Abstract
In chalk mines, the method of room and pillar mining has been widely used in France. Yet, many large collapses have occurred during or after their exploitation, with the collapse of Clamart (south of Paris, France) being well known as one of the most catastrophic. Today, 50 years after the collapse, the main causes of the event are still not well understood. This paper presents a back-analysis of the case study, using both an empirical approach and a numerical approach. Based on a set of hypotheses, an empirical approach and 3D numerical modeling have indicated a plausible scenario that may explain the collapse: The large collapse may have been caused by a lack of bearing capacity of the pillars and the sudden rupture of a hard limestone bed on which the load would have accumulated until overload occurred. The bed weakness between the two mine levels may also have had an influence on the mine’s general lack of stability. Moreover, under the given hypothesis, the study shows a very low influence of the water table due to flooding of the mine.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Al Heib M (2008) State of the art of the prediction methods of short- and long-term ground movements (subsidence and sinkholes) for mines in France. In: Michel T, Fournier H (eds) Coal geology research progress. ISBN:978-1-60456-596-6. Nova Science Publishers, Inc, New York, pp 53–76
Bekendam R (2004) Stability and subsidence assessment over shallow abandoned room and pillar limestone mines. In: Engineering geology for infrastructure planning in Europe. A European Perspective. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, pp 657–670
Bell FG, Culshaw MG, Moorlock BSP, Cripps JC (1992) Subsidence and ground movements in chalk. Bull Int Assoc Eng Geol 45(1):75–82
Bell FG, Stacey TR, Genske DD (2000) Mining subsidence and its effect on the environment: some differing examples. Environ Geol 40(1–2):135–152
Bell FG, Donnelly LJ, Genske G, Ojeda J (2005) Unusual cases of mining subsidence from Great Britain, Germany and Colombia. Environ Geol 47(5):620–631
Berest P, Brouard B, Feuga B, Karimi-Jafari M (2008) The 1873 collapse of the Saint-Maximilien panel at the Varangeville salt mine. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci 45(2008):1025–1043
Bianchi FG, Bozzanob F, Cardarellia E, Cercatoa M (2013) Underground cavity investigation within the city of Rome (Italy): a multi-disciplinary approach combining geological and geophysical data. Eng Geol 152(1):109–121
Castellanza R, Fernandez Merodo JA, di Prisco C, Frigerio G, Crosta GB, Orlandi G (2013) Deterministic evaluation of collapse risk for a decommissioned flooded mine system: 3D numerical modeling of subsidence, roof collapse and impulse water flow. Geophysical Research Abstracts, vol 15, EGU 2013-14143
Deb D, Choi SO (2006) Analysis of sinkhole occurrences over abandoned mines using fuzzy reasoning: a case study. Geotech Geol Eng 24:1243–1258
Edmonds CN (2008) Karst and mining geohazard with particular references to the chalk outcrop, England. Q J Eng Geol Hydrogeol 41(3):279–290
Esterhuizen GS, Iannacchione AT, Ellenberger JL, Dolinar DR (2006) Pillar stability issues based on a survey of pillar performance in underground unusual cases of mining subsidence from Great Britain, Germany and Colombia. Environ Geol 47:620–631
Esterhuizen GS, Dolinar DR, Ellenberger JL (2011) Pillar strength in underground stone mines in the US. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci 48(1):42–50
Fairhurst C, Piguet J-P, Van der Merwe N (2003) Examen de la méthode GEODERIS d’évaluation des risques et des conséquences potentielles relatifs aux affaissements de surface dans le bassin ferrifère lorrain [Examination of the GEODERIS method for evaluating potential risks and consequences relating to surface subsidence in the Lorraine iron basin], French version
Gely J-P, Lorenz C, Obert D (1990) Tectonique synsédimentaire cassante et karst dans l’anticlinal de Meudon [Brittle and karst synsedimentary tectonics in the Meudon anticline]. Bull Int Eng Paris 27(4):34–37
Gilbride LJ, Free KS, Kehrman R (2005) Block cave subsidence at the Molycorp, Inc., Questa mine—a case study, 2005, ARMA, American Rock Mechanics Association, ARMA/USRMS 05-881 limestone mines, 25th international conference on ground control in mining, Morgantown, pp 354–361
Gombert Ph, Auvray Ch, Al Heib M (2013) In-situ and laboratory tests to evaluate the impact of water table fluctuations on the stability of underground chalk mines. Procedia Earth Planet Sci 7(2013):304–308
Grgic D, Homand F, Hoxha D (2003) A short- and long-term rheological model to understand the collapses of iron mines in Lorraine, France. Comput Geotech 30(7):557–570
Gutiérrez F, Galve JP, Lucha P, Bonachea J, Jordá L, Jordá R (2009) Investigation of a large collapse sinkhole affecting a multi-storey building by means of geophysics and the trenching technique (Zaragoza city, NE Spain). Environ Geol 58(5):1107–1122
Haitao MJ, Wang YW (2012) Study on mechanics and domino effect of large-scale goaf cave-in. Safety Science, vol 50(4), April 2012, pp 689–694. First international symposium on mine safety science and engineering
Helm PR, Davie CT, Glendinning S (2013) Numerical modelling of shallow abandoned mine working subsidence affecting transport infrastructures. Eng Geol 154:6–19
Kalendra Singh B, Bharat Dhar B (1997) Sinkhole subsidence due to mining. Geotech Geol Eng 1997(15):327–341
Kaufmann O, Quinif Y (2002) Geohazard map of cover-collapse sinkholes in the ‘Tournaisis’ area, southern Belgium. Eng Geol 65(2002):117–124
Laouafa F, Tritsch JJ (2005) Stabilité des Carrières: Analyse critique de quelques méthodes analytiques dans Evaluation et gestion des risques liés aux carrières souterraines abandonnées [Stability of quarries: critical analysis of some analytic methods in the evaluation and management of risks associated with abandoned subterranean quarries]—Actes des journées scientifiques du LCPC mai 2005
Maury V (1979) Effondrements spontanés. Synthèse d’observations et possibilité de mécanisme initiateur par mise en charge hydraulique [Summary of observations and possibility of initiator mechanism by hydraulic loading]. Revue de l’Industrie Minérale October 1979, pp 511–522
Salamon M (1999) Strength of coal pillars from back-calculation. In: Amadei B, Kranz RL, Scott GA, Smeallie PH (eds) Proceedings of 37th US rock mechanics symposium, Vail, vol 1.: A. A. Balkema, Rotterdam, pp 29–36
Szwedzicki T (2001) Geotechnical precursors to large-scale ground collapse in mines. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci. 38(7):957–965
Toulemont M (1995) Abandoned underground mines: risks and prevention: presentation of the Seminar. April, 1995, vol 51(1), p 94
Vachat JC (1982) Les désordres survenant dans les carrières de la région parisienne—Etude théorique et pratique de l’évolution des fontis [Disorders occurring in the quarries of the Paris region—theoretical and practical study of the evolution of sinkholes], CNAM thesis, 1982
Waltham T, Bell F, Culshaw M (2005) Sinkhole and subsidence: Karst and cavernous rocks in engineering and construction. Springer, Berlin
Wang JA, Shang XC, Ma HT (2008) Investigation of catastrophic ground collapse in Xingtai gypsum mines in China. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci 45:1480–1499
Watelet J-M (1996) Méthode d’analyse et diagnostic des conditions de stabilités de carrières souterraines (Method for analysing and diagnosing stability conditions of subterranean quarries). Conservatoire National des Arts et Métiers, Dissertation for engineering degree
Whittaker BN, Reddish DJ (1989) Subsidence: occurrence, prediction and control. Elsevier, Amsterdam
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Al Heib, M., Duval, C., Theoleyre, F. et al. Analysis of the historical collapse of an abandoned underground chalk mine in 1961 in Clamart (Paris, France). Bull Eng Geol Environ 74, 1001–1018 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10064-014-0677-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10064-014-0677-6