Abstract
Background
The surgical management of cervical brachialgia utilising anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) or posterior cervical foraminotomy (PCF) is a controversial area in spinal surgery. Previous studies are limited by utilisation of non-validated outcome measures and, importantly, absence of pre-operative analysis to ensure both groups are matched. The authors aimed to compare the effectiveness of ACDF and PCF using validated outcome measures. To our knowledge, it is the first study in the literature to do this.
Methods
The authors conducted a 5-year retrospective review (2008–2013) of outcomes following both the above procedures and also compared the effectiveness of both techniques. Patients with myelopathy and large central discs were excluded. The main outcome variables measured were the neck disability index (NDI) and visual analogue scores (VAS) for neck and arm pain pre-operatively and again at 2-year follow-up. The Wilcoxon signed-rank test and Student t-tests were used to test differences.
Results
A total of 150 ACDFs and 51 PCFs were performed for brachialgia. There was no differences in the pre-operative NDI, VAS neck and arm scores between both groups (p > 0.05). As expected, both ACDF and PCF delivered statistically significant improvement in NDI, VAS-neck and VAS-arm scores. The degree of improvement of NDI, VAS-neck and VAS-arm were the same between both groups of patients (p > 0.05) with a trend favouring the PCF group. In the ACDF group, two (1.3 %) patients needed repeat ACDF due to adjacent segment disease. One patient (0.7 %) needed further decompression via a foraminotomy. In the PCF group one (2.0 %) patient needed ACDF due to persistent brachialgia.
Conclusions
We found both interventions delivered similar improvements in the VAS and NDI scores in patients. Both techniques may be appropriately utilised when treating a patient with cervical brachialgia.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bydon M, Mathios D, Macki M, de la Garza-Ramos R, Sciubba DM, Witham TF, Wolinsky JP, Gokaslan ZL, Bydon A (2014) Long-term patient outcomes after posterior cervical foraminotomy: an analysis of 151 cases. J Neurosurg Spine 21(5):727–731
Cho TG, Kim YB, Park SW (2014) Long term effect on adjacent segment motion after posterior cervical foraminotomy. Korean J Spine 11(1):1–6
Clark JG, Abdullah KG, Steinmetz MP, Benzel EC, Mroz TE (2011) Minimally invasive versus open cervical foraminotomy: a systematic review. Global Spine J 1(1):9–14
Clarke MJ, Ecker RD, Krauss WE, McClelland RL, Dekutoski MB (2007) Same-segment and adjacent-segment disease following posterior cervical foraminotomy. J Neurosurg Spine 6(1):5–9
Davis RA (1996) A long-term outcome study of 170 surgically treated patients with compressive cervical radiculopathy. Surg Neurol 46(6):523–530, discussion 530–3
Fouyas IP, Statham PF, Sandercock PA (2002) Cochrane review on the role of surgery in cervical spondylotic radiculomyelopathy. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 27(7):736–747
Gregorius FK, Estrin T, Crandall PH (1976) Cervical spondylotic radiculopathy and myelopathy. A long-term follow-up study. Arch Neurol 33(9):618–625
Henderson CM, Hennessy RG, Shuey HM Jr, Shackelford EG (1983) Posterior-lateral foraminotomy as an exclusive operative technique for cervical radiculopathy: a review of 846 consecutively operated cases. Neurosurgery 13(5):504–512
Herkowitz HN, Kurz LT, Overholt DP (1990) Surgical management of cervical soft disc herniation. A comparison between the anterior and posterior approach. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 15(10):1026–1030
Hilibrand AS, Carlson GD, Palumbo MA, Jones PK, Bohlman HH (1999) Radiculopathy and myelopathy at segments adjacent to the site of a previous anterior cervical arthrodesis. J Bone Joint Surg Am 81(4):519–528
Hwang JC, Bae HG, Cho SW, Cho SJ, Park HK, Chang JC (2010) Morphometric study of the nerve roots around the lateral mass for posterior foraminotomy. J Korean Neurosurg Soc 47(5):358–364
Jagannathan J, Sherman JH, Szabo T, Shaffrey CI, Jane JA (2009) The posterior cervical foraminotomy in the treatment of cervical disc/osteophyte disease: a single-surgeon experience with a minimum of 5 years’ clinical and radiographic follow-up. J Neurosurg Spine 10(4):347–356
Korinth MC, Krüger A, Oertel MF, Gilsbach JM (2006) Posterior foraminotomy or anterior discectomy with polymethyl methacrylate interbody stabilization for cervical soft disc disease: results in 292 patients with monoradiculopathy. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 31(11):1207–1214, discussion 1215–6
Onan OA, Heggeness MH, Hipp JA (1998) A motion analysis of the cervical facet joint. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 23(4):430–439
Onimus M, Destrumelle N, Gangloff S (1995) Surgical treatment of cervical disk displacement. Anterior or posterior approach? Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot 81(4):296–301
Persson LC, Moritz U, Brandt L, Carlsson CA (1997) Cervical radiculopathy: pain, muscle weakness and sensory loss in patients with cervical radiculopathy treated with surgery, physiotherapy or cervical collar. A prospective, controlled study. Eur Spine J 6(4):256–266
Terai H, Suzuki A, Toyoda H, Yasuda H, Kaneda K, Katsutani H, Nakamura H (2014) Tandem keyhole foraminotomy in the treatment of cervical radiculopathy: retrospective review of 35 cases. J Orthop Surg Res 16:9–38
Tomaras CR, Blacklock JB, Parker WD, Harper RL (1997) Outpatient surgical treatment of cervical radiculopathy. J Neurosurg 87(1):41–43
Tumialán LM, Ponton RP, Gluf WM (2010) Management of unilateral cervical radiculopathy in the military: the cost effectiveness of posterior cervical foraminotomy compared with anterior cervical discectomy and fusion. Neurosurg Focus 28(5), E17
Wirth FP, Dowd GC, Sanders HF, Wirth C (2000) Cervical discectomy. A prospective analysis of three operative techniques. Surg Neurol 53(4):340–346, discussion 346–8
Zdeblick TA, Zou D, Warden KE, McCabe R, Kunz D, Vanderby RJ (1992) Cervical stability after foraminotomy. A biomechanical in vitro analysis. Bone Joint Surg Am 74(1):22–27
Conflicts of interest
None.
Funding
None.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Selvanathan, S.K., Beagrie, C., Thomson, S. et al. Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion versus posterior cervical foraminotomy in the treatment of brachialgia: the Leeds spinal unit experience (2008–2013). Acta Neurochir 157, 1595–1600 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00701-015-2491-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00701-015-2491-8