Abstract
Personal information management research has consistently shown navigation preference over search. One possible explanation for this is that search requires more cognitive attention than navigation. We tested this hypothesis using the dual-task paradigm. We read a list of words to each of our 62 participants, asked them to navigate or search to a target file, and then compared the number of words recalled in each condition. Participants remembered significantly more words when retrieving by navigation than by search. The fact that they performed better at the secondary task when navigating indicates that it required less cognitive attention than search. Our results also cast doubt on the assumption that search is more efficient and easier to use than navigation: Search took nearly three times longer than navigation, was more vulnerable to mistakes and retrieval failures and was perceived as more difficult on a subjective evaluation. Our results also support the folk belief that women are better than men and that younger people are better than older ones, at multitasking.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Similar results regarding navigation retrieval time were obtained in [27].
References
Barreau DK, Nardi BA (1995) Finding and reminding: file organization from the desktop. SIGCHI Bull 27(3):39–43
Boardman R, Sasse MA (2004) “Stuff goes into the computer and doesn’t come out”: a cross-tool study of personal information management In: SIGCHI conference on human factors in computing systems, Vienna, Austria. ACM Press, 985766, pp 583–590, doi:10.1145/985692.985766
Kirk D, Sellen A, Rother C, Wood K (2006) Understanding photowork. In: SIGCHI conference on human factors in computing systems, Montreal. ACM. doi: 10.1145/1124772.1124885
Teevan J, Alvarado C, Ackerman MS, Karger DR (2004) The perfect search engine is not enough: a study of orienteering behavior in directed search. In: SIGCHI conference on human factors in computing systems, Vienna, Austria. ACM Press, pp 415–422
Bergman O, Beyth-Marom R, Nachmias R, Gradovitch N, Whittaker S (2008) Improved search engines and navigation preference in personal information management. ACM Trans Inform Syst 26(4):1–24. doi:10.1145/1402256.1402259
Kidd A (1994) The marks are on the knowledge worker In: Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference on human factors in computing systems: celebrating interdependence. ACM Press, Boston, MA, pp 186–191
Malone TW (1983) How do people organize their desks? Implications for the design of office information systems. ACM Trans Off Inform Syst 1:99–112
Whittaker S, Sidner C (1996) Email overload: exploring personal information management of email. In: Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference on human factors in computing systems: common ground. ACM Press, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada, pp 276–283
Dumais ST, Cutrell E, Cadiz JJ, Jancke G, Sarin R, Robbins DC (2003) Stuff I’ve seen: a system for personal information retrieval and re-use. In: Proceedings of the 26th annual international ACM SIGIR conference on research and development in information retrieval. ACM Press, Toronto, Canada, pp 72–79
Lansdale MW (1988) The psychology of personal information management. Appl Ergon 19(1):55–66
Russell D, Lawrence S (2007) Search everything. In: Jones W, Teevan J (eds) Personal information management. University of Washington Press, Seattle, pp 153–166
Cutrell E, Dumais ST, Teevan J (2006) Searching to eliminate personal information management. Commun ACM 49(1):58–64
Dourish P, Edwards WK, LaMarca A, Lamping J, Petersen K, Salisbury M, Terry DB, Thornton J (2000) Extending document management systems with user-specific active properties. ACM Trans Inf Syst 18(2):140–170
Freeman E, Gelernter D (1996) Lifestreams: a storage model for personal data. SIGMOD Rec 25 (1):80–86. doi:10.1145/381854.381893
Raskin J (2000) The humane interface: new directions for designing interactive systems. ACM Press/Addison-Wesley Publishing Co., Boston
Kobayashi M, Takeda K (2000) Information retrieval on the web. ACM Comput Surv 32(2):144–173. doi:10.1145/358923.358934
Capra RG, Pérez-Quiñones MA (2005) Using web search engines to find and refind information. Computer 38(10):36–42
Whittaker S, Bergman O, Clough P (2009) Easy on that trigger dad: a long term family pictures retrieval study. Pers Ubiquit Comput 13(5):17–30
Whittaker S, Matthews T, Cerruti J, Badenes H, Tang J (2011) Am I wasting my time organizing email? A study of email refinding. In: Conference on human factors in computing systems, Vancouver
Brown J (1958) Some tests of the decay theory of immediate memory. Q J Exp Psychol 10:12–21
Peterson LR, Peterson MG (1959) Short-term retention of individual verbal items. J Exp Psychol 58(3):193–198
Gwizdka J (2010) Distribution of cognitive load in Web search. J Am Soc Inform Sci Technol 61(11):2167–2187
Kim YM, Rieh SY (2005) Dual-task performance as a measure for mental effort in library searching and web searching. In: 68th annual meeting of the American society for information science & technology, USA
Wicken CD (2002) Multiple resources and performance prediction. Theor Issues Ergon Sci 3(2):159–177
Baddeley A (1992) Working memory. Science 255(5044):556–559. doi:10.1126/science.1736359
Miller G (1956) The magical number seven, plus or minus two: some limits on our capacity for processing information. Psychol Rev 63(2):81–97
Bergman O, Whittaker S, Sanderson M, Nachmias R, Ramamoorthy A (2010) The effect of folder structure on personal file navigation. J Am Soc Inform Sci Technol 61(12):2426–2441
Ingwersen P (1996) Cognitive perspectives of information retrieval interaction: elements of a cognitive IR theory. J Doc 52(1):3–50
Hambrick DZ, Oswald FL, Darowski ES, Rench TA, Brou R (2010) Predictors of multitasking performance in a synthetic work paradigm. Appl Cogn Psychol 24(8):1149–1167
Ren D, Zhou H, Fu X (2009) A deeper look at gender difference in multitasking: Gender-specific mechanism of cognitive control. Paper presented at the fifth international conference on natural computation, Tianjin
Peter N (2010) Gender differences in multitasking. Tinbergen Institute, Amsterdam
Fisher H (1999) The first sex: the natural talents of women and how they are changing the world. Random House
Popper KR (1963) Conjectures and refutations: the growth of scientific knowledge. Routledge
Gurian M, Stevens K (2004) With boys and girls in mind. Educ Leadersh 62(3):21–26
Carrier LM, Cheever NA, Rosen LD, Benitez S, Chang J (2009) Multitasking across generations: multitasking choices and difficulty ratings in three generations of Americans. Comput Hum Behav 25(2):483–489. doi:10.1016/j.chb.2008.10.012
Acknowledgments
We thank our participants, Prof. Ruth Beyth-Marom, and Smadar Pilo. This research was partially funded by the European Union Marie Curie Grant, PERG-GA-2009-248997.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bergman, O., Tene-Rubinstein, M. & Shalom, J. The use of attention resources in navigation versus search. Pers Ubiquit Comput 17, 583–590 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00779-012-0544-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00779-012-0544-z