Abstract
This article sets out to inquire whether or not—political desiderata apart—genuine intercultural dialogue is feasible between Europe and East Asia, and if so, in which subject areas this could be done productively. It therefore examines the underlying value patterns which are grounded in religious traditions on both sides. It retraces the consequences which Communist rule had (and continues to have) on religious practice and ethnic identities of affected societies, and reviews the salient inter-ethnic and inter-religious conflicts which surfaced during the past quarter century on both continents. This is done in order to be able to qualify empirically Huntington’s theory on predominantly cultural clashes between civilizations. In conclusion we find a large measure of congruence between normative values of Christianity and Buddhism and between the secularized work ethics of Confucianism and of (Calvinist) Protestantism, so as to permit a meeting of minds. Conflicts were caused by the religious and ethnic suppression by Communist regimes (Soviet Union, China, N. Korea, Vietnam, Cambodia), by other authoritarian regimes (post Communist Serbia and Russia, Myanmar), and by nationalist: chauvinism. Conflicts between cultures (Bosnia, Nagorno Karabach, Abkhazia, Chechnya, Eastern Indonesia, East Timor, Pattani, Mindanao, Tibet, Xinjiang) occured as well as within them (Transnistria, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Aceh). Huntington is thus frequently right, but not universally so. Moreover open conflicts on the two continents have rather been limited in extent and mostly took place in peripheral regions. Coexistence with Muslims is difficult both in Europe and in East Asia. But more often than not they appear as victims of aggression (Bosnia, Chechnya, Xinjiang, Pattani, the Cham) rather than as its perpetrators (Northern Cyprus, East Timor, Eastern Indonesia, and Al Quaida linked terrorism in the UK, Spain, Bali and Mindanao). In view of common values and similar problems, dialogue and cooperation should—and are—perfectly possible and potentially productive on a wide range of subjects, starting from conflict management and prevention, confidence building and reconciliation, to grand subjects of managing the consequences of globalization, of global security, of sharing experiences on regional integration, of lessons to be learned from development cooperation, on environmental protection and resource conservation, and on solving common demographic problems.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Given the strength of historical ties and cultural traditions it appears as not correct to award Japan a separate “civilization” status as distinct from “Confucianism” (i.e. read: “China”) Huntington (1993, 26) does in his simplified categorization of seven world civilizations, which also overlooks Buddhism entirely.
References
Hahm C (2006) Confucianism and the idea of liberty. Asia Europe Journal 4(4):477–489
Hoppe T (1997) Tibet heute. Institut für Asienkunde, Hamburg
Huntington SP (1993) The clash of civilizations. Foreign Aff 72(3):22–49
Jockel R (1958) Die lebenden religionen. Safari Verlag, Berlin
Kanagawa Shimbun (1986) Kami ga orita—kiseki no shinshukyo Ozama-Nezu-no-mikoto-shinji-kyokai. The Press Kanagawa, Yokohama
Köpping K-P (1990) Die neuen Religionen Japans. OAG, Tokyo
Langguth G (2003) Asian values revisited. Asia Europe Journal 1(1):25–42
Lee CY (2003) Do traditional values still exist in modern chinese societies? Asia Europe Journal 1(1):43–49
Levenson JR (1964) Modern China and its Confucian past. Anchor Books, New York
Murakami H (2004) Untergrundkrieg. Der Anschlag von Tokyo. BTB Verlag, Gütersloh
Rashid A (1995) The resurgence of Central Asia. Islam or Nationalism? Zed Books, London
Roy O (2005) The new Central Asia. The Creation of Nation. New York University Press, New York
Seidel A (1990) Taoismus, die inoffizielle Hochreligion Chinas. OAG, Tokyo
Shamsul AD (2005) Islam embedded: religion and plurality in South East Asia as a mirror for Europe. Asia Europe Journal 3(2):159–178
Sukura R (2004) War on terror, Islam and the imperative of democracy. Asia Europe Journal 2(1):85–93
Tyler C (2003) Wild west China. The taming of Xinjiang. John Murray, London
Wieczorek I (2002) Neue religöse Bewegungen in Japan. Institut für Asienkunde, Hamburg
Further Readings
Antes P (1997) Der Islam als politischer Faktor. Bonn: Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung
Aspinall E, Feith H, Van Klinken G (eds) (1999) The last days of president Suharto. Monash Asia Institute, Clayton
Buzo A (1999) The guerilla dynasty. Politics and leadership in North Korea. I.B. Tauris, London
Christie K, Robert C (eds) (2002) Historical injustice and democratic transition in Eastern Asia and Northern Europe. Routledge Curzon, London
Elleman BA (2001) Modern Chinese warfare, 1795–1989. Routledge, London
Federal Ministry of Foreign Affairs (1999) NATO crimes in Yugoslavia. documentary evidence. FMFA, Belgrade
Hamilton-Paterson J (2000) Die Geister von Manila. Suhrkamp, Frankfurt/Main
Hassel F (ed) (2003) Der Krieg im Schatten. Rußland und Tschetschenien. Suhrkamp, Frankfurt/Main
Hughes J (2003) The end of Sukarno. A coup that misfired: a purge that ran wild. Archipelago, Singapore
Human Rights Watch (2000) Welcome to hell. Arbitrary detention, torture, and extortion in Chechnya. HRW, New York
Huntington SP (1996) Der Kampf der Kulturen. Europa Verlag, München
Kang C-h (2001) The aquariums of Pyongyang. Ten years in the North Korean Gulag. Basic Books, New York
Kappeler A (2001) Rußland als Vielvölkerreich. Verlag C.H Beck, München
Kleveman L (2003) The new great game. Blood and oil in Central Asia. Atlantik Books, London
Kotkin S, Elleman BA (eds) (1999) Mongolia in the twentieth century. M.E. Sharpe, New York
Kunz H (1995) Von Marcos zu Aquino Der Machtwechsel auf den Philippinen und die katholische Kirche. Institut für Asienkunde, Hamburg
Rothacher A (2002) Im wilden Osten. Hinter den Kulissen des Umbruchs in Osteuropa. Krämer Verlag, Hamburg
Rothacher A (2007) Asien ohne Mythen. Licht- und Schattenseiten einer Region im Aufbruch. Olzog Verlag, München
Schmid T (ed) (1999) Krieg im Kosovo. Rowohlt, Reinbek
Shirley S (2004) Guided by God. The legacy of the catholic church in Philippine politics. Eastern Universities Press, Singapore
Simon R (1996) Der chinesische Gulag. Rowohlt, Reinbek
Simms B (2001) Unfinest hour. Britain and the destruction of Bosnia. Penguin, London
Tanner M (1999) Croatia. A nation forged by war. Yale University Press, New Haven
Thomson MR (2004) Democratic revolutions. Asia and Eastern Europe. Routledge, London
Wheatcroft A (2004) Infidels. A history of the conflict between Christendom and Islam. Penguin, London
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Adapted lecture on “Dialogue of Cultures and Religions within and with East Asia” given at the Afro-Asian Institute, University of Graz (Austria) on 9.10.2007. Note that this article reflects only personal views.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rothacher, A. Clashes and dialogues of civilizations revisited— the case of contemporary East Asia and Europe. AEJ 6, 129–143 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10308-007-0144-0
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10308-007-0144-0