Abstract
The ability of phenotypically similar species to coexist at local scales is paradoxical given that species that closely resemble each other should compete strongly for resources and thus be subject to competitive exclusion. Although theory has identified the key requirements for species to stably coexist, empirical tests of coexistence have rarely been conducted. We explored a key requirement for species to stably coexist: a species can invade a community when it is initially rare. We also assessed whether primary productivity (manipulated using phosphorus availability) affected invasion success by increasing the amount of resources available. Using two mesocosm experiments and an assemblage of phenotypically similar amphipod species in the genus Hyalella, we found no evidence for invasion success among the three Hyalella species. Further, patterns of species exclusions differed among the species, which suggests that one species is an especially poor competitor. Finally, these patterns were consistent regardless of whether mesocosms were fertilized with low or high levels of phosphorus. Our results, suggest that species differences in resource competition and predator avoidance ability found in previous studies using these Hyalella species may not be sufficient to allow for coexistence. Moreover, our study demonstrates the importance of using a variety of empirical approaches to test species coexistence theory.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abrams PA (1998) High competition with low similarity and low competition with high similarity: exploitative and apparent competition in consumer-resource systems. Am Nat 152:114–128
Adler PB, Drake JM (2008) Environmental variation, stochastic extinction, and competitive coexistence. Am Nat 172:186–195
Adler PB, HilleRisLambers J, Kyriakidis PC, Guan Q, Levine JM (2006) Climate variability has a stabilizing effect on the coexistence of prairie grasses. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 103:12793–12798
Adler PB, HilleRisLambers J, Levine JM (2007) A niche for neutrality. Ecol Lett 10:95–104
Adler PB, Fajardo A, Kleinhesselink AR, Kraft NJB (2013) Trait-based tests of coexistence mechanisms. Ecol Lett 16:1294–1306
Angert AL, Huxman TE, Chesson P, Venable DL (2009) Functional tradeoffs determine species coexistence via the storage effect. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 106:11641–11645. doi:10.1073/pnas.0904512106
Armstrong RA (1976) Fugitive species: experiments with fungi and some theoretical considerations. Ecology 57:953–963
Bousfield EL (1996) A contribution to the reclassification of Neotropical freshwater hyalellid amphipods (Crustacea: Gammaridea, Talitroidea). Boll Museo Civ Stor Nat Verona 20:175–224
Chesson P (2000) Mechanisms of maintenance of species diversity. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 31:343–366
Cooper WE (1965) Dynamics and production of a natural population of a fresh-water amphipod, Hyalella azteca. Ecol Monogr 35:377–394
Cothran RD, Henderson KA, Schmidenberg D, Relyea RA (2013a) Phenotypically similar but ecologically distinct: differences in competitive ability and predation risk among amphipods. Oikos 122:1429–1440
Cothran RD, Stiff AR, Chapman K, Wellborn GA, Relyea RA (2013b) Reproductive interference via interspecific pairing in an amphipod species complex. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 67:1357–1367
Descamps-Julien B, Gonzalez A (2005) Stable coexistence in a fluctuating environment: an experimental demonstration. Ecology 86:2815–2824
Gliwicz ZM, Wrzosek D (2008) Predation-mediated coexistence of large- and small-bodied Daphnia at different food levels. Am Nat 172:358–374
Gravel D, Guichard F, Hochberg ME (2011) Species coexistence in a variable world. Ecol Lett 14:828–839
Hardin James William, Hilbe Joseph M, Hilbe Joseph (2007) Generalized linear models and extensions, 2nd edn. Stata, College Station
Hargrave B (1970) The utilization of benthic microflora by Hyalella azteca (Amphipoda). J Anim Ecol 39:427–437
Hubbell S (2006) Neutral theory and the evolution of ecological equivalence. Ecology 87:1387–1398
Hutchinson GE (1951) Copepodology for the onithologist. Ecology 32:571–577
Hutchinson GE (1959) Homage to santa rosalia or why are there so many kinds of animals? Am Nat 93:145–159
Jiang L, Morin PJ (2007) Temperature fluctuation facilitates coexistence of competing species in experimental microbial communities. J Anim Ecol 76:660–668
Kneitel JM, Chase JM (2004) Trade-offs in community ecology: linking spatial scales and species coexistence. Ecol Lett 7:69–80
Leibold MA, McPeek MA (2006) Coexistence of the niche and neutral perspectives in community ecology. Ecology 87:1399–1410
Levine JM, HilleRisLambers J (2009) The importance of niches for the maintenance of species diversity. Nature 461:254–258
MacArthur R (1972) Geographical ecology. Princeton University Press, Princeton
MacNeil C, Dick JTA, Elwood RW (1997) The trophic ecology of freshwater Gammarus spp. (Crustacea: Amphipoda): problems and perspectives concerning the functional feeding group concept. Biol Rev 72:349–364
Morin PJ (1998) Realism, precision, and generality in experimental tests of ecological theory. In: Resetarits WJ, Bernardo J (eds) Issues and perspectives in experimental ecology. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 50–70
Parker G (1974) Assessment strategy and evolution of fighting behavior. J Theor Biol 47:223–243
Siepielski AM, McPeek MA (2010) On the evidence for species coexistence: a critique of the coexistence program. Ecology 91:3153–3164
Silvertown J (2004) Plant coexistence and the niche. Trends Ecol Evol 19:605–611
Stomp M, Huisman J, de Jongh F, Veraart AJ, Gerla D, Rijkeboer M, Ibelings BW, Wollenzien UIA, Stal LJ (2004) Adaptive divergence in pigment composition promotes phytoplankton biodiversity. Nature 432:104–107
Turnbull LA, Rees M, Crawley MJ (1999) Seed mass and the competition/colonization trade-off: a sowing experiment. J Ecol 87:899–912
Wellborn GA (1994) Size-biased predation and prey life histories: a comparative study of freshwater amphipod populations. Ecology 75:2104–2117
Wellborn G (2002) Trade-off between competitive ability and antipredator adaptation in a freshwater amphipod species complex. Ecology 83:129–136
Wellborn GA, Broughton RE (2008) Diversification on an ecologically constrained adaptive landscape. Mol Ecol 17:2927–2936
Wellborn GA, Capps E (2013) Establishment of a new population by a single gravid colonist: implications for Hyalella biogeography and speciation. Evol Ecol 27:101–115
Wellborn GA, Cothran RD (2004) Phenotypic similarity and differentiation among sympatric cryptic species in a freshwater amphipod species complex. Freshw Biol 49:1–13
Wellborn GA, Cothran RD (2007a) Ecology and evolution of mating behavior in freshwater amphipods. In: Thiel M, Duffy EJ (eds) Evolutionary ecology of social and sexual systems. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 147–167
Wellborn GA, Cothran RD (2007b) Niche diversity in crustacean cryptic species: complementarity in spatial distribution and predation risk. Oecologia 154:175–183
Wellborn GA, Skelly DK, Werner EE (1996) Mechanisms creating community structure across a freshwater habitat gradient. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 27:337–363
Wellborn GA, Cothran RD, Bartholf S (2005) Life history and allozyme diversification in regional ecomorphs of the Hyalella azteca (Crustacea: Amphipoda) species complex. Biol J Linn Soc 84:161–175
Werner EE (1998) Ecological experiments and a research program in community ecology. In: Resetarits WJ, Bernardo J (eds) Experimental ecology: issues and perspectives. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 3–26
Wilson W, Osenberg CW, Schmitt RJ, Nisbet RM (1999) Complementary foraging behaviors allow coexistence of two consumers. Ecology 80:2358–2372
Witt JDS, Hebert PDN (2000) Cryptic species diversity and evolution in the amphipod genus Hyalella within central glaciated North America: a molecular phylogenetic approach. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 57:687–698
Witt JDS, Threloff DL, Hebert PDN (2006) DNA barcoding reveals extraordinary cryptic diversity in an amphipod genus: implications for desert spring conservation. Mol Ecol 15:3073–3082
Acknowledgments
We thank B. French, J. Hua, A. Stoler, R.J. Bendis, C. Hensley, H. Schaffery, W. Brogan, R. Greco, C. Greco, and C Murray. This work was funded by an NSF grant and an REU supplement awarded to R.A.R. to support P.N.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Communicated by Barbara J. Downes.
R. D. Cothran and P. Noyes authors contributed equally to the manuscript.
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cothran, R.D., Noyes, P. & Relyea, R.A. An empirical test of stable species coexistence in an amphipod species complex. Oecologia 178, 819–831 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00442-015-3262-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00442-015-3262-1