SpringerLink
Log in

The Self Model and the Conception of Biological Identity in Immunology

  • Published:
Biology and Philosophy Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

The self/non-self model, first proposed by F.M. Burnet, has dominated immunology for 60 years now. According to this model, any foreign element will trigger an immune reaction in an organism, whereas endogenous elements will not, in normal circumstances, induce an immune reaction. In this paper we show that the self/non-self model is no longer an appropriate explanation of experimental data in immunology, and that this inadequacy may be rooted in an excessively strong metaphysical conception of biological identity. We suggest that another hypothesis, one based on the notion of continuity, gives a better account of immune phenomena. Finally, we underscore the mapping between this metaphysical deflation from self to continuity in immunology and the philosophical debate between substantialism and empiricism about identity.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Log in via an institution

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • M.L. Albert (2004) ArticleTitleDeath-defying immunity: do apoptotic cells influence antigen processing and presentation? Nat. Rev. Immunol. 4 223–231

    Google Scholar 

  • V.R. Aluvihare M. Kallikourdis A.G. Betz (2004) ArticleTitleRegulatory T cells mediate maternal tolerance to the fetus Nat. Immunol. 5 IssueID3 266–271 Occurrence Handle10.1038/ni1037

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Aristotle 1984. Categories. In: Barnes J. (eds),The Complete Works of Aristotlethe revised Oxford translation. Princeton University Press, Princeton.

  • Aristotle 1984. Metaphysics. In: Barnes J. (eds), The Complete Works of Aristotlethe revised Oxford translation. Princeton University Press, Princeton.

  • P.G. Ashton-Rickardt A. Bandeira J.R. Delaney L. Kaer ParticleVan H.P. Pircher R.M. Zinkernagel S. Tonegawa (1994) ArticleTitleEvidence for a differential avidity model of T-cell selection in the thymus Cell 76 IssueID4 651–663 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0092-8674(94)90505-3

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • H. Atlan I.R. Cohen (1998) ArticleTitleImmune information, self-organization and meaning Int. Immunol. 10 IssueID6 711–717 Occurrence Handle10.1093/intimm/10.6.711

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Y. Belkaid C.A. Piccirillo S. Mendez E.M. Shevach D.L. Sacks (2002) ArticleTitleCD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells control Leishmania major persistence and immunity Nature 420 502–507 Occurrence Handle10.1038/nature01152

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Y. Belkaid B.T. Rouse (2005) ArticleTitleNatural regulatory T cells in infectious disease Nat. Immunol. 6 IssueID4 353–360 Occurrence Handle10.1038/ni1181

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • R.D. Berg (1996) ArticleTitleThe indigenous gastrointestinal microflora Trends Microbiol. 4 430–435 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0966-842X(96)10057-3

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • D.W. Bianchi G.K. Zickwolf G.J. Weil S. Sylvester M.A. DeMaria (1996) ArticleTitleMale fetal progenitor cells persist in maternal blood for as long as 27 years postpartum Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 93 705–707 Occurrence Handle10.1073/pnas.93.2.705

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • R.E. Billingham L. Brent P.B. Medawar (1953) ArticleTitleActively acquired tolerance of foreign cells Nature 172 603–606

    Google Scholar 

  • G. Boniolo M. Carrara (2004) ArticleTitleOn Biological Identity Biol. Phil. 19 443–457

    Google Scholar 

  • F.M. Burnet F. Fenner (1949) The Production of Antibodies EditionNumber2 Macmillan Melbourne

    Google Scholar 

  • F.M. Burnet (1957) ArticleTitleA modification of Jerne’s theory of antibody production using the concept of clonal selection Aust. J. Sci. 20 67–69

    Google Scholar 

  • F.M. Burnet (1959) The Clonal Selection Theory of Acquired Immunity Cambridge University Press Cambridge

    Google Scholar 

  • F.M. Burnet (1960) ArticleTitleImmunological recognition of self Nobel Lect. Physiol. Med. 3 689–701

    Google Scholar 

  • F.M. Burnet (1962) The Integrity of the Body Harvard University Press Cambridge, Massachusetts

    Google Scholar 

  • F.M. Burnet (1965) The Darwinian approach to immunity J. Sterzl (Eds) Molecular and Cellular Basis of Antibody Formation Academic Press New York 17–20

    Google Scholar 

  • F.M. Burnet (1969) Self and Not-self Melbourne University Press and Cambridge University Press Victoria

    Google Scholar 

  • F.M. Burnet (1970) Immunological Surveillance Pergamon Sydney

    Google Scholar 

  • C.A. Buscaglia J.M. Di Noia (2003) ArticleTitleTrypanosoma cruzi clonal diversity and the epidemiology of Chagas’ disease Microbes and Infection 5 419–427 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S1286-4579(03)00050-9

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • E.D. Carosella P. Moreau J. Maoult ParticleLe M. Discorde ParticleLe J. Dausset N. Rouas-Freiss (2003) ArticleTitleHLA-G molecules: from maternal-fetal tolerance to tissue acceptance Adv. Immunol. 81 199–252

    Google Scholar 

  • F. Claas (2004) ArticleTitleChimerism as a tool to induce clinical transplantation tolerance Curr. Opin. Immunol. 16 578–583 Occurrence Handle10.1016/j.coi.2004.07.006

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • I.R. Cohen (1992) ArticleTitleThe cognitive paradigm and the immunological homunculus Immunol. Today 13 490–494

    Google Scholar 

  • I.R. Cohen (2000) Tending Adam’s Garden – Evolving the Cognitive Immune Self Academic Press San Diego

    Google Scholar 

  • D.C. Douek L.J. Picker R.A. Koup (2003) ArticleTitleT Cells Dynamics in HIV-1 Infection Annu. Rev. Immunol. 21 265–304 Occurrence Handle10.1146/annurev.immunol.21.120601.141053

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • P. Ehrlich (1900) ArticleTitleOn immunity with special reference to cell life Proc. Royal Soc. 66 424–448

    Google Scholar 

  • T.A. Ferguson T.S. Griffith (1997) ArticleTitleA vision of cell death: insights into immune privilege Immunol. Rev. 156 167–184

    Google Scholar 

  • A.A. Freitas B. Rocha (1999) ArticleTitlePeripheral T cell survival Curr. Opinion Immunol. 11 152–156

    Google Scholar 

  • K.C. Garcia M. Degano L.R. Pease M. Huang P.A. Peterson L. Teyton I.A. Wilson (1998) ArticleTitleStructural basis of plasticity in T cell receptor recognition of a self peptide-MHC antigen Science 279 1166–1172 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.279.5354.1166

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • S.F. Gilbert (2002) ArticleTitleThe genome in its ecological context Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 981 202–218

    Google Scholar 

  • N. Girones M. Fresno (2003) ArticleTitleEtiology of Chagas disease myocarditis: autoimmunity, parasite persistenceor both? Trends Parasitol 19 IssueID1 19–22

    Google Scholar 

  • P. Godfrey-Smith (2001) Organismenvironmentand dialectics R.S. Singh K. Krimbas D.B. Paul J. Beatty (Eds) Thinking About Evolution: Historical, Philosophical and Political Perspectives Cambridge University Press New York

    Google Scholar 

  • D. Haig (1999) ArticleTitleWhat is a marmoset? Am. J. Primatol. 49 285–296 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1098-2345(199912)49:4<285::AID-AJP1>3.0.CO;2-X

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • L.V. Hooper J.I. Gordon (2001) ArticleTitleCommensal host-bacterial relationships in the gut Science 292 1115–1118 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.1058709

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • N.K. Jerne (1974) ArticleTitleTowards a network theory of the immune system Ann. d’immunologie 125 IssueIDC 373–389

    Google Scholar 

  • J.W. Kappler N. Roehm P.T. Marrack (1987) ArticleTitleT cell tolerance by clonal elimination in the thymus Cell 49 273–280

    Google Scholar 

  • J. Klein (1982) Immunology: The Science of Self-Nonself Discrimination Wiley New York

    Google Scholar 

  • R.E. Langman M. Cohn (2000) ArticleTitleA minimal model for the self-nonself discrimination: a return to the basics Sem. Immunol. 12 189–195

    Google Scholar 

  • G.W. Leibniz (1714) Monadologietranslation Monadology and Other Philosophical Essays Bobbs-Merrill Indianapolis

    Google Scholar 

  • R. Lewontin (2000) The Triple Helix: GeneOrganismand Environment Harvard University Press Cambridge, Massachusetts

    Google Scholar 

  • N. Lila N. Rouas-Freiss J. Dausset A. Carpentier E.D. Carosella (2001) ArticleTitleSoluble HLA-G protein secreted by allo-specific CD4 + T cells suppresses the allo-proliferative response: a CD4 + T cell regulatory mechanism Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 98 IssueID21 12150–12155 Occurrence Handle10.1073/pnas.201407398

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Löwy I. 1991. The immunological construction of the self. In A.I. Taubered., Organism and the Origins of Self, KluwerBoston, (1991), pp. 43–75.

  • L. Margulis M. J. Chapman (1998) ArticleTitleEndosymbioses: cyclical and permanent in evolution Trends Microbiol. 6 342–345 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0966-842X(98)01325-0

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • F. Marincola E. Jaffee D. Hicklin S. Ferrone (2000) ArticleTitleEscape of human solid tumors from T-cell recognition: molecular mechanisms and functional significance Adv. Immunol. 74 181–273

    Google Scholar 

  • W. Martin M. Müller (1998) ArticleTitleThe hydrogen hypothesis for the first eukaryote Nature 392 37–41 Occurrence Handle10.1038/32096

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Maturana H.R. and Varela F.J. 1980. Autopoiesis and Cognition – The Realization of the Living D. Reidel. Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 42: Boston.

  • P. Matzinger S. Gallucci M. Lolkema (1999) ArticleTitleNatural adjuvants: Endogenous activators of dendritic cells Nat. Med. 5 IssueID11 1249–1255

    Google Scholar 

  • R. Medzhitov C. Janeway (2000) ArticleTitleHow does the immune system distinguish self from non-self? Sem. Immunol. 12 185–188 Occurrence Handle10.1006/smim.2000.0230

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • R. Medzhitov C. Janeway (2002) ArticleTitleDecoding the Patterns of Self and Nonself by the Innate Immune System Science 296 298–300 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.1068883

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • J.F.A.P. Miller (1961) ArticleTitleImmunological function of the thymus The Lancet ii 748–749

    Google Scholar 

  • J.B. Murphy (1913) ArticleTitleTransplantability of tissues to the embryo of foreign species J. Exp. Med. 17 482–492 Occurrence Handle10.1084/jem.17.4.482

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • N. Nanda E. Sercarz (1995) ArticleTitleInduction of anti-self-immunity to cure cancer Cell 82 13–17 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0092-8674(95)90047-0

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • R. Owen (1945) ArticleTitleImmunogenetic consequences of vascular anastomoses between bovine twins Science 102 400–401

    Google Scholar 

  • S. Oyama (1985) The Ontogeny of Information – Developmental Systems and Evolution Cambridge University Press Cambridge

    Google Scholar 

  • D. Pardoll (2003) ArticleTitleDoes the immune system see Tumors as Foreign or Self? Ann. Rev. Immunol. 21 807–839 Occurrence Handle10.1146/annurev.immunol.21.120601.141135

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • R. Pedotti D. Mitchell et al. (2001) ArticleTitleAn unexpected version of horror autotoxicus: anaphylactic shock to a self-peptide Nat. Immunol. 3 216–222

    Google Scholar 

  • T. Pradeu E.D. Carosella (2004) ArticleTitleAnalyse critique du modèle immunologique du soi et du non-soi et de ses fondements métaphysiques implicites Comptes Rendus de l’Académie des Sciences Biologies 327 IssueID5 481–492

    Google Scholar 

  • S. Sakaguchi (2004) ArticleTitleNaturally arising CD4+ regulatory T cells for immunologic self-tolerance and negative control of immune responses Ann. Rev. Immunol. 22 17.1–17.32 Occurrence Handle10.1146/annurev.immunol.21.120601.141122

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • J. Savill I. Dransfield C. Gregory C. Haslett (2002) ArticleTitleA blast from the past: clearance of apoptotic cells regulates immune responses Nat. Rev. Immunol. 2 965–975 Occurrence Handle10.1038/nri957

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • E. Seung J.P Mordes A.A. Rossini D.L. Greiner (2003) ArticleTitleHematopoietic chimerism and central tolerance created by peripheral-tolerance induction without myeloablative conditioning J. Clin. Invest. 112 795–808 Occurrence Handle10.1172/JCI200318599

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • A.M. Silverstein N.R. Rose (1997) ArticleTitleOn the mystique of the immunological self Immunol. Rev. 159 197–206

    Google Scholar 

  • A.M. Silverstein N.R. Rose (2000) ArticleTitleThere is only one immune system! The view from immunopathology Sem. Immunol. 12 173–178 Occurrence Handle10.1006/smim.2000.0228

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • H.H. Smits E.C. Jong Particlede E.A. Wierenga M.L. Kapsenberg (2005) ArticleTitleDifferent faces of regulatory DCs in homeostasis and immunity Trends Immunol. 26 IssueID3 123–129 Occurrence Handle10.1016/j.it.2005.01.002

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • A.I. Tauber (1994) The Immune Self: Theory or Metaphor? Cambridge University Press Cambridge

    Google Scholar 

  • A.I. Tauber (1999) ArticleTitleThe elusive immune self: a case of category errors Perspect. Biol. Med. 42 459–474

    Google Scholar 

  • A.I. Tauber (2000) ArticleTitleMoving beyond the immune self? Sem. Immunol. 12 241–248 Occurrence Handle10.1006/smim.2000.0237

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • L.S.K. Walker A.K. Abbas (2001) ArticleTitleThe enemy within: keeping self-reactive T cells at bay in the periphery Nat. Rev. Immunol. 2 11–19

    Google Scholar 

  • H.G. Wells J.S. Huxley G.P. Wells (1929) The Science of Life The Literary Guild New York

    Google Scholar 

  • D. Wiggins (2001) Sameness and Substance Renewed Cambridge University Press Cambridge

    Google Scholar 

  • D. Wilson (1972) The Science of Self – A Report of the New Immunology Longman London

    Google Scholar 

  • R.M. Zinkernagel G.N. Callahan A. Althage S. Cooper P.A. Klein J. Klein (1978) ArticleTitleOn the thymus in the differenciation of “H-2 self-recognition“ by T cells: evidence for dual recognition? J. Exp. Med. 147 882–896

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

  1. Institut d’Histoire et de Philosophie des Sciences et des Techniques (IHPST) Department of Philosophy, Paris1-Sorbonne University, Paris, France

    Thomas Pradeu

  2. Service de Recherches en Hémato-Immunologie, Commissariat à l’Énergie Atomique CEA-DRM-DSV, Hôpital Saint-Louis, Paris, France

    Edgardo D. Carosella

Authors
  1. Thomas Pradeu
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  2. Edgardo D. Carosella
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Thomas Pradeu.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Pradeu, T., Carosella, E.D. The Self Model and the Conception of Biological Identity in Immunology. Biol Philos 21, 235–252 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-005-8621-6

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-005-8621-6

Keywords

Search

Navigation